FW27 Alternatives PDT Preferred AP Preferred Cmte Preferred
4. Scallops - (December 1-3, 2015) - M
FW27 Alternatives 2.1 OFL and ABC 2.1.1 No Action OFL and ABC 2.1.2 Updated OFL and ABC 2.2 Fishery Specifications 2.2.1 Overall Fishery Allocations 2.2.1 Alt.1 No Action (2016 default) 2.2.2 Alt.2 Basic Run 2.2.3 Alt 3 Basic Run with CA2south extension 2.2.4 Alt 4 Basic Run with ETA extension 2.2.5 Alt 5 Basic Run with NL-N access 2.2.6 Alt 6 AP Recommendation 2.2.6 Default measures for 2017 2.2.2 Allocation method for LA access areas 2.2.2.1 Lottery Option 1 (no NL access) 2.2.2.2 Lottery Option 2 (with NL access)
PDT Preferred
AP Preferred
Cmte Preferred
**
**
**
PDT Mixed PDT does not support access in NL
**
lottery for LA PT if NL open
Several options developed for LA PT vessels 2.2.3 Allocation of LAGC IFQ trips in AAs 2.2.3.1 LAGC AA Allocations (total number of fleetwide trips) 2.2.3.1.1 Allocation Option 1 - No Action - Default of 602 Trips starting in April 2.2.3.1.2 Allocation Option 2-2,553 trips (same AA proportion as LA - 34%) 2.2.3.1.3 Allocation Option 3-1,523 trips (equal to overall allocation of 5.5%) 2.2.3.1.4 Allocation Option 4 - Status Quo - 2,065 trips (same # as FY2015)
Cmte does not have a preferred; motion to add Alt 6 for analysis
**
PDT has concerns about resoruce inshore so Opt2 would move some in AA, but at a cost LT to AA resource
**
**
2.2.3.2 LAGC AA Allocations (by area) Because AP motion keeps NL closed Option 1 by Cmte does not have default
2.2.3.2.1 Area Option 1 (no NL access) All trips in MAAA 2.2.3.2.2 Area Option 2 (with NL access) Prorate CA2 trips to MAAA and NL evenly 2.2.3.2.3 Area Option 3 (with NL access) Prorate CA2 trips all to NL
2.2.4 Additional measures to reduce impacts on small scallops 2.2.4.1 Alt.1 - No Action (Default - RSA in open areas only) 2.2.4.2 Alt.2 - Status Quo (RSA in any area open to fishery) 2.2.4.3 Alt.3 - Prohibit RSA comp fishing in NL
a preferred; motion to analyze some access in NL (option 4)
PDT does not support access in NL, but if there is access (opt2) would have lower potential impacts
**
**
**
#2a
FW27 Alternatives 2.1 OFL and ABC 2.1.1 No Action OFL and ABC 2.1.2 Updated OFL and ABC 2.2 Fishery Specifications 2.2.1 Overall Fishery Allocations 2.2.1 Alt.1 No Action (2016 default) 2.2.2 Alt.2 Basic Run 2.2.3 Alt 3 Basic Run with CA2south extension 2.2.4 Alt 4 Basic Run with ETA extension 2.2.5 Alt 5 Basic Run with NL-N access 2.2.6 Alt 6 AP Recommendation 2.2.6 Default measures for 2017 2.2.2 Allocation method for LA access areas 2.2.2.1 Lottery Option 1 (no NL access) 2.2.2.2 Lottery Option 2 (with NL access)
PDT Preferred
AP Preferred
Cmte Preferred
**
**
**
PDT Mixed PDT does not support access in NL
**
lottery for LA PT if NL open
Several options developed for LA PT vessels 2.2.3 Allocation of LAGC IFQ trips in AAs 2.2.3.1 LAGC AA Allocations (total number of fleetwide trips) 2.2.3.1.1 Allocation Option 1 - No Action - Default of 602 Trips starting in April 2.2.3.1.2 Allocation Option 2-2,553 trips (same AA proportion as LA - 34%) 2.2.3.1.3 Allocation Option 3-1,523 trips (equal to overall allocation of 5.5%) 2.2.3.1.4 Allocation Option 4 - Status Quo - 2,065 trips (same # as FY2015)
Cmte does not have a preferred; motion to add Alt 6 for analysis
**
PDT has concerns about resoruce inshore so Opt2 would move some in AA, but at a cost LT to AA resource
**
**
2.2.3.2 LAGC AA Allocations (by area) Because AP motion keeps NL closed Option 1 by Cmte does not have default
2.2.3.2.1 Area Option 1 (no NL access) All trips in MAAA 2.2.3.2.2 Area Option 2 (with NL access) Prorate CA2 trips to MAAA and NL evenly 2.2.3.2.3 Area Option 3 (with NL access) Prorate CA2 trips all to NL
2.2.4 Additional measures to reduce impacts on small scallops 2.2.4.1 Alt.1 - No Action (Default - RSA in open areas only) 2.2.4.2 Alt.2 - Status Quo (RSA in any area open to fishery) 2.2.4.3 Alt.3 - Prohibit RSA comp fishing in NL
a preferred; motion to analyze some access in NL (option 4)
PDT does not support access in NL, but if there is access (opt2) would have lower potential impacts
**
**
**
#2a
