A feedback model of perceptual learning and categorization
Ca$ZHX P`Fba2a`b6 IJJO6 M_ EIR6 MINcMO]
! "##$%&'( )*$#+ *" ,#-'#,./&+ +#&-0102 &0$ '&.#2*-13&.1*0 !" #" $%&'()*+, !"#"$"%& %' (&)"&**+"&), -"&).$ /%00*)* 1%&2%&, 3&2 /*&4+* '%+ 5+3"& 3&2 /%)&"4"#* !*#*0%67*&4, 5"+89*:8 /%00*)*, 1%&2%&
!" -" ./0+1/+ /*&4+* '%+ 5+3"& 3&2 /%)&"4"#* !*#*0%67*&4, 5"+89*:8 /%00*)*, 1%&2%&
2/%34/5+6 78849':;6 *+7)'(*/+ %&/:811*+," $*:0'8)"1%&'()*+,[;:)"':"'(*/+ %&/:811*+, 9? 4*&8:()? *+7)8+(WW *1 (08 %'((8&+ /7 %&81?+'%(*: ':(*=*(? (/ 50*:0 (0'( +8'+? 4*73 78&8+( %08+/>8+' *+ (08 4/>'*+ /7 %8&:8%(8 >8:0'+*1>1 /7 :0'+,8 *+ +8/+1(&'(81 (0'( ' 1*+,)8 )8'&+*+, >8:0'+*1> :'+ '::/%&*+(*+,6 %8&:8%(16 *+=/)=*+, :/&(*:') 78849':; %'(05'?16 :'+ '::/8:0'+*1>1 *1 )*;8)? (/ &81/&8 '48f8 >/48) 0'1 988+ '%%)*84 %&8=*/8:0'+*1>1 ,*=8 &*18 (/ ' +98& /7 4*1(*+:( %1?:0/3 )/,*:') %08+/>8+'"
12(0/-$ P/&(*:') 78847/&5'&4 '+4 78849':; :/++8:(*/+1 %&878&8+(*'))? ('&,8( 4*1(*+:( &8,*/+1 /7 %?&'>*4') :8)) 48+4&*(81 E188 D*,*:'))? /918&=84 18,&8,'(*/+ /7 *+%'&*)? 4&*=8+ 9? 78843 7/&5'&4 *+%*4') :8))" U?&'>*4') :8))1 '&8 (08 %&84/>*+'+( :)'11 /7 8B:*('(/&? +8/&%0/)/,? /7 %?&'>*4') :8))1 *1 0*,0)? ='&*'9)8" -/58=8&6 /+8 &8)'(*=8)? :/+1*1(8+( 78'(/&8 1*4') :8))1 *+ (08 1 &8,*/+1 0*,08& *+ (08 :/&(*:') 0*8&'&:0?R ('&,8( (08 '%*:') 48+4&*(81" P8)) >/&%0/)/,? '4'%(84 7&/> U'&8i6 X'+,6 '+4 T81(8B08 EMNNQR"
!"8
$%&'()*+, '+- ./0+$/+
D/48)6 (08 &81%/+18 /7 ' +88 &8,*/+ :/>%8(8 (/ &8%&818+( 4*1(*+:( 1(*>16 :/>%8(*(*/+ '+4 ,'*+ >/4%8(8 (/ 98 &8%&818+(84 9? :/&(*:') ':(*=*(?" 208 /8 /7 (0*1 :/>%8(*(*/+ *1 *+7)3 ' &'+,8 /7 4*778&8+( 1//4'(' 10/5+ '1 7*))84 (&*'+,)81R" 20818 >/48) +8%'&(>8+(1V 208 9'1') 48+4&*(816 50*:0 &8:8*=8 78847/&5'&4 :/++8:(*/+1 E10/5+ '1 1/)*4 )*+81R6 '+4 (08 '%*:') 48+4&*(816 50*:0 &8:8*=8 78849':; :/++8:(*/+1 E10/5+ '1 4'1084 )*+81R" b/481 *+ 4*778&8+( &8,*/+1 '&8 &8:*%&/:'))? :/++8:(84 9? 78847/&5'&4 '+4 78849':; %&/A8:(*/+1 E/+)? (08 :/++8:(*/+1 /&*,*+'(*+, 7&/> /+8 %'*& /7 +/481 '&8 10/5+R '+4 '&8 ('&,8(84 9? :/++8:(*/+1 /&*,*+'(*+, 7&/> /(08& 1/8 '1 (08 1?+'%(*: 58*,0(1 '( (08 9'1') 48+4&*(81 58&8 )8'&+(" T*1(*+:(6 +/+/=8&)'%%*+,6 *+%/+1(&'(84 (0'( *( %&/=*481 ' %/58&7 7/& (08 D?H;I GD@;= :@;C8+(" `+8 18( /7 %'&(*:*%'+(1 )8'&+( (0'( (08 %'*&1 /7 /9A8:(1 *+ 8':0 &/5 /7 D*,8>98&1 /7 (08 1'>8 :'(8,/&?6 50*)8 ' 18:/+4 18( /7 18 :'(8,/&?6 (08 %'&(1 10/5+ '( (08 9/((/> 58&8 4*',+/1(*: 7/& (0/18 :'(8,/&*81"
*+7/&>'(*/+ *+4*:'(84 (0'( %'((8&+1 5*(0*+ (08 1'>8 &/5 508&8 *+ (08 1'>8 :'(8,/&?6 /+8 +/48 *+ (08 '(*/+ *+4*:'(84 (0'( %'((8&+1 5*(0*+ (08 1'>8 :/)+ 7/&>84 4*1(*+:( :'(8,/&*816 /+8 +/48 *+ (08 8 :'(8,/&? ED*,8+(1 78849':; 8+0'+:81 (08 ':(*=*(*81 /7 +88+(1 5*(0 ' :/>%8(*(*=8 '4='+(',8 /=8& +8',8 78'(/48) (/ (08 /+8 481:&*984 08&8 (/ 1*> ' %&8=*//&8 )*;8)? (/ 98 %8&:8*=84 '1 (08 7*,*)'&)?6 %&*/& 8B%8&*8+:8 :'+ 8+'9)8 (08 18,>8+('(*/+ /7 '98>98&10*% 8=8+ 508+ )/53)8=8) :/41 *+ 4*1(*+:( :'(8,/&*81 EF/)41(/+86 MNNQK F/)41(/+86 X*%%'6 G $0*77&*+6 IJJMK -'&+'46 MNQ\6 IJJ_R" 208 >/48) 58 0'=8 %&818+(84 '9/=8 :'+ ')1/ 1*>'(:0 (08 )8'&+( /9A8:(" $*>*)'&)?6 *7 ' +/=8) /9A8:( *1 1*)'& (/ ' %&8=*/'(:0 (08 %&/(/(?%8 *1 )*;8)? (/ &81/&8 (0'+ /+8 1(/&84 &8%&818+('(*/+6 :/>%8(*(*/+ 98(588+ (0818 &8%&818+('(*/+1 5*)) 48(8&>*+8 50*:0 1(*>/48+(1 *+4*:'(84 *+ E'R" b/(8 (0'( *+ (08 (/% '+4 9/((/> ,&'%01 ')) (08 +/481 &8%&818+(*+, /+8 /& /(08& /7 (0818 18(1 /7 )*+8 18,>8+(1 0'=8 @8&/ ':(*='(*/+ '( ')) (*>81" a+18(1 10/5 (08 &81%/+181 /7 +/481 *+ (08 %8& G -'&+'46 IJJJR" D/& //48) (08 4*778&8+( ':(*='(*/+ 1('(81 &81 :/>%8(*(*/+ 98(588+ (08 +/481 *+ (08 8(8&1 ')/+, (5/ %8&:8%(',81 /7 1f/48) 5'1 '%%)*84 (/ ' 1*>*)'& ('1;6 *+ 50*:0 (&'*+*+, 4'(' :/+1*1(84 /7 (08 7/',81 58&8 %&818+(84 *+ &'+4/> /&48& (/ (08 9'1') 48+4&*(81 /7 (08 )/58& &8,*/+6 (/,8(08& 5*(0 *+%',81 5*(0*+ (08 '&&'?6 508+ E9R (08 +8(5/&; 0'4 988+ (&'*+84 (/ :)'11*7? *>',81 *+ (08 ',+*(*+8 0/5 4*1(*+:()? 4*778&8+( *>',81 58&8 &8%&818+(84 9? (08 +8(5/&; E188 (08 H:(*='(*/+ 18:(*/+ /7 (08 H%%8+4*BR" 208 4*1(*+:(*=8+811 /7 (08 +8 (08 (&'*+*+, '&&'?6 '=8&',84 /=8& MJ (&*')1 5*(0 8':0 /7 (08 (5/ :)'11*7*:'(*/+ ('1;1 *1 10/5+ *+ D*,8+1*/+1 &'(08& (0'+ (08 *&&8)8='+( 4*>8+1*/+1 E$*,')' G X/,/(08(*16 IJJMR" `+8 %/11*9)8 8B%)'+'(*/+ 7/& (0818 8778:(16 *+ ',&88>8+( 5*(0 //48)6 *1 (0'( (/%34/5+ *+7/&>'(*/+ 7&/> /(08& :/&(*:') &8,*/+1 18&=81 (/ 10'%8 (08 18+1*(*=*(? /7 a2 +8%)86 4*1(/&(84 =8&1*/+1 /7 (08 7/8 %8&:8%(8+( *+%%)'&R6 E7R 508+ 78849':; *1 4*&8:(84 (/ (08 =8&(*:') 9'& '( (08 :8+(&8 /7 (08 )/58& 0')7 /7 (08 *+%',8 E' 78'(%)*7? &81%/+181 (/ (08 *+4*=*4/+8 G T%)8 /7 (08 1(*>%)8 /7 (08 1(*>" #*(0/%)'& %&818+(84 (/ (08 +8(5/&;" T*)'&*(? /7 /(08& 8B8>%)'&16 (08 1'>8 +/48 5*)) ')1/ 5*+ 1%)'&1" a+ (08 %&818+:8 /7 78849':;6 /+8 *+%%8(*(*/+ 5*)) )8'&+ ' 1(&/+,8& 1?+'%(*: 58*,0( (/ (0*1 78'(%)'&1 E*"8"6 ')) (08 9'&1 :/+('*+84 *+ (08 %&/(/(?%8R" a+ (0*1 :/+4*(*/+6 +/481 *+ (08 ',8 78'( 8f/&8 4*778&8+(*'(84 5*(0 ',8 E7/& 48=8)/%*+, *+7'+(16 o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d');8+*?(06 MNNQK 48 $'6 MNNhK 48 $' G d'))'&46 MNNQK L'? G U0*))*%16 MNN\K L/g&4*+,6 G L/g+*,6 IJJMK U0*))*%16 L'?6 G $>?(06 MNN]K U0*))*%1 G $*+,8&6 MNN\R" D8849':; *+7/&>'(*/+ (0'( 18)8:(*=8)? >/4/48)6 1*)*'& 1(*>86 !'&)/(6 G 20/&%86 IJJMK L8?18&16 p*'/6 D/g)4*'i;6 G U8&&8((6 IJJMR" 208 7/&>'(*/+ /7 1%8:*')*@84 78'(/&8 &'%*46 &8:/,+*(*/+ /7 1(*>*,0( /(08&5*18 98 4*77*:*: 9*+4*+, E->8)6 IJJMK Y/1;*816 MNNNR /& (/%3 4/5+6 '((8+(*/+')6 %&/:81181 EY8?+/)41 G T81*>/+86 MNNNR 18&* G F'%*&*:') 8=*48+:8 (0'(*/+ /7 >/&8 1%8:*7*: '+4 1%8:*')*@84 &8%&818+('(*/+1" P'(8,/&*@'(*/+ &8f16 50*)8 *48+(*7*3 :'(*/+ &8f*+'(*/+ '>/+, 1*>*)'& *(8>1" a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
$6&% ' $7 &% $6&% ( $7 &%
%*&
6 508&8 $7 &% '+4 $&% '&8 (08 18+1*(*=*(? =')%)/?84V '%4*#$ ' 4#$ & !.*#$ ! (%!#$ ' !$ &( 4 )#$ )!!
%!!&
( #08&8 4#$ *1 (08 >8'+ /7 (08 *+%8 /4*7*'9)8 *+ 7/1( :/>%8(*(*=8 )8'&+*+, '),/&*(0>16 +/481 '((8>%( (/ jj9)/:;WW /(08& +/481
' 322-4'56 1/-2) /3 %2&52%(7') )2'&+*+,
!MO
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
!MQ
$%&'()*+, '+- ./0+$/+
48,&88 /7 >*1>'(:0 &8f'(:0*+, *+% 7/& :/>%8(*(*/+ E5*(0*+ ' 1*+,)8 )'?8& /7 +/481R &'(08& (0'+ (08 '1 8>%)/?84 *+ HY2" a+ '44*(*/+ (/ (08 *+(&'&8,*/+') :/>%8(*(*/+6 481:&*984 '9/=86 (08 %&818+( >/48) ')1/ *+:/&%/&'(81 >8:0'+*1>1 7/& *+(8&&8,*/+') ://%8&'(*/+V SB:*('(/&? 78847/&5'&4 '+4 78849':; :/++8:(*/+1 98(588+ 4*1(*+:( +8/48)6 +/481 0'=8 (5/ 78+(1 *+ 50*:0 18%'&'(8 18(1 /7 78847/&5'&4 '+4 78849':; *+%/41 0'=8 %&/%/184 4*1(*+:( 7%'&(>8+(1 (/ '))/5 78849':; (/ >/4%)/?84 +8/48)1 >';8 +/ 4*1(*+:(*/+ 98(588+ 78847/&5'&4 '+4 78849':; :/++8:(*/+1" 208 >/48) %&83 18+(84 *+ (0*1 %'%8& (0%%'&(>8+(1 :'+ :/+(&*9%'(*/+1 *+ (08 5/&)41 /7 7&/,1 '+4 &/9/(1" ?+4"'":"30 @&4*00")*&:*6 AB6 ]_cQJ" d';8&6 P" a"6 d80&>'++6 !"6 G `)1/+6 P" Y" EIJJIR" a>%':( /7 )8'&+*+, /+ &8%&818+('(*/+ /7 %'&(1 '+4 50/)81 *+ >/+;8? *+78&/(8>%/&') :/&(8B" C34D+* C*D+%$:"*&:*6 EEMMR6 MIMJcMIMO" d');8+*0/)(@W1 8:0'+*1>1 7/& =*18+') =*1*+, 1%'&18 &8%&818+('(*/+1 9? )/:') '+(*3-899*'+ )8'&+*+," 5"%0%)":30 /O9*+&*4":$6 RT6 MO]cM\J" D&*1(/+6 L" ."6 G d CI (/ C]^ !2 *+ 0'+1" Q+%:**2"&)$ %' 4H* C34"%&30 ?:32*7O %' N:"*&:*$ VN?6 UAEM_R6 \]NMc\]NO" D&*1(/+6 L" ."6 G U&*:86 P" ." EIJJMR" T?+'>*: &8%&818+('(*/+1 '+4 ,8+8&'(*=8 >/48)1 /7 9&'*+ 7 *+(8&':(*=8 ':(*='(*/+ (/ '4'%(*=8 &81/+'+:8" /%)&"4"#* N:"*&:*6 PP6 I_cO_" F&/1198&,6 $"6 G Y'*@'4'6 Y" EIJJJR" P/+(&'1(318+1*(*=8 %8&:8%(*)*'& 7':81" L+*&2$ "& /%)&"4"#* N:"*&:*$6 TENR6 __Jc__\" -'&+'46 $" EMNQ\R" U1?:0/%0?1*:') '+4 :/,+*(*=8 '1%8:(1 /7 :'(8,/&*:') %8&:8%(*/+V H :&*(*:') /=8&=*85" a+ $" -'&+'4 ES4"R6 /34*)%+":30 6*+:*64"%&M LH* )+%D&2>%+8 %' :%)&"4"%& E%%" Mc]IR" P'>9&*4,86 ZLV P'>9&*4,8 Z+*=8&1*(? U&811" -'&+'46 $" EIJJ_R" P'(8,/&*:') %8&:8%(*/+" a+ (&:O:0%6*2"3 %' :%)&"4"#* $:"*&:*" d'1*+,1(/;86 ZLV !':>*))'+^b'(%)*:'(*/+1 7/& 10'%8 %8&:8%(*/+ '+4 /9A8:( &8:/,+*(*/+" F"$D30 /%)&"4"%&6 W6 hQNc]M\" -%0&8?16 F" #"6 G D/&486 S" !" S" EIJJMR" -*8&'&:0*816 1*>*)'&*(?6 '+4 *+(8&':(*=*(? *+ /9A8:( &8:/,+*(*/+V jjP'(8,/&?31%8:*7*:WW +8816 H" P"6 U'?+86 d" Y"6 X/>98&6 $" F"6 F*&'&46 U"6 G d%&/=81 4*1:&*>*+'(*/+ 98(588+ 7*,>86 C" H" D"6 G Y/8)718>'6 U" Y" EIJJJR" 208 4*1(*+:( >/481 /7 =*1*/+ /778&84 9? 78847/&5'&4 '+4 &8:'++6 d" EMNNNR" H +85 :8)) 7/& :/%+8$6 WE_R6 __]c_OI" !:H4'>16 P" ."6 G !'6 WW6 _\]chJ\" !80('6 H" T"6 Z)98&(6 a"6 G $:0&/848&6 P" S" EIJJJR" a+(8&>/4') 18)8:(*=8 '((8+(*/+ *+ >/+;8?1" aaV U0?1*/)/,*:') >8:0'+*1>1 /7 >/46 H" EIJJMR" `9A8:( &8:/,+*(*/+ '+4 /9A8:( 18,&8,'(*/+ *+ h"]3>/+(03/)4 *+7'+(1" X%D+&30 %' (=6*+"7*&430 /H"02 Q$O:H%0%)O6 AWEMR6 _cII" `A'6 S" EMNQNR" b86 !" #"6 G H109&*4,86 S" EMNNQR" S=*48+:8 '::%+8M /%76D434"%& "& C*D+30 NO$4*7$6 REIR6 II]cIhO" U0*))*%16 #" H"6 G $*+,8&6 #" EMNN\R" a+ 18'&:0 /7 :/>>/+ 7/%/6 F" ."6 G D8&+'+48@3T1 /7 :/,+*(*=8 1;*))1" /%&$:"%D$&*$$ 3&2 /%)&"4"%&6 R6 IO\cINJ" o') 81(*>'(*/+ '%%&/':0 (/ =*1/48) /7 =*1/+86 Y" EIJJJR" H((8+(*/+ *+:&8'181 18+1*(*=*(? /7 Ch +8" C*D+%&6 BTEMR6 \cN" Y8)0'&(6 T" S"6 -*+(/+6 F" S"6 G #*))*'>16 Y" ." EMNQOR" X8'&+*+, *+(8&+') &8%&818+('(*/+1 9? 8&&/& %&/%','(*/+" a+ T" S" Y8)0'&(6 ." X" !:P)8))'+46 '+4 208 UTU Y818'&:0 F&//48) /7 >88(" LH* C*D+%$:"*&4"$46 AE]R6 h_JchhJ" $')*+'16 S"6 G 20*8&6 U" EIJJJR" F'*+ >/4%8+( /7 78'('(*/+ :/484 9? 1*+,)8 +8%/&') =*1'(8 =*1'6 $"6 !86 C" H" D"6 G $:0*))8&6 U" -" EMNNOR" P/+(8B('&? =*1
! "##$%&'( )*$#+ *" ,#-'#,./&+ +#&-0102 &0$ '&.#2*-13&.1*0 !" #" $%&'()*+, !"#"$"%& %' (&)"&**+"&), -"&).$ /%00*)* 1%&2%&, 3&2 /*&4+* '%+ 5+3"& 3&2 /%)&"4"#* !*#*0%67*&4, 5"+89*:8 /%00*)*, 1%&2%&
!" -" ./0+1/+ /*&4+* '%+ 5+3"& 3&2 /%)&"4"#* !*#*0%67*&4, 5"+89*:8 /%00*)*, 1%&2%&
2/%34/5+6 78849':;6 *+7)'(*/+ %&/:811*+," $*:0'8)"1%&'()*+,[;:)"':"'(*/+ %&/:811*+, 9? 4*&8:()? *+7)8+(WW *1 (08 %'((8&+ /7 %&81?+'%(*: ':(*=*(? (/ 50*:0 (0'( +8'+? 4*73 78&8+( %08+/>8+' *+ (08 4/>'*+ /7 %8&:8%(8 >8:0'+*1>1 /7 :0'+,8 *+ +8/+1(&'(81 (0'( ' 1*+,)8 )8'&+*+, >8:0'+*1> :'+ '::/%&*+(*+,6 %8&:8%(16 *+=/)=*+, :/&(*:') 78849':; %'(05'?16 :'+ '::/8:0'+*1>1 *1 )*;8)? (/ &81/&8 '48f8 >/48) 0'1 988+ '%%)*84 %&8=*/8:0'+*1>1 ,*=8 &*18 (/ ' +98& /7 4*1(*+:( %1?:0/3 )/,*:') %08+/>8+'"
12(0/-$ P/&(*:') 78847/&5'&4 '+4 78849':; :/++8:(*/+1 %&878&8+(*'))? ('&,8( 4*1(*+:( &8,*/+1 /7 %?&'>*4') :8)) 48+4&*(81 E188 D*,*:'))? /918&=84 18,&8,'(*/+ /7 *+%'&*)? 4&*=8+ 9? 78843 7/&5'&4 *+%*4') :8))" U?&'>*4') :8))1 '&8 (08 %&84/>*+'+( :)'11 /7 8B:*('(/&? +8/&%0/)/,? /7 %?&'>*4') :8))1 *1 0*,0)? ='&*'9)8" -/58=8&6 /+8 &8)'(*=8)? :/+1*1(8+( 78'(/&8 1*4') :8))1 *+ (08 1 &8,*/+1 0*,08& *+ (08 :/&(*:') 0*8&'&:0?R ('&,8( (08 '%*:') 48+4&*(81" P8)) >/&%0/)/,? '4'%(84 7&/> U'&8i6 X'+,6 '+4 T81(8B08 EMNNQR"
!"8
$%&'()*+, '+- ./0+$/+
D/48)6 (08 &81%/+18 /7 ' +88 &8,*/+ :/>%8(8 (/ &8%&818+( 4*1(*+:( 1(*>16 :/>%8(*(*/+ '+4 ,'*+ >/4%8(8 (/ 98 &8%&818+(84 9? :/&(*:') ':(*=*(?" 208 /8 /7 (0*1 :/>%8(*(*/+ *1 *+7)3 ' &'+,8 /7 4*778&8+( 1//4'(' 10/5+ '1 7*))84 (&*'+,)81R" 20818 >/48) +8%'&(>8+(1V 208 9'1') 48+4&*(816 50*:0 &8:8*=8 78847/&5'&4 :/++8:(*/+1 E10/5+ '1 1/)*4 )*+81R6 '+4 (08 '%*:') 48+4&*(816 50*:0 &8:8*=8 78849':; :/++8:(*/+1 E10/5+ '1 4'1084 )*+81R" b/481 *+ 4*778&8+( &8,*/+1 '&8 &8:*%&/:'))? :/++8:(84 9? 78847/&5'&4 '+4 78849':; %&/A8:(*/+1 E/+)? (08 :/++8:(*/+1 /&*,*+'(*+, 7&/> /+8 %'*& /7 +/481 '&8 10/5+R '+4 '&8 ('&,8(84 9? :/++8:(*/+1 /&*,*+'(*+, 7&/> /(08& 1/8 '1 (08 1?+'%(*: 58*,0(1 '( (08 9'1') 48+4&*(81 58&8 )8'&+(" T*1(*+:(6 +/+/=8&)'%%*+,6 *+%/+1(&'(84 (0'( *( %&/=*481 ' %/58&7 7/& (08 D?H;I GD@;= :@;C8+(" `+8 18( /7 %'&(*:*%'+(1 )8'&+( (0'( (08 %'*&1 /7 /9A8:(1 *+ 8':0 &/5 /7 D*,8>98&1 /7 (08 1'>8 :'(8,/&?6 50*)8 ' 18:/+4 18( /7 18 :'(8,/&?6 (08 %'&(1 10/5+ '( (08 9/((/> 58&8 4*',+/1(*: 7/& (0/18 :'(8,/&*81"
*+7/&>'(*/+ *+4*:'(84 (0'( %'((8&+1 5*(0*+ (08 1'>8 &/5 508&8 *+ (08 1'>8 :'(8,/&?6 /+8 +/48 *+ (08 '(*/+ *+4*:'(84 (0'( %'((8&+1 5*(0*+ (08 1'>8 :/)+ 7/&>84 4*1(*+:( :'(8,/&*816 /+8 +/48 *+ (08 8 :'(8,/&? ED*,8+(1 78849':; 8+0'+:81 (08 ':(*=*(*81 /7 +88+(1 5*(0 ' :/>%8(*(*=8 '4='+(',8 /=8& +8',8 78'(/48) (/ (08 /+8 481:&*984 08&8 (/ 1*> ' %&8=*//&8 )*;8)? (/ 98 %8&:8*=84 '1 (08 7*,*)'&)?6 %&*/& 8B%8&*8+:8 :'+ 8+'9)8 (08 18,>8+('(*/+ /7 '98>98&10*% 8=8+ 508+ )/53)8=8) :/41 *+ 4*1(*+:( :'(8,/&*81 EF/)41(/+86 MNNQK F/)41(/+86 X*%%'6 G $0*77&*+6 IJJMK -'&+'46 MNQ\6 IJJ_R" 208 >/48) 58 0'=8 %&818+(84 '9/=8 :'+ ')1/ 1*>'(:0 (08 )8'&+( /9A8:(" $*>*)'&)?6 *7 ' +/=8) /9A8:( *1 1*)'& (/ ' %&8=*/'(:0 (08 %&/(/(?%8 *1 )*;8)? (/ &81/&8 (0'+ /+8 1(/&84 &8%&818+('(*/+6 :/>%8(*(*/+ 98(588+ (0818 &8%&818+('(*/+1 5*)) 48(8&>*+8 50*:0 1(*>/48+(1 *+4*:'(84 *+ E'R" b/(8 (0'( *+ (08 (/% '+4 9/((/> ,&'%01 ')) (08 +/481 &8%&818+(*+, /+8 /& /(08& /7 (0818 18(1 /7 )*+8 18,>8+(1 0'=8 @8&/ ':(*='(*/+ '( ')) (*>81" a+18(1 10/5 (08 &81%/+181 /7 +/481 *+ (08 %8& G -'&+'46 IJJJR" D/& //48) (08 4*778&8+( ':(*='(*/+ 1('(81 &81 :/>%8(*(*/+ 98(588+ (08 +/481 *+ (08 8(8&1 ')/+, (5/ %8&:8%(',81 /7 1f/48) 5'1 '%%)*84 (/ ' 1*>*)'& ('1;6 *+ 50*:0 (&'*+*+, 4'(' :/+1*1(84 /7 (08 7/',81 58&8 %&818+(84 *+ &'+4/> /&48& (/ (08 9'1') 48+4&*(81 /7 (08 )/58& &8,*/+6 (/,8(08& 5*(0 *+%',81 5*(0*+ (08 '&&'?6 508+ E9R (08 +8(5/&; 0'4 988+ (&'*+84 (/ :)'11*7? *>',81 *+ (08 ',+*(*+8 0/5 4*1(*+:()? 4*778&8+( *>',81 58&8 &8%&818+(84 9? (08 +8(5/&; E188 (08 H:(*='(*/+ 18:(*/+ /7 (08 H%%8+4*BR" 208 4*1(*+:(*=8+811 /7 (08 +8 (08 (&'*+*+, '&&'?6 '=8&',84 /=8& MJ (&*')1 5*(0 8':0 /7 (08 (5/ :)'11*7*:'(*/+ ('1;1 *1 10/5+ *+ D*,8+1*/+1 &'(08& (0'+ (08 *&&8)8='+( 4*>8+1*/+1 E$*,')' G X/,/(08(*16 IJJMR" `+8 %/11*9)8 8B%)'+'(*/+ 7/& (0818 8778:(16 *+ ',&88>8+( 5*(0 //48)6 *1 (0'( (/%34/5+ *+7/&>'(*/+ 7&/> /(08& :/&(*:') &8,*/+1 18&=81 (/ 10'%8 (08 18+1*(*=*(? /7 a2 +8%)86 4*1(/&(84 =8&1*/+1 /7 (08 7/8 %8&:8%(8+( *+%%)'&R6 E7R 508+ 78849':; *1 4*&8:(84 (/ (08 =8&(*:') 9'& '( (08 :8+(&8 /7 (08 )/58& 0')7 /7 (08 *+%',8 E' 78'(%)*7? &81%/+181 (/ (08 *+4*=*4/+8 G T%)8 /7 (08 1(*>%)8 /7 (08 1(*>" #*(0/%)'& %&818+(84 (/ (08 +8(5/&;" T*)'&*(? /7 /(08& 8B8>%)'&16 (08 1'>8 +/48 5*)) ')1/ 5*+ 1%)'&1" a+ (08 %&818+:8 /7 78849':;6 /+8 *+%%8(*(*/+ 5*)) )8'&+ ' 1(&/+,8& 1?+'%(*: 58*,0( (/ (0*1 78'(%)'&1 E*"8"6 ')) (08 9'&1 :/+('*+84 *+ (08 %&/(/(?%8R" a+ (0*1 :/+4*(*/+6 +/481 *+ (08 ',8 78'( 8f/&8 4*778&8+(*'(84 5*(0 ',8 E7/& 48=8)/%*+, *+7'+(16 o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d');8+*?(06 MNNQK 48 $'6 MNNhK 48 $' G d'))'&46 MNNQK L'? G U0*))*%16 MNN\K L/g&4*+,6 G L/g+*,6 IJJMK U0*))*%16 L'?6 G $>?(06 MNN]K U0*))*%1 G $*+,8&6 MNN\R" D8849':; *+7/&>'(*/+ (0'( 18)8:(*=8)? >/4/48)6 1*)*'& 1(*>86 !'&)/(6 G 20/&%86 IJJMK L8?18&16 p*'/6 D/g)4*'i;6 G U8&&8((6 IJJMR" 208 7/&>'(*/+ /7 1%8:*')*@84 78'(/&8 &'%*46 &8:/,+*(*/+ /7 1(*>*,0( /(08&5*18 98 4*77*:*: 9*+4*+, E->8)6 IJJMK Y/1;*816 MNNNR /& (/%3 4/5+6 '((8+(*/+')6 %&/:81181 EY8?+/)41 G T81*>/+86 MNNNR 18&* G F'%*&*:') 8=*48+:8 (0'(*/+ /7 >/&8 1%8:*7*: '+4 1%8:*')*@84 &8%&818+('(*/+1" P'(8,/&*@'(*/+ &8f16 50*)8 *48+(*7*3 :'(*/+ &8f*+'(*/+ '>/+, 1*>*)'& *(8>1" a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
$6&% ' $7 &% $6&% ( $7 &%
%*&
6 508&8 $7 &% '+4 $&% '&8 (08 18+1*(*=*(? =')%)/?84V '%4*#$ ' 4#$ & !.*#$ ! (%!#$ ' !$ &( 4 )#$ )!!
%!!&
( #08&8 4#$ *1 (08 >8'+ /7 (08 *+%8 /4*7*'9)8 *+ 7/1( :/>%8(*(*=8 )8'&+*+, '),/&*(0>16 +/481 '((8>%( (/ jj9)/:;WW /(08& +/481
' 322-4'56 1/-2) /3 %2&52%(7') )2'&+*+,
!MO
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
!MQ
$%&'()*+, '+- ./0+$/+
48,&88 /7 >*1>'(:0 &8f'(:0*+, *+% 7/& :/>%8(*(*/+ E5*(0*+ ' 1*+,)8 )'?8& /7 +/481R &'(08& (0'+ (08 '1 8>%)/?84 *+ HY2" a+ '44*(*/+ (/ (08 *+(&'&8,*/+') :/>%8(*(*/+6 481:&*984 '9/=86 (08 %&818+( >/48) ')1/ *+:/&%/&'(81 >8:0'+*1>1 7/& *+(8&&8,*/+') ://%8&'(*/+V SB:*('(/&? 78847/&5'&4 '+4 78849':; :/++8:(*/+1 98(588+ 4*1(*+:( +8/48)6 +/481 0'=8 (5/ 78+(1 *+ 50*:0 18%'&'(8 18(1 /7 78847/&5'&4 '+4 78849':; *+%/41 0'=8 %&/%/184 4*1(*+:( 7%'&(>8+(1 (/ '))/5 78849':; (/ >/4%)/?84 +8/48)1 >';8 +/ 4*1(*+:(*/+ 98(588+ 78847/&5'&4 '+4 78849':; :/++8:(*/+1" 208 >/48) %&83 18+(84 *+ (0*1 %'%8& (0%%'&(>8+(1 :'+ :/+(&*9%'(*/+1 *+ (08 5/&)41 /7 7&/,1 '+4 &/9/(1" ?+4"'":"30 @&4*00")*&:*6 AB6 ]_cQJ" d';8&6 P" a"6 d80&>'++6 !"6 G `)1/+6 P" Y" EIJJIR" a>%':( /7 )8'&+*+, /+ &8%&818+('(*/+ /7 %'&(1 '+4 50/)81 *+ >/+;8? *+78&/(8>%/&') :/&(8B" C34D+* C*D+%$:"*&:*6 EEMMR6 MIMJcMIMO" d');8+*0/)(@W1 8:0'+*1>1 7/& =*18+') =*1*+, 1%'&18 &8%&818+('(*/+1 9? )/:') '+(*3-899*'+ )8'&+*+," 5"%0%)":30 /O9*+&*4":$6 RT6 MO]cM\J" D&*1(/+6 L" ."6 G d CI (/ C]^ !2 *+ 0'+1" Q+%:**2"&)$ %' 4H* C34"%&30 ?:32*7O %' N:"*&:*$ VN?6 UAEM_R6 \]NMc\]NO" D&*1(/+6 L" ."6 G U&*:86 P" ." EIJJMR" T?+'>*: &8%&818+('(*/+1 '+4 ,8+8&'(*=8 >/48)1 /7 9&'*+ 7 *+(8&':(*=8 ':(*='(*/+ (/ '4'%(*=8 &81/+'+:8" /%)&"4"#* N:"*&:*6 PP6 I_cO_" F&/1198&,6 $"6 G Y'*@'4'6 Y" EIJJJR" P/+(&'1(318+1*(*=8 %8&:8%(*)*'& 7':81" L+*&2$ "& /%)&"4"#* N:"*&:*$6 TENR6 __Jc__\" -'&+'46 $" EMNQ\R" U1?:0/%0?1*:') '+4 :/,+*(*=8 '1%8:(1 /7 :'(8,/&*:') %8&:8%(*/+V H :&*(*:') /=8&=*85" a+ $" -'&+'4 ES4"R6 /34*)%+":30 6*+:*64"%&M LH* )+%D&2>%+8 %' :%)&"4"%& E%%" Mc]IR" P'>9&*4,86 ZLV P'>9&*4,8 Z+*=8&1*(? U&811" -'&+'46 $" EIJJ_R" P'(8,/&*:') %8&:8%(*/+" a+ (&:O:0%6*2"3 %' :%)&"4"#* $:"*&:*" d'1*+,1(/;86 ZLV !':>*))'+^b'(%)*:'(*/+1 7/& 10'%8 %8&:8%(*/+ '+4 /9A8:( &8:/,+*(*/+" F"$D30 /%)&"4"%&6 W6 hQNc]M\" -%0&8?16 F" #"6 G D/&486 S" !" S" EIJJMR" -*8&'&:0*816 1*>*)'&*(?6 '+4 *+(8&':(*=*(? *+ /9A8:( &8:/,+*(*/+V jjP'(8,/&?31%8:*7*:WW +8816 H" P"6 U'?+86 d" Y"6 X/>98&6 $" F"6 F*&'&46 U"6 G d%&/=81 4*1:&*>*+'(*/+ 98(588+ 7*,>86 C" H" D"6 G Y/8)718>'6 U" Y" EIJJJR" 208 4*1(*+:( >/481 /7 =*1*/+ /778&84 9? 78847/&5'&4 '+4 &8:'++6 d" EMNNNR" H +85 :8)) 7/& :/%+8$6 WE_R6 __]c_OI" !:H4'>16 P" ."6 G !'6 WW6 _\]chJ\" !80('6 H" T"6 Z)98&(6 a"6 G $:0&/848&6 P" S" EIJJJR" a+(8&>/4') 18)8:(*=8 '((8+(*/+ *+ >/+;8?1" aaV U0?1*/)/,*:') >8:0'+*1>1 /7 >/46 H" EIJJMR" `9A8:( &8:/,+*(*/+ '+4 /9A8:( 18,&8,'(*/+ *+ h"]3>/+(03/)4 *+7'+(1" X%D+&30 %' (=6*+"7*&430 /H"02 Q$O:H%0%)O6 AWEMR6 _cII" `A'6 S" EMNQNR" b86 !" #"6 G H109&*4,86 S" EMNNQR" S=*48+:8 '::%+8M /%76D434"%& "& C*D+30 NO$4*7$6 REIR6 II]cIhO" U0*))*%16 #" H"6 G $*+,8&6 #" EMNN\R" a+ 18'&:0 /7 :/>>/+ 7/%/6 F" ."6 G D8&+'+48@3T1 /7 :/,+*(*=8 1;*))1" /%&$:"%D$&*$$ 3&2 /%)&"4"%&6 R6 IO\cINJ" o') 81(*>'(*/+ '%%&/':0 (/ =*1/48) /7 =*1/+86 Y" EIJJJR" H((8+(*/+ *+:&8'181 18+1*(*=*(? /7 Ch +8" C*D+%&6 BTEMR6 \cN" Y8)0'&(6 T" S"6 -*+(/+6 F" S"6 G #*))*'>16 Y" ." EMNQOR" X8'&+*+, *+(8&+') &8%&818+('(*/+1 9? 8&&/& %&/%','(*/+" a+ T" S" Y8)0'&(6 ." X" !:P)8))'+46 '+4 208 UTU Y818'&:0 F&//48) /7 >88(" LH* C*D+%$:"*&4"$46 AE]R6 h_JchhJ" $')*+'16 S"6 G 20*8&6 U" EIJJJR" F'*+ >/4%8+( /7 78'('(*/+ :/484 9? 1*+,)8 +8%/&') =*1'(8 =*1'6 $"6 !86 C" H" D"6 G $:0*))8&6 U" -" EMNNOR" P/+(8B('&? =*1
