Correlating XML Data Streams Using Tree-Edit Distance Embeddings Minos Garofalakis
Amit Kumar
Bell Laboratories Lucent Technologies 600 Mountain Avenue Murray Hill, NJ 07974
Bell Laboratories Lucent Technologies 600 Mountain Avenue Murray Hill, NJ 07974
[email protected] [email protected] ABSTRACT
!" #$ %"'&(*),+- . -0/1!"234!"5 &6/*7 / +' 34+' 8! 9 / &:; )@?/*A/ 2 B/ C!"&6/1EDF +G9/ H?I+' -GJK&6/*+A!"2 3L/ ? -H?M%8NM/$2 --A/*O '-.P? !QR? !"A/ +-S&:G !+ T4UVW-NM'"-. &:-X*)Y , "!" Z!"V/*[ ' / "2 !Q&\)] 4 %!"[!" "N$'&$. % '??!"2M '-.P? !Q;? !"A/ +-:&:- !"+'!"/ _^7`S[W'+-* H/*+' !"E2 H/1A/ 8''!"2_/ 5 -$% H?a*)b$DF" 2c d 2efdOJ; R? !"A/ +-?!"* ! M% GgV-'Z/ 8N6?/1A/ -',!QM/*V&: dh? ''Ti_I?-&: A/1j M-&;% ??!"2B/ "2 *!Q& +'/ _% 6/*"!"?k!+' *l+-!" !Q_1kA/ ? &m -+G . !"2'+G!n8' oEDpJ%!"?_/E+' &:H/*+-SN !S )K/&6/*. !"[W 38 / &:!"2?/*A/R '7H/1X+/ :% 7 ?:/ ,/+' +'!" 2 /*)]*)]"f '!"/ C !"&6/* '-.P? !QK?!"A/ +' +- &: A/*!" 'qL/ ?L3rDPs J/*C !"&6/*S' QR*)X --.P?!Q . ? !"A/ +-t !"&:!"/*!QgNtl !"I1[W-k+' 8!" Iu?8+'&:'8 '/ &:'TvUYV% 'X )f X"?2 3W' /*VV,/ Q. 2 !Q&:!"+K' Q7 6"7.w?!" !" E'&;% ??!"2 X)x 7 'G.w'?!Q ? !"A/ +-7&:- !"+''3W/*H?S ;+- '/*!"2:DF T 2T"3W 2 ; !"&:!"0/1!QgN lg !"AJ7B?/1A/;!"E '/ &:!"2$&:? 'FT 1.
VU XINTRODUCTION yvC' !%"V=/1 >Y/*2 H/ 2 RDFrJH!"OA/ !?QN'&:G2 . !"2z/*Ek-{A/ H?/*A?|)]*k?/1A/a-' '8A/1! }/*H?i-C. +AH/*2 : B;~wG-T$UV$ !"&:" 3Y 'Q)x.w?- +-!"%!"2/* *)MA/ H?/*A?a &:!" '9I'/ %"M/k% W/ ? !QM*) -C .P2 '-A/*!" ~g8-GS/ "!+'/*!" '3rA/ 2 !"2)0 &m!"8'"!Q. 2 '8,4'%$ /1+G!"2/ ?:n8- N !"2K'"'+- !"+K+- &:&:-+' Tr~g &6/*8N$' '+-'3k?8+-&:'8V/1!"A/*+''*)4-G;]
FA'
F ;W
P orV?-QN !"2?/1A/R&:?'+' &:!" 'X/ E WG G ;
F A*)7 G:G
X? ''3-/ +A6'"'&:'8V+/*6% R'!Q. -X/ ;/* &:!+?/*A/K!"-& X/R+' &: !Q?/1A/+' "-+-!" :+' . !"!"2S )L-)x-'+-'D]' ' '8?:/ ,?2 'AJX+A!"?$'"'&:'8 !"$7M ' TX -3 WA DF*3
P gJv ?;!Q: ?/*A/;--&:'8?' +-!"% / +-/ L '&6/ 8!"+' )r?/1A/ T UVM-C !%!"!QwNa )Z@?/*A/I&:?-7&6/ W'9!Q6/k[ - N
Permission to make digital or hard copies of all or part of this work for personal or classroom use is granted without fee provided that copies are not made or distributed for profit or commercial advantage and that copies bear this notice and the full citation on the first page. To copy otherwise, to republish, to post on servers or to redistribute to lists, requires prior specific permission and/or a fee. PODS 2003, June 9-12, 2003, San Diego, CA. Copyright 2003 ACM 1-58113-670-6/03/06 ... 5.00.
H/1A/*f/ H?: VG )] 8 f)x V-' '8!"29?/1A/)0 &/!? [ /*!"-gNk*)7~g8--?/1A/M +'''TM)V+' 3r2 ![ 'B;gN . !"+/ X/* &SN ), +AI +'''3L!?'8!"+/ * !"&:!"0/1?/1A/Z!" . A/ +''9+/ a% :' ' '8?_ !"2B? !Qf-'8;L.w?8+-&:'8 '9 +- ''T9 GC/*&:" 3O?!Qf--R !"$- +'- &6/'NR 4? !"!+-O8+'&:-OUvN v- +-!" 4DFUVJ +G'&6/ S-C V'!Q7-4 !"''3'/ ?!"299?!Qf-'8V?0/*% '" / ?M ' +-''T,yv[W'Z'E/ &:UV! ?L3 ' "!"2Z ''&6/NM*R/[W/ &: +G 3f? ;' -+'*)v !" H/ L'"'&:'8/*H?/1 !%'Qp'*T !"[W'IS' -+'9 )V +Gk +GA/ v? !Qf-'+-'/ ?k!" . +' !"'+-!-'3!"X!"v %[!" /*v+'* '/*!"2M?/1A// +- ?!Qf--O +''O'? LV-"NR 6G H ¡ x:
w4L.w?8+'&:'8 &6/*+A!"237GIk/ C!"&6/1! |!"En8/ 8!QH?5 2 / B/ !/*S2 '-A/ K xA
P* A::G
FGF9% -wV''It?/*A/ '''Th¢+A|/&:G !+M)] Z+' &:H/1!2*A?-?50/*% '"?5 '- H/*R% '-I?'[W- ?%8NM+' &9%!"H/1 !/ r/* -#&6/1+G!"2 +' &:&;!QgN6!"E)x &( )7
F - ]
K*]
P AS £1PT7¤,!"-N83 '-.P? !Q4? !"A/ +-7&:- !"+7!7H/* A/ 2 '-A/ "!"¥/1! 6 )f? !" ?!"A/*+'E)0 &¦E !"2? &6/*!"Oq' '8!/ "QN83VE '-.P? !" ?!"A/*+'#% -wV'-zg4 ' +-':' ' '8:&:!"!". &;&§ &;% -X*)r%H/* !"+R? !"4 -A/1!" DF?K!" - '3?-G''3 / ?Z'/*% '"AJ'?'?Z; A/*)]*&( -;*-T UO'G.w'?!Q? !A/*+'S!"/:H/1A/*r&:- !"+S)x R+' '/1!2/*H? ?!" +'1[WG!26/ C !&6/1&6/*+A-7!E_? 8+'&:'8+' "-+-. !" 9DF T 2 T3 2 #/*I/ !0/1'QN#? -H?E !"&:!"0/1!QgN."l !" GA/*!" HJGTUVZ %-&m% '+' &:-S/* !"+'0/1QN+AH/*"'2 !"2 !";4+' 8-CX )r
F *;]89?/*A/R +'-'qWH/1,!"'3W' +A#+'* '/*!" n-!"'R'?E6% 8+'- ?k1[WG+' !". 4#?/*A/ '/ &:,/*4/* !"[WK/ ?$''?;S% 8+'' ? I/$+- 8!" K%/ !"'3H!Q K% '-K )v -[W-A/ YH/ - 1[W-v/KA/*!"+ 3 - !"'8X?/*A/K!"&6/ 2 Tv¨"2 *!Q&:Y)x X+' -0/1 . !"29 +AMB?/*A/ / &:V4 ?6''?6SV :H? -7[W- N !"2 '8R+' A/*!8'3 wN!"+/ "QN *[!?!"2kD/* 1C !"&6/*JVG. Q4S Gn8-!"'4!" oD/WJ,"8 !"2;/*VK--[ /*V ?/1A/} © HAt Hz]#ªY¡8 8GhD?G-&:!"?%8N /*&$.g/1 !"[ /*VH/1 - JGq,/ ?L3KDF% J !2k/a$ ] /*&: 89 ) &:'&:* N;D]wN!"+/ "QN831" 2W/1!Q&:!"+,*r "N " 2 /*!Q&:!"+,!, !"¥' )V /*&ZJ,Qp 38s3p'« 3p£*T,)+' 3W +G9 / &:!"2*.P '+A!0n8'S/*Z&: :2 --A/*QN/*!"+/*%"Z!_:+' 8-C9 ) 2 3HUO-A/ %8Na?/*A/ %/ ''3- - )x &:!"2;&;Q!"" H/* '71[W-,?/*A/9+- &: K/ Z-C/ +-V- QV+/*M% *. !"%!"!"[W-"Nk-C ' !"[W T6~gk +A +-'H/1! '3vH/[!"2B]8 - *A3 WA-]¬5-PG
|n8- N.P8+-' !"2#/*2 !Q&:/*S*. ?+'2 8?.wn/ "!QgNE/ C !&6/1/ V-K f-/$[W- NZ[!/ %
/*H?/1 A/ +-!"[W/*Q-H/1![ :"p'«*T ®*¯x°®k±}°H®*²v³;=/ !"[W 3O+- 8!" ?/1A/: / &:R/*!" ;/* . A/ "QNI!"B/6[ /*!"-gN )4?!Qf-'8/*!"+/1!" B? &6/*!"'3f!"+'"? . !"2-wV*#&: !Q*!23O-A/ !"Q.P+G/ !"_/*H?¨XU=´ A/ / +-!" 8+'' !"2 3Y'%.P -[WG'+- A?I 2 2 !23r/ H?# M OT¨/:-. Q34V/*M!Q' !"2a/#'+''8: 2 *)!"8-':!"5?/1A/*. '/ &¦+' &: A/*!" L3,!+AtH/ ;'?k '[W-A/*D]'*-!"+/ /*H?kA/ +G!+'/ 0JH?!"' !"21[W'v -.PH/* / "2 *!Q&: !Q|"!"&:!Q?5&:-&: N_n8!"-&:'8;)]*E? !Qf-'86 %"'&:'q GC/*&:"'#!"+-? on/ 8!""_/ ?h*A?- .PA/*!"!"+'I+' &:A/1. !" kQpµ3fp'¶*Pq? !!"+- .P'"'&:'84+- 8!"26 ¶3 ·1q )0n8'8,!Q'&$. GI+' !"2h 39s8p-q:'!"&6/1!2t)0n8'+-Ni&: &:-'3Xl !" !"¥'-'37/ ?5? !Qf-'+-M &:EQp 3s3Kp p 3Rp¸1qK/ ?L3,+' &:!"2 -.*:&;Q!".w? !&:- !" / V! 2 A/*&:: :¹R/ /*;7/[W'"-6? -. +- &: !Q!" $Qp£3rs s1TR¨"Y- 9/ -K'QN# k/ I/* 1C !Q. &6/1Sn- N.P8+'' !"2$&:?'F3HwN !"+/ "QNM%H/ '? I/ I/* . !/*SH? -QN !2E © HG H]S?/*A/: +- TUVSN -*) +A !"+'S)x R/$&;% G7 )v/*% 1[W-.P+'!Q?E/ -/*%H/* ? :W-NB!?/*)7 H-G P º»WG
PA¼G6!"+AO3v' -!/*QN83 +'/ I% S 2 8*)V/*R !"&:" 3 A/*H? &:!"¥'?"!"/11l'+G! *),H?G"N !"2?/*A/!Q'DFAJXD/* &:?RK% , !"Y! &: &:-!"+[W'+-* H/*+'1JGT ½K'+'-#4 @ ¾L.P%H/* ?h%!" H¿* % +-!"% aN '&: ? / "6!Q|¾? 8+'&:-$ / &:'37%6 QNz!"z+' . GC ), !"&:" 3 ?!"+/1-.P%H/* ?:ª
wGA]E*)4!"?!"[!0? H/*r?8+-. &:-4 µq8+'"/*QN83*V %-&} )H-À:+'!"'8QNS+' '/1!2 ? 8+'&:-/*+- &: !"K /*&:K2 !"[W'7!" $/ ?A/ !"+/*QN5?!Qf--9 -; )! ''T H/#-:/*FT"p'*K? ! +- -[W-A/ ?!Qf--/ "2 *!"&:)] X - )x &:!"2K '-.P? !"?!"A/ +' lg !"R*[ -R?/*A/*%H/* ''TUV'!QV*!"8 ?+-S'/ !"- . . +- &: % H? K E --.P?!Q?!"A/ +'&:- !"+/ ?E - '!"!"+':H/16+/ z !2 !QH+'/ 8QN5? +'M+' &: A/*!" / +- M!+' '?|?/ "Q.w/ !Q6 '-.P?!QM?!"A/*+'I+' &:A/1. !" 'TX¹RV-[W-3 H/S-K/ FTX)]8+' "'QNE ¡WW-
rlg !"+' &$. A/1! / ?B'!Q9/ "2 !Q&:Sn8!Q;
F -G6*[ - 7?/1A/ qW!" %[! QNS'H? -r'&}!/ "!"+/ %7!";/?/1A/*. '/ &( - !"2 T Á$ ®ÃS°HÄLÅ'®*¯xÆ Â Å¯x° ÄYÇ ³#¨"v/1!"-4 I B+' '/1!2+' . !" ?/*A/; /*&:D] 2 L3 T 2 T"3 l !" K*&È+' &:A/1. !" AJS!"a &6/*4 H/ +-M/ 9-!"?a _Z/ &:!" a*)H/*3 -0/1!" H/*?/1A/!Q'&::1[W-Z &:/ !0/1_6GA#É '
P* WAGqK!"$!":+'- A/ !""NaE+/* E!Q5E W-+A.P%/ ? N !"&:-+G/ !" &ÊD?!" +' ?k/ % 1[W1JG3 !+AIH/*R% ''# /*"2 !Q&:!+S8 *),+A !"+'9)x &: *)X' S/*"!"-' '/*+A Gf 'TË)]* /*'QN83'!L"!"&:!"A/1!" 'H? -L/*"!"- /*&$. !"2- Q4 '"' 4)]*7? !"-+-QN6?/*"!2!"6 /*&:,*),
FA'
F BW]Ì1 -
FZ?GH'?B1[W-9/E+' &:"-C6G
FA6P GG3X +G/ L.w?8+-&:'8L / &:L!Q;/V '-.P? !Q?!"A/*+',&:- !"+ Tr¨K /&: X+' +--,-C/ &: 31+' !0? -r, %"'&@ )'!"&6/*!"2 ;' "S !"¥'6 )7/B]; *G]
© Ì ]a -A/*!" H/1Klg !" -'!"IwVM! f.w?8+'&:'8 '/ &:R ; 'G.w'?!Q ? !"A/ +-E!";% '"Í &:Z -G¿ /*!"+/1!" .w? -H?_' ?LT ¨ H/*+'-.P-À:+-!-3 -.PH/ r/ "2 *!"&¾)]*X/ C!"&6/1!2 +G 5 !"&:!"/*!QgN:lg !"V ?B 1[ !? $/ B!" [ / "/ %"S8 F3Y)x !"A/ +- 3? !"2?/*A/!"8'2 A/1!" ;';V/17 N!"2R'!Q. &6/14;Î?-2 '7*) +' 8'8 !"&:!"/*!QgN Ï% GgV-'9wV? !!"+- ?/1A/ +'',/ '!QX?8+'&:'8+' 8'8v/17 / &:!"2 !"LT ~wE!"H/* -34 ªvG
!" ; %-& )O/*C !"&6/*!"26DF!"6 &6/ "H / +'1Jv7' Q7*)Y+- . -0/1!" Zn8-!"'X%H/* ?$ $ 'G.w'?!QV? !"A/ +-SDF"!"W7 !"&:!"/* . !QwN4l !";? ' +-!"% ?/ % 1[WJL1[W-O+' 8!" L6?/1A/V / &:'T
UV9+''8-!-+'$ )4 "!" !"/Z1[W'v/ "2 !Q&Ð)x -)0. )]-+-!"[W'QNDF!FT T"3Îg %"!"[! QN Ï6"p'·*xJKG:A W ]89 / &:!"2 / ?, 'G.w'?!Qv?!"A/*+'V&:G !+,!"/&:-!"+,[W-+- / +' n8!" ?!"I9A/ ?/*A?k^7`?!"A/*+'$ &3 !"$2 H/1 . / 8'-!2/zÑ, G
w - GM% ?z )9b$DF" 2 cfd" 2eLdOJ: ?!"A/*` +'R?!" !" Z% -wV''Z/*N:?/*A/ '-4!QE/1V&: dt?-'T R '&;% '??!"2M!"+' &:"-'QNB?--&:!"!!"+6/*H? '"!"' SH/1 !"2/ S: '4!"8K/K!GA/*+AN*) -+'!/ % . '''T,R V/* !"2S&6/ W-, *)r/?G-&:!"!"!"++' !". !"2 8+-' $'+''8QNa!"8 ?+'?a%8NÒ4 &:? /*H?t=E8!" . H/*z Ó*X)]*S'&;% ??!"2M/E[ /*!/ 8*)V$ !"2 .P?!QS? !A/*+' !"8a^ ` qR14'[W-3V !+'VI/1I?/*"!2!Q|2 --A/*K '- A/*-$/ /*$ !2 '37 :-&;% ??!"2k/ "2 !Q&Ô/*H?!Q / / QN !"/*R !"2 !QH+/*8"N6&:*+' &:GCL3 /*H?$' "V!Z? !"fG . '8% H? 7 E?!"A/ +'?!"* ! OT _/*" h? '&: A/*a1´ [ '+- .P / +''&9% ?? !2 +' +G! 5+'/ % E+' &;%!?!Q/*"!"-6 W-+A!"2I-+G . !n8-MQp 3p'« 3p1¸7k %A/*!a1[W'V/*"2 !Q&:9)]*oIDp1J+' . +G!2a/ &6/*K W-+AzN !"6 )S/B&6/ !"[W 37 '/ &:!"2 ?/*A/$ '9/*+/ k% S ?#/*/:+' +'!" ; 2W/1;)]* v)]" -4!" '-.P?!Qv? !"A/ +-4+' &:A/1!" 'q / ?L3 DPs Jf'!Q. &6/*!"2$' QR !¥-9*)V/$ '-.P? !Q .g? !"A/ +-S !"&:!"/*!QgN;l !" 1[W-9gVI /*&:;*)R@? 8+'&:-'TUY#Z% '; ) "?2 3 /*K,ªXAA
4/ "2 !Q&:!"+R' QV Z %!"[!" '-.P? !Q:?!"A/*+'-&;% ??!"2 '3X/ H? -f-+-!"[W'QN+' -0/1 . !"2M+' 8!" '3L&6/ !"[W$ /*&: )Vt?/*A/T9;% '"!"'[W H/17 '&;% '??!"29/*"2 !Q&Í/ " $/ 7 -7!"&: A/*8/ . "!"+/1! 'qL/*R/*-C/ &: 3+' &:H/1?M6/ E-C ' !"[W 3-C/ +- '-.P? !Q6?!"A/ +'E+- &: A/*!" t/*2 !Q&´H/*;+/ n8!Q _kb$DFdLÕ*J!"&:k £*34 ;'&;% ??!"2E+/ % Z ?_I*. [!?6/ |G W H¡ ]:*
wM?!"A/*+'ID]E!Q!"a/Eb$DF 2cfd" 2He dOJ )F/*+- GJ7!"B *- ]f A3 !FT T"3 b$DFd" 2 e dYJ,!"&: T 2. PRELIMINARIES
ZÖ ×¾Ø}ÙZÚÅ'Ú×}°LÛYÜ ÝVÚHÄrÛÞV®1ÜÜ8ßàRÛr¯0Å:ÙE¯]Ç'Å-ÚHÄrá Ü ³¨E ?8+-&:'8Z!"' '8!/ "QN@/ § 8G WA 5
FBâ3- /*+G?I!"|âÐ' ' '8E/*¾'"'&:-E/ ?z!"E+AH/1 . / +G-!"¥'?5%8N_/ WA A/ W-)0 &Ô/#C ?/*H/*% -$*) !"2 "!Q-A/ ";ãvTZäR? :0/*% '"9+'/ $: '&6/*8!+-S*)75'"-. &:'8'3/ ?M? 2 '!"Mâ@+/*R'"'&:'8'!"2;!"ER ?/1A/ T!Q V )r2 'GA/ "!QgN83 V/* &:KH/*7/*H/1. % -;ã+/ ';/ "7? M/ % -'34"!"GA/ "'37/*H?a/* &:!"+E[ / "' H/1R+'/ I/ /*R!"I/ # -MDF T 2 T3f%/ ? ?- . QN !2IUV$DFAJ JGq44E/*" k)x8+'$ aZ A?G?L3X/ % '"?_ ' +Gk )k§?/1A// H?|!"2 kIA/'7.w+AH/1A/ +-G ?/1A/+' 8'8X!" !?K? 'X!Q: !"2/ % -RD]åæ ç8èWé è3æ ç8è éWè3 -+ T JGTV Zê â9ê/ ?_ê ã4ê6?' S&;% -7*)X?-!" âh/ ?Z&;% -4 )vN &;% 7!"ãv3' '+-!"[W-"N8T !"[W'#g4E5? 8+'&:'8K ''Râ ` / H?â 3f6
F-g ]
]
P HA% -wV'-9â ` /*H?â c D?' ?%8Në D]â `'ì c â c J JL!X? -H? / 4&:!"!"&;&i &;% -Y )H --.P?!Q -A/*!" A/ )]*& : ':!"I/**-TUV6A/ ?/*A?B -;*)7 '-.P? !"9 G . /*!" Z £1V!"+-?''oZDpJ$ WA ]DF!FT T3v+AH/*2 !2E:/*% '0J )X/S '? íHqYDPs JS8 G
FxM/S '? íkD/*H?Z&:*[!"2$/ " )íHî S+G!"0?'a?-!QSH/1'8GJGqX/ H?f37D£WJ;]-GG
F]8_/EG ? VíH?Gv/K?Vït/*H?&:*[!"2/;
F 7-- ð-G A )rïSî 7+A!"? 'BD/ H?:-!"K? ' +''?/*AJXH? -V-i? íHTDFäR*K/*V?-.P!" G ! M -A/*!" E!"V' '8!/ "QN6 ` ¨K"L" 2Hî !"6!"7H/* -?- R%H/ G.s" 2W/1!Q&:'q " 2efdk?G. *'6&;% G )" 2B/ "!"+/*!" 9n8!"'??+':d k/In/ 8!QgNBH/*9!"Mñjp 34/ H?_!":/_É G © Ñ © !"+G/ !"2 )]+-!" )dT
+- &:"'&:-R )4?;?'"-!" OT J_¨I-C/ &:";a ';/ H? --.P?!QM -A/1! }/1k?'!+G?|!"hr!"2 ap T\~g|!"M/*. G3O4:+' !0? -S/M[ /*!/**)VS '-.P? !"S? !"A/ +-$&:- !"+ 3 G&:?
F-g*]
*]
P A$ÑXx
x¼I-
F :$ É G3 H/*3f!"k/ ??!Q. !" _I6/ % 1[W:-ZA/*H?/*A?_? !"S -A/*!" '3V/*";/ % ':I% 6&:1[W?BH? -9/I-u?6!"_: 'Z!"a -OT4% '"!"'[WH/1 % '&:1[W-K&6/*W ' S/ /$!"&$. !Q!"[WS?!Q -A/1!" k!+' 8-C )X?/1A/9òM!0? '8!"+/ % +-';+/ 5/ /*:!"5?!Qf-'8;8+'/*!" kD])x :GC/*&$. " 3f?6/$ "!2 8[ /*!/*!" #*)vUVJG3H/ ?M/* A/*2 !2 +G % +-- ? %H/ %QNB% :+- !? -?a/ %/ !"+ /* -A/*!" _/ ? $!" - !" B 9?-G! OT:~wk;'&6/*! . ? -7*)Y!"V/ -38-&´Îw 'G.w'?!Q?!"A/*+''Ï9/ &:'4 )x 4 !&:!Q!"[W7? !Q, -A/*!" ,?' +-!"% ?:/*% 1[W 3W/ &:'QN9? -0/*% '"!"2 '3 ?'"-!" '3H!" G ! '3H/ H?Z % '&:1[W''T publication book title
authors
publication paper
title
author author author
DELETE
authors author author
book title
authors
paper title author author
author author author
ó¯xô  ®1ÜIõöR÷Xøù úEûfü"ýþÿGý ýù -ý*ý ÷ ûfý-ù ÙZÚÅ'ÚLÅ'®1ÜÚÇVÚÄrÛ!SÚHǯ]á"L²HÜ Å'á$#r¯xÄYôY³X~g/?/*A/*.P /*&:!"2 - [!Q &:'83 ?/*A/*.P 8+'' !"2Z/ "2 !Q&:R/*9/ ""14?#: ' M!"+' &:!"2k?/*A/'+'*A?DF T 2 T3X'/*!" H/ 7"';*: ? 8+'&:-AJK © A/ V-NZ/* '/ &:!"2S!"M)x &{DF !Q. %QNHJ7? !"fG'8R?/*A/; +'-;Qp 3 s3Yp'«*T¤V/*+G8 A/*+G!"2:1[W- '/ &Ê/ ?B-C !"+'!QS/*+'+'' E/ S?/*A/M'+- A?!"!"&: !Q. %" T6UV$?/*A/1.P8+'' !"2#/ "2 *!Q&m!"S/ " #/ ""V?/M &6/ " /*&: *)&:'&:* N838gN !"+/*QN W A]
x¼9; 7 © W A]
x¼9 !"Z?/*A/1.w '/ &Í !"¥' 3!"M*A?-79&6/ !"8A/ !"M+- +-! $ © G H ];?/1A/E +G'R)x ;! /*DFAJGT$~gB/ ??!Q!" '!Q4 &6/*" / +'7n8!Q'&:-3*- 7N ', 0?;/ " % '/ !"QNa+' &:A/*%":!"/ !2 "ZH/ 91[W-Z?/1A/#/ ?!" &6/*"O - .'+- A?M 8+'' !"2$!"&: TX¨VK/*N6 !"K!"M!"&: 3 /*"2 !Q&¾+/ S+' &;%!"X4&6/ !"8A/ !"?+' ""'+-!" 9 )N ' ;?+'/ E/ C !&6/1R' "T )]8+'Y vH/1 !"+'/*OgN v ) /*&hN -'3 / &:'QN 'GW P W*»WG
PA¼Gq W-+A'YH/[WX1[!0? ?-f'+-!"[W4 . " ! ;)x 6 '[ -A/ 7 /*&:!"2k %"'&:'3X!+'"H? !2Zlg !"5/ H? &9Q!Q."l !"# 8+'' !"2B"p 3Os3p'«*3f*&j+' &: A/*!" aQp p 3p1¸P3 ? !"!+- .P'"'&:'8L+' 8!2 ·*3W/*H?R!" 2 A/*&}*Y¹R/ /* .V/1[ '"- +- +-!" iQp£37s s1TM? ' +-!"% M6%H/ !"+'; )K W-+A!"2 !"2M/Z !"&:"S%!"H/1 N.lg !"I+/*A? !"H/ "!QgNI-!&6/1!" Bn- N_QpGPT =E*B -+'!QH+/*QN83/ &:/*ZVI7/*Z'!"&6/*%'& æ( )+*8é D-,`/.1023, c JG3V!FT T"37M+/*A? !/ "!QgN5 );lg !"| )g4 '/ &:!"2:'/*!" 4, ` /*H?5, c 1[W-/ I/1 !%6DF 3H -*) /1 !"%-AJ76S3W [ / "',4/ &:9D]!Q 4" 7 )O2 -. GA/ "!QgNJMA/ 2 6*[ -988p ì;:=@? TI>L- !"2@ACB D1DwJ:D-EF&Ðp ì sq DG&p ì;:::LìH= JX?' 77)x'n'+GN$ )LIDKJ1L[ /*!M, B 38!" !"X/ NS '7/*N%O&QPSTVR U ` A ` D1DgJ>A c D1DwJGqW'3%@+'/ $% 7+' &$. ?S-C/ +-QNS!":b$D = Jr H/*+' Tv~w9-!"v -&:!/ V*f3W¨" ;- /*FTrQp 3 s1O @i$%!?M/9A/ ? &:!"¥''?M'!"&6/*)x W%! &6/*"3f!FT T"3Lb$DF" 2 = JK H/*+' T¤,!"-N83HSW-NM!?/:!"6%!"0? /E»WG
PA¼_DF' '8!/ "QN83 /9A/*H? &:!"¥'?E"!"'/*K1l'+G! J7 ) ? !" !%!" [ '+- 6)x '/ +A! 6 / &T¢ +A/ -+G )x 9, B !"; !"&:QN?-?/ YX B & PSTVR U ` A B D1DwJ[Z T D-E\&mp ì s JG3
G/8;Z T oD]&p ì;:=@? !"/:)F/*&:!""NI*) ^' A;^- -Ñv]- ]H8w G 8G
8+_p ìa` p ? A/ H? &¦[ /*!/*%"''T@UVEW-NG!" H/1,ZRA/ H? &\[ /*"',+/ 6% +' +-'?6 .P"!" !"2S/ '?Z ) !"¥' QNMb$DF" 2 = JG3/*H?Z&6/ !"8'/ +-R )GX B 1[W- b,4B$ /*&Ð!"-C '&:-"NE !"&:" oKA/* !"XBc&¾«M/*H? l9/ ??Z T !XBM''[ -D J1L [ / "$*)6u!"S % G[W? !"z# '/ &T¾~P6!"Z'|/*Nz_ 1 H/16#? +- ),9 W-+A'dX `]e X c !"/ k%!/* ?k-!&6/1;)]*Y%$3O!FT T"3 f: XM` e X &g%:TrUYR% 8 vV/*+'+' A/ +-N;/ ?S+' H?'+'4*)H '!"&6/* c 3 '[ -A/ L!"H?- 'H? '87+' !"' )r/ % 1[W-.w? ' +-!"% ? /* &:!"+R W-+A!"2S-!&6/1R+/*M% K&6/ !"8A/ !"?6/ H?6+' &;%!"? !"2:/[W-A/ 2 !"26/ ?M&:? !/ .P '"'+G! GA/*!" 9Qp 3Hs1T 3. OUR APPROACH: AN OVERVIEW
UVWGN'"'&:'8K ), R&:G? " 2 NM)]*+' -0/1!"2Z+' . !" $h?/1A/B /*&:$!"M/I1[W-/*"2 !Q&¦H/*IG$ A : A? -?f3r/ % '"?k ''S/ ?B; --.P?!QS?!"A/*+':&:- . !"+;/*R !8!I/#DF&:G!+J7&9Q!Q.w?!"&:' !" H/ O[W'+-*R / +' n8!" ?6!QEA/ ?/1A?E^ ` [W'+-*K?!"A/ +' 3 !""S2 H/1 . / 8'-!26/: &6/ "r? !* !" # )v?!"A/ +'9&:G !+ TV~g#*- V*A?'37 $-+G!n8';-"N 5&6/*!2B'/ +A5@ 'Zâ M/Z&:G!+[W-+- dh6D]âRJK +G#/*R9 'G.w'?!Q? !A/*+'- % -wV''M !"2 !/ r '-/1V'"Q.w/ C!"&6/1?E%8NM^` [W'+G 7? !"A/ +-'V )L 'K!"&6/ 2 -V?-,&6/ !"2 q8H/* !"'3W)]*V/*8NSwVM ''7iI/ H?â3 ^7`X?!"A/*+'Sê"ê h6DKivJj_ h:D]âJ'ê"ê ` &kPlVê h:DKivJ- m _nh6D]âRJ- m wêH2 !"[W'R/62 8?B/* 1C !"&6/*. !" *)r --.P?!QK?!"A/*+'ë DKi ì âRJGT ¤4' !? '2 H/1A/ 8''!"2/M &6/*"X% ?I B$?!"A/*+':? !". !" O3rM% 6/ "!+'/ %":!"_/E?/*A/1.P / &m - !"23 +G/ '&9% ?? !2/ "2 *!Q&}'? L/*!")0NgVK/ ??!Q!" / Wn8!"G. &:'8'oDpJZ-&;% ??!"2 0?_n8!"6 &6/*4 H/ +-E/*H? !"&:7 -4?/*A/ ' q / H?f3HDPs JK-&;% ??!"2 0?$% SW xÉF 3 /*!"Y4[W'+G !"&6/ 2 Ih$D]âRJO )H/ ',âa+/ *X?' '? M -7 ''7!"M!"7 /*DFAJGT,R7-&;% ??!"29/ "2 *. !Q&Í/1!'K/ "O' n8!Q'&:-'T UVGS!"K/ #GC - !"[W"!Q-A/* #"7.g? !" !" #'&9% ? . ?!"2 V*)r&:- !"+R / +'-7!8S*&:?:[W'+-*7 H/*+'''q)]*K/ Z-C. +''""'8v [ -N ),- Q!"S!r/*/3W"/* 7 '4,'+'- H/* -K%8N6~gH?N #"p'·*T4¨hW-N:- QK!M!"/*/$!"K¤4 2W/*!"Oî "'&:&6/$1[!"26H/1/ B/*%!Q A/* N!Q;&:- !"+S H/*+';!"'&$. % ??/ %"!"/ E^ c [ '+- / +'!"E 2W/1!"&:!"+?!" !" Oq )]* H/1'QN83,¤4 2W/ !"Lî $-+G!n86!"$'!Q-$ &6/*7 / +' * %"!"[ !" _DF!FT T"3!QEn8!"-E"?2 *)9B+' &:"- &:- !"+6 H/*+'1JG3v #-6!";# %[!" 7/'NBI/ QN_!Q;!"/ ?/1A/*.P /*&Í - !"2#Qp·1PT4UY;% 'K )r K"? 2 3 / "2 !Q&È2 !"[W'V4ªXA
4 %"!"[ !" '3 &6/ "f H/*+'1¿1!"&:[W'+-* . H/*+''&9% ?? !29)x /;+' &:"-C6 '-.P? !"K? !"A/ +-&:- !"+ T !"[W' Y/ "2 *!"&@)x r/ C!"&6/1'QN'&9% ?? !24 /*&$. !"2S# ''/*H?$ '-.P? !"7?!"A/ +'R!"M/ M^ ` [ '+- V H/ +- 3 6 / &:!"2-+G!n8'KDF"! KK -+G!"2&:-?:? !". +' ?:!M¢'+-!" Ms Jv|% -+' &:'"'[ / 8T~g$!"4H/* -38V )]8+-r wV!"&: A/*r/ "!"+/*!" r ) Y' QY!"X+' . -C ) '/ &:!"2X3Y/ ? :1[W-4/*2 !Q&:)x o Dp1JX%!"?!"2;/S &6/ " W-+A6N !7*)/&6/ !"[W 3 '/ &:!"2 E?/*A/K ' q8/*H?f3HDPs J/*C !"&6/*!"2KV !"¥'*)f/R !"&:!"0/1 . !QgN$lg !"k*[ -a /*&:'TSR+-;/*2W/ !"L3O' $/19 ' ": 5+- '/*!"2|DF!"5 &6/* / +'1JS&6/ !"[WEh?/*A/ /*&:K%/ ?M MR '-.P? !QR? !"A/ +-&:- !"+ T
4. THE EMBEDDING ALGORITHM
~g!"R '+-!" O3 V9?- +-!"% 9 -&;% ??!"26/*2 !Q& )]* $ --.P?!QS?!"A/*+'6&:- !"+$!"a? -A/ !",/ H?B1[W$!QS &6/ "Q.
!"&:/*H?M?!"A/ +'-.w?!" !" 2 /*A/ 8'-'TXA/* K%8N6!"8 . ? +'!"2$ &:'+'' /1 NE A/1! H/*Y+' [ '8! 'T Ò4 !?GR/*E*A?-?f3/*% '"?Z 'âi1[WGK/ "/ % -ãv3/ H? "-;do&mê â9êQTk¨K" 3X"-;ík% Z/? Z!"_â3v/*H?_"-;ÇM? '* /I
F 9--ð-GHG$*)4+A!"? '#*)X?SíZ!#âT~w)v ?'!"IÇ9/1;/*Y'/1[ ''3 'MV-)]-6Ç9/*/I
F" * p^GgA¼ A-- ð-G Ak*)íHT@D¨ "/1)+A!"?5*)í/*:!":* / ?*l/ +''8X/ 8N9 -X'/*)L+G!"0?9 )fí!",+/*"'?:/ f q^A¼ *)KíHT J_: 6âS í ì Ç-,I?' :: % '6 )7â % A/ !"? /*;!" k )7/ "v % -'8 ?/*?'!"_Ç;/ H?k? íM!Q 'Q)g3f-A/ !"!2Z/ "? S/*% '"'TR_S/* Z A/*!" ârP í ì ÇGHS?' K-C/ +-QN9K/ &: % 'K/ 4âS í ì ÇG3-C +'' /*V$? 6 / 8+'!/16/ 8N#/ % 'r!QI8 ?SíE*) ; % ' TS_9?GH;/kÉ* FM-
F Z ),â§/ /*8NI % - *)O7)] &§âS í ì Ç-38â r í ì Ç-3 V//*:*)r? '2 'G.s?'KDF!FT T3 /IA¼*]J!âTKr!"H/*""N83V9/ &:S/:H/* )]+-!" sYDPJVH/1 &6/*S6 -:*)R/*"7[ /*!?a % ''9 )KâÈI-0/*% '"$!"t/ -.*.w #)F/* !" !Q|!2 %H/ %!"!QwNLq +A/)]+-!" +'/ #% +' &:?Z!" &6/ "Y / +'¿1!"&: 3H)x -C/ &:" 3 !"2$/ !"&:R&:?!QH+/1!" E*)Y4t/* .w½/ %!"M !"2SH2 - !8!"2 /*"2 !Q& Qp'Ó*T ¨VY/V!"2 "'[W-31 r/ "2 *!"&h ?+''r/K¼8PG A¼ AA x$ )Oâi!89/9&9Q!" -Iu:D]âRJX )Y '+'!/ L[ / "!?Z % '''T,UV [ '+- v!"&6/*2 Ih:D]âRJO )Hâ!"v' '8!/ "QNS$Îw+G/*A/ +G-!"!+[W-+-. *Ï)]*6E&9Q!" -/u:D]âRJEDF1[W-$ H/*+' )/ " !"%" [ / "!?6 % -'AJGTXyX[ ': 2 6?!"&:' ! H/*!QwN: )h6D]âRJX!"'3 !":2 '-A/*F3GC '8!/ !":dv3 ,+' +-!" 6!""H2 H/*A/*8' /*vh:D]âRJ,!"/ " :[W- N6 /* ovK A/*O&9% -V*) .P¥'- +- &: '87!"@h6D]âRJ,!"K "NMb$DFdOJGT UV'3LS-+G!"+/ +GC#"!"'!"I9?-A/*!"*)4 !GA/* . +A!"+/*O/* !"298+'- V)] â/*7 ?+-'4[ /*"!0?.P % - &9Q!" -wu6D]âRJGTk&6/*W# k )9/a !"2*.w 8+'' !"2t % . !" ' '8?%8N#Ò4*&:?S/ ?I=E8!" / B Ó1rH/1 'v?G-&:!"!"!"+V+' !" .P !"2RKHH? H :*»*4!;/ 9! !"2MiV3!"+G/*'M ?E: !Q4i!"8:2 *),s; £+' '+-!"[WK+G/*A/ +G-'TX¨|W-N; G gN9 )L'!Q,0/*H? &6/*8. %/ ?k2 !"2Z'+A!nMD]G&:?Iæ$xyz{+|C}~I!"k!"H/* -GJ !"SH/*3v2 !"[W'/ !"2I )"'2 E 3:+A !"+'Z )/ '+-!"+ +AH/1A/ +-Gz/*$/I/ H? &6/*5D/ H?f3X+' n8'8QN83Z+G ' 2* z )+AH/*A/*+--:H/1$+' 8A/ !"fJ9?' '?9 QN t +AH/1A/ +-G4QN !2!6/RA/ ?!", )L" 2eE ` µ"-)07/ ?;!"2 8 *)I Ó*TXUV'3 / !"2*.P?!QV -A/*!" Z8+-+' !"2S !?!" "8+/*-!2 % 8?|*)S/_+G/*A/*+-- !Z2 /*A/*-?z*M /1f'+-:2* )]*&:?B+' 8A/ !"!"25OTZ¨V$!""V ' 3Y!" - wNS!v+-+'!/ !"$1[!"27?!"A/*+'-.w? !* !" $% H? )x -&;% ??!"29/ "2 *!Q&T R :/*2 !Q&º+' +-:/I!"-A/1+G!"+/ H/1 !"2k )RâÈ! -[W-A/ L/ ''TXT ~wMH/ WD3 R/ "2 *!Q&(%!? 7/ M A?G?L3 /*% '"? T1 -` Zâ /*$!"$ %A/*!?_)x &´ 'Z )KZ'[!" H/* $â %8Nk+' 8 A/*+-!"2+'G A/ !"a?2 ''TBDUV:!"!Q!/ 4 - âv4T !"-C/*+-QNS4*!2 !"H/ !"r ',âST JUV'3 / +A;?4í/ â +'* ' ?RM/6+' '+-'?I % '9 )Xâ
!"I)]/ +-3O /*"2 !Q&\2 H/1A/ 8''r/*!" % 'X!"% V/9É* FRA-
F A *)âT4>L-Kí D]âRJVT ?' [ / "!?E % '*)râ}+- ' H?!"2 E?:ítâ q$? $/ % 'X)] Sí#!"S?-G&:!?B%8N# / .P)x+-!" I[ /*"bsYDFí D]âRJ JG3H-bsYDPJ![ /*"!0?.P % - / &:!"2S)]+-!" ?-?M/ % 1[W T UV -H?*.P+'?? ' +-!"!" ) '&9% ?? !"2S/ "2 *!Q& D]G&:?/W]IOJ!"7? '!"+-'?$!Zr!"2 s8TX¨4?' +-!"% ? /*% 1[W 3 K/ "2 *!"&È%!"0? /S!"-A/*+A!"T +/*O/* !"29 +- DF!FT T"3f/;!"-A/*+A8NM*)v+' 8 A/*+-?M '-â JV1[W-7!"7 - â3Y8!"r; ':!"+' A/*+-?I#/M !"2 "Z?Dê â T ê&jp1JGT UV&;Q!".P -u6D]âRJ,*)[ / "!?Z % ''7 ?+'?6%N6 /*.
-Ä ®1°Lá Â Ü Å Û öÂ ®1AÜ5? -v?L3 ]/ % I-'?EXDr â}'J âT Á$Â Å Â Å öI,-+- K'&9% ?? !29h:D]âRJ4 )râT ÆvÜô ¯]Ä p TDo &« q âW;o &hâ sT9#r¯]ÝxÜkDKê â T êpSJ7ÛY° £ T w°®ZÜÚá$#zD&6/1C !&6/*f+G/ !" )?'2*'-.gs9? '!"Eâ T J7ÛY° ¶T Ë æ$xyz${j|C}~6:? ![!?+AH/ !"!"8;2* ),s9* £;? ' µT Ò4 8 A/ +-/ +A?2* M;)]*&(/;-@? )Yâ TV ` T Ü ÄrÛP°H® ¸T w°®ZÜÚá$#zD?íEâ T !QFzs9+A!"? 'IJVÛO° · T P°H®ZÜÚHáC#zD&6/*C !"&6/ f+' !"2 '/*)x.P+A!"? % n8'+' Ç*)íMJVÛY° Ó T ¯RDKê Ç8êhs$JVÅ;#YÜ Ä p«T Ò4 !?-Ç/ K/; !"2:/ ?MEæ$xyz{+|C}~6:?!"[!?Ç !8$2* )XsS £;? ' p p T Ò4 A/*+-K/ +A?2* M;)]*&j/9-i? )â TV ` p1s8T Ü Ý]Ç'ÜI¯RDKê Ç8ê&upÚHÄrÛaÇY&8ï ? !""-)0&: K +AE"/1) % n8'+'?-í J4Å#YÜ Ä p£T =E-2 ` !""/*)0.w+A!"?ï@!8$í:;)x &(/;-@? )â T p'¶ T Ü ÄrÛw°H® p1µ8T(Ü ÄrÛP°H® pTDKo &
D ` p p1¸8TYÜ ÄrÛ#r¯]ÝxÜ p·TGu:D]âRJo &8+tí D]â T J ì D o í/Mâ T )x R/ "LH/* 'ID ? pÓTh:D]âRJo &ÐÎg+AH/*A/*+--!"!"+9[ '+- Ï; )u6D]âRJRDF '?-!Q!" !"MGC GJ Ü ÄrÛ ó¯xô  ®1ÜLö Á$ ®MÞV®1Ü Ü8ßàWIÆvÜ ÛrÛr¯xÄYô\ZÝxôH°H®*¯xÅ#t³ !"2a)]*Eâj+' 8A/*!/*R[ /*!? % ''Z+' - H? !"2at/ " ? '4*)OKH/*H!"-A/1+G!+'/ H/1 !"2S +- A/*2 2 ?6!Q /H/ I/ % -a? !!"2 !" |% GgV-'| % ''6!"?!Qf-- / ''T q H/*X!"'3+u6D]âRJO+' &:!" 'X/ "tí D]â T J ì D a)x 4/ " ?- íEâ 1[W-/*"OH/ -]DDP¢'#p· JGT,r!/ "QN83V? -HR^ ` [W'+G !"&6/ 2 Yh6D]âRJ,*)râi$% REÎg+AH/*A/*+--!"!"+[W'+-*Ï$ ) R&;Q!Q.P -u:D]âRJGq!"*-4 A?'3 h6D]âRJ- ¢¡ ì D 7 o & &;% -4 )!"&:'Vc¢¡ ì DNi % --. H/* +' &;%!"/*!" #/* /1!!u6D]âRJGT D]_, 44 A/*!" /h D]âJfR? '*4X' !"+-!" $*)£h$D]âJ _ QNz % '-Z8+-+' T !"2/1ZH/* 5D T J{¨ &6/ "K-C/ &:" -C '+' !" ;*) X'&;% ??!"2/ "2 !Q&!"X?'!"+-?9!"+- !/ "QN !"#r!"2 £ T UV6^ ` ?!"A/*+':% -wV'-:[W-+- !"&6/ 2 ' )7wVE '- ii/ H?kâ!"S?-?k!":A/*H?/1A?&6/ -3Y!FT T37êê h6D]âJ _ h:DKiXJ'ê"ê ` &¤Po¥¦§N¨©ª«§ ¨¬ªHê h6D]âJ- _Oh:DKivJ- wêQTu~g|kG. &6/ !"?- )v!"K '+-!" L3 VS1[W R&6/*!"'*'&j '/* .P"!/*!"&:R+- &:"-C !QgN$ ) ^ ` '&;% '??!"29/*"2 !Q& / ?I9" 2W/*!Q&:!+$?!" !" k% H? RH/1 '&9% ?? !2 2 /*A/*-'K)x '-.P?!Q?!"A/*+'&:- !"+ T v£®£Ê¶T"p T/¯O¼W]I# W A]
x¼¾A*
FG-
FV
x¼ É -
P 7]$8 h$D]âRJ7p^7 $x H
L
Fvâ@]$
F]:b$Dê â9êg" 2 e ê â;ê Ja° ^GA
x¼GG
x¼6É -
P ch:D]âRJZ
P ]:
R$
7b$Dê â9ê J$ *H±*G R *fG
FOGi ` ? '*!i r í ì Ç-PTB>L-/i ? '*:6 '6 %A/*!"? %8N|? '"-!"2gir`Z)0 & i4T§UVIc '*'& / % 1[WI!"&:"!"'6H/* ê"ê hZDKivJ_DKh:DKi `I` i J J'ê"ê ` !Mb$DF" 2c d" 2eLdOJGT§¤4 M4I+/ !"+- i!` Fi c /*" c /*9:)x ': %A/*!?_%8Na? '"-!"2i` )x &}âTUV'3ê"ê h6D]âRJC_Yh:DKi `C` i c J'ê"ê ` !v/*" b$DF" 2cfdR 2eLdOJGT UO!/ 2 "!"n8H/*"!"wNZ@!&:"!-R' "T r!"H/*QN83* XVV? '"-V/? 4íK)x & iVTr>O-YXH/*- )Xí6% ïSTV¨"Y+A!"? - )Xí6h% '+' &:+A!"? 'E )vïTV_ +/*Z!$ )L!"V 8+'' /*4)] "'T7>L-ÇK% K+A!"? 'Z ) íHTvr!Q44&:1[Wi r í ì Ç- / ?$&6/ W!Q4/+A!"?$ )LïTäR3íS!" /:"/*),? 3 6V9/*l?'"-!"2M/:"/1)4?STUV '3 7' Q4)]*4!X+/* )] "V)0 &§K/*2 &:'8X/ % 1[W)]* ?-G!2:/;"/1)v?/*H?Z&:*[!"2;/; % ' T UV'3*!Qr À:+''LK 1[W4UV' -&}¶T £TXRO8*) 8+''? / " 26)] T "!"2M!"''T;? -H/ a] "4HGHA9 Z)]* /*+G$ '7â !: ,!"-A/1+G!+'/ H/* !"2 Tv~g!Q!/ "QNDF!FT T"38H/ «WJG3v!S'2 !" 5!"lg96? MíB/*9!"+Ga4E? '"-?_ â`9 % - TB¤43v!"S'2 !" 2*1$/ ;4M 8+''?_#GC / ''TY_4';/12 VH/*r!")VV!"2 V!!" H-+'4-2 !" / ?6+'* ' ?!"2S'2 !" E!6â` ` â 3-Zg49 '- "8 t[W- N !"&:!"/*kDF!"|/ 8NH/ JGTiUVc '37!Q)4+/ 5% H? SA/*:/1!"+AB!'2 !" 2 V$+'/ _/*" E% H?# ^7`?!"A/ +';% GgV-'#gVZ[W'+G 'TSUVS/ k8N!" 'UV!";!";/ "!"2 8QN¾Îw2 '-A/ "!"¥'? ÏB % ':&:1[W 3r !"+'Z!Q9/ Q. "$)] Z/k+' 8!"2 DF %HJg n8'+'M*) !"%"!"2B % ''; % &:1[W?!"z 'LT¹R4'[W-34!"Z!":/*N5B 'H/1:!Q +/*5% M !&9/*'?!Qt QNa 'M !"&:G:?!Q: -A/*!" '3 H/*&:'QN83/?!" - !" L3/S !"2 "-.P % -R&:1[W 3/*H?Z/S? ?-G! OTXUV'3W ,' QX ![!/ "QN:+/1 N:1[W-X+/ ) Îg !"2 "-.P % '&:*[ 'Ï;? !Q -A/1! 'T
*/ W/ +AS ?4 !"YX)x ""1!"2;oO'V,+G/ 2 ,â/1 &: !"3?'X)F/1/'7/'N$)x &!Q4-&6/ !":/*f'+-'?$!: )x ""!2; ' òSK G4*)Y?'X!"6!"+G6/H/1 !"+'T /*4? !"6/ DO!"" % 2* ?$':/* !"27 'â '&6/*! +AH/*2 '?LTEUV!"9!"9/#?!Q'+-9+' n8-+':*)7: - !"' *)vSæ$xyz${j|C}~M8+''? ?E)]*R2* !"26? '!"#/*+G H/* T @8+-'?M!QE8 )wTX-H$D]â `G` â J T / 7 -+' - H? !"2;ZD]â` ` TV â ` c J4/17R% -2 !"!2;*c )T / WD T /'N6H/*K/ST ? 4!Eâ
P ]V/;?4 r Zâ !Q)r G7 )O? 'V!":â T !"+G6VGR&:-2 ?$)x & Z+' A/*!"] r T ¨K8N6?Rïh!"Mâ +'* ' ?7:/9 %2*A/ Mï9D]âRJ,!"ZâSTv~P !"+-'/*/*ïSD]âRJ!"/*Q7/'N /Z+- '+-?# %2 A/*I )XâTR~P !"R/ " 6+'"/*/*K!Q)Xï/ ?ï r /1wVZ?!Qf--K?'!â T 3 'EïSD]âRJV/ ?Mï r D]âRJV/*? !]lg !"8T z
vi
(a)
vi
(b)
ó¯xô Â ®1Ü#Yö%$ù'&/(ý )+*o J rGK ? T L J rr!"R/$+- GR"/1),? 3 -R*)X?-ÇWMD J ì Jr]J% -g4''D Jk/ N? T J rv/*"/[W''3L/*H? ê ÇWMD J ì J r J'êO ñ 6T@UV'L37/ ?P ? J| = T¾DF~gtH/* !"+'/*3 6H/16/ 8Na"T /1)+A!"?a Q) G#!"+A5!":/I+'*-:? 2 -K/ ???6 = T J DF!!0JZ>O-L JI% T"-)x&: R" '/*)X+G!"0?*B) G;!"+G#!" / QT / ?N!"K ? DF!Q)v +G#/9+G!?EGC!"AJGTVUV'L3H/ ?A? J = T DF!"!!0JZ>O-Kï¾% T !"2 -R?!" ? T DF :!QR!"/ I/ +''* )+-'8-Kí JGT4>OGL J#% S/*#/ +'' )vïTV¢ !"!S+/ SH/*/ "? '% -wV'' JB/ H?Iï3f-C +'' -H/*Rï3 /1[ 9? '2 -:s3L/*H?ES"'2 I )X/* l !"!2 JI/ ?Mï}!"K/*K&: L ZTXUV'L3H/ ?H? J = T T DF!"[JZ¢ G,!"r/7+A!"Q? J9*+) G7 +AH/1r/*? ' +''?/*T )L !"%"!"2 4 R) JkDF*-,H/* JM!Q 'Q)AJ4/1R/*Q/ ?N:!"A T? T >O-S J r % V74'7? ' +''?/ 8X T) J$!+A:!",!"H ? T~w) J r r !"/*8N#?- +''H?/ 8 B ) J r +AH/1S/*$lg !"!"2 '&§+' A/*!"7? '2 'G.s?', QN#DF!"+'"H?!"2-H? . T !"8AJG3/*H?ZH/ "'2 /1&: U 63'Z4/ ?5? J r rL = T
∆ i
v
u
v
i
< ∆
∆
(a)
(b)
ó¯xô Â ®1ÜWVLöX$ù'&!(ý Hý2 +aGý$% CV *üý2DýCkùjHý$ aY= T ,)ý!an ) ü"ý1A$q & ZL$[[&ZXù \$[V[&I$]*,&b(ýHý1M +aGý$A CV *ü"ý6ýCùjHý$ a= T ,)ýda9 ) ü"ý$q_^3&a`MjGý4ù ù üxüGHý2b 1ý Hùj 4c T!d e IùjGýMjdHý1b ý Hù+dOGR% !GNE?' +-!"% 8NE4S'?E' )] "''T7_ %H/* !"+/ "QN7/ 8O!"+-?,/ "8 ,?'r!" = T 4T /* !"2 +/*Z% /*f-+-?6!")LV?-GR 4&:?!Q)xN;K?-4!"5? TvUV
9 ':"''3X!"a+' *l+-!" _!Q_Z - !"'9 )K /* !"2 3v/*:'/ !"QN_ ''B+/ ;!")]/ +-TMUV:0/*9" !"S/M"!Q "$&: 9 % T6¢ J_!"S/M+A!"?k*g) GT; -3 /* &:6/*4?' +-'H?/ 8 g) G-C +'- -/ : g) J/1 !"5 ? T T½K'&:'&9% -vH/1V/* ?',!"A ? T /1[ K% -'6&:?!QH?f3 a-Nz&6/'Nt*E/[W#% '' ' '8M/*E/ "!"|#*!2 !"H/ - T$¤,3L!Q)4Vl; ? T 3L' GM% -+' &:'/M? ;*) ? '2 -:s$ "N83!"+GI&:/*H/1R!QR4 0?I/1f'+-% JB/ H? !Q? '2 --.gsZ? ' +''?/ 8R/*;/* ?aTUV!)F/ +G!"+/ ? %8N6":DF!"[JGT R1|+' !0? -7+/ R )7 AfGH8GT4¢ L G9/ /1"/ wVZ+G!"0?'OT|'#V9H/1 9â T 3 V$&6/'N&:G2 9/ "/1)4+A!"N? Jk B) G:!8 GTK~P)v 3 -EVS&6/*6g46!&:&:G. ? !/*: !"%"!"2 S*) J/ +- G9?':DF -6r!2 Ê JGT6¨2 / !"O3 9!? /:-S!"RH/19&:-2 !"2: B) Jk!8H G6+/ k/*f-+-R /* !"2#*)V- : !%"!2#? ''-NB/*: k? 1 ;'/1[ ''T
i
v a u
b
ó¯xô Â ®1ÜIhLöiKý1 ù')+ý!Hý5fkú 1^ ý2:)HûaDc T Z Hý2@j6ù k *Lý2 ;úMýl ;;ý$bHý1; R¹ /[ !"2_?- +-!"% ? = T 37"-Z6j?GHD? TV ` 3!T TVT"37` !" H-+':'2 ! z/196-C9-[W'V*) ;H/* !"2T0? !" -R*)v ST ` ? 'K!â TV ` !+A#+' A/*!"I/6? ) = T T UVT +-'8-V*) ? !XK? K!+A6+' TV 8` A/*!,K+-'8-V*) = 3!FT T"/3 GTX -&: 3/ 8N:?K!:â !"+AM+' 8A/ !"4/ +- G?!""r/*2W/ !"#% /9+' -K? T ~w!Q!/ "QN83v?GH ? & 81í ? TUV:+G!"0?'_*)íI!"+Ga/1 !"&:&:? !/*'QN5 z#G)xE/ H?| z!"2 M )'&:1[W? % n8'+'MÇE/1E&6/1W?_/*$+' -:T ?''T_¤VT / ? a /*% 1[WE"''34!Q6!:'/ N 'MH/* ? / ? = /1#/ Q7/'N +- '+-?M % -'7 )â T T ~PR!"!"&: * A/ 8Z H/1BÎw-C'H? ?Ï:!"'+'-. 2 !" = T !"T ? -HT ?E!"I +AI/6&6/*-H/*K/* !"26 )4/ T" ?'7!"6â _ = !""O 7% R/*f'+-'?Z%8N$R+AH/ 2 '7!"A ? T UV!"S)]/ +-9!"V% -+' &::+'"/1$/*S468+'''?!"B:8*)] !"k!" 'T +-!" LT:_$1\? -H:/M+- ' H?!"2 -3 m T 3Y! D]â ` ` â J TXUV'&6/ !"H? -V*)O '+-!" Z!"7?'[ ?;S1[8. !"2/*c ZI? 'E!"â T _n? T / H?¾D]â` ` â c J T _#m T +/ % 9&6/*+A?#!"k &:;&6/*-3f M/*/*+GkH/*!Q )4&6/*+A? ?'R+' ' H?##8G
FFA % '-!"Iâ/ H?aD]â `` â c JG3 - '+-!"[W'QN8T T UV9 GQ m !"aD]â `` â J T !"R?-?#/*)] "'6T m T / Q7/'N +- 8A/ !"$T Z8*: )â` T c Tt -3,/k?5J
§T D]â` ` â c J T !"6!"# m 37!Q)/ ?5 QNz!Q)--C !"Z0 / Jr W ? +A5H/1 JYD]â` ` â c JpoNJ r D]âRJ!" .P'&: gNDMJrD]â` ` â c JG3Y/ -C '+-'?L3 ? '*'7 % '+- ' H?!"2;l J#!"Eâ ` 6â c JGT I&6/ !"8A/ !"z#)x ""1!"25!"[ /1!/ 8Bo !"[W'/*Nz?
T
i
f
(T1 + T) 2 f(x)
Ni Mi
i
x
Pi
óK¯0ô Â ®1Ü0qfösrúMùû3g;-O-: |jrv% T :/Z?;!tD]â` ` â c J +GIH/1: T |#+' 8A/ !" | r Th~w: ) |r W m 37'5-#!"M/_?5 r ? +G5H/* r D]âRpJ oA| r D]â` ` â c J
& T9T >OGd% STV ` ;?9!Iâ T ` !+A +' A/*!" r T¢ !"+'" r = 3 @? TVäR3rD]âRJ,o5|fD]â `` â c TV5J ` r D]âRSJ o| r D]â` ` â c J & Ta¤4$'I |_ ?a% E!" m 3T /$+' A/ ?!"+-!" LTVUV--)xT 33| rT D m T TV¤XNZ!" [ /*!/* )]*â 3 -!"K/;?d Tr£ M` â C _ ? +GE/*g |jr&SAYD1 rxJGT >OGGS% ,TV X` ? ,!"â +- 8A/ !"!"2v r T¨K2W/*!L3 !Q) r = T 3 -b!N ? Tv¤4Y'YrD]âR J o!|LD]â `;` â c >J g r D]âR J o!| r D]â `$` â c JG3!"+GE!K .P'&: gN6T% '` +/* d r D]âRJ # & | r D]â` ` â JGTVUV!" V ?I!&:QNEH/16|50m T¢M r = T T¤4'Lc 3f%NM 8N - !; )RTVE ` "'&:&6/3 YD]âJ & |fD]â` ` â JGTz G37 +/**% !"? 3f G ! @|M!""r% S!Km c TV ` TUV'3H "'&:&6/9!"7 T
~PX!'3 --)x 3 À:+'!"'8v1[WV/*S ~ D]âJ & ~CrwD]â `+` â JGT VU !"R!"K/*V '-M6?;-CTVRK8*), 'T /$+/ -.P%8c N. +'/ #/*H/ QN !"6 )Í? ï(2 -:/* ?!"tâ T5 6/*+G +'/ 3 VR?'&: A/*KH/17ï r !""Y/*" ;2 GH/* '?Z!"Z-C/ +-QN $/ &:9&6/ -!"I; -D]â `N` â c J T T$~wk;!"8-'*) / +'E/ ?+- 8!" !QgN83r4?G)]-9M?-A/*!"$*)!"$8*) )]L[W- !" )r!"K/ -SQp1sT UV'34H/[W-A/ %"!" '?MR)]/ +-/*3!")YV"8 M/*7 [ '+- ch:D]âJ/*H?nh:D]â` ` â c JG3r:?-S+- ' H?!"2I H/* bD7*)]h:T D]âRJ7!"+GB/*S*- '8!"h:D]â `` â c JK/*T 9/ % -K*)S? T,R-C'!"7$% H?6 !"¥'*)B? T I u¶ T µT/¯O¼7] "4G AK l ? T ^'* ¼ -7D7 AxA
F q^Kb$D1D8" 2 e dOJ WG² ®1°f° öäR*T RH/17R&;% -4 )?'7*)v?'2*'sS/*/1 / ?? ?( ? D]"'VDF!"!"!xJr/*H?6DF!"[J JL/*7/1&: 1s ZTv¢ 3 / ??!"2 1[WG,T DLA/ 2 '4*)f V/*2 !Q&§7&;% -*)L +A$? ' !"A ? +'/ 6% R/17&: Vb$D1DW" 2 e dOJGT,¢38V''?:S% H?; &;% -7*)? '7H/12 -/ ???M?;"'DF!0J7/ H?kDF!"!xJGT i7/*$+- 8R T &;% -V )v"/*)X+A!"? 'M ) +-'8-S?:íT T !"+Aa/*6!"I ? TE>OG9E % $:&9% -*) +A!"? - )Ví !+A% -+' &:$"/[W-)x T T 9!"&:$!"Bâ T /*H? /*M&6/*W'?a/ $+'*-$?-'T>O- % ZM?';! ? T !+A:V-/ ???:/*,K"/1)Y+A!"? -: )fK+''8-,? *)â T 37)]*E &:5D-r/ D T¾UVT1 '` O3Vl 4I+'/ !"&ÔH/*5 T +/ z% /* !Q!" ?_!"/*S&: bP l U ` E ` p:+' !"2 9 GS +G /*S/*+Ga -S/ 9/*S&: S¶ Ð --&:'8'TM:1[W;!S%8N !"?+G! D TV¢3 !QK!7 R)]*â T T T Ò4 !?GV +A6/+' !"2 4 -, )L"/[W'X!"H ò9+/*!"! `T 3 ê `T êñz¶ ZT,&6/'NE/ ?D? "T /[W-K*)ví T 'T !Q-K !?*S) `T !"+GI/19+' 8!2 !" ` $S G = TUV'3H!"K - &6/'N#2*\E/Z !"¥':*)71 +' !"2 '/1[ ''T$¤,'k4 /* !"K -3HV!""Y?+'!QR%8NE/*'/ / Q)gTUV'3!" G$!"7Í+' 8A/*!t/1:&: $£ m'/1[ 'D]!"+A!$/*$&: ¶ $JGT UV--)x 3f/*+G#*)v P lT-U ` ` E l ` p` +- 8!"2 -!" T +- ' H?M:/9+' 8!"2 K -K!"Mâ TV *T ) !"¥'S/*T &: K¶ ZT ä34B&6/'Nz/ ??|*-E"/[W'E*)Sí = T\UV!"+/ / 'M QN6!Q)/+' -? R% '+- &:'7/"/*)wT §+' T '+' ![ "/[W-4 :-!"-, !0? *)f!",?7!"" % / ?? ?9 = TXUV'3 4;&6/'NI/ ??@E T &: S +AI - ),+' '+' !"[W;"/[W' = T T UV!"+' &:"-'7 K!"H? +-!"[W/12 &:'8T ¤,9 6H/1;'/ +AtH/* E/ ??9/*;&: $s+' -$?''T ¢3£P lT U ` E l ñisCD TUV!" KH/*K&9% - )X?'! T !"Rb$D1D 2 e dOJGT,UV!"1[W'7' QT i'?Z9% H?:?'7!"D]â `` â J T !+A/1 v!"â T Tv¤,r!+'/ S% 7? 4!"9-C/ +-QNS/ / " c 2 ,&6/*G !Q)4!Q+GR "' )âh/*H?ZT â` ` â c !"ET R8 )xK/ % 1[W T UV'38VK+/ 6? -TH/T % -7% )XD]â `T ` â c J /*H?:/$p-.pK&6/ )0 &(D]â` ` â c J _% /R % -, ) â +G9H/* DFïRJ-D]âRJG& ïSD]â `N` â c J)]*'[WG N#ïkzD]â `` â T c J T _n% T T GRV9+/ }!"/9 !&:!"/*&6/ -4H/*Sê % êñ5b$DF" 2 c d 2 e dOJGT /*1'/ ? NZ$+' &:"-R8*)v )vUV' -& ¶ T £ T ®1°f° M° EÞY#YܰH®1Ü Y ³ fökr!"C5/I/ !D TzÒ4 !0? -: % '-¡ +G/*Wh T D]âJ- g¡ ì D]7oh T D]â `G` â c J- ¡ ì D77T ~w: -,4 A? '3+¡X/ '/*4&:*7)xn8-QN;!$H/* '?: - â T / !"MD]â `;` â c J T T>L-rX -*)H +GS % ''Y% 4?' ? %8N RTY_ % -[ H/* ê ? T êF 2¦ h T D]âRJ- ¢¡ ì DN7_\h T D]â `G` â c J- ¢¡ ì D7 : J
~g?''?LT 3 +' !?G/$ '"¡WKRT>OG"h ` % S9 -R )X[W- !"+'- J!"Iâ +Ak/*Q JrD]âRJI& ¡-T9¢ !"&:!"/*QN83O?-9 -Yh !" D]â `` â c J T T,¢ 3Yê h ` ê _5ê h c ê$&Oh T D]âRJ- n¡ ì DN7_Fh T D]â `` â c c J- T ¡ ì DI7 : ä3H)]+-!" AI&;&6/*I/:T [W- -CE!hO` _I? :/;[ - -C6!"@h c T4¢ !"+'"A!"pGT.p 3 h ` C _ ? +/*E/1[ /*K&: ê h c ê ?''T~w: -,4 A? '3'? &;v+- 8A/ !"Iê h ` _ h c ê*?- )x & hO`-TK¨R?? !"2;!K)x R/ "r +G# % ''K!"N 2 !"[W-R R!n8H/*!QwN/*% *[ T _6+/*_7!QE/# !"&:!"0/1$!"'n/ "!QgNB)] 9% T TB¨??!"2E' L3V2 G ê ? T ê ` ê % T ê+F ê h T D]âJ- ¢¡ ì D 7_Fh T D]â `` â c J- ¢¡ ì D 7wê ì J GR &!"71[W-7/ "f % -''Tv~w)OV/ ??61[W-/*L[ / "' )D 3 V2 -? ' !Q?M' "T 4.2 Lower Bound Proof
RM8*))] ""I/ " 2tI4- .P% ?|8*);*)$Ò4* . &:?S/*H?I=E!" H/ Ó13f!/*!Q?8-R*R&6/*W )Y/ 8N: -+'!/ - !"'V*)Y V!"-A/*+A!"+/*f -/* !"2 q!" . / ?L3vV6 QN/ &:6/*S6H/1 !"2I +- :%!Q; #*)vS?/1A/; '9!" )X% H?'??'2*'YE_DF!"# +/* 3f ) +' 3 E& £ JGTBUVZ!0? /#!";'_# Í3X2 !"[W'_wV ?/1A/ ''/i}/*H?_â3vVZ+/ 6tÎg+G?!QÏI)x & M^` ?!Qf--+'*)'!Q6[W-+- 6'&9% ?? !"2 Iê"ê h:D]âJ_Sh:DKivJ'êê ` A/ )]*& i!"89âTX¨7!"B Ó13H 8*)!"K+- +-!"[W/*H? 1}S*[ -A/ "vH/1 !2M +-)]*bi}DF!"+'"H? !"2 i !Q 'Q),/*"/[W'AJ7+/*% A/ )] &:'?E!"$/*)]*âq A/ )]*&6/*!" |!"6 - )x &:?t-[W'Q.P%N.P"'[W'7!"/k% &$.w )F/* !" zDFA/* !"2E)0 &{$"/[W' )4$/* !"2 +-JGT DUV;?!"A/ +'-.w?!"* ! "V-% ?#)x '&9% ?? !"26!" / E!&:&:'?!/*+' n8'+' )v>L'&:&6/¶T ;!Q5E&¾£ T J Ig \¶T (T ;]8¼PG A¼FA G]8RA
FA-
FÑv]
x¼ 8 E*
R:*A
7n E VE§s
x¼M É G ] *G]8I
FG-
F4^-
F/iÍ AM
F *V^' A6 ]
Pa ¡WW-
©
x¼
9p^Z
F A;â{Ñv]
x¼
V$
VDPsCEc_5pJ'êê h6D]âJG_\h6DKivJ'ê"ê `
F-g ]
KG G
F H H8 ]'GA
F78 G
wGX WA 4 :-
F 9: É G7 $² ®1°f° AöK¨KV!"B Ó1P3 VK7 G )] &È/S .w?6H/ 71[WGV H/1 !"2S +- R )Gi43&6/*!"2S/ "f? '76 %2 A/* / /*!"MR% *EH/1 -. ' +-''3&6/ !"2S H/* I&9% -Z )S&6/* ? i? '/1"'[W';DF!T T"3/ 1J/D$ ) 6/* 6 'E? 8'; 9-C +''?¢h T D]âRJ- D]4M /t!"/ ? ),í D1fJVZ/ " E? '*S9[ / "!? % 'S+' ' H? !2Z/ !"*A?-M !&:"!")0NI; A/1! JGT:R' +''?/ 8*)7&6/* ? ? '/*S/ " 6&6/*W'?LT4=/*W'??-/1BÎw*'+-? Ï6? . !"2$H/1 -. ': A/ )x &6/1! a8+'- ;? ' +-!"% ?% '"3 !"E ' H/14?:*/ ""1¾/ #? !Q -A/*!" I; "!Q /;&6/1W?6? T _7 8+''?$% * &$.P;*[ -vH/1 !2 +- 7)] ik!" b$DF" 2VdOJ ?MD]-ZdO&(&6/1C8 ê i7ê ì ê â9ê ? JG3X' !"2IH/* /*)0-$E'?_ )R ?\DVE/[WM+G/*?t/ gi T +AaH/* ê"ê h D]âRJ _ h DKi J'ê"êQ`9&(« TkUV6%/ Z+/ kDF!FT T3X"'[W-V«WJS?/*" !QT B !"&:T T ?;/*% '"/ ?I+G/*'di !k/$)F/*!Q"NI A/*!"2 8 . )]* 7/1A?97/'NfoY)x v/*+G90/*% '' f3 !Q)h DKivJ- 8gh D]âRJ- 88'V ?-GRDKh DKivJ- 8K_nh D]âRJ- xJf&6/1W?R+- !"'Y )/fq - !" 3 !Q)Yh DKivJ- 8c h D]âR J- 8P3,'tV#/ ??@DKh D]âRJ- 8-_ h DKivJ- 8]J "/*)r?-K/*% '"?5Z/* &:"8+/*!" )Ni4Tv~wE/*+GM+/ 3 V - )x & ê h DKivJ- _Sh D]âRJ- 8gêr'?!Q: GA/*!" 6!"+Gt!":-C. / +G"NM+' 8 !%!" E )X/ % 'RZIê"ê h D]âRJ_\h DKivJ'êê `T4~wK!" /*NkM ';/*3Y/*$/ H?I )4$/*% 1[W$8+-' '3Y4$H/[W ê"ê h D]âJ_\h DKi J'êê `7&« T
~wH? +-!"[W'QN83L/* &:9/*3f-k4$A/* 9 A/ )]*&6/*. !" z/1:"'[W'ID 3,4E/1[ M' 2 t?-:/*:"'[ 'D7_@p q7H/1 !"'3Rê"ê h T1 ` D]âRJa_ h T- ` DKi T- ` J'êê ` &j« Tk_6 1ÈI+-/1 i !"2B/*6&: #DPs$Ew_@p1J'ê"ê h D]âJ]_Sh DKi J'êê `6 % '-.P&:1[W T -A/*!" 'TÒ4 !0? -#/_?@T i/*M"'T[W'vT DD/ 2 / !"O3Ka !"&$. "!")0N9V*A/*!" L3 47/ " 7;? '*4V+- ' H?!"2 [ / "!?E % '1JGTX~P)Nh T DKiXJ- Oh T D]âRJ- 3'ZVH/[WR-C/ +-QN h D]âRJ- K&6/*W'?5?-6/*Z"'[W'ID )Yi4î 6H/1 'EH/1 4T !"r / Q-q'&6/*!!"2:+' !"'!"r% "!"K$)]*& *-,"'[W'Q.KDL?-,/*4? ' +-!"% ?;-CTr~P)h DKivJ- £ h D]âRJ- 3 'VS-?E6%!"?#/ I-C A/#DKh T D]âRJ- KT _
h T DKivJ- xJKT +' !"' *) z?/16"'[W'ID T5? '&: A/*E(/ +A5 +G +- 8Nk+/ _% ;%!"Q%8Nk !"2kñÍDPs$E/_p1J % '$&:1[W; - . /1!" R!I*A?-Z% !"2: 2 --9ñQE"'[W'Q.AD1D_zpJ? ' )x &#DF*/*v-C !"'+' ) - K"'[ 'Q.GD1D_Ep1J?-,!" 2 H/1A/ 8'?%8NZ)F/*+-/*;ê"ê h T1 `1D]âRJa_
h T1 `DKi T- `GJ'ê"êQ`4&«WJGT ¢!"+'#DKh D]âRJ- -_h DKiXJ- xJ!"-C/ +-QNI$+- 8 !"%!" )] _êê h T D]âRT Ja_h T DKi T J'ê"T ê `3O$1[W-A/ "v A/ )] &6/1!" B)x S"'[W'ND 'n!Q'K/*K&: DPsCEc_tpJ'ê"ê h T D]âRJa_Oh T DKi T J'ê"ê ` '?!QK -A/1! 'T v1
x v1
v2
v1
v2
x v2
v3
v3
x
(a)
(b)
(c)
ó¯xô Â ®1ÜLö:'ú!6ùMYý^ ý ü]S8bHý UO9 '|4)]*&uvZ? R/17"'[W'Dr KH/*3%/ ? B R'&;% ??!"26/*"2 !Q&3L-$/19 ';? !"!+-+/* ' )x X4)x &6/1! $ )9)x &"'[ 'Q.GD1DC_MpJr?-'38/ ,?-!"+-?S! r!"2 · D/*.P+1JGTv~gZ+/* $D/WJG3jM!V)x &:?:%8NÎw)x ?!"2 Ï;9DF . !"%!"2 AJY"-)x&: "/*)+G!"0?í c )H/K?Xí ` !8!QrH/1'8q 4 +'/ +G/*;$ +''/*!"#? '!"+-?I!"r!"2 6·D/ JR/ !"QNk!" wV % 'k&:*[ ''oa ka'&:1[WI/*8N '8!/ R % - 8*?/*9:"'[W'Q.AD1D _ipJ?Zí c D]V6+/*a/ +'Z!Q$H?G í c î M*!"2 !"H/*H/*-M/1M#-[W'Q.AD1DI_}p1J$ '1JG3K/ ?| I &:1[WMaDF"/*)J6í c H? -:Eí ` ? T¾¢ !"&:!"0/1QN83V)]*M +-'H/1! ?-!"+-?E!"#+/* ';DF%L3 +1JG34S%/ !"+/*QN#'?/1R&: E6 % '&:1[W',96? '7!" [ "[W?6!"9"/[W''3/ H? /1:&: 9E _@p/ ??!Q!" / 7&:1[W'SI&:*[ 6' E"/[W-$!" ;!"2 8)]*&6/*!" /* H?I $ )4' Eñ E#?-'T6UV'3 4+/ +G/*/*+G#+' 8NM*)!Q_ñ}DPsCEb_zpJ7 % '&:1[W -A/*!" 'T¨V9E-H?a )!"$8+-' '3VVEH/[WBêê h T D]âRJa_ h DKi J'ê"ê ` &« TKä H/14;? : +/1ZÑr¼G 9!""'[W'Q. DT 'T 4#+-/*#!|? qK-C/*+-Z/ +'-&:'8:!"% A/*W'+'/* )X/1K!"2 -K-[W'" )RH/* !"2: +- TXUV!" +- &:"--8*)gT 5.
SKETCHING A MASSIVE, STREAMING XML DATA TREE
~w9!v '+G! O3W4?' +G!% 75 v '-.P? !Q4? !"A/ +-7'&$.
% '??!"2#/ "2 *!Q& +/ a% : ? % A/ !"/ &6/ "F3 'H? . A/*H? &Ê »WG
PA¼#N !"R ),/$&6/* ![ Sa?/1A/: -S!" '/ &:!"2M&:?'FT;UV!" W-+ABN !"n8!Q' QNI &6/ " DF" 2W/*!Q&:!+J / +' 3r/ ?!Q+/ _% : ?/*;/M&;+AI &6/ ""- 2 /*6)] S:-!Q6?/*A/E ':!"a/*C !"&6/*$ 'G.w'?!Q
? !"A/*+'K+' &:A/1! v!Q:2 H/1A/ 8'?:- *V% H? , $ n8H/*!QwN9*)HV/ C!"&6/1! ;%/ ?; 97?!" !" $% H? 2 /*A/*-?B)x &m 9-&;% ??!"2 TZ=E S!"&: A/*QN83Y/ V }!#!K '+-!" O3 - !"'*)X '&9% ?? !26/ "2 *. !Q&/144W-NH/1v/ "",rR%!"?S!" WG+GSN !" !": &6/ "H / +'/ ,?-,*)L7 'R/1 '/ &:!"2%8NS!" '[WG%H/ +A8 A/ +A!2$ M?/*A/ T =E # -+'!QH+/*QN83+' !?GZ %"'&Ô*)'&;% '??!"2/ ?/1A/V 'XâB ) !"¥'Xd$!"/7[W-+- Y H/ +- 3*%f!L!"&:,/* &: H/1;â!9 QN_&6/* ![ BDF!FT T"34d5)F/*$-C +''? 9Z/*&: 89 ) /[ /*!"0/*%"7 A/*2 1JGTv~w/ ?L3*V/* &:4/*V4 'V,?- )âz/*X/R+' 8!" X?/1A/ /*&\!"9 &:7/*!" !?--&:!"? A? -TS~g#S'*'&Ð% -3LV;/ &:SH/19?- ) âi/1 ![ R!":R*A?-4 )r/ H 8GZDF!FT T"3?' .4/ ?6"-)0 . .!"2 8GJr A/[W-/ ) âTvUV' -&§?'&: A/*-X/*v [W'+G bh:D]âJK+' +-?I)]*Sâ\%8NI S^`-&;% ??!"2M/ "2 *. !Q& +/ -t% Z+' +G?t!" H/*+'b$DFë," 2cfdR 2eLdOJG3 G;ë#? '*'R;?' # ),âSTSUV; WG+GI ),â!"' ' . !/ "QN/V W-+A )7h$D]âRJ [W'+-*4D? '*?R%8:N '1'¡ LDKh$D]âRJ J J H/1E+'/ % # '?z)] ^`M? !A/*+'k+/*+-/*!" !"zI'&$. % ??!"2I[W'+G 9 H/ +- T¢+A/ t^ ` W-+Aa )4h6D]âRJ+/ % % A/ !"'?_DF!E &6/ "Y / +'1J7 !"2;-C !"!"2: WG+G!26/ "2 *. !Q&:7*)~g? N #Qp1¸1T v£®£´µT"p (T »WG
PA5¼ '1O!"?' A/ I¶D ¾W>YJ$-&:&6/k)]*6I^7`6 &T@UV'37- ''&:v% % [!" XV/'N; '2*'$UV'*'&T"pK!Q ¼1¼ HWW- ]
© ? !A/*+'-!&6/1''T UV9)] ""!"2I+' "0/1 N /*!2 .P %H/*%!""!"wNI'!Q. &6/*-v/*7 !"%7!Q)H4/ ""t)x ,/ ;-C A/Rb$]D ¿ ²'JY&;Q!""!"+/1. !"[WV)F/*+- 4!";K?!"A/*+'K?!"* ! OTXUV7!0? /GK!"v ^ [W'+-*6 &:9_/ C !"&6/*^ ` *&:$-C " !"!"2 )F/*c +-H/1/ +A@h:D]âJX[W'+-*/ /1&: Kb$DM²J4 .P¥'G$+' &$. '8'3/ ?$'$ A/*H?/*A?L3!"2 .P %H/*%!""!QgN:^ c ?!"&:'. !" / "!QgN6?+-!" BDF T 2T"3 2 H¾W>rJGT)Y+' 3/;?!Qf-- / / +A6/*4+' 0?:2 ![ 2 GV' QXV ?6% N;
-&;% ? '-.P? !Q?!"A/ +'# x -
© ]
PE^ c 3L%R!"R'&6/*! /* - %"'&T À ®£T® Á1Á2£1 Â(T sT/¯O¼Z
F - ]
; ]
P HAGW^- 6
x¼#G
F]:
FF #p^ê §¨ ©3«| ¨¡¬LD ,` ì c ì ® J'ê]¯O¼ GÄ Ã² Å9 AGA
Fx:
w Ñv]
x¼S¼1¼R HWW- ]
©
PÑv]
x¼]M^'W-
P p^vb$D ¿ ² " 2 ,c ²f 2Te ²J;² 7.
w~ }CONCLUSIONS !"IH/* -3SVH/[Wa ' '8?h_B/ "2 *!Q&:!"+ - QM |# %"'&Ô*)-f'+-!"[W-"N5+'* '/*!"2iDF!"| &6/ " / +'J6&6/* ![ k¾?/1A/_ / &:Z%H/* ?| i/* 1C !"&6/* --.P?!QZ?!"A/*+'#+' &: A/*!" 'T@R6 !" z'"!"'Z z/ 1[W'S/ "2 *!Q& )]*k %"!"[!" QNh'&;% '??!"2t\ '-I/ !"I!"/*^ ` [ '+- k / +'_!"2 /*A/*-'!"2i/z" 2 /*. !Q&:!+4 .P+/ 9 -R% ?E #S? !A/*+'9?!"* ! OT $H/[W;+' &9%!"?I S'&;% ??!"2M/ "2 !Q&m!Q 'H? . A/*H? & W-+A!"2B'+G!n8'$a %A/*!z1[W'F3 &6/ "Q.P H/*+' /*"2 !Q&:4)]*7%!? !2+' +'!" R W-+A6N 'V/*H?6/ C. !"&6/1!2 !&:!"/*!QwNl !V1[W-4 / &:!"2k?/*A/T,R,'&$. % '??!"2M' "9/* #/ -S!"&: A/ 8/*"2 !Q&:!+Z/*"!Q. +'/*!" '3v T 2T"3X/ 9/M8 ,)] 9[W- NI)]/ 3X/ C !"&6/*; 'G.w'?!Q ? !"A/ +-+' &:A/*!" 'T
8.Æ Ç±ÈLÉBREFERENCES Ê Ë¡Ì6ÍBÎÏÊ ÐÑÒRÓÔÏÎÏÎÏÔÏÕsÖ>×ÔÏÙÙ÷/÷ 0 þ6ÿ : o þ ò¡ùÜö ò z ÷ ö ù±óbñ7ôªûMô þ ø¡ò¡ñ±öeû ü ùÜÑ á ÌÐ ) àÜÌÐç¯ÔÏÚÜç¯ÊÑ & ÌÎÏÔ ê[Ê à]ÐÔ_Ì1Ñ1éÌÐ + Ìà7^ ä %33%1× Æ $Ç 3 ÈLÍ>ÎÏÔÏ@ Ð G>Ê ÙàÜÌ1ÑÌ ÞÌ á Þ]à ã ÌíQÚ î ×1ïMÐðñ7òªóôÜôõ ö ÷2ø ùLò]úû ü1ôD,6X X,Qþ6ÿ | ÷ûMôbñ±÷¡û[ö[ò ÷ ÿTò ÷ªú¯ôbñ]ôb÷>ç±ÞÜÊ Ù ã à $Ç ###1× Æ $Ç % È(ÝlÔÏÐÊ ÚBØ!ÌàÜÊê[ÌÎ_Ìè2ÔÏÚBÌÐßÍBíQÔ M Þ F + í:Ìàb×3å & Ê àÜà ã Î_Ì ÞÜÔÏÐD Ë b!Ýlì G!Ì ÞÌ á ÞÜà ã ÌíQ Ú ?SÚÜÔÏÐËLæ3à ã¯ã ë _yßÔ 1 Þ G>ÔÏÚ7ÞÌÐ1ç ã _Rí(Ù ã ßßÔÏÐË Ú î ×Ö ã ÎÏÎ ì3ÌÙÚSæ ã çÜÓÐÔÏçbÌÎ,Ý ã íQÊ àÌÐß + ílÑ1ÝÌà]çL Ó %3381× Æ $Ç 8 ÈLÍ>ÐÐÌ & ר>ÔÏÎÏÙ ã à7ÞªÑ1ÛpÌÐÐ1ÔÏ1 Ú F!ÊÞ]ÔÏßÔÏÚbÑ á ×Ý + ÞÜÓ + èàÜÔÏÚ]ÓÐÌÐÑO-v69DIJ4% .8 ? '7!"+A'!Q-K/1[ ? '2 -;g4M*/*$"/1)V+A!"? 'k ), .8 ?- )4?'2*' wV T,R% -[W,H/*V .P"/*)H?-X!"6SD IJOH/[W4 QN9 +A!"?LTvR-Hu 6D IJ,/ ,R?'V!Q6g4; V&: R+A!"? -OT UVV8 v!"X/ " / ??'?Su 6D IJGTv¢46SD IJY/ ^? 6D IJO+' 8A/*! /*",: .w"/1)7? 'S )Vâ T TZ~w'&6/ !"E+' !0? -S"/[W' !" ´!"+AH/[W;/*"/* ; !%"!2 !"+G/*$+A!"? ' *)7$8*T#>OG^ 6`1D IJR% $: -S*)K/ "4 +G_"/[W-@ J_)x !"+Gtê Ç fêisTR>O-D c D IJ7% S -*)4/*" +A#'/1[ ')x !"+Gkê Ç ê$&}p/*H?JZ!XK"-)x&: 7 +A:+G!"0?:*)Y!QV/*'8T R-Hz D IJKE% ;;-&6/ !"!"2M"/[W' ) 3O!FT T"3"/[W' JI)]*R!+Atê Ç Lêj&§p9%U Jk!*S"-)0&: R +A#+G!?*) !QH/1'8TX K A/*!" H/ O+' [W-!"'+- 3V H/*"r/ " 6? '* ê 6SD IJ'ê%8N 69D IJ,/ H?M !&:!"/*QNZ)]**-K -'T RK *[ RR)x ""!2Z/ +-!"/* NE"'&:&6/ T I ¨T"p T³Y* ©
w $
Fo ´Ñv]
x¼M
$H8G D IJ4 ñ c D IJ ` 6SD IJ s_tpj² ®1°f° ö7_1[W!"7%8N:!"H?+-!" Z 6K&;% GV )Y? ' !" T¢ H/*E QN|g4t?''TUV- D IJ5& « ì c D IJN&p ì 69D IJ&h«T¢;"'&:&6/;!" )x K %H/* +'/ T ¢ !QZ!"6 E)]*M/ "8*?5 '':!Q|"' :H/*|d ?''Ta¢ L-L E% ZZ8*$ D) T r!QR+' !0? -R+/ '| $/ K "NE 9+A!"?L3 +'/ "r!QU T >L- r % R % 'R8 '?E/*- TX¤,N6!"?+G! Oq3 D r J4ñ D r J ` 69D r J s_Zp T,Ò4"/1"N8/3 D IJ & D r JGT~g D IJ 'nc / Ld c D!r0J-_UVS QN+'/ 'I/$ ?:JI+/ #8c +'+- !" c D r J% !" c D IJK!"'Q ;/ QNI $+A!"?L3 JO34!"+Az/*" H/* '9k% /I"/*)wTÒ4"/1"N83>J
c D r J % -+/ R!Q4/*'8,!,78 TX¤4 4!,!"4*4+/* !"