A Cognitive Approach to Judicial Opinion Structure: Applying Domain ...
A Cognitive Approach to Judicial Opinion Structure: Applying Domain Expertise to Component Analysis Jack G. Conrad
Daniel P. Dabney
Research & Development Thomson Legal & Regulatory St.Paul, MN 55123 USA
West Online Research West Group St.Paul, MN 55123 USA
[email protected]
[email protected]
!#" $&% ' (*)+ ,.-/+ 021!04365" 7989 : $= ?/@ ( A" 4$" $4 B B" $CD :E'FE ?*F4 G =4 7H IGJK'!L*" 7MN"'@ " E?/$ 'F ?OP"Q" R" 7S TU'V :W/P : F X"'G ?4 YQ= F G" =4FE F" $ ' " =4 M' 9%=4FF[ZM"B " $ V : P" $ %4( S7H"'MF R?4 :\ $!CQI ]& A ^U =4$ ?4 ! FE LU $X_ >F=?/C`F"9=$4" ^U :a7H=4$ ?' $QFE " P"'@ $ :$bF S"'7a;c= ?/(:d'e" 4$" $4 97f" =$?g$*8. :'$h' i(ZBISjM >F= ?bCiZM V (?4 ?G%QCG`F k" 7PF[ZM ^U 9 :W/P : FR'F F"'$ :Cb@l ?4F"' ZSF#g" m%4($4 ?nF" FE A" 7`opUqNCU ' X" 7M( :TU R ?4F$Tg :W/P :@ $4 IrjM $QF\ =?4( A" 4$" $4 vK :W/P : FB'F F" $4 :C/ `ZM" =(?O?/ ^U " O :\ $4 ? $?s$QF :$ w ?m E S" 7F V:" $QF $QF $?i >F =4:F=4 R" 7P T ' IAxc$F M >F= ?bC F $QF VZV : yP :F F ?GF"i?4 !(%P %P" Fr" $4 /F @l :d F ?&'$ ?D7f" F @l :d F ?r:" P" $4 $QF IjM =4FE'$QFi:" P" $4 $QF vz :4 $QF$Thg" i%$ F" $&"'7MF FcZV"O%/"U ?t F T "'( : v9' g P"' F ?u" $u$tF 'P :I{8`?/@ ?4F" $ a :W/P : $QF S' y:=4 $QFCF =4:F=4 v4" T $F^U B"b?/ v' XdZ $ C/ Mj ! z h :W/sP :Gg n$QFKsT'i :Z#" =/Fe"'7" =4e$4 ?`F"S >FE'% mSLb$"ZS@ ?/T :@l% ' M7H"'R ( F ?m TU' "'= 'EzvU$4= ?4$4Ty >F= ?/( : $F.." =4z MF" = '$ ?4 V" 7K7f=@ F :WbFn?4'FE'% : h 4 :$bF$4TF :E'%QC/F : h" 7m($/7H"''F" $avyF ;>" F[C7f"Q= " $uF4 g TU'`?/" '($aIjz"O' ( >F¤U>¦ c¡[[[¦9©P[¤U¡S·V ¥¢³ ·VB¡c¦E « c ¶z9Ubc¡«
[N[¤U¡¼K¨ cb¡E O¦ § ¢R¢EªªA¤U¦c¤rX¦ « °Q¡«®½c ³ ¦E¢¢ ¬ ¶ .´b « ¬B©P¦Ec¡R¢Eª&¦ U[[[©2S¢c¥¡A¦E¢¢¡¦ [ ©¦![¡ec¤Q:¤UE§ ¡V´b¡¡ m¦¦¨U.¨U¢:c¡«X!§ ¡e[B¡¶ ©([¡E ¤'¨U U«U[¡«Uy©V¬ ¡E[!®h¾¤U¡i¦Ec¡Bc¡sc¨ UU¢¡B¡ '[¡«D´ ¬ ¦BB¡ 'cc¡A©f¨U « [¤U¡.¢¡E¥ ¢2¢ [¡>:[¨Uc¡®S·V [¡E ©a¦BB i¢ªt¥cEªRR´'¬iU[ ¦¡cR©K¦¦c¡ [ ¶/cB¡ ³ ªA¤Q:_¢±¡`B¦Ec¢z[¡¡©l¶_ U¡ ª¦Ec¡Sc¡.«U¡¦«U¡«g U« «U« ¡E«scB [¦cU¨U9¿ ÀÀ Á6® x[79F : F G'$u'' $QFG('!L&"'7` >F =4:F=4 N'FiF = ?/T IÃ_Äg" " ^U :vQF4 . =/ 76' :@l ^U >F =4:F=4 SF FV" $ S\ $?4 ($hG%P"b?/CN" 7A : ` .$4 'Ch 9^ ( ?h 9F B =%b;> ::F` F F : Fy ?4?/ IsjM4 y B?4 4F sF4 s7H :FBF'Fy" ^U !`F 9;c= ?/T $ ?*" F4 : y ^ iF ?nF"N >FE'% & :2 !F(^ iZ_C/ y"'7VZ_F$T " $4(" $ XÅo:ÆÇI ]ºF&FE t" 7M4T Cb@l Lb( ?r'F F" $4 :C/ B "CQ ? F"=?4( P" $4@ (" $zIÉjMb=4 %P TU'${" =/ :2" F F"DFE {$QF"rF4 @ ($4T4v2F" =T D$4" FX?/ :\ $4F(^ IBÏ`"ZV ^U :B !W/F :$ ^U s" =4y ?4F" (' " =/ v7f" 94E':F a " $ SF :CZV : B$"'F.=4$F ?aI !F(" $NËB"'7zF4 R P :R ^b( !ZS R ('F ?ZV" LG$F 9 B" 7 ?4"Q=4 $QFB >F =:F=/ $ C/ Ih`=/X :W/P : $QFE :F4"b?4" @ à ÐHÑXÒlÓ Ô ÕÖ'×:ÖUØ ÙcÚ ÛcÜQÝEÞHß>ÞHàEáâ>ã Þä ÞHâEäNÔ Õå ÕÇØ æBÒlçyæ'Ø Ñ çEÒ[ØAÒlÓ Ø_Õ6Òl×!ÒlØ è_Ø ÑÒéê ×9×:ÙÇëÇì:å'å'æ Ø ì!æBØ.éUç!Ø>Ù_î(ç:í ÙÇç:Øå'Ò[Ù6Ó'ÒMØ ç!è.îÚQÒlïzÓ'Ó'Ø.Ô ícæ'ÓBØ í Ø>Ô ð ÕÇÔ ÖUç!ç!ÑGå ÙÇÑ'Ø æ'×:ÕKícÓ'ÒlÓ Ø æGØRñ ÙÇ× Ø ïOì:×!×!ÙÇæ ÕAÔ ×!Ñ'Ö ìBÖ'×Xñ Ô Ø í æ.×:å'Ò[ç9ÕÇØ.ÒlÓ ÒlÙÇØRÔ Ø í æG×:ÕÇç:Ø!Ù Ú ×:Ñ'æsæ'Ø>Òl×:Ô ñ ÕÒlÓ'ØMÙÇØ ×:ÕÇç:Ñ'Õå Ö ç:ÑBïKÓ'Ô í[ÓXÒlÓ'ØeëÇå æ'ì:è_Ø ÑÒeÔ ÕRé'×:ÕÇØ æUòRóPêií ç!Ñ'ô Ò[ÙÇ×!ÕÇÒ>Ú4ßcàEõEöáàE÷Nç:ÙKá(öHø'àEábß>àEõEöcõÙÇØ>î(Ø ÙÇÕÒlçAÒlÓ'ØKí ç!ñ ñ Ø í>ÒlÔ ç:ÑVç!îbÙÇØ ÖUç:Ù6ÒlØ æ_í ×:ÕÇØ Õ ïKÓ'Ô ícÓMî(ç!Ùlè_ÕP×AéUçæ êMçEî ëlå'ÙÇÔ ÕÇÖ ÙÇå'æ Ø Ñ'í Øeù(Ô(ò Ø!ò ÚÒlÓ Øzñ × ïgçEîQ×VÖ'×:Ù6ÒlÔ í å'ñ ×:Ù4Õlå'é ô ëlç!Ø Òlí>Ó ÒØ Ùaî(ç:ÕÇÙÇç:è_å'Ø ÙÇí æiØ ÕKéêsç!îÒlñÓ'× ØSïæ ò Ø í Ô æ'Ø æsí ×:ÕÇØ ÕlúA×!Ñ æGÔ ÕVæ'Ô Õ6Ò[Ô Ñ í>Òî(ÙÇç:èÉÕ6Ò[×EÒlå'ÒlØ ÕV×!Ñ æ
1.
Permission to make digital or hard copies of all or part of this work for personal or classroom use is granted without fee provided that copies are not made or distributed for profit or commercial advantage and that copies bear this notice and the full citation on the first page. To copy otherwise, to republish, to post on servers or to redistribute to lists, requires prior specific permission and/or a fee. ICAIL-2001 St. Louis, Missouri USA Copyright 2001 ACM 1-58113-368-5/01/0005 ... 5.00.
»
o
" T'Cg 9?4 : :%P ?g$ :F" $npbI :F" $gûG/ $QF _F ` =4F " 74" =/e >F=?/CQvZS :F" $mqM :W4 $ : zF A" $= " $ KZV M' %4 yF"?/EZº7f" üF `\$ ?/($4T IAJz >FCQv :F" $hým4 :$bF $g"'^ :^b( !Z"'7eF `$ :Z?4 !F(" $ SF M !n _FE Lb$T/I } 2. þ.ÿ sþ` G 8uT' 'FV?4 %P $iZ_F F :$ %P" =4FF _ :W/ $?mT E'G@ 'F'' P :F A" 72 T P?/( :" =4 XÅ /vbË 'Æ $?m"b?4 " 7P'T =/@ $QFE'F^U i?4 " =4 i ^U m%P : $nZSd?/ CD >F= ?4 ?#Å p/veÍ ÆÇI R :FB $b=i%P :" 7PF4 _"b?4 :( ^ M%P $?/ ^U " P ?sZSF" =4FR :WbF $4@ ^U Ch:" $ =4F($4TGF Xb='$g4E':FF" $ ! `" 7F4 `?/" '($4 I xc$r" F4 :iZV" E?/ veF :CO 4P 'XF"h%P %4=Fs7d" F m E$ ?4"ZS$gE F :_F $g7d" F4 yb= $F E':F" i s $QF( C#'$#$47H"''F" $O :Wb@ F E !F(" $F =4:F=4 " $iF :WbF= '?/"Q= :$bF K($m" F !Z_C/ vU7H"' $ >FE'$ vU%bCi T $QF($4TB`F :WbFA$bF"Bi=F@l 'E'T E'G=4$F F ! %QC%P $Tt/ ?{F"# P" $?ºF"#$ !Z T ( :$bFg" 7 YQ= : V % y"'7K7f"Q= $Ti" $F . =%4F" y?/" '($*ÅopbvzoË ÆÇI RCg" $QF E >FvPG$/=4m%P :S"'7 'E ! ` ^U XP : 7f" ?N :Wb@ F $4 (^ m'$ CbF >F=?4 ." $nF s :W/ >F($4TN$QF :$ e >F =4:F=4 " 7e^ (" = _"b?/ _" 7$'F=/E 2( $T = 'T X?4 " =4 IRjM4 B ^U $=?4 ?T $4 :E 2$'F=4E'2d'$T = T B4" GÅ Ë Íbvaoû'ÆÇv4F4 XÌ T E'G@ 'e" 7`?4 " =/ &Åo ÍÆlvM mZV 9 G :W/P" F" $Å ý'ÆÇvM'T =4 $4@ FE'F" $D$n ?/F" ( ?/ " =/ NÅ p'ÆÇv2$4 :ZS y' y?4 " =4 F"'( _?/( :" =4 N $?& "Q:d F ? % >F E':F F=?/Cu $?{ >F 7f" &$b=i%P :"'7s\ (?4 $F nb=4@ $4F( : B $?nF4 m "Q('A :( :$ {$T =4 >F(: v $QF4" P" " T'CQv "Q" " T CQv4 >C/!4" " T'CQvb" T $F^U ` :( :$ v4'$ ?" F4 : IA8." $T F S" >FVP" FE'$QFR 'EF =4:F=4 hÅ Ë Í ÆÇ I V'$y ;>LPvz(L GB $4 :FÅ 'ÆÇv F $?4 GF"O=4$ ?/ : " NF g "Q:d'y'$ ?u:=F=4E'.?/ $ " $4 " 7 ( $4T = 'T D= D Nm=4!{ F n" T $F^U I ` F *$ :Z ?4 !@ ^U " $QF s($#7f" _T'E v(" T vM $ ?t F\( S$QF @ T $4 v2F X\ (? :F4"b?4" (" T '(CD'$ ?gF :" :F'(C { >F( Z_'F 9%4" ?/ :. 4('F" $#Å Ë ÆÇI Jz(?4?/C= ?u " n" 7`F * g4" P" F(" $ F $: g" 7` :W/( 9= mZS4! ^U '_ =Eu >F =4:F=4 rÅoý'ÆÇI xc$n^ (?'F" $u/"Q ?4=/ vRJz(??bC# "ZV ?&F 'Fm4"'7H " $ %4 >F E :F"'
Daniel P. Dabney
Research & Development Thomson Legal & Regulatory St.Paul, MN 55123 USA
West Online Research West Group St.Paul, MN 55123 USA
[email protected]
[email protected]
!#" $&% ' (*)+ ,.-/+ 021!04365" 7989 : $= ?/@ ( A" 4$" $4 B B" $CD :E'FE ?*F4 G =4 7H IGJK'!L*" 7MN"'@ " E?/$ 'F ?OP"Q" R" 7S TU'V :W/P : F X"'G ?4 YQ= F G" =4FE F" $ ' " =4 M' 9%=4FF[ZM"B " $ V : P" $ %4( S7H"'MF R?4 :\ $!CQI ]& A ^U =4$ ?4 ! FE LU $X_ >F=?/C`F"9=$4" ^U :a7H=4$ ?' $QFE " P"'@ $ :$bF S"'7a;c= ?/(:d'e" 4$" $4 97f" =$?g$*8. :'$h' i(ZBISjM >F= ?bCiZM V (?4 ?G%QCG`F k" 7PF[ZM ^U 9 :W/P : FR'F F"'$ :Cb@l ?4F"' ZSF#g" m%4($4 ?nF" FE A" 7`opUqNCU ' X" 7M( :TU R ?4F$Tg :W/P :@ $4 IrjM $QF\ =?4( A" 4$" $4 vK :W/P : FB'F F" $4 :C/ `ZM" =(?O?/ ^U " O :\ $4 ? $?s$QF :$ w ?m E S" 7F V:" $QF $QF $?i >F =4:F=4 R" 7P T ' IAxc$F M >F= ?bC F $QF VZV : yP :F F ?GF"i?4 !(%P %P" Fr" $4 /F @l :d F ?&'$ ?D7f" F @l :d F ?r:" P" $4 $QF IjM =4FE'$QFi:" P" $4 $QF vz :4 $QF$Thg" i%$ F" $&"'7MF FcZV"O%/"U ?t F T "'( : v9' g P"' F ?u" $u$tF 'P :I{8`?/@ ?4F" $ a :W/P : $QF S' y:=4 $QFCF =4:F=4 v4" T $F^U B"b?/ v' XdZ $ C/ Mj ! z h :W/sP :Gg n$QFKsT'i :Z#" =/Fe"'7" =4e$4 ?`F"S >FE'% mSLb$"ZS@ ?/T :@l% ' M7H"'R ( F ?m TU' "'= 'EzvU$4= ?4$4Ty >F= ?/( : $F.." =4z MF" = '$ ?4 V" 7K7f=@ F :WbFn?4'FE'% : h 4 :$bF$4TF :E'%QC/F : h" 7m($/7H"''F" $avyF ;>" F[C7f"Q= " $uF4 g TU'`?/" '($aIjz"O' ( >F¤U>¦ c¡[[[¦9©P[¤U¡S·V ¥¢³ ·VB¡c¦E « c ¶z9Ubc¡«
[N[¤U¡¼K¨ cb¡E O¦ § ¢R¢EªªA¤U¦c¤rX¦ « °Q¡«®½c ³ ¦E¢¢ ¬ ¶ .´b « ¬B©P¦Ec¡R¢Eª&¦ U[[[©2S¢c¥¡A¦E¢¢¡¦ [ ©¦![¡ec¤Q:¤UE§ ¡V´b¡¡ m¦¦¨U.¨U¢:c¡«X!§ ¡e[B¡¶ ©([¡E ¤'¨U U«U[¡«Uy©V¬ ¡E[!®h¾¤U¡i¦Ec¡Bc¡sc¨ UU¢¡B¡ '[¡«D´ ¬ ¦BB¡ 'cc¡A©f¨U « [¤U¡.¢¡E¥ ¢2¢ [¡>:[¨Uc¡®S·V [¡E ©a¦BB i¢ªt¥cEªRR´'¬iU[ ¦¡cR©K¦¦c¡ [ ¶/cB¡ ³ ªA¤Q:_¢±¡`B¦Ec¢z[¡¡©l¶_ U¡ ª¦Ec¡Sc¡.«U¡¦«U¡«g U« «U« ¡E«scB [¦cU¨U9¿ ÀÀ Á6® x[79F : F G'$u'' $QFG('!L&"'7` >F =4:F=4 N'FiF = ?/T IÃ_Äg" " ^U :vQF4 . =/ 76' :@l ^U >F =4:F=4 SF FV" $ S\ $?4 ($hG%P"b?/CN" 7A : ` .$4 'Ch 9^ ( ?h 9F B =%b;> ::F` F F : Fy ?4?/ IsjM4 y B?4 4F sF4 s7H :FBF'Fy" ^U !`F 9;c= ?/T $ ?*" F4 : y ^ iF ?nF"N >FE'% & :2 !F(^ iZ_C/ y"'7VZ_F$T " $4(" $ XÅo:ÆÇI ]ºF&FE t" 7M4T Cb@l Lb( ?r'F F" $4 :C/ B "CQ ? F"=?4( P" $4@ (" $zIÉjMb=4 %P TU'${" =/ :2" F F"DFE {$QF"rF4 @ ($4T4v2F" =T D$4" FX?/ :\ $4F(^ IBÏ`"ZV ^U :B !W/F :$ ^U s" =4y ?4F" (' " =/ v7f" 94E':F a " $ SF :CZV : B$"'F.=4$F ?aI !F(" $NËB"'7zF4 R P :R ^b( !ZS R ('F ?ZV" LG$F 9 B" 7 ?4"Q=4 $QFB >F =:F=/ $ C/ Ih`=/X :W/P : $QFE :F4"b?4" @ à ÐHÑXÒlÓ Ô ÕÖ'×:ÖUØ ÙcÚ ÛcÜQÝEÞHß>ÞHàEáâ>ã Þä ÞHâEäNÔ Õå ÕÇØ æBÒlçyæ'Ø Ñ çEÒ[ØAÒlÓ Ø_Õ6Òl×!ÒlØ è_Ø ÑÒéê ×9×:ÙÇëÇì:å'å'æ Ø ì!æBØ.éUç!Ø>Ù_î(ç:í ÙÇç:Øå'Ò[Ù6Ó'ÒMØ ç!è.îÚQÒlïzÓ'Ó'Ø.Ô ícæ'ÓBØ í Ø>Ô ð ÕÇÔ ÖUç!ç!ÑGå ÙÇÑ'Ø æ'×:ÕKícÓ'ÒlÓ Ø æGØRñ ÙÇ× Ø ïOì:×!×!ÙÇæ ÕAÔ ×!Ñ'Ö ìBÖ'×Xñ Ô Ø í æ.×:å'Ò[ç9ÕÇØ.ÒlÓ ÒlÙÇØRÔ Ø í æG×:ÕÇç:Ø!Ù Ú ×:Ñ'æsæ'Ø>Òl×:Ô ñ ÕÒlÓ'ØMÙÇØ ×:ÕÇç:Ñ'Õå Ö ç:ÑBïKÓ'Ô í[ÓXÒlÓ'ØeëÇå æ'ì:è_Ø ÑÒeÔ ÕRé'×:ÕÇØ æUòRóPêií ç!Ñ'ô Ò[ÙÇ×!ÕÇÒ>Ú4ßcàEõEöáàE÷Nç:ÙKá(öHø'àEábß>àEõEöcõÙÇØ>î(Ø ÙÇÕÒlçAÒlÓ'ØKí ç!ñ ñ Ø í>ÒlÔ ç:ÑVç!îbÙÇØ ÖUç:Ù6ÒlØ æ_í ×:ÕÇØ Õ ïKÓ'Ô ícÓMî(ç!Ùlè_ÕP×AéUçæ êMçEî ëlå'ÙÇÔ ÕÇÖ ÙÇå'æ Ø Ñ'í Øeù(Ô(ò Ø!ò ÚÒlÓ Øzñ × ïgçEîQ×VÖ'×:Ù6ÒlÔ í å'ñ ×:Ù4Õlå'é ô ëlç!Ø Òlí>Ó ÒØ Ùaî(ç:ÕÇÙÇç:è_å'Ø ÙÇí æiØ ÕKéêsç!îÒlñÓ'× ØSïæ ò Ø í Ô æ'Ø æsí ×:ÕÇØ ÕlúA×!Ñ æGÔ ÕVæ'Ô Õ6Ò[Ô Ñ í>Òî(ÙÇç:èÉÕ6Ò[×EÒlå'ÒlØ ÕV×!Ñ æ
1.
Permission to make digital or hard copies of all or part of this work for personal or classroom use is granted without fee provided that copies are not made or distributed for profit or commercial advantage and that copies bear this notice and the full citation on the first page. To copy otherwise, to republish, to post on servers or to redistribute to lists, requires prior specific permission and/or a fee. ICAIL-2001 St. Louis, Missouri USA Copyright 2001 ACM 1-58113-368-5/01/0005 ... 5.00.
»
o
" T'Cg 9?4 : :%P ?g$ :F" $npbI :F" $gûG/ $QF _F ` =4F " 74" =/e >F=?/CQvZS :F" $mqM :W4 $ : zF A" $= " $ KZV M' %4 yF"?/EZº7f" üF `\$ ?/($4T IAJz >FCQv :F" $hým4 :$bF $g"'^ :^b( !Z"'7eF `$ :Z?4 !F(" $ SF M !n _FE Lb$T/I } 2. þ.ÿ sþ` G 8uT' 'FV?4 %P $iZ_F F :$ %P" =4FF _ :W/ $?mT E'G@ 'F'' P :F A" 72 T P?/( :" =4 XÅ /vbË 'Æ $?m"b?4 " 7P'T =/@ $QFE'F^U i?4 " =4 i ^U m%P : $nZSd?/ CD >F= ?4 ?#Å p/veÍ ÆÇI R :FB $b=i%P :" 7PF4 _"b?4 :( ^ M%P $?/ ^U " P ?sZSF" =4FR :WbF $4@ ^U Ch:" $ =4F($4TGF Xb='$g4E':FF" $ ! `" 7F4 `?/" '($4 I xc$r" F4 :iZV" E?/ veF :CO 4P 'XF"h%P %4=Fs7d" F m E$ ?4"ZS$gE F :_F $g7d" F4 yb= $F E':F" i s $QF( C#'$#$47H"''F" $O :Wb@ F E !F(" $F =4:F=4 " $iF :WbF= '?/"Q= :$bF K($m" F !Z_C/ vU7H"' $ >FE'$ vU%bCi T $QF($4TB`F :WbFA$bF"Bi=F@l 'E'T E'G=4$F F ! %QC%P $Tt/ ?{F"# P" $?ºF"#$ !Z T ( :$bFg" 7 YQ= : V % y"'7K7f"Q= $Ti" $F . =%4F" y?/" '($*ÅopbvzoË ÆÇI RCg" $QF E >FvPG$/=4m%P :S"'7 'E ! ` ^U XP : 7f" ?N :Wb@ F $4 (^ m'$ CbF >F=?4 ." $nF s :W/ >F($4TN$QF :$ e >F =4:F=4 " 7e^ (" = _"b?/ _" 7$'F=/E 2( $T = 'T X?4 " =4 IRjM4 B ^U $=?4 ?T $4 :E 2$'F=4E'2d'$T = T B4" GÅ Ë Íbvaoû'ÆÇv4F4 XÌ T E'G@ 'e" 7`?4 " =/ &Åo ÍÆlvM mZV 9 G :W/P" F" $Å ý'ÆÇvM'T =4 $4@ FE'F" $D$n ?/F" ( ?/ " =/ NÅ p'ÆÇv2$4 :ZS y' y?4 " =4 F"'( _?/( :" =4 N $?& "Q:d F ? % >F E':F F=?/Cu $?{ >F 7f" &$b=i%P :"'7s\ (?4 $F nb=4@ $4F( : B $?nF4 m "Q('A :( :$ {$T =4 >F(: v $QF4" P" " T'CQv "Q" " T CQv4 >C/!4" " T'CQvb" T $F^U ` :( :$ v4'$ ?" F4 : IA8." $T F S" >FVP" FE'$QFR 'EF =4:F=4 hÅ Ë Í ÆÇ I V'$y ;>LPvz(L GB $4 :FÅ 'ÆÇv F $?4 GF"O=4$ ?/ : " NF g "Q:d'y'$ ?u:=F=4E'.?/ $ " $4 " 7 ( $4T = 'T D= D Nm=4!{ F n" T $F^U I ` F *$ :Z ?4 !@ ^U " $QF s($#7f" _T'E v(" T vM $ ?t F\( S$QF @ T $4 v2F X\ (? :F4"b?4" (" T '(CD'$ ?gF :" :F'(C { >F( Z_'F 9%4" ?/ :. 4('F" $#Å Ë ÆÇI Jz(?4?/C= ?u " n" 7`F * g4" P" F(" $ F $: g" 7` :W/( 9= mZS4! ^U '_ =Eu >F =4:F=4 rÅoý'ÆÇI xc$n^ (?'F" $u/"Q ?4=/ vRJz(??bC# "ZV ?&F 'Fm4"'7H " $ %4 >F E :F"'
