Learning Measurement Models for Unobserved ... - Semantic Scholar
Carnegie Mellon University
Research Showcase @ CMU Department of Philosophy
Dietrich College of Humanities and Social Sciences
8-2003
Learning Measurement Models for Unobserved Variables Ricardo Silva Carnegie Mellon University
Richard Scheines Carnegie Mellon University
Clark Glymour Carnegie Mellon University
Peter Spirtes Carnegie Mellon University
Follow this and additional works at: http://repository.cmu.edu/philosophy Part of the Philosophy Commons
This Article is brought to you for free and open access by the Dietrich College of Humanities and Social Sciences at Research Showcase @ CMU. It has been accepted for inclusion in Department of Philosophy by an authorized administrator of Research Showcase @ CMU. For more information, please contact [email protected].
!"#$% '& ()'+*, -& .0/21436587:9;?3A@.0/21CB(36587D;EnBPo$p!#%$ = # V = q&r !#%$L7N_ $TBs? $L #tZS = @U!BP = # ^`X #'L #t L7Nm$EruL3U S ; S = @U!BP = &r Q#R$vL7NTo#%A"S = @U!BP = # Vw`[\X oBxBy#'L ; = # ^ >E = B ; Q#ML]N L J#tL ; = # VYX #RAT#tL ; = # [ = W>?LoJL #u&r !#%$zL7N o$yBP $$(acLu#'L ; = # ^ o# ;J= ; p&% o$p ; N Lo{QS A!BPQ!#%$cL7N V C = S Q# $ErmQ &t$(A !$)| 9 BxBR ; C = # e f ;o= >Q$) ;T= #R$pL ^ # ; BxB} ; C = # e h ;o= >Q$) ; N L [ = #R$pL ^ |
¢
hJjse-n6pquwv jududp{h4bÎcwhOkm`ElJudj?ed`]km` bZckh6n6`]~qu}pqb?pªv¡`ElJv¡ hJu`]edx4`]n}x8l"ewpqlJ?~q`pqul~{pqb?`]lJeRf\j?bvºcdpqhJb'h"fsp{cwu(slJed`]bZcwuRs~{jsu lJnsn6pcwp{x4` b?h4pqud` qg R l d (s` ew` `]l4v¡ ew` ?ew`]ud` bZcwuzl'sl"ew` bZcgh"fRcw?`}hJsud` ewxJ`EDn d ?l"bn (pquzpqbsn6` U` bsn6`]bZch"fl"~q~AxClJedpªl"s~{`EuapqbOcd?`kmh6n6`]~Rh"cw?` egcwsl"db § 1 3F 2H(/\Y]/¹9H ,:4 WT:58FmQSFG3?I]T:58FGQSFGH«YgQ9R7:FGp= 8v9 !"!#%$"L ; !Bi¢ VYj ^_j?[\j?emfmj?emh ¦ = & = Nmo# ; L #RBA ^_X % A E = #C@BPBs $)Q#R$&% = NZNQL !S !#%$Y # ; ; )&r $) N L QS An!BP!"!#%$ = # VM w ^ \|
¢ ¦ ¢ ¦ * hJcdpªv `}cwsl8cE spqbÎlm?j?ew`k`ElJudj?ew` km` bZckmhGn?` ~ý [ mlJbsn e h 6§ H 4 V 36Y]FGH«Ym>?3658/2r3 (=¹ZF s5836[}B 8_I= S !# Q$ 1 3F 2H(/\Y]/¹9
L7N"Bs $)Q#R$YS = @U!BP VX !$mL7N L S = 3UQBs u[\X Q$ L7NZL3U S ; S = 3UQBP O^`X $E !$ L7NZ ; C egfX e # ; egh?X WBP $)Q#R$+S = @U!BPmC ?&rE VYj ^_j?[\j?ej?emfmj?emh = ; = >!$p ; @>!A@>!B = >uC ?&%E X BxBz ; C3 = # e E% S UL $E !# ; &%L = #R$ = # VYX # ; $Er ;o= >Q$) ; 3>QA@>!B = >uC &rE ; b¡+#' ; U!A$Er¢$ &'BP V j^_j?[ljkegfmjkegh ONQL £" !Q#R$ L ; QBP|
V¢
¢
¦
¦
pqxJ` b
l ~ªl8cw` bZc x8l"ewpqlJ?~q` r4ewlJ?R cw?` cwj??~q` ¢ V j^Zjk[ljke f jke h ¦,pqu p{cwuk`ElJudj?ew` km` bZckmh6n6`]~¹§ µ` pq~{~#uwlCy°lN~ªl8cw` bZcÎx8l"ewpqlJ?~{`»r4ewlJ?pqu sj?ed`»p{fmpc¡uÎkm`]l" udj?ed`]km` bZc kmh6n6`]~ pqu ?j?ew`J l"bsn³cdsl"c²l~qp{b?`El"eN~ªl8cd`]bZc x8l"ewpqlJ?~q`r4ewlJ? pªuÉlÆ~ªl8cw` bZcÉx8l"ewpqlJ?~{` rJe¡l"s p{cd%l ~qp{b?`El"ekm`]lJudj?ew` km` bZckh6n6`]~¹§i?j?ewp¬Uv l8cwp{h4bÎh"fzl ~ªl8cd`]bZc x8l"ewpqlJ?~q`zr4ewlJ?pqul?jsed`~ªl8cw` bZcx8l"ewpqlJ?~{`gr4ewlJ?#h46cwlJp{b?`En Gy Uh4uwupq?~qy0n6` ~q` cwp{bsr uh4k`}hJf:cw?`hJsud` ewxJ`En x8l"ewpªl"?~q`]u]§
¦
g?`»n6` ¬sb?p{cdpqhJbh"fVlkm`ElJudj?ed`]km` bZc kh6n6`]~#ud`Ev p{¬s`]u pqb ?pªv¡glCy hJu`]edx4`]n x8l"ewpªl"?~q`]u}l"ew`p{bsn?pqv]l8cdh4ewuhJfa~ªl8cd`]bZc f2lJv cdh4ewug?j?cn6hG`]ub?hJcv h4bsupªn6`]ezsh8udjsv¡f2lJvºcwhJe¡ul"ew`}ed` ~ªl8cd`EnA§n*h6n6`Eu'pqb [ ew` sed`Eu`]b4cn6` U` bsn?` bZcV~ql"cd` bZc` ewedh4ewu] l"bl"~qhJrJh4jsucdh ` ewedh4e}xClJedpªl"s~{`Eu pqbed`]rJew`]uwupqhJbE $Er $J$xE%d$ &tBs©¢ VYj^Zjk[ljke jke f jke h ¦ = nB = #t BPo$p!#%$ S = @U!BP`C ?&rE # ;©_ M ±£= ³#'L #R]Q &t$(A !$JL7N& = ¡+ > $ = L # L]NT >?En$xE% $ X = #´!S ADC ?&%Eduµ _ M ± X oBxB BPo$p!#%$W#tL ; EroSno$JBP $"$E ¶L@U S ; >E = B ; !# = # µ |
g?`Okmh"cdpqx8l8cwp{h4bSf\hJemew`]¸Zj?pqedpqb?r©l"c~q`]l4uccdsed`]`h4su`]edx4`]n v¡?pq~qn?ed`]b²`]e0~ªl8cd`]bZcpqbX?j?ewp¬Uv l8cwp{h4bsuVhJf£lJedpªud`]umf\ewhJk v h4bsucde¡l"pqb4c¡uhJbpªn6` bZcwp¬lJ?pq~{p{cyJ§ g?pªu-pq~{~a`` xGpªn6` bZc#pqb cds`b?` ¶Gc±ud`]vºcwp{h4bsu] "?` ew`z`zpqbZcdewh6n6jsv `lJbmlJ~{r4hJewpcw?kÉf\h4e ~q`]l"ewb?pqb?r f2lJkmp{~qp{`EuhJf±km`]l4uj?ew` km`]b4ckmhGn?` ~ªu?¢ = S BP!#t> >!BP ¦cwsl8c¬sc#l rJpqxJ` bv h8x8l"ewpªl"bsv `'kVl8cwedp{ ¶ ¯h"fl u` c h"fx8 lJ ed pªl"?~q`]u ^ § g?`lJuwuj?km6cwp{h4bsu j?bsn6`]e ?pªv¡Îcw?`ml"~{ rJh4edp{cdsk³pquv hJewed`Evºcl"ew` cw?`hJsud` ewxJ`En x8l"ewpªl"?~q`]u ^ l"ew`}v hJbZcwp{bGj?h4jsu Å pªu:f2l"p{cd6f\j?~q~qyrJ` bs` e¡l8cd`En}Gy}lJb#j?bs®Zbsh8b?j?ewp¬lJ?~q` ~qp{bs`]l"e~ªl8cw` bZcx8l"ewpqlJ?~{`}r4ewlJ? V¢ VYj^Zjk[ljkemjkegfmjkeghj M ± ¦ºÅ cw?`Vn6pqucdewpq?j6cdpqhJbu hJf ^ V l"bn [ slCx4`'ud`]v h4bsnÎkmhJ km` bZc¡u Å µ`l4ududj?km`cdl8czcd?`km`]lJudj?ew` km` bZc±kmh6n6`]~Upªua~{pqb?`]lJe] Z?j6c z`0n6hÎb?hJcl4ududj?km`Vcdl8c-cw?`0ew` ~ªl8cwp{h4bsuU` cz` ` bScd?`~ql" cd`]bZcwugl"ew`~qp{b?`El"eE 4bshJegn6h#z` l4ududj?km` lJbZyZcw?p{bsr#l"UhJj6czcds` f2l"kmpq~{yh"f(?edh4sl"sp{~qpcyn6pqucdewpq?j6cdpqhJbugh8xJ` e ^ V hJe [ § L # $ = #%$ l"kmhJbsr ud` cwu h"ff\h4j?ex8l"ewpqlJ?~q`]u]§ pqxJ` bOcw?`#v h8x8lJedpªl"bsv `}kml"cdewp¶Oh"f(f\hJj?e e¡l"bsn6h4k,x8l"ewpªl"?~q`]Yu §$# j&%qj'mj)( «Z 4z`slCx4`gcdsl"*c `]edh JhJbs` hJegcw?ew` `}h"f(cd?`}f\h4~{~qh8pqb?rv hJbsucde¡l"pqbZcwuzkVlCy ?h4~qn +-, .*+0/21 +-, /5+0.41 +-, .*+0/21
+0, /3+0.41 +0, 1+0.4/ +0, 1+0.4/
ÌZc¡l8cdpªucdpªv l"~ cd`]ucwu»f\hJecd` cde¡lJnv h4bsucde¡l"pqb4c¡uhJeSx8l"bspqud?pqb?r cd` cde¡lJnXn?pÇ«` ew` bsv `]uOl"ew`ucde¡l"pqrJZcf\h4edgl"e¡nNlJuwujskpqb?rSbshJed kVl"~v h8xClJedpªl8cw`]u]§ gs`Îv hJbucwewlJp{bZcwumv]l"b ` cw`]ucd`]nf\h4e l ~ªl"ewrJ` ef2l"kmpq~{y°h"fn?pqucdewp{sj6cdpqhJbsu jupqb?rf\hJj?edcdkmhJkm` bZcwu ¢2´zh4~{~q` bR z7 686Z¦º§ gs` pqe#x8l"~qj?` ~qp{`Eupqb»cd?` f2lJvºc#cdsl"c#x8l"ed pqhJjsu-udpqks~{`0´glCy4`]u}b?` c#ucwedjsv cdj?ew`]u-p{km?~qyv¡l"e¡lJvºcw` ewpqucdpªv udj?sud` cwu0h"f}hZududpq?~{`Îcd` cwewl4n²v h4bsucwewlJp{bZc¡uf\hJe0udy6ucw` kVu pqb ?pªv¡ hJu`]edx4`]nx8l"ewpqlJ?~{`Eun6`]`]bsnV~qp{b?`El"ew~{yhJbV~ªl8cw` bZcw u l udp{b?r4~{`0~ql"cd` bZcmv l"ju` hJff\hJj?ehJu`]edx4`]nx8l"ewpqlJ?~{`Eu-pqkm?~{pq`]u l"~q~}cdsed`]`x8lJb?pqud?pqb?rcd` cwewl4n?u]Å'lNupqb?r4~{`~ªl8cd`]bZc v]l"jsud`h"f cdsed`]`h4su`]edx4`]nx8l"ewpªl"?~q`]ul"bsnl"b?hJcd?`]e'~ªl8cw` bZcVv l"ju`h"f lf\hJjsecwOh4sud` ewxJ`]n0x8l"ewpqlJ?~{`4 ?pqks~{pq`]ulJ~{~Rcd?ew` `x8l"bspqud?pqb?r cd` cde¡lJn?u] «b?hOkml"ccw` e}?h8cds`~ªl8cw` bZcwu}lJed`'ed`]~ql"cd`]nRÅRl0udp{b6 rJ~q`~ªl8cw` bZcv l"ju` h"fRczh#h4su`]edx4`]nmx8l"ewpªl"?~q`]ual"bsnl"b?hJcd?`]e ~ªl8cd`]bZcmv]l"jsud`0hJfcahh"cds` ehJsud` ewxJ`EnxClJedpªl"s~{`Eu pqkm?~{pq`]u ` ¶?l4vºcd~qySh4b?` xClJb?pªu?pqb?rcd` cde¡lJnA z` c¡v"§¯¢ ~{yGkmhJj?eE z` c l"~ý§{ 689;:J¦º§ 7 ® -0/ K'=¹T:I]Y]FZ58/2H 3?H:7²/¹Q»[T ?A@CB;DEGFH? ¢ ;RFZY Å g¦v hJj?bZc¡ucds`bGj?k#U` e h"fcd` cde¡lJnv hJbucwewlJp{bZcwu:cwsl8c?h4~qnl"kmh4b?r `]~{`]km` bZcwupqb ;RFZY ?pªv¡lCxJ`'lOv h8x8lJedpªl"bsv `#kVl8cwedp{¶©lJu}lOujs?kVl8cdewp{¶Îh"If l"bnm?` ew`f\hJeab?hcwedpq?~qT` §7J j&KcjML «ON ; ?A@;BCDEXFH? pªun?` ¬sb?`En cwhU` ]` ewhs§ pqxJ` b©cd?`mv h8x8lJedpªl"bsv `-kVl8cwedp{¶ h"f
l#ud` czh"fRx8l"ewpªl"?~q`]ualJu±lJb pqb??j6cE 6p{b h4j6cd~qpqb?`cw?`sedh6v `En6j?ew` pªu J§gpªn6` bZcwpf\yÉ?pªv¡,x8lJedpªl"?~q`]ul"ew`Sj?bsv hJewed`]~ql"cd`EnAÅ0udjsv¡ x8l"ewpªl"?~q`]ugv lJb?b?hJcgU`pqbcw?`-uwl"km`v ~qjsucw` eEÅ 6§gpªn6` bZcwpf\yD?pqv¡slJp{e¡u h"fx8l"ewpqlJ?~{`Eu»¢ J j&K ¦ v]l"b?b?hJc f\h4edk!lmhJb?` ¹f2l4vºcdh4ekmhGn?` ~7$? HB 7¢ §7J # « § pqb (l"?~q`#4§ ` ew`J Zj xClJj&ed% pªl"sj ~{`EuKv§$j&'m# j&j)( %Dj&'mj)( «l"ew`hJcd?`]e x8l"ewpªl"?~q`]uzpqbcw?`-v h8x8lJedpªl"bsv ` kVl"cdewp¶AÅ
§gpªn6` bZcwpf\ymv ~qpq¸Zj?`Euf\h4edkm`]nmGy'xClJedpªl"s~{`Eu?` ew`b?h-l"pqe glJu~ªl"U` ~q`]n»l4upqbsv h4kl8cdpq?~q` GylJbGy©h"fgcw?`Vcdsed`]` v edp{cd`]edpªl'lJh8x4`J§ (l"?~q` ` cwj?ewbsucwedj?`#hJb?~qy0p{fb?hVx8l"ewpqlJ?~q`p{b ^ slJul v h4kmkh4bl"ew` bZcpcwÎl"bGy x8l"ewpqlJ?~q`pqb ^ §g?`-uyGk'h4~ P AT 'ew` ?ew`]ud` bZc¡ucds`#slJecwpqlJ~:v h4edew` ~ªl8cwp{h4b h"v f 0lJbsn 'v hJbsn6p{cdpqhJbs`]nhJd b 4§ ízå4ò¡ÓÛÙZÕ×ÖÒwØÒ¡ ß "!#%$&('*)+& ,-)+&(.-/C0é 213#%$&54*)+& 67)+& 89/:)=?= @BAC $& ~ )+&ED/ FG "!2HI 21Z*é & ~ ÞÛÕÙZåZòwÚ]ØÜØÒ¡ÓÔ ÖÒ¡ß'àÞïÖG Ñ &ED JK7L-MNJO ÖÜØÙZÒ
KQPSC RTKGJK7L-MNJO \ ]_ ` & 4 )U& 6 F !WV 1 )YX[Z Z I#^ \ ]_ C &54[)U& 6:)U& 8aFb "! V 21[)cX Z Z :d Z ON#^ C0f Fb "!7)?gih Z g Z Z #^gih Z g Z Z #jgkOeh ` Z g Z Z _ ON` C0f Fb 1 )?g h Z lmgiZ n?Z0oW#^g h Z npgiZ l-Z0oW#^g h Z o L S = o#t> $ = L7N Q$¢L]NGL3U S ; # ; L S = @U!BP n^ |tE%Q# X a = BxBU = #$xE%¢" !Q#R$ = S BsQ#'>?³>!BP i i ^Zj X o# ; >E>!BP a = BxBgU? C = S!# UQA´$Er¶? Q!#%$m&% $($p #5L@U!$p = #t ; $xE L CE $ c= # :; QQ#R$ Y $($p # ^_j \|
¢ g¦ ¢ g¦
W T:58/21J36YE/29UH iÉkm`]l4ujsed`]k`]bZcsl8cdcd`]edb pªub?hJc lVkm`]l4ujsed`]k`]bZckh6n6`]~¹§ ?j6cp{cpquzUh4uwupq?~q`cwh#¬sbnlJ~{~«?j?ew`}km`]lJudj?ew` km` bZczkh6n6`]~qu h"f0cd?` j?b?®Gb?h8b,cdewj?`r4ewlJ?Éf\ewhJk cw?`km`ElJudj?ed`]km` bZc sl"ccd`]edb?LoS = #'>?` $ = L7ND !$TL7NqL@U S ; # ; L S = @U!BP O^ | !$ i iU?Z$xE%_" QQ#R$&ro$b$) # >L &rLo# ;o= #C{$pL $Er = S BP!#t>:>QBs i i ^_j !| Q$ 656 UW$Er !$ L7N" BxBt& = ¡> $ = L # L7NTi iY| 'Er!# 656 _± |
¢ g¦
M
K'9s589U=2=¹365CP ¢
!S A & L = UQBs % & = % L]N L / & ¡ @ ! U P B B t # s B ) $ Q R # $ S @ ! U P B C ? % & E = = = V j^Zjk[ jkem0@jkegf(3jkeghYoj ± J # ; ¨ V j ^_j?[ j NQ = $E N BxB A C3!#t o$ = # C X $Er emk@j?emf(jkegh 3j ± >L S = o#t>J"o$ = L7N ^`X acTEr S ± 2 ± |
M ¦
M ¦
M
¢
M
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
¿ ÂÜ g?`ÎlJ~{r4hJewpcw?kVuma` slCx4` n?pquwv jsuwud`]nf\hJe ~q`]lJedb?pqb?rkm`]l" udj?ed`]km` bZc sl"ccw` ewbsu lJbsn ?jsed`'k`ElJudj?ew` km` bZc kmh6n6`]~qul"ew` ` ¶6UhJb?`]bZcdpªl"~RpqbOcd?`-zhJe¡ucv]lJud`J sudpqbsv `}cw?` yOed`E¸Zj?p{ew`¬sbsnG pqb?rmkml"¶6p{kVl"~AlJbsn0kVl"¶Gpqk#jsk³v ~qpq¸Zj?`Eu § g?` Eye7>7$? HB cd`Eucpc¡u`]~fkVlCyed`E¸4jsp{ewD` m¢ ª ¦-ucd`]su cds` bGj?k#U` e'h"f x8l"ewpqlJ?~q`]u]§±ÌGjsv¡ v hZuc¡ugkmlCy0~{pqkmpccw?`#lJ??~qpqv]l8cdpqhJbOh"fhJjse ?ewh6v `]n?j?ed`f\h4e-~qlJedr4` e?ewhJs~{`]kmu] @ ¢ý j ¦lJbsn % $> @ ¢ j J¦º «?`]ed``]l4v¡ÎhJbs` sl4u'sedpqhJem?ewhJslJ?pq~{p{cyh"f s§ ?§ ±l4v¡S` ewewhJe'cd` ewk [ U pqu n6pªucwedpq?j6cw`]n l4ulmkmp¶Gcdjsed`-hJfl % $> @ ¢ j J¦gl"bnOcd?`#udyGk km` cwedpªvVh"fl % $> @ ¢¹ j ¦º (?` ew`V`]l4v¡v hJkmUhJb?`]b4c-pqbcds` kmp¶Gcwj?ed`'slJul sedpqhJe ?edh4sl"sp{~qpcycdl8c}pqu j?b?p{f\hJewkm~{y n6pªu cdewpq?j6cd`En²pqb j ý lJbsn cd?`kmp¶Gcdjsed`ÎsedpqhJe¡u0lJed`În6e¡lCb pqbsn6pqxZpªn6jslJ~{~qy f\h4e`]l4v¡~ªl8cw` bZcp{¶b §l ¨ ¥ © «Z§ g?`` ewedh4e cd`]edkVuaf\hJegcw?`}p{bn6pqv]l8cwhJe¡ualJ~qudh#f\h4~{~qh8°j l'kmj p¶Gcdjsed`}h"f:` cwlJu ¢¹ ¦l"bsnO¢ J¦ J`ElJv¡hJb?`p{cdVl}kmp¶6pqb?r}?ewhJUhJedcdpqhJbp{b6 n6pqxGj pqn6jl"~q~{y v¡?j hZu`]bÎlJv v hJe¡n6pqb?rVcdhOl j?bspf\h4edkn6pªucwedpq?j6cwp{h4b pqb ק¨Üb ?ewp{bsv p{s~{`4 6cd?`'lJudyZkm6cwh"cwpqv}n6pªucwedpq?j6cwp{h4bOf\ed`]` cd`Eucjh"fgcd` cde¡lJnSv hJbsucde¡l"pqbZcwu}f\ewhJk ¢2´zh4~{~q` bR g$ 6 6Z¦}ushJj?~ªn U`0cw?`0km` cw?h6nShJf v¡?hJpªv `0pfcw?` n?l8c¡l©n6hG`]u'b?hJc'sl4udu'l b?h4edkVl"~qp{cycw`]uc]§ h8z` xJ`]e] ujsv¡°cd`Euc jsud`]ucd?`f\h4j?ecw kmhJkm` bZc¡u±hJfUcw?`` km?pqedpªv lJ~n6pªucwedpq?j6cwp{h4bR G?pªv¡ v l"b cwl"®4` l ~qhJb?r cwp{km`mcdhv hJkm?j?cd`Vp{fzcw?` bGj?k'`]e-h"fgx8l"ewpqlJ?~{`Eu}pqu ~ªl"ewrJ`¢2udp{bv `p{cRcwlJ®J`Eu m¢ © ¦Rucw` su] ]s` ew` ,pªu«cd?`±bZjsk' U` e}h"fansl8cwlUhJpqb4c¡ul"bsn pªucw?`mbGj?k#U` e}h"faxClJedpªl"s~{`Euw¦ § _zlJv¡sp{b?r l~ªl"ewrJ`kVl8cdewp{¶Xh"f#f\h4j?edcd°kmh4k`]bZcwuOkVlCy²ed` ¸Zj?pqed`ud`]v h4bsn?lJedy km`]kh4edyucwhJe¡l"rJ`4 Gj?b?~q`]uwuhJb?`}pªupq~{~qp{bsr cdhslCyf\hJek#j?~{cdpq?~q`#sl4udud`]ucd?ewhJj?r4 cd?`mn?l"cwl ud` c` xJ`]edy cdpqkm`-lcd`Eucpªun6`]kmlJbsn6`Enh4epflm~ªl"ewrJ`}l"kmhJj?bZchJsf i | pªulCx8l"pq~qlJ?~{`4§¨Üb ?e¡lJvºcwpqv `J ?ew`]ud`]lJewv¡s` e¡u±kVlCy0U`j?bGpq~{~qp{bsr hJejsbsl"?~q`cwhrJh}cdh}cw?`cwedh4j??~q`J§(µ`slCx4`gcd?`]ed` f\hJew`gjsu`En cds`µ²pªudsl"edccw`]ucV¢¹u`]`mÌ6?p{edcd`Eu` cl"~ý§{
Research Showcase @ CMU Department of Philosophy
Dietrich College of Humanities and Social Sciences
8-2003
Learning Measurement Models for Unobserved Variables Ricardo Silva Carnegie Mellon University
Richard Scheines Carnegie Mellon University
Clark Glymour Carnegie Mellon University
Peter Spirtes Carnegie Mellon University
Follow this and additional works at: http://repository.cmu.edu/philosophy Part of the Philosophy Commons
This Article is brought to you for free and open access by the Dietrich College of Humanities and Social Sciences at Research Showcase @ CMU. It has been accepted for inclusion in Department of Philosophy by an authorized administrator of Research Showcase @ CMU. For more information, please contact [email protected].
!"#$% '& ()'+*, -& .0/21436587:9;?3A@.0/21CB(36587D;EnBPo$p!#%$ = # V = q&r !#%$L7N_ $TBs? $L #tZS = @U!BP = # ^`X #'L #t L7Nm$EruL3U S ; S = @U!BP = &r Q#R$vL7NTo#%A"S = @U!BP = # Vw`[\X oBxBy#'L ; = # ^ >E = B ; Q#ML]N L J#tL ; = # VYX #RAT#tL ; = # [ = W>?LoJL #u&r !#%$zL7N o$yBP $$(acLu#'L ; = # ^ o# ;J= ; p&% o$p ; N Lo{QS A!BPQ!#%$cL7N V C = S Q# $ErmQ &t$(A !$)| 9 BxBR ; C = # e f ;o= >Q$) ;T= #R$pL ^ # ; BxB} ; C = # e h ;o= >Q$) ; N L [ = #R$pL ^ |
¢
hJjse-n6pquwv jududp{h4bÎcwhOkm`ElJudj?ed`]km` bZckh6n6`]~qu}pqb?pªv¡`ElJv¡ hJu`]edx4`]n}x8l"ewpqlJ?~q`pqul~{pqb?`]lJeRf\j?bvºcdpqhJb'h"fsp{cwu(slJed`]bZcwuRs~{jsu lJnsn6pcwp{x4` b?h4pqud` qg R l d (s` ew` `]l4v¡ ew` ?ew`]ud` bZcwuzl'sl"ew` bZcgh"fRcw?`}hJsud` ewxJ`EDn d ?l"bn (pquzpqbsn6` U` bsn6`]bZch"fl"~q~AxClJedpªl"s~{`EuapqbOcd?`kmh6n6`]~Rh"cw?` egcwsl"db § 1 3F 2H(/\Y]/¹9H ,:4 WT:58FmQSFG3?I]T:58FGQSFGH«YgQ9R7:FGp= 8v9 !"!#%$"L ; !Bi¢ VYj ^_j?[\j?emfmj?emh ¦ = & = Nmo# ; L #RBA ^_X % A E = #C@BPBs $)Q#R$&% = NZNQL !S !#%$Y # ; ; )&r $) N L QS An!BP!"!#%$ = # VM w ^ \|
¢ ¦ ¢ ¦ * hJcdpªv `}cwsl8cE spqbÎlm?j?ew`k`ElJudj?ew` km` bZckmhGn?` ~ý [ mlJbsn e h 6§ H 4 V 36Y]FGH«Ym>?3658/2r3 (=¹ZF s5836[}B 8_I= S !# Q$ 1 3F 2H(/\Y]/¹9
L7N"Bs $)Q#R$YS = @U!BP VX !$mL7N L S = 3UQBs u[\X Q$ L7NZL3U S ; S = 3UQBP O^`X $E !$ L7NZ ; C egfX e # ; egh?X WBP $)Q#R$+S = @U!BPmC ?&rE VYj ^_j?[\j?ej?emfmj?emh = ; = >!$p ; @>!A@>!B = >uC ?&%E X BxBz ; C3 = # e E% S UL $E !# ; &%L = #R$ = # VYX # ; $Er ;o= >Q$) ; 3>QA@>!B = >uC &rE ; b¡+#' ; U!A$Er¢$ &'BP V j^_j?[ljkegfmjkegh ONQL £" !Q#R$ L ; QBP|
V¢
¢
¦
¦
pqxJ` b
l ~ªl8cw` bZc x8l"ewpqlJ?~q` r4ewlJ?R cw?` cwj??~q` ¢ V j^Zjk[ljke f jke h ¦,pqu p{cwuk`ElJudj?ew` km` bZckmh6n6`]~¹§ µ` pq~{~#uwlCy°lN~ªl8cw` bZcÎx8l"ewpqlJ?~{`»r4ewlJ?pqu sj?ed`»p{fmpc¡uÎkm`]l" udj?ed`]km` bZc kmh6n6`]~ pqu ?j?ew`J l"bsn³cdsl"c²l~qp{b?`El"eN~ªl8cd`]bZc x8l"ewpqlJ?~q`r4ewlJ? pªuÉlÆ~ªl8cw` bZcÉx8l"ewpqlJ?~{` rJe¡l"s p{cd%l ~qp{b?`El"ekm`]lJudj?ew` km` bZckh6n6`]~¹§i?j?ewp¬Uv l8cwp{h4bÎh"fzl ~ªl8cd`]bZc x8l"ewpqlJ?~q`zr4ewlJ?pqul?jsed`~ªl8cw` bZcx8l"ewpqlJ?~{`gr4ewlJ?#h46cwlJp{b?`En Gy Uh4uwupq?~qy0n6` ~q` cwp{bsr uh4k`}hJf:cw?`hJsud` ewxJ`En x8l"ewpªl"?~q`]u]§
¦
g?`»n6` ¬sb?p{cdpqhJbh"fVlkm`ElJudj?ed`]km` bZc kh6n6`]~#ud`Ev p{¬s`]u pqb ?pªv¡glCy hJu`]edx4`]n x8l"ewpªl"?~q`]u}l"ew`p{bsn?pqv]l8cdh4ewuhJfa~ªl8cd`]bZc f2lJv cdh4ewug?j?cn6hG`]ub?hJcv h4bsupªn6`]ezsh8udjsv¡f2lJvºcwhJe¡ul"ew`}ed` ~ªl8cd`EnA§n*h6n6`Eu'pqb [ ew` sed`Eu`]b4cn6` U` bsn?` bZcV~ql"cd` bZc` ewedh4ewu] l"bl"~qhJrJh4jsucdh ` ewedh4e}xClJedpªl"s~{`Eu pqbed`]rJew`]uwupqhJbE $Er $J$xE%d$ &tBs©¢ VYj^Zjk[ljke jke f jke h ¦ = nB = #t BPo$p!#%$ S = @U!BP`C ?&rE # ;©_ M ±£= ³#'L #R]Q &t$(A !$JL7N& = ¡+ > $ = L # L]NT >?En$xE% $ X = #´!S ADC ?&%Eduµ _ M ± X oBxB BPo$p!#%$W#tL ; EroSno$JBP $"$E ¶L@U S ; >E = B ; !# = # µ |
g?`Okmh"cdpqx8l8cwp{h4bSf\hJemew`]¸Zj?pqedpqb?r©l"c~q`]l4uccdsed`]`h4su`]edx4`]n v¡?pq~qn?ed`]b²`]e0~ªl8cd`]bZcpqbX?j?ewp¬Uv l8cwp{h4bsuVhJf£lJedpªud`]umf\ewhJk v h4bsucde¡l"pqb4c¡uhJbpªn6` bZcwp¬lJ?pq~{p{cyJ§ g?pªu-pq~{~a`` xGpªn6` bZc#pqb cds`b?` ¶Gc±ud`]vºcwp{h4bsu] "?` ew`z`zpqbZcdewh6n6jsv `lJbmlJ~{r4hJewpcw?kÉf\h4e ~q`]l"ewb?pqb?r f2lJkmp{~qp{`EuhJf±km`]l4uj?ew` km`]b4ckmhGn?` ~ªu?¢ = S BP!#t> >!BP ¦cwsl8c¬sc#l rJpqxJ` bv h8x8l"ewpªl"bsv `'kVl8cwedp{ ¶ ¯h"fl u` c h"fx8 lJ ed pªl"?~q`]u ^ § g?`lJuwuj?km6cwp{h4bsu j?bsn6`]e ?pªv¡Îcw?`ml"~{ rJh4edp{cdsk³pquv hJewed`Evºcl"ew` cw?`hJsud` ewxJ`En x8l"ewpªl"?~q`]u ^ l"ew`}v hJbZcwp{bGj?h4jsu Å pªu:f2l"p{cd6f\j?~q~qyrJ` bs` e¡l8cd`En}Gy}lJb#j?bs®Zbsh8b?j?ewp¬lJ?~q` ~qp{bs`]l"e~ªl8cw` bZcx8l"ewpqlJ?~{`}r4ewlJ? V¢ VYj^Zjk[ljkemjkegfmjkeghj M ± ¦ºÅ cw?`Vn6pqucdewpq?j6cdpqhJbu hJf ^ V l"bn [ slCx4`'ud`]v h4bsnÎkmhJ km` bZc¡u Å µ`l4ududj?km`cdl8czcd?`km`]lJudj?ew` km` bZc±kmh6n6`]~Upªua~{pqb?`]lJe] Z?j6c z`0n6hÎb?hJcl4ududj?km`Vcdl8c-cw?`0ew` ~ªl8cwp{h4bsuU` cz` ` bScd?`~ql" cd`]bZcwugl"ew`~qp{b?`El"eE 4bshJegn6h#z` l4ududj?km` lJbZyZcw?p{bsr#l"UhJj6czcds` f2l"kmpq~{yh"f(?edh4sl"sp{~qpcyn6pqucdewpq?j6cdpqhJbugh8xJ` e ^ V hJe [ § L # $ = #%$ l"kmhJbsr ud` cwu h"ff\h4j?ex8l"ewpqlJ?~q`]u]§ pqxJ` bOcw?`#v h8x8lJedpªl"bsv `}kml"cdewp¶Oh"f(f\hJj?e e¡l"bsn6h4k,x8l"ewpªl"?~q`]Yu §$# j&%qj'mj)( «Z 4z`slCx4`gcdsl"*c `]edh JhJbs` hJegcw?ew` `}h"f(cd?`}f\h4~{~qh8pqb?rv hJbsucde¡l"pqbZcwuzkVlCy ?h4~qn +-, .*+0/21 +-, /5+0.41 +-, .*+0/21
+0, /3+0.41 +0, 1+0.4/ +0, 1+0.4/
ÌZc¡l8cdpªucdpªv l"~ cd`]ucwu»f\hJecd` cde¡lJnv h4bsucde¡l"pqb4c¡uhJeSx8l"bspqud?pqb?r cd` cde¡lJnXn?pÇ«` ew` bsv `]uOl"ew`ucde¡l"pqrJZcf\h4edgl"e¡nNlJuwujskpqb?rSbshJed kVl"~v h8xClJedpªl8cw`]u]§ gs`Îv hJbucwewlJp{bZcwumv]l"b ` cw`]ucd`]nf\h4e l ~ªl"ewrJ` ef2l"kmpq~{y°h"fn?pqucdewp{sj6cdpqhJbsu jupqb?rf\hJj?edcdkmhJkm` bZcwu ¢2´zh4~{~q` bR z7 686Z¦º§ gs` pqe#x8l"~qj?` ~qp{`Eupqb»cd?` f2lJvºc#cdsl"c#x8l"ed pqhJjsu-udpqks~{`0´glCy4`]u}b?` c#ucwedjsv cdj?ew`]u-p{km?~qyv¡l"e¡lJvºcw` ewpqucdpªv udj?sud` cwu0h"f}hZududpq?~{`Îcd` cwewl4n²v h4bsucwewlJp{bZc¡uf\hJe0udy6ucw` kVu pqb ?pªv¡ hJu`]edx4`]nx8l"ewpqlJ?~{`Eun6`]`]bsnV~qp{b?`El"ew~{yhJbV~ªl8cw` bZcw u l udp{b?r4~{`0~ql"cd` bZcmv l"ju` hJff\hJj?ehJu`]edx4`]nx8l"ewpqlJ?~{`Eu-pqkm?~{pq`]u l"~q~}cdsed`]`x8lJb?pqud?pqb?rcd` cwewl4n?u]Å'lNupqb?r4~{`~ªl8cd`]bZc v]l"jsud`h"f cdsed`]`h4su`]edx4`]nx8l"ewpªl"?~q`]ul"bsnl"b?hJcd?`]e'~ªl8cw` bZcVv l"ju`h"f lf\hJjsecwOh4sud` ewxJ`]n0x8l"ewpqlJ?~{`4 ?pqks~{pq`]ulJ~{~Rcd?ew` `x8l"bspqud?pqb?r cd` cde¡lJn?u] «b?hOkml"ccw` e}?h8cds`~ªl8cw` bZcwu}lJed`'ed`]~ql"cd`]nRÅRl0udp{b6 rJ~q`~ªl8cw` bZcv l"ju` h"fRczh#h4su`]edx4`]nmx8l"ewpªl"?~q`]ual"bsnl"b?hJcd?`]e ~ªl8cd`]bZcmv]l"jsud`0hJfcahh"cds` ehJsud` ewxJ`EnxClJedpªl"s~{`Eu pqkm?~{pq`]u ` ¶?l4vºcd~qySh4b?` xClJb?pªu?pqb?rcd` cde¡lJnA z` c¡v"§¯¢ ~{yGkmhJj?eE z` c l"~ý§{ 689;:J¦º§ 7 ® -0/ K'=¹T:I]Y]FZ58/2H 3?H:7²/¹Q»[T ?A@CB;DEGFH? ¢ ;RFZY Å g¦v hJj?bZc¡ucds`bGj?k#U` e h"fcd` cde¡lJnv hJbucwewlJp{bZcwu:cwsl8c?h4~qnl"kmh4b?r `]~{`]km` bZcwupqb ;RFZY ?pªv¡lCxJ`'lOv h8x8lJedpªl"bsv `#kVl8cwedp{¶©lJu}lOujs?kVl8cdewp{¶Îh"If l"bnm?` ew`f\hJeab?hcwedpq?~qT` §7J j&KcjML «ON ; ?A@;BCDEXFH? pªun?` ¬sb?`En cwhU` ]` ewhs§ pqxJ` b©cd?`mv h8x8lJedpªl"bsv `-kVl8cwedp{¶ h"f
l#ud` czh"fRx8l"ewpªl"?~q`]ualJu±lJb pqb??j6cE 6p{b h4j6cd~qpqb?`cw?`sedh6v `En6j?ew` pªu J§gpªn6` bZcwpf\yÉ?pªv¡,x8lJedpªl"?~q`]ul"ew`Sj?bsv hJewed`]~ql"cd`EnAÅ0udjsv¡ x8l"ewpªl"?~q`]ugv lJb?b?hJcgU`pqbcw?`-uwl"km`v ~qjsucw` eEÅ 6§gpªn6` bZcwpf\yD?pqv¡slJp{e¡u h"fx8l"ewpqlJ?~{`Eu»¢ J j&K ¦ v]l"b?b?hJc f\h4edk!lmhJb?` ¹f2l4vºcdh4ekmhGn?` ~7$? HB 7¢ §7J # « § pqb (l"?~q`#4§ ` ew`J Zj xClJj&ed% pªl"sj ~{`EuKv§$j&'m# j&j)( %Dj&'mj)( «l"ew`hJcd?`]e x8l"ewpªl"?~q`]uzpqbcw?`-v h8x8lJedpªl"bsv ` kVl"cdewp¶AÅ
§gpªn6` bZcwpf\ymv ~qpq¸Zj?`Euf\h4edkm`]nmGy'xClJedpªl"s~{`Eu?` ew`b?h-l"pqe glJu~ªl"U` ~q`]n»l4upqbsv h4kl8cdpq?~q` GylJbGy©h"fgcw?`Vcdsed`]` v edp{cd`]edpªl'lJh8x4`J§ (l"?~q` ` cwj?ewbsucwedj?`#hJb?~qy0p{fb?hVx8l"ewpqlJ?~q`p{b ^ slJul v h4kmkh4bl"ew` bZcpcwÎl"bGy x8l"ewpqlJ?~q`pqb ^ §g?`-uyGk'h4~ P AT 'ew` ?ew`]ud` bZc¡ucds`#slJecwpqlJ~:v h4edew` ~ªl8cwp{h4b h"v f 0lJbsn 'v hJbsn6p{cdpqhJbs`]nhJd b 4§ ízå4ò¡ÓÛÙZÕ×ÖÒwØÒ¡ ß "!#%$&('*)+& ,-)+&(.-/C0é 213#%$&54*)+& 67)+& 89/:)=?= @BAC $& ~ )+&ED/ FG "!2HI 21Z*é & ~ ÞÛÕÙZåZòwÚ]ØÜØÒ¡ÓÔ ÖÒ¡ß'àÞïÖG Ñ &ED JK7L-MNJO ÖÜØÙZÒ
KQPSC RTKGJK7L-MNJO \ ]_ ` & 4 )U& 6 F !WV 1 )YX[Z Z I#^ \ ]_ C &54[)U& 6:)U& 8aFb "! V 21[)cX Z Z :d Z ON#^ C0f Fb "!7)?gih Z g Z Z #^gih Z g Z Z #jgkOeh ` Z g Z Z _ ON` C0f Fb 1 )?g h Z lmgiZ n?Z0oW#^g h Z npgiZ l-Z0oW#^g h Z o L S = o#t> $ = L7N Q$¢L]NGL3U S ; # ; L S = @U!BP n^ |tE%Q# X a = BxBU = #$xE%¢" !Q#R$ = S BsQ#'>?³>!BP i i ^Zj X o# ; >E>!BP a = BxBgU? C = S!# UQA´$Er¶? Q!#%$m&% $($p #5L@U!$p = #t ; $xE L CE $ c= # :; QQ#R$ Y $($p # ^_j \|
¢ g¦ ¢ g¦
W T:58/21J36YE/29UH iÉkm`]l4ujsed`]k`]bZcsl8cdcd`]edb pªub?hJc lVkm`]l4ujsed`]k`]bZckh6n6`]~¹§ ?j6cp{cpquzUh4uwupq?~q`cwh#¬sbnlJ~{~«?j?ew`}km`]lJudj?ew` km` bZczkh6n6`]~qu h"f0cd?` j?b?®Gb?h8b,cdewj?`r4ewlJ?Éf\ewhJk cw?`km`ElJudj?ed`]km` bZc sl"ccd`]edb?LoS = #'>?` $ = L7ND !$TL7NqL@U S ; # ; L S = @U!BP O^ | !$ i iU?Z$xE%_" QQ#R$&ro$b$) # >L &rLo# ;o= #C{$pL $Er = S BP!#t>:>QBs i i ^_j !| Q$ 656 UW$Er !$ L7N" BxBt& = ¡> $ = L # L7NTi iY| 'Er!# 656 _± |
¢ g¦
M
K'9s589U=2=¹365CP ¢
!S A & L = UQBs % & = % L]N L / & ¡ @ ! U P B B t # s B ) $ Q R # $ S @ ! U P B C ? % & E = = = V j^Zjk[ jkem0@jkegf(3jkeghYoj ± J # ; ¨ V j ^_j?[ j NQ = $E N BxB A C3!#t o$ = # C X $Er emk@j?emf(jkegh 3j ± >L S = o#t>J"o$ = L7N ^`X acTEr S ± 2 ± |
M ¦
M ¦
M
¢
M
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
¿ ÂÜ g?`ÎlJ~{r4hJewpcw?kVuma` slCx4` n?pquwv jsuwud`]nf\hJe ~q`]lJedb?pqb?rkm`]l" udj?ed`]km` bZc sl"ccw` ewbsu lJbsn ?jsed`'k`ElJudj?ew` km` bZc kmh6n6`]~qul"ew` ` ¶6UhJb?`]bZcdpªl"~RpqbOcd?`-zhJe¡ucv]lJud`J sudpqbsv `}cw?` yOed`E¸Zj?p{ew`¬sbsnG pqb?rmkml"¶6p{kVl"~AlJbsn0kVl"¶Gpqk#jsk³v ~qpq¸Zj?`Eu § g?` Eye7>7$? HB cd`Eucpc¡u`]~fkVlCyed`E¸4jsp{ewD` m¢ ª ¦-ucd`]su cds` bGj?k#U` e'h"f x8l"ewpqlJ?~q`]u]§±ÌGjsv¡ v hZuc¡ugkmlCy0~{pqkmpccw?`#lJ??~qpqv]l8cdpqhJbOh"fhJjse ?ewh6v `]n?j?ed`f\h4e-~qlJedr4` e?ewhJs~{`]kmu] @ ¢ý j ¦lJbsn % $> @ ¢ j J¦º «?`]ed``]l4v¡ÎhJbs` sl4u'sedpqhJem?ewhJslJ?pq~{p{cyh"f s§ ?§ ±l4v¡S` ewewhJe'cd` ewk [ U pqu n6pªucwedpq?j6cw`]n l4ulmkmp¶Gcdjsed`-hJfl % $> @ ¢ j J¦gl"bnOcd?`#udyGk km` cwedpªvVh"fl % $> @ ¢¹ j ¦º (?` ew`V`]l4v¡v hJkmUhJb?`]b4c-pqbcds` kmp¶Gcwj?ed`'slJul sedpqhJe ?edh4sl"sp{~qpcycdl8c}pqu j?b?p{f\hJewkm~{y n6pªu cdewpq?j6cd`En²pqb j ý lJbsn cd?`kmp¶Gcdjsed`ÎsedpqhJe¡u0lJed`În6e¡lCb pqbsn6pqxZpªn6jslJ~{~qy f\h4e`]l4v¡~ªl8cw` bZcp{¶b §l ¨ ¥ © «Z§ g?`` ewedh4e cd`]edkVuaf\hJegcw?`}p{bn6pqv]l8cwhJe¡ualJ~qudh#f\h4~{~qh8°j l'kmj p¶Gcdjsed`}h"f:` cwlJu ¢¹ ¦l"bsnO¢ J¦ J`ElJv¡hJb?`p{cdVl}kmp¶6pqb?r}?ewhJUhJedcdpqhJbp{b6 n6pqxGj pqn6jl"~q~{y v¡?j hZu`]bÎlJv v hJe¡n6pqb?rVcdhOl j?bspf\h4edkn6pªucwedpq?j6cwp{h4b pqb ק¨Üb ?ewp{bsv p{s~{`4 6cd?`'lJudyZkm6cwh"cwpqv}n6pªucwedpq?j6cwp{h4bOf\ed`]` cd`Eucjh"fgcd` cde¡lJnSv hJbsucde¡l"pqbZcwu}f\ewhJk ¢2´zh4~{~q` bR g$ 6 6Z¦}ushJj?~ªn U`0cw?`0km` cw?h6nShJf v¡?hJpªv `0pfcw?` n?l8c¡l©n6hG`]u'b?hJc'sl4udu'l b?h4edkVl"~qp{cycw`]uc]§ h8z` xJ`]e] ujsv¡°cd`Euc jsud`]ucd?`f\h4j?ecw kmhJkm` bZc¡u±hJfUcw?`` km?pqedpªv lJ~n6pªucwedpq?j6cwp{h4bR G?pªv¡ v l"b cwl"®4` l ~qhJb?r cwp{km`mcdhv hJkm?j?cd`Vp{fzcw?` bGj?k'`]e-h"fgx8l"ewpqlJ?~{`Eu}pqu ~ªl"ewrJ`¢2udp{bv `p{cRcwlJ®J`Eu m¢ © ¦Rucw` su] ]s` ew` ,pªu«cd?`±bZjsk' U` e}h"fansl8cwlUhJpqb4c¡ul"bsn pªucw?`mbGj?k#U` e}h"faxClJedpªl"s~{`Euw¦ § _zlJv¡sp{b?r l~ªl"ewrJ`kVl8cdewp{¶Xh"f#f\h4j?edcd°kmh4k`]bZcwuOkVlCy²ed` ¸Zj?pqed`ud`]v h4bsn?lJedy km`]kh4edyucwhJe¡l"rJ`4 Gj?b?~q`]uwuhJb?`}pªupq~{~qp{bsr cdhslCyf\hJek#j?~{cdpq?~q`#sl4udud`]ucd?ewhJj?r4 cd?`mn?l"cwl ud` c` xJ`]edy cdpqkm`-lcd`Eucpªun6`]kmlJbsn6`Enh4epflm~ªl"ewrJ`}l"kmhJj?bZchJsf i | pªulCx8l"pq~qlJ?~{`4§¨Üb ?e¡lJvºcwpqv `J ?ew`]ud`]lJewv¡s` e¡u±kVlCy0U`j?bGpq~{~qp{bsr hJejsbsl"?~q`cwhrJh}cdh}cw?`cwedh4j??~q`J§(µ`slCx4`gcd?`]ed` f\hJew`gjsu`En cds`µ²pªudsl"edccw`]ucV¢¹u`]`mÌ6?p{edcd`Eu` cl"~ý§{
