78JANUS CAPITAL GROUP, INC., ET AL. v. FIRST DERIVATIVE ...
#$%&'"('&)&*)+"
(,-(./0" -/012" 34!4"
!"
$5%%6789" :(-/;" ?>" &@" &9" A>69&7%>2" 6" 95%%6789" #=>6B)*@>+" C&%%" 7>" ?>%>69>B2" 69" &9 7>&)D" B*)>" &)" E*))>E@&*)" C&@=" @=&9" E69>2" 6@" @=>" @&F>" @=>" *'&)&*)" &9" &998>BG -=>" 95%%6789" E*)9@&@8@>9" )*" '6?@" *A" @=>" *'&)&*)" *A" @=>" ,*8?@" 78@" =69" 7>>) '?>'6?>B" 75" @=>" 0>'*?@>?" *A" H>E&9&*)9" A*?" @=>" E*)I>)&>)E>" *A" @=>" ?>6B>?G" $>>"!"#$%&'($)$%*"IG"+%$,-#$'.#/0%,'1'23/0%,'4-56"344"JG"$G"K3!2"KKLG"
!"#$%&%'()"$*')+'*,%'"-.*%/'!*0*%!' $5%%6789"
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`"&)"E*))>E@&*)"C&@="@=>"'8?E=69>"*? 96%>"*A"9>E8?&@&>9G""-=>"E*F'%6&)@"6%%>D>B2"#"$%,')8#)6"@=6@"M,R"6)B"&@9" C=*%%5"*C)>B"9879&B&6?52"'>@&@&*)>?"M6)89",6'&@6%"16)6D>F>)@"QQ," #M,1+2" F6B>" A6%9>" 9@6@>F>)@9" &)" F8@86%" A8)B" '?*9'>E@89>9" A&%>B" 75 M6)89"P)I>9@F>)@"S8)BYA*?"C=&E="M,1"C69"@=>"&)I>9@F>)@"6BI&9>?" 6)B" 6BF&)&9@?6@*?Y6)B" @=6@" @=*9>" 9@6@>F>)@9" 6AA>E@>B" @=>" '?&E>" *A M,Ra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b34#6+G" 9%8&:'.>E689>" @=>" A6%9>" 9@6@>F>)@9" &)E%8B>B" &)" @=>" '?*9'>E@89>9" C>?> F6B>"75"M6)89"P)I>9@F>)@"S8)B2")*@"75"M,12"M,1"6)B"M,R"E6))*@ 7>"=>%B"%&67%>"&)"6"'?&I6@>"6E@&*)"8)B>?"08%>"!47WXG""O'G"XW!3G #6+"N%@=*8D=" )>&@=>?" 08%>" !47WX" )*?" @=>" 9@6@8@>" &@" &)@>?'?>@92 b!4#7+"*A"@=>"NE@2">['?>99%5"E?>6@>9"6"'?&I6@>"?&D=@"*A"6E@&*)2"98E="6)" \6E@&*)" &9" &F'%&>B" 8)B>?" b!4#7+G`" " (3;%,#"$%"&%"$' -_ F6&)9" @=>" %6C2`" ($-"%,#&C%' ="7%*$/%"$' D),$"%,*6' 224" IG" (E#%"$#9@&*)"6@"&9_ 98>2"@=>",*8?@"&9"F&)BA8%"@=6@"&@"F89@"D&I>"\)6??*C"B&F>)9&*)9"G"G"G"@*" 6"?&D=@"G"G"G",*)D?>99"B&B")*@"68@=*?&f>"C=>)"&@"A&?9@">)6E@>B"@=>"9@6@_ 8@>"6)B"B&B")*@">['6)B"C=>)"&@"?>I&9&@>B`"&@2"#&56"6@"!dLG" O'G"XW!4G #!+"S*?" 08%>" !47WX" '8?'*9>92" @=>" F6Z>?" *A" 6" 9@6@>F>)@" &9" @=> '>?9*)" *?" >)@&@5" C&@=" 8%@&F6@>" 68@=*?&@5" *I>?" @=>" 9@6@>F>)@2" &)E%8B_ &)D" &@9" E*)@>)@" 6)B" C=>@=>?" 6)B" =*C" @*" E*FF8)&E6@>" &@G" " 9@" C=6@" @*" 9652" )*@ " \F6Z>`"6"9@6@>F>)@"&)"&@9"*C)"?&D=@G""-=&9"?8%>"A*%%*C9"A?*F"4%"$,)8' @)"A' -5' G5" IG" H#,*$' ="$%,*$)$%' @)"A' -5'G52" X!!" JG"$G" !dc2" !e42" C=&E=" =>%B" @=6@" 08%>" !47WXa9" '?&I6@>" ?&D=@" *A" 6E@&*) B*>9" )*@" &)E%8B>" 98&@9" 6D6&)9@" 6&B>?9" 6)B" 67>@@*?9" C=*" E*)@?&78@> \9879@6)@&6%"699&9@6)E>`"@*"@=>"F6Z&)D"*A"6"9@6@>F>)@"78@"B*")*@"6E_ @86%%5"F6Z>"&@G""0>6B&)D"\F6Z>`"F*?>"7?*6B%52"@*"&)E%8B>"'>?9*)9"*? >)@&@&>9" %6EZ&)D" 8%@&F6@>" E*)@?*%" *I>?" 6" 9@6@>F>)@2" C*8%B" 9879@6)_ @&6%%5" 8)B>?F&)>" 4%"$,)8' @)"A" 75" ?>)B>?&)D" 6&B>?9" 6)B" 67>@@*?9" 6%_ F*9@" )*)>[&9@>)@G" " -=>" ,*8?@a9" &)@>?'?>@6@&*)" &9" 6%9*" 98DD>9@>B" 75" ($-"%,#&C%6'XX3"JG"$G2"6@"!d!2"6)B"6EE*?B9"C&@="@=>")6??*C"9E*'>"@=6@" F89@"7>"D&I>)"@=>"&F'%&>B"'?&I6@>"?&D=@"*A"6E@&*)2"#&56"6@"!dLG" O'G"dWeG #3+"-=>" ,*8?@" ?>h>E@9" @=>" R*I>?)F>)@a9" E*)@>)@&*)" @=6@" \F6Z>`" 9=*8%B" 7>" B>A&)>B" 69" \E?>6@>2`" @=>?>75" 6%%*C&)D" '?&I6@>" '%6&)@&AA9" @* 98>" 6" '>?9*)" C=*" '?*I&B>9" @=>" A6%9>" *?" F&9%>6B&)D" &)A*?F6@&*)" @=6@" 6)*@=>?"'>?9*)"'8@9"&)@*"6"9@6@>F>)@G "NB*'@&)D"@=6@"B>A&)&@&*)"C*8%B 7>" &)E*)9&9@>)@" C&@=" ($-"%,#&C%6' *3;,)2" 6@" !d!2" C=&E=" ?>h>E@>B" 6" '?&_ I6@>"08%>"!47WX"98&@"6D6&)9@"E*F'6)&>9" &)I*%I>B"&)"B>E>'@&I>"@?6)9_ 6E@&*)92" >I>)" C=>)" &)A*?F6@&*)" 67*8@" @=*9>" @?6)96E@&*)9" C69" %6@>?" &)E*?'*?6@>B"&)@*"A6%9>"'87%&E"9@6@>F>)@9G""S&?9@"H>?&I6@&I>")*@>9"@=>" 8)&g8>%5" E%*9>" ?>%6@&*)9=&'" 7>@C>>)" 6" F8@86%" A8)B" 6)B" &@9" &)I>9@_ F>)@"6BI&9>?2"78@"@=>"E*?'*?6@>"A*?F6%&@&>9"C>?>"*79>?I>B2"6)B"?>6'_ '*?@&*)F>)@" *A" %&67&%&@5" &)" %&D=@" *A" @=&9" E%*9>" ?>%6@&*)9=&'" &9" '?*'>?%5" @=>" ?>9'*)9&7&%&@5" *A" ,*)D?>992" )*@" @=>" E*8?@9G" " S8?@=>?F*?>2" S&?9@" H>?&I6@&I>a9" ?8%>" C*8%B" ?>6B" &)@*" 08%>" !47WX" 6" @=>*?5" *A" %&67&%&@5 9&F&%6?" @*Y78@" 7?*6B>?" @=6)YE*)@?*%_'>?9*)" %&67&%&@5" 8)B>?" b34#6+G" O'G"eW!4G #7+"N%@=*8D="M,1"F65"=6I>"7>>)"9&D)&A&E6)@%5"&)I*%I>B"&)"'?>'6?_ &)D"@=>"'?*9'>E@89>92"&@"B&B")*@"&@9>%A"\F6Z>`"@=>"9@6@>F>)@9"6@"&998> A*?" 08%>" !47WX" '8?'*9>9G" " P@9" 699&9@6)E>" &)" E?6A@&)D" C=6@" C69" 96&B C69"987h>E@"@*"M6)89"P)I>9@F>)@"S8)Ba9"8%@&F6@>"E*)@?*%G""O'G"!4W!3G"
Xdd"SG"KB"!!!2"?>I>?9>BG" -U(1N$2" MG2" B>%&I>?>B" @=>" *'&)&*)" *A" @=>" ,*8?@2" &)" C=&E=" 0(./0-$2" ,G"MG2"6)B"$,NQPN2"i/::/Hj2"6)B"NQP-(2"MMG2"h*&)>BG"".0/j/02"MG2"A&%>B"6" B&99>)@&)D" *'&)&*)2" &)" C=&E=" RP:$.J0R2" $(-(1Nj(02" 6)B" iNRN:2" MMG2" h*&)>BG"
$%&'"()*" +,-"./"0/"!!!!"123##4"
#"
56%7%87"89"&:'"$8;:%)"86%7%87"%)");AB'C&"&8"98Z5]T0"H'E%F'
(,-(./0" -/012" 34!4"
!"
$5%%6789" :(-/;" ?>" &@" &9" A>69&7%>2" 6" 95%%6789" #=>6B)*@>+" C&%%" 7>" ?>%>69>B2" 69" &9 7>&)D" B*)>" &)" E*))>E@&*)" C&@=" @=&9" E69>2" 6@" @=>" @&F>" @=>" *'&)&*)" &9" &998>BG -=>" 95%%6789" E*)9@&@8@>9" )*" '6?@" *A" @=>" *'&)&*)" *A" @=>" ,*8?@" 78@" =69" 7>>) '?>'6?>B" 75" @=>" 0>'*?@>?" *A" H>E&9&*)9" A*?" @=>" E*)I>)&>)E>" *A" @=>" ?>6B>?G" $>>"!"#$%&'($)$%*"IG"+%$,-#$'.#/0%,'1'23/0%,'4-56"344"JG"$G"K3!2"KKLG"
!"#$%&%'()"$*')+'*,%'"-.*%/'!*0*%!' $5%%6789"
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`"&)"E*))>E@&*)"C&@="@=>"'8?E=69>"*? 96%>"*A"9>E8?&@&>9G""-=>"E*F'%6&)@"6%%>D>B2"#"$%,')8#)6"@=6@"M,R"6)B"&@9" C=*%%5"*C)>B"9879&B&6?52"'>@&@&*)>?"M6)89",6'&@6%"16)6D>F>)@"QQ," #M,1+2" F6B>" A6%9>" 9@6@>F>)@9" &)" F8@86%" A8)B" '?*9'>E@89>9" A&%>B" 75 M6)89"P)I>9@F>)@"S8)BYA*?"C=&E="M,1"C69"@=>"&)I>9@F>)@"6BI&9>?" 6)B" 6BF&)&9@?6@*?Y6)B" @=6@" @=*9>" 9@6@>F>)@9" 6AA>E@>B" @=>" '?&E>" *A M,Ra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b34#6+G" 9%8&:'.>E689>" @=>" A6%9>" 9@6@>F>)@9" &)E%8B>B" &)" @=>" '?*9'>E@89>9" C>?> F6B>"75"M6)89"P)I>9@F>)@"S8)B2")*@"75"M,12"M,1"6)B"M,R"E6))*@ 7>"=>%B"%&67%>"&)"6"'?&I6@>"6E@&*)"8)B>?"08%>"!47WXG""O'G"XW!3G #6+"N%@=*8D=" )>&@=>?" 08%>" !47WX" )*?" @=>" 9@6@8@>" &@" &)@>?'?>@92 b!4#7+"*A"@=>"NE@2">['?>99%5"E?>6@>9"6"'?&I6@>"?&D=@"*A"6E@&*)2"98E="6)" \6E@&*)" &9" &F'%&>B" 8)B>?" b!4#7+G`" " (3;%,#"$%"&%"$' -_ F6&)9" @=>" %6C2`" ($-"%,#&C%' ="7%*$/%"$' D),$"%,*6' 224" IG" (E#%"$#9@&*)"6@"&9_ 98>2"@=>",*8?@"&9"F&)BA8%"@=6@"&@"F89@"D&I>"\)6??*C"B&F>)9&*)9"G"G"G"@*" 6"?&D=@"G"G"G",*)D?>99"B&B")*@"68@=*?&f>"C=>)"&@"A&?9@">)6E@>B"@=>"9@6@_ 8@>"6)B"B&B")*@">['6)B"C=>)"&@"?>I&9&@>B`"&@2"#&56"6@"!dLG" O'G"XW!4G #!+"S*?" 08%>" !47WX" '8?'*9>92" @=>" F6Z>?" *A" 6" 9@6@>F>)@" &9" @=> '>?9*)" *?" >)@&@5" C&@=" 8%@&F6@>" 68@=*?&@5" *I>?" @=>" 9@6@>F>)@2" &)E%8B_ &)D" &@9" E*)@>)@" 6)B" C=>@=>?" 6)B" =*C" @*" E*FF8)&E6@>" &@G" " 9@" C=6@" @*" 9652" )*@ " \F6Z>`"6"9@6@>F>)@"&)"&@9"*C)"?&D=@G""-=&9"?8%>"A*%%*C9"A?*F"4%"$,)8' @)"A' -5' G5" IG" H#,*$' ="$%,*$)$%' @)"A' -5'G52" X!!" JG"$G" !dc2" !e42" C=&E=" =>%B" @=6@" 08%>" !47WXa9" '?&I6@>" ?&D=@" *A" 6E@&*) B*>9" )*@" &)E%8B>" 98&@9" 6D6&)9@" 6&B>?9" 6)B" 67>@@*?9" C=*" E*)@?&78@> \9879@6)@&6%"699&9@6)E>`"@*"@=>"F6Z&)D"*A"6"9@6@>F>)@"78@"B*")*@"6E_ @86%%5"F6Z>"&@G""0>6B&)D"\F6Z>`"F*?>"7?*6B%52"@*"&)E%8B>"'>?9*)9"*? >)@&@&>9" %6EZ&)D" 8%@&F6@>" E*)@?*%" *I>?" 6" 9@6@>F>)@2" C*8%B" 9879@6)_ @&6%%5" 8)B>?F&)>" 4%"$,)8' @)"A" 75" ?>)B>?&)D" 6&B>?9" 6)B" 67>@@*?9" 6%_ F*9@" )*)>[&9@>)@G" " -=>" ,*8?@a9" &)@>?'?>@6@&*)" &9" 6%9*" 98DD>9@>B" 75" ($-"%,#&C%6'XX3"JG"$G2"6@"!d!2"6)B"6EE*?B9"C&@="@=>")6??*C"9E*'>"@=6@" F89@"7>"D&I>)"@=>"&F'%&>B"'?&I6@>"?&D=@"*A"6E@&*)2"#&56"6@"!dLG" O'G"dWeG #3+"-=>" ,*8?@" ?>h>E@9" @=>" R*I>?)F>)@a9" E*)@>)@&*)" @=6@" \F6Z>`" 9=*8%B" 7>" B>A&)>B" 69" \E?>6@>2`" @=>?>75" 6%%*C&)D" '?&I6@>" '%6&)@&AA9" @* 98>" 6" '>?9*)" C=*" '?*I&B>9" @=>" A6%9>" *?" F&9%>6B&)D" &)A*?F6@&*)" @=6@" 6)*@=>?"'>?9*)"'8@9"&)@*"6"9@6@>F>)@G "NB*'@&)D"@=6@"B>A&)&@&*)"C*8%B 7>" &)E*)9&9@>)@" C&@=" ($-"%,#&C%6' *3;,)2" 6@" !d!2" C=&E=" ?>h>E@>B" 6" '?&_ I6@>"08%>"!47WX"98&@"6D6&)9@"E*F'6)&>9" &)I*%I>B"&)"B>E>'@&I>"@?6)9_ 6E@&*)92" >I>)" C=>)" &)A*?F6@&*)" 67*8@" @=*9>" @?6)96E@&*)9" C69" %6@>?" &)E*?'*?6@>B"&)@*"A6%9>"'87%&E"9@6@>F>)@9G""S&?9@"H>?&I6@&I>")*@>9"@=>" 8)&g8>%5" E%*9>" ?>%6@&*)9=&'" 7>@C>>)" 6" F8@86%" A8)B" 6)B" &@9" &)I>9@_ F>)@"6BI&9>?2"78@"@=>"E*?'*?6@>"A*?F6%&@&>9"C>?>"*79>?I>B2"6)B"?>6'_ '*?@&*)F>)@" *A" %&67&%&@5" &)" %&D=@" *A" @=&9" E%*9>" ?>%6@&*)9=&'" &9" '?*'>?%5" @=>" ?>9'*)9&7&%&@5" *A" ,*)D?>992" )*@" @=>" E*8?@9G" " S8?@=>?F*?>2" S&?9@" H>?&I6@&I>a9" ?8%>" C*8%B" ?>6B" &)@*" 08%>" !47WX" 6" @=>*?5" *A" %&67&%&@5 9&F&%6?" @*Y78@" 7?*6B>?" @=6)YE*)@?*%_'>?9*)" %&67&%&@5" 8)B>?" b34#6+G" O'G"eW!4G #7+"N%@=*8D="M,1"F65"=6I>"7>>)"9&D)&A&E6)@%5"&)I*%I>B"&)"'?>'6?_ &)D"@=>"'?*9'>E@89>92"&@"B&B")*@"&@9>%A"\F6Z>`"@=>"9@6@>F>)@9"6@"&998> A*?" 08%>" !47WX" '8?'*9>9G" " P@9" 699&9@6)E>" &)" E?6A@&)D" C=6@" C69" 96&B C69"987h>E@"@*"M6)89"P)I>9@F>)@"S8)Ba9"8%@&F6@>"E*)@?*%G""O'G"!4W!3G"
Xdd"SG"KB"!!!2"?>I>?9>BG" -U(1N$2" MG2" B>%&I>?>B" @=>" *'&)&*)" *A" @=>" ,*8?@2" &)" C=&E=" 0(./0-$2" ,G"MG2"6)B"$,NQPN2"i/::/Hj2"6)B"NQP-(2"MMG2"h*&)>BG"".0/j/02"MG2"A&%>B"6" B&99>)@&)D" *'&)&*)2" &)" C=&E=" RP:$.J0R2" $(-(1Nj(02" 6)B" iNRN:2" MMG2" h*&)>BG"
$%&'"()*" +,-"./"0/"!!!!"123##4"
#"
56%7%87"89"&:'"$8;:%)"86%7%87"%)");AB'C&"&8"98Z5]T0"H'E%F'
