Inquiry Letter - Special Inspector General for Afghanistan Reconstruction
June 9, 2014 The Honorable Tom Vilsack Secretary U.S. Department of Agriculture Dear Mr. Secretary: Thank you for your response to my inquiry letter dated April 17, 2014, concerning the Soybeans for Agricultural Renewal in Afghanistan Initiative (SARAI) funded by the U.S. Department of Agriculture (USDA). After examining the materials that you provided, I’m concerned about the viability of the project and the apparent lack of analysis and planning performed prior to the project’s initiation. I’m most troubled by the following issues: •
The USDA confirmed that soybean production in Afghanistan has not met expectations and that there are doubts concerning the long-term sustainability of a soybean processing factory built as part of the project.
•
The project’s implementer, the American Soybean Association, did not conduct feasibility or value-chain studies prior to initiation of the project in 2010.
•
Scientific research conducted for the UK Department for International Development between 2005 and 2008 concluded that soybeans were inappropriate for conditions and farming practices in northern Afghanistan, where the program was implemented.
•
Despite the lack of prior planning and analysis, and despite evidence that may have put the success of the program in doubt, USDA provided $34.4 million in commodities, transportation, and administrative funds to ASA for SARAI.
I understand that Afghanistan’s operating environment poses daunting challenges for reconstruction and development programs, and that any project in the country is bound to meet its fair share of difficulties. However, what is troubling about this particular project is that it appears that many of these problems could reasonably have been foreseen and, therefore, possibly avoided. Moving forward, I recommend that you take the following actions prior to any further investment of U.S. government funding in SARAI: •
Implement a thorough and comprehensive evaluation of the project’s future sustainability, including a review of existing research on the economic viability of growing soybeans in Afghanistan. If a viable business case cannot be supported, withhold further investment.
•
Develop an in-depth plan to address the deficiencies and challenges already identified.
Additionally, I recommend that USDA thoroughly review the process by which the Food for Progress program evaluates project proposals and makes its final selections.
I thank you for your cooperation in this matter. Should you have any questions, please contact my Director of Special Projects, Mr. Jack Mitchell, at or at . Sincerely,
John F. Sopko Special Inspector General for Afghanistan Reconstruction Attachments: I: USDA Response to SIGAR-14-51-SP Inquiry Letter II: Third-Party Evaluation of SARAI III: SIGAR-14-51-SP Inquiry Letter: USDA Soybean Program
SIGAR-14-69-SP Inquiry Letter: USDA Response to Soybean Inquiry
Page 2
ATTACHMENT I: USDA RESPONSE TO SIGAR-14-51-SP INQUIRY LETTER
SIGAR-14-69-SP Inquiry Letter: USDA Response to Soybean Inquiry
Page 3
SIGAR-14-69-SP Inquiry Letter: USDA Response to Soybean Inquiry
Page 4
SIGAR-14-69-SP Inquiry Letter: USDA Response to Soybean Inquiry
Page 5
SIGAR-14-69-SP Inquiry Letter: USDA Response to Soybean Inquiry
Page 6
SIGAR-14-69-SP Inquiry Letter: USDA Response to Soybean Inquiry
Page 7
SIGAR-14-69-SP Inquiry Letter: USDA Response to Soybean Inquiry
Page 8
SIGAR-14-69-SP Inquiry Letter: USDA Response to Soybean Inquiry
Page 9
SIGAR-14-69-SP Inquiry Letter: USDA Response to Soybean Inquiry
Page 10
SIGAR-14-69-SP Inquiry Letter: USDA Response to Soybean Inquiry
Page 11
SIGAR-14-69-SP Inquiry Letter: USDA Response to Soybean Inquiry
Page 12
SIGAR-14-69-SP Inquiry Letter: USDA Response to Soybean Inquiry
Page 13
SIGAR-14-69-SP Inquiry Letter: USDA Response to Soybean Inquiry
Page 14
SIGAR-14-69-SP Inquiry Letter: USDA Response to Soybean Inquiry
Page 15
SIGAR-14-69-SP Inquiry Letter: USDA Response to Soybean Inquiry
Page 16
SIGAR-14-69-SP Inquiry Letter: USDA Response to Soybean Inquiry
Page 17
ATTACHMENT II: THIRD-PARTY EVALUATION OF SARAI
SIGAR-14-69-SP Inquiry Letter: USDA Response to Soybean Inquiry
Page 18
SIGAR-14-69-SP Inquiry Letter: USDA Response to Soybean Inquiry
Page 19
SIGAR-14-69-SP Inquiry Letter: USDA Response to Soybean Inquiry
Page 20
SIGAR-14-69-SP Inquiry Letter: USDA Response to Soybean Inquiry
Page 21
SIGAR-14-69-SP Inquiry Letter: USDA Response to Soybean Inquiry
Page 22
SIGAR-14-69-SP Inquiry Letter: USDA Response to Soybean Inquiry
Page 23
SIGAR-14-69-SP Inquiry Letter: USDA Response to Soybean Inquiry
Page 24
SIGAR-14-69-SP Inquiry Letter: USDA Response to Soybean Inquiry
Page 25
SIGAR-14-69-SP Inquiry Letter: USDA Response to Soybean Inquiry
Page 26
SIGAR-14-69-SP Inquiry Letter: USDA Response to Soybean Inquiry
Page 27
SIGAR-14-69-SP Inquiry Letter: USDA Response to Soybean Inquiry
Page 28
SIGAR-14-69-SP Inquiry Letter: USDA Response to Soybean Inquiry
Page 29
SIGAR-14-69-SP Inquiry Letter: USDA Response to Soybean Inquiry
Page 30
SIGAR-14-69-SP Inquiry Letter: USDA Response to Soybean Inquiry
Page 31
SIGAR-14-69-SP Inquiry Letter: USDA Response to Soybean Inquiry
Page 32
SIGAR-14-69-SP Inquiry Letter: USDA Response to Soybean Inquiry
Page 33
SIGAR-14-69-SP Inquiry Letter: USDA Response to Soybean Inquiry
Page 34
SIGAR-14-69-SP Inquiry Letter: USDA Response to Soybean Inquiry
Page 35
SIGAR-14-69-SP Inquiry Letter: USDA Response to Soybean Inquiry
Page 36
SIGAR-14-69-SP Inquiry Letter: USDA Response to Soybean Inquiry
Page 37
SIGAR-14-69-SP Inquiry Letter: USDA Response to Soybean Inquiry
Page 38
SIGAR-14-69-SP Inquiry Letter: USDA Response to Soybean Inquiry
Page 39
SIGAR-14-69-SP Inquiry Letter: USDA Response to Soybean Inquiry
Page 40
SIGAR-14-69-SP Inquiry Letter: USDA Response to Soybean Inquiry
Page 41
SIGAR-14-69-SP Inquiry Letter: USDA Response to Soybean Inquiry
Page 42
SIGAR-14-69-SP Inquiry Letter: USDA Response to Soybean Inquiry
Page 43
SIGAR-14-69-SP Inquiry Letter: USDA Response to Soybean Inquiry
Page 44
SIGAR-14-69-SP Inquiry Letter: USDA Response to Soybean Inquiry
Page 45
SIGAR-14-69-SP Inquiry Letter: USDA Response to Soybean Inquiry
Page 46
SIGAR-14-69-SP Inquiry Letter: USDA Response to Soybean Inquiry
Page 47
SIGAR-14-69-SP Inquiry Letter: USDA Response to Soybean Inquiry
Page 48
SIGAR-14-69-SP Inquiry Letter: USDA Response to Soybean Inquiry
Page 49
SIGAR-14-69-SP Inquiry Letter: USDA Response to Soybean Inquiry
Page 50
SIGAR-14-69-SP Inquiry Letter: USDA Response to Soybean Inquiry
Page 51
SIGAR-14-69-SP Inquiry Letter: USDA Response to Soybean Inquiry
Page 52
SIGAR-14-69-SP Inquiry Letter: USDA Response to Soybean Inquiry
Page 53
SIGAR-14-69-SP Inquiry Letter: USDA Response to Soybean Inquiry
Page 54
SIGAR-14-69-SP Inquiry Letter: USDA Response to Soybean Inquiry
Page 55
SIGAR-14-69-SP Inquiry Letter: USDA Response to Soybean Inquiry
Page 56
SIGAR-14-69-SP Inquiry Letter: USDA Response to Soybean Inquiry
Page 57
SIGAR-14-69-SP Inquiry Letter: USDA Response to Soybean Inquiry
Page 58
SIGAR-14-69-SP Inquiry Letter: USDA Response to Soybean Inquiry
Page 59
SIGAR-14-69-SP Inquiry Letter: USDA Response to Soybean Inquiry
Page 60
SIGAR-14-69-SP Inquiry Letter: USDA Response to Soybean Inquiry
Page 61
SIGAR-14-69-SP Inquiry Letter: USDA Response to Soybean Inquiry
Page 62
SIGAR-14-69-SP Inquiry Letter: USDA Response to Soybean Inquiry
Page 63
SIGAR-14-69-SP Inquiry Letter: USDA Response to Soybean Inquiry
Page 64
SIGAR-14-69-SP Inquiry Letter: USDA Response to Soybean Inquiry
Page 65
SIGAR-14-69-SP Inquiry Letter: USDA Response to Soybean Inquiry
Page 66
SIGAR-14-69-SP Inquiry Letter: USDA Response to Soybean Inquiry
Page 67
SIGAR-14-69-SP Inquiry Letter: USDA Response to Soybean Inquiry
Page 68
SIGAR-14-69-SP Inquiry Letter: USDA Response to Soybean Inquiry
Page 69
SIGAR-14-69-SP Inquiry Letter: USDA Response to Soybean Inquiry
Page 70
SIGAR-14-69-SP Inquiry Letter: USDA Response to Soybean Inquiry
Page 71
SIGAR-14-69-SP Inquiry Letter: USDA Response to Soybean Inquiry
Page 72
SIGAR-14-69-SP Inquiry Letter: USDA Response to Soybean Inquiry
Page 73
SIGAR-14-69-SP Inquiry Letter: USDA Response to Soybean Inquiry
Page 74
SIGAR-14-69-SP Inquiry Letter: USDA Response to Soybean Inquiry
Page 75
SIGAR-14-69-SP Inquiry Letter: USDA Response to Soybean Inquiry
Page 76
SIGAR-14-69-SP Inquiry Letter: USDA Response to Soybean Inquiry
Page 77
SIGAR-14-69-SP Inquiry Letter: USDA Response to Soybean Inquiry
Page 78
SIGAR-14-69-SP Inquiry Letter: USDA Response to Soybean Inquiry
Page 79
SIGAR-14-69-SP Inquiry Letter: USDA Response to Soybean Inquiry
Page 80
SIGAR-14-69-SP Inquiry Letter: USDA Response to Soybean Inquiry
Page 81
SIGAR-14-69-SP Inquiry Letter: USDA Response to Soybean Inquiry
Page 82
SIGAR-14-69-SP Inquiry Letter: USDA Response to Soybean Inquiry
Page 83
SIGAR-14-69-SP Inquiry Letter: USDA Response to Soybean Inquiry
Page 84
SIGAR-14-69-SP Inquiry Letter: USDA Response to Soybean Inquiry
Page 85
ATTACHMENT III: SIGAR-14-51-SP INQUIRY LETTER: USDA SOYBEAN PROGRAM
SIGAR-14-69-SP Inquiry Letter: USDA Response to Soybean Inquiry
Page 86
SIGAR-14-69-SP Inquiry Letter: USDA Response to Soybean Inquiry
Page 87
SIGAR-14-69-SP Inquiry Letter: USDA Response to Soybean Inquiry
Page 88
The USDA confirmed that soybean production in Afghanistan has not met expectations and that there are doubts concerning the long-term sustainability of a soybean processing factory built as part of the project.
•
The project’s implementer, the American Soybean Association, did not conduct feasibility or value-chain studies prior to initiation of the project in 2010.
•
Scientific research conducted for the UK Department for International Development between 2005 and 2008 concluded that soybeans were inappropriate for conditions and farming practices in northern Afghanistan, where the program was implemented.
•
Despite the lack of prior planning and analysis, and despite evidence that may have put the success of the program in doubt, USDA provided $34.4 million in commodities, transportation, and administrative funds to ASA for SARAI.
I understand that Afghanistan’s operating environment poses daunting challenges for reconstruction and development programs, and that any project in the country is bound to meet its fair share of difficulties. However, what is troubling about this particular project is that it appears that many of these problems could reasonably have been foreseen and, therefore, possibly avoided. Moving forward, I recommend that you take the following actions prior to any further investment of U.S. government funding in SARAI: •
Implement a thorough and comprehensive evaluation of the project’s future sustainability, including a review of existing research on the economic viability of growing soybeans in Afghanistan. If a viable business case cannot be supported, withhold further investment.
•
Develop an in-depth plan to address the deficiencies and challenges already identified.
Additionally, I recommend that USDA thoroughly review the process by which the Food for Progress program evaluates project proposals and makes its final selections.
I thank you for your cooperation in this matter. Should you have any questions, please contact my Director of Special Projects, Mr. Jack Mitchell, at or at . Sincerely,
John F. Sopko Special Inspector General for Afghanistan Reconstruction Attachments: I: USDA Response to SIGAR-14-51-SP Inquiry Letter II: Third-Party Evaluation of SARAI III: SIGAR-14-51-SP Inquiry Letter: USDA Soybean Program
SIGAR-14-69-SP Inquiry Letter: USDA Response to Soybean Inquiry
Page 2
ATTACHMENT I: USDA RESPONSE TO SIGAR-14-51-SP INQUIRY LETTER
SIGAR-14-69-SP Inquiry Letter: USDA Response to Soybean Inquiry
Page 3
SIGAR-14-69-SP Inquiry Letter: USDA Response to Soybean Inquiry
Page 4
SIGAR-14-69-SP Inquiry Letter: USDA Response to Soybean Inquiry
Page 5
SIGAR-14-69-SP Inquiry Letter: USDA Response to Soybean Inquiry
Page 6
SIGAR-14-69-SP Inquiry Letter: USDA Response to Soybean Inquiry
Page 7
SIGAR-14-69-SP Inquiry Letter: USDA Response to Soybean Inquiry
Page 8
SIGAR-14-69-SP Inquiry Letter: USDA Response to Soybean Inquiry
Page 9
SIGAR-14-69-SP Inquiry Letter: USDA Response to Soybean Inquiry
Page 10
SIGAR-14-69-SP Inquiry Letter: USDA Response to Soybean Inquiry
Page 11
SIGAR-14-69-SP Inquiry Letter: USDA Response to Soybean Inquiry
Page 12
SIGAR-14-69-SP Inquiry Letter: USDA Response to Soybean Inquiry
Page 13
SIGAR-14-69-SP Inquiry Letter: USDA Response to Soybean Inquiry
Page 14
SIGAR-14-69-SP Inquiry Letter: USDA Response to Soybean Inquiry
Page 15
SIGAR-14-69-SP Inquiry Letter: USDA Response to Soybean Inquiry
Page 16
SIGAR-14-69-SP Inquiry Letter: USDA Response to Soybean Inquiry
Page 17
ATTACHMENT II: THIRD-PARTY EVALUATION OF SARAI
SIGAR-14-69-SP Inquiry Letter: USDA Response to Soybean Inquiry
Page 18
SIGAR-14-69-SP Inquiry Letter: USDA Response to Soybean Inquiry
Page 19
SIGAR-14-69-SP Inquiry Letter: USDA Response to Soybean Inquiry
Page 20
SIGAR-14-69-SP Inquiry Letter: USDA Response to Soybean Inquiry
Page 21
SIGAR-14-69-SP Inquiry Letter: USDA Response to Soybean Inquiry
Page 22
SIGAR-14-69-SP Inquiry Letter: USDA Response to Soybean Inquiry
Page 23
SIGAR-14-69-SP Inquiry Letter: USDA Response to Soybean Inquiry
Page 24
SIGAR-14-69-SP Inquiry Letter: USDA Response to Soybean Inquiry
Page 25
SIGAR-14-69-SP Inquiry Letter: USDA Response to Soybean Inquiry
Page 26
SIGAR-14-69-SP Inquiry Letter: USDA Response to Soybean Inquiry
Page 27
SIGAR-14-69-SP Inquiry Letter: USDA Response to Soybean Inquiry
Page 28
SIGAR-14-69-SP Inquiry Letter: USDA Response to Soybean Inquiry
Page 29
SIGAR-14-69-SP Inquiry Letter: USDA Response to Soybean Inquiry
Page 30
SIGAR-14-69-SP Inquiry Letter: USDA Response to Soybean Inquiry
Page 31
SIGAR-14-69-SP Inquiry Letter: USDA Response to Soybean Inquiry
Page 32
SIGAR-14-69-SP Inquiry Letter: USDA Response to Soybean Inquiry
Page 33
SIGAR-14-69-SP Inquiry Letter: USDA Response to Soybean Inquiry
Page 34
SIGAR-14-69-SP Inquiry Letter: USDA Response to Soybean Inquiry
Page 35
SIGAR-14-69-SP Inquiry Letter: USDA Response to Soybean Inquiry
Page 36
SIGAR-14-69-SP Inquiry Letter: USDA Response to Soybean Inquiry
Page 37
SIGAR-14-69-SP Inquiry Letter: USDA Response to Soybean Inquiry
Page 38
SIGAR-14-69-SP Inquiry Letter: USDA Response to Soybean Inquiry
Page 39
SIGAR-14-69-SP Inquiry Letter: USDA Response to Soybean Inquiry
Page 40
SIGAR-14-69-SP Inquiry Letter: USDA Response to Soybean Inquiry
Page 41
SIGAR-14-69-SP Inquiry Letter: USDA Response to Soybean Inquiry
Page 42
SIGAR-14-69-SP Inquiry Letter: USDA Response to Soybean Inquiry
Page 43
SIGAR-14-69-SP Inquiry Letter: USDA Response to Soybean Inquiry
Page 44
SIGAR-14-69-SP Inquiry Letter: USDA Response to Soybean Inquiry
Page 45
SIGAR-14-69-SP Inquiry Letter: USDA Response to Soybean Inquiry
Page 46
SIGAR-14-69-SP Inquiry Letter: USDA Response to Soybean Inquiry
Page 47
SIGAR-14-69-SP Inquiry Letter: USDA Response to Soybean Inquiry
Page 48
SIGAR-14-69-SP Inquiry Letter: USDA Response to Soybean Inquiry
Page 49
SIGAR-14-69-SP Inquiry Letter: USDA Response to Soybean Inquiry
Page 50
SIGAR-14-69-SP Inquiry Letter: USDA Response to Soybean Inquiry
Page 51
SIGAR-14-69-SP Inquiry Letter: USDA Response to Soybean Inquiry
Page 52
SIGAR-14-69-SP Inquiry Letter: USDA Response to Soybean Inquiry
Page 53
SIGAR-14-69-SP Inquiry Letter: USDA Response to Soybean Inquiry
Page 54
SIGAR-14-69-SP Inquiry Letter: USDA Response to Soybean Inquiry
Page 55
SIGAR-14-69-SP Inquiry Letter: USDA Response to Soybean Inquiry
Page 56
SIGAR-14-69-SP Inquiry Letter: USDA Response to Soybean Inquiry
Page 57
SIGAR-14-69-SP Inquiry Letter: USDA Response to Soybean Inquiry
Page 58
SIGAR-14-69-SP Inquiry Letter: USDA Response to Soybean Inquiry
Page 59
SIGAR-14-69-SP Inquiry Letter: USDA Response to Soybean Inquiry
Page 60
SIGAR-14-69-SP Inquiry Letter: USDA Response to Soybean Inquiry
Page 61
SIGAR-14-69-SP Inquiry Letter: USDA Response to Soybean Inquiry
Page 62
SIGAR-14-69-SP Inquiry Letter: USDA Response to Soybean Inquiry
Page 63
SIGAR-14-69-SP Inquiry Letter: USDA Response to Soybean Inquiry
Page 64
SIGAR-14-69-SP Inquiry Letter: USDA Response to Soybean Inquiry
Page 65
SIGAR-14-69-SP Inquiry Letter: USDA Response to Soybean Inquiry
Page 66
SIGAR-14-69-SP Inquiry Letter: USDA Response to Soybean Inquiry
Page 67
SIGAR-14-69-SP Inquiry Letter: USDA Response to Soybean Inquiry
Page 68
SIGAR-14-69-SP Inquiry Letter: USDA Response to Soybean Inquiry
Page 69
SIGAR-14-69-SP Inquiry Letter: USDA Response to Soybean Inquiry
Page 70
SIGAR-14-69-SP Inquiry Letter: USDA Response to Soybean Inquiry
Page 71
SIGAR-14-69-SP Inquiry Letter: USDA Response to Soybean Inquiry
Page 72
SIGAR-14-69-SP Inquiry Letter: USDA Response to Soybean Inquiry
Page 73
SIGAR-14-69-SP Inquiry Letter: USDA Response to Soybean Inquiry
Page 74
SIGAR-14-69-SP Inquiry Letter: USDA Response to Soybean Inquiry
Page 75
SIGAR-14-69-SP Inquiry Letter: USDA Response to Soybean Inquiry
Page 76
SIGAR-14-69-SP Inquiry Letter: USDA Response to Soybean Inquiry
Page 77
SIGAR-14-69-SP Inquiry Letter: USDA Response to Soybean Inquiry
Page 78
SIGAR-14-69-SP Inquiry Letter: USDA Response to Soybean Inquiry
Page 79
SIGAR-14-69-SP Inquiry Letter: USDA Response to Soybean Inquiry
Page 80
SIGAR-14-69-SP Inquiry Letter: USDA Response to Soybean Inquiry
Page 81
SIGAR-14-69-SP Inquiry Letter: USDA Response to Soybean Inquiry
Page 82
SIGAR-14-69-SP Inquiry Letter: USDA Response to Soybean Inquiry
Page 83
SIGAR-14-69-SP Inquiry Letter: USDA Response to Soybean Inquiry
Page 84
SIGAR-14-69-SP Inquiry Letter: USDA Response to Soybean Inquiry
Page 85
ATTACHMENT III: SIGAR-14-51-SP INQUIRY LETTER: USDA SOYBEAN PROGRAM
SIGAR-14-69-SP Inquiry Letter: USDA Response to Soybean Inquiry
Page 86
SIGAR-14-69-SP Inquiry Letter: USDA Response to Soybean Inquiry
Page 87
SIGAR-14-69-SP Inquiry Letter: USDA Response to Soybean Inquiry
Page 88
