Modeling High-Dimensional Index Structures ... - Semantic Scholar
Modeling High-Dimensional Index Structures using Sampling Christian A. Lang
Ambuj K. Singh
Department of Computer Science University of California Santa Barbara, CA 93106
Department of Computer Science University of California Santa Barbara, CA 93106
[email protected]
[email protected]
*"./ ( 1
02 3 & & ) 4* -4 $ 1 5 !4 #" $ & 0 %" $ 769 &8:,' )).(* * (*;+," *$%*" %?(@ H " * & %. 5( *#"J$I9 * &%>" K - &&AB" (*7"3 &$ C0)#"$7". -*D%" " *E (&8=M0 * " $(> %?- (C & *4*^ . *-/^4-$ ". G * &$("BaKK1--] " (*$(*1-1]S ]d-" " \c( %& -"^^7"D44 & *$ &K= -" T ' *-a]D TB $ &-#" &$ 02 &8 &a% " R5 1 3 W " ( B & 3" (--$ &6[02$ W Q-%-$ $ * #"$.4*4" & " *&8^ &^ 9-ea". =$ ++ . *D =B W b --b -7" - D [" &(*1 T] =02" (. D-" *4* ^ 1 '-B%?" *- *" V T-^ 44* " -Q"O]D " (* U'*f b]_" (* "N 4 8
ABSTRACT
*".@INTRODUCTION g ( 1-02 E * &C h 4*V - D4- $ 1 * h E h#"$ 4** % &" 0* *U >" (* U * ? fA _4 -- \$w& &. - R}r2:#k-D-k Ql&`!q2n>4 1K= ]T$-" .- " 76(o- [o$+ Ul14*=l 4" 8--$ " 1 DZ9%&6{ & -%. 3 " -} W *D Q" +, - )2k -n- m Xk9l 9Ab6G:$U:$Z9 +
1.
Permission to make digital or hard copies of all or part of this work for personal or classroom use is granted without fee provided that copies are not made or distributed for profit or commercial advantage and that copies bear this notice and the full citation on the first page. To copy otherwise, to republish, to post on servers or to redistribute to lists, requires prior specific permission and/or a fee. ACM SIGMOD 2001 May 21-24, Santa Barbara, California, USA Copyright 2001 ACM 1-58113-332-4/01/05 ... 5.00.
]_ &7" #"(( 1%0 C 3*" b" -* yJ /> " (* \ " * ? & f EAT " (*$`c /8N'*V *N%& \ *" ( ?
%1 - U > * & *"1 8 .-769A^" ( "$$6}" E$-0 /%1 > * ?+ $% 1 W' 1]_& 2-¦§-TK?-¦P?5¢a G-¦T' $'$N9¦K $-K K$>-b-¦§??£>. #1$9?9 ?T¦,3[ D®V-4 1" ]D(* 1 * &Q02% " 1A * [- ? **-Q* *(]TC-$% .(*`(+, & *%1- E & &&8 *$$>- - \" (#" ;$ %? *" ?* &#"¯($ -%?z"" *W [".`2 9 D" $ %?& }" 02- 4 .^%$c"[14--( W$ " &(* W&8 =^024 uT ? (4%& _%11A¯ W]T >9 6" U(*$ & * /' * V bQ" [$((%& W1-]|4*(* 1=] ++ $ $ 1W @ -"O4*]D4* & & -%.U(YA^1]W- +, }I9 -7("O6-(*+, I9"B --#"7"OP6)4* & *"[%$" 1 ]| 34*f 1U %? &" - @-$6-+ b *% *" $` *9E+§ " -(*$
& X- 4 4 -2W-%.(Y 8N R} } ;4-4* $ C& 9 @"V4"O]D(-$ " & &&8%?)(* I9C & 1_%?'(}\" 4*%? ( ?++ %&I9 $ - AD 1 @]T '- * & *02 7vc- 4S & 9%&-"#" &' C$65$b"w& )&A_ & #" =".b-$ " " /$" (*w& /&A_:#± - %&- #"7+ * & \ *-$ - < ",]T7" C &&8.U *R5 _$(*¯1b]--" ( 7=" "U N" '(E-#"" %?Q(*" ( I9 > &N 1 $ * "O[]D &" ( &
4 $7 " QB$(-%%&1 &]$$ " &( B]=_"B7 " *(b^U *$` 9 &+§* 4 - $ =&0 & a( c 8a(CuT4*( _ 1 %?4" - - &% 9%&".*. % ?6 + ]_( G="" ( / >" b 1 **%& E" ( /4 1 *%" - S%&-#"K
*( * I * &/"V -$ $ 1& E%& G *&8" (* V* 7'%& -4 ",6G $$-$ H]_4*7" " (!- )4* 1 %" " ( ; HK." &%%?".( -+ K" -(* (* & $(*b +, )-7-"O 6)" ($$( ? < 1" ]_- W\"%?(* * ( ".=I9 "[8@ >" (*uz" &G($ b" "b(- Z &p*%b" -" $% E &&%.k($8 *$ &IW*$ -8! UR} E44 & %1 =" ]_- " ( uK- b(*RELATED T C %&$
7K -- $ %>74 "OJ6d 1 E%&E - * 3"%& & 9G"$" .(*°* G " #" 1/02 & $#+ + T X 6 I9 $ E$6 -4 N _ & &-+§\"$ Y 9 &" AN] T$ & -%?3" " 1-(* ) &0 S9 &6 %&-" (*6}%& 3 I9=-" X- *" &" (*&8$ G C uT102?(" [.--°-8h E#"\i7 l&`*j *sQC=]_ " ]T - & &f#"-$ >%" 1 " *5" $-- i +,7 *l&sY4* & * &$$ & 9 "__ %&= ".#" _8y:, S &Xc$" bC4-%&4- *1+ A % &$`4*"-$%%& &$$ &V" K -N "O]T `2+,1 *]_$` &_ $$- -C"z X=".4* 8_ 1 _%$"363" ( >"V- 8;Ci n=sa ?-C0 "$" (* * C6 ?". --$ $ 1 * G {#" /$ " ( %?6 =" $*" " &(U >C * N%&* C *I9 * *>C -; &-> * K- *".GX$*46G ?%.vc 9`2" &" %" -&8 [1]_®V- b 1 y]T `9024+O -1++ A *l? &+§ &V- 9^" -=I97".*6- $ ]_" &7&8" W( D" ( ( %. (9 ( " +, * E & &$"\ $ t--8< 7-i"Oq-6 cs^$4]_4 -( &%&$ %. &(d8P 9"\uTb(*b& 6 %&6=".-N$$* ;4* 1" ¯" *N9 &N ;-4*"Q 1(* %? /" -' N & 1$*a7" -a / ;" ((- (*$ + %& *- $ &"1&88 PuT(T$(*-$" %&- [ & " [4 =.- "$ %Q * &D *$%&$$ & 2.
uT(* &$ _ * &B"$$6;" ;-%&%&- 9"^'-^" ( W * +,* 7' 7"O6[-" (*
2.2 Globally Parametric Models
K° . =#"".%Q3".-%&9_-6>#" V & &$ &c '3--V7"N7"O Q69+t8)$"$ &b Q-*K- " ]$ $1- >3 - "C -" ¯(8S4 U=Ji7.l1.--n=s_%".4* " a ? * $ &A& 9" & 1`2 * 5 \$" " (( *
+ -/7 *"O6[".]_$ ("1%.83(3uTB%(*&U°- #" 1; " U * T ¯" ]W(* -UO * (#" $ &%? 9" "P 1 X *" b &. *-$ * I9", 6 ?U - " 02 & "_$ * 1- C E" 7K_"B-]T' N9 +§l?`>V+§V96>hI9La*I9- 4 ? & &8 ;^4D -* _ +tN"$ - & / &&8 " %& Q ? "U * 8_#"t$8;uT (i7l& ? o6 +s " V ! BI9 ? -. &8B D:O b" \%1-4 $ N 1 *-Y%"^$4 " (%& N VT4LB$H" 7" - 3 :$ *± *hA " %&(-#"P"D &f%.(. * I-* V Q ? + $- 7 X" B Z & &$$ &i 9" j-lsB76-0 3 3(*b#" --. * &z^K-=\024 ?^ 1" *(* _%" *=".b-" $ (*"1 8B4uT ?(*$' &- *b *%&
]_" -(c( C.%.(b 9 %&- QPTI9 &$ ? %&$- 7P" 76 3 &- 04$% .*B]$" $ D-1 G- _`96E *" D$4 (=w" *J` ;¯= *U- "."U-4-- 83$ U&i &8=" s§ 8 % &*uT4#" & (* X *&A & Y 9 *-"N0- -- 9B".$" % 1#"] _ 9%&"$%& *. *%%6 1 ( d _$ -&%&$%-$" #"*W f- &ANc3.]D- X * $( V* 1-] 3(7 *" 1 1 1] @ -#"-T- 4* 9- *"(-N-%&W- hI9 &* E -$ &69&8$ 8X^1uT SuT((*"
* "_$ &%" ]_¯ 1-c]_7" (/" ( V7" 1 &z02-> 1* }D9 6)= *°" & **#" [P" 02-[ 4 $4 1 X *%-"PP" (*" " E%& #"V &$- $6T" ( \ G" 1(*= 4 -`2- ^ &_- -4*z " 1(* %" O [ -7+§%&% * . - %?69A= "z z" ( V4I-*$". $ 6"c]T" _ &` *$ * c a8D" *( -=T"Y" " (*(*
uT(* *W+§#" $ % - " (* U-(- &7" -((x"N-'a-_" (*" U(* V"$ & 8 7P+§6> * ?#+ N U b%&" ( N $ K AWf" ( *b - c$A9$]D* U &%1`- / -%.1(]_ & 102 * N-" G(-WU#"" $(* %" .- c$#"$ J=%" 7"O 69 8 " " ? (* &&A ^ 1- 1U4 c-8/ :, & 5$4$ &" & 9(%" 3 1° G%1K -%&-7=6 ]_ G¬a * * CA^]TZ 4 447'"9 1%& * " +ti ?+t"$Uj- q- &#"st$ ?8) +,®V%?`2" 31*]T#" $ & V02* -%1+ A ]D &Z8 %& D" (* D 7+§ ;a7"B CN$*$ "B " ( D ".$ "1A ]D
(7Y1]T02 V V" *C$ U 1 W[%& N " ( U44 -l \l&%&o-4 -f%&" (7"O N6/-- %&% - . *-f * =769". 8PA 1--_%.(< *4 -- V4 A " 4(*- C " &8U 7N+§U G /" ]_( BN%&]T - 9.". -&A )c" ( X ;14 02 . [--%1 /-4l -%&l17"Oo/6PN" (* 1 C **%& 1- 9-6 " (*- - *%? " -3l 1 l1 &o&A8 " Z( U *%& 1 b Q%&+t"$ & > & 2- W *-w&B /44-- 9" " _4[ Q1 b *b]_ %&(-102$
U#"$" (* %?" *=. X-c" $$( * 7`"O698/AuT" ((* V4 $(-*-= U]_&;"69 ( =" "[W &-02¯ &" 5(* V" (*'* *c () ]D
¯ >-" (** U l; *7 +§4 *%" ?_" < ( \ \%& - "Q % &" %& $ 7",6/]T 1 &I9 /-" (8 \ - -¯- " $ (*?" Tz ¯--*4* T b4 l2 TQ *& &694* %"1" 8BQ"¯ (* V *l2 t / a#"$$( *1%]_" B" [(* D% #"-$ *-%" 1 G=". + " ¯(*- _*- 3 l2 t Tf * &".4*%$ " W"" ¯( U [ 7l +§ %=^ $(* =%&]_-^" #" $( _%? -" 1 >4*- 1 / " (= U". -$ 3" + 4* 1 * b $(= ".- $ *`"18^ Q /D-$ %&&%& &- 9 3"_" -(*z Q - ? 4*4 ** 8PA2uT" (*( _ 4 ?-'-- & D -A*]Dc" U(( _102 V " 7 + 4 -1-]} " J&(69 &-!*"\$ 6U ;.£" V>ª*" ?(* C?-¦ £--Q ©&-2P¦§ £- *" ?_ f8bV`2 ¯%&" [(" a( 3 &$*" *J *= + " 9 6) %& * 9 *" / */V " &(#" .- **C$(* 1 f\A]D_ C 4*" ? & *$ &%%"Q" " ( * [ 4",]T &% &" 1 } :# ± 4~ &%%" 1#" I9* $6b & *V (* fA ]_( ?W*%14*- * 1 $ Q%(*" qE¯ * ". $
\n"/A]_%?O(*8G uz N-]D N G.-l= /\m- o- 5oCn9%&l-+§V4 {= I9 1 ) " ( & bP b%" " ( 4 - 4*- N%&%$ &w&$ &$ &8&PV]Q_T 7" ( 4" ( & ;%" 4 1 c 1A2 *" (% Q" 14* &4 *--% " 4 *$ 9 " \ &4* u_ $ ?&8 9" */" " * ' 1=" * 02 &%?" - ; ".- 1 XK " (* bD- D:Ob
n kk-A$r m o-A q2oE p p m3l=*p k1u_o+, *+,? 8 & $$- --D44 9 9" " ;T &4*4 & &$ $ && 9 9" " ;K" 1 " " * & _['$ 1=%." *(@ U-02 $4%" &-% "$T.-P %&Y9- F % "_ " b&AB-%- & 9U" ' "$ . K# 1'" & 1&A -p A m- ;o-o\$-j p-o.+,- * 9"a' & 1 *=$" *- &z 4* ". 9" a 1 ; &94*6U $
&&%& 9" . * *V " _(" D(4* T m %&nW W ?-"$" p A m-ao--o; #"" (9 D%.-`B4(0 - B "B * T¯69$4 1 _` &'"$ .9 6#l=K-m- oQ$4 1 C 1-*` $ &8 au_?8
N =
j
j
!
'7.'7,. ., ,. +
37% 24% 14% 6% 1% 10%
'&N!
25%
)(
Sample size
+* +-,
)'2
3 5 %
5 % 9 ,.' /
50%
).
01) 3, ,
K" -(*V & 02- & /4*" (* Q"$ w& & b%.( **I* U" " " ( ; 4 $ K 8_9%&N% *-4 " (* %Q6)%& - *W#"" $(*. - 9"U 7 + 4 - * c"1A-8^" Z( T *%& QU44 D . _=" - Wc%1" (- W &02 * ?+§B T $ [bC-* #"BP" (*( >l "P 1A -#"]_D(* *
W" ( \4- \%&-4 %&7"O6>-¯" (* V'*z c8 * *N * % & "1U;A]T" ( 3( Q4 -]_(G &($
-&$ 9 V-"\?-(*
*(* (G * %&3%&*" .(* \%6) ' *"O ?6 4 %1 7 *6(*:# P± K -= ]_ / *4*\ &$ *&%%" " * /B -*%&$%%&& .$-Y"% 69(8 D * ] 44* -%.( [- 1=" 4 _ &+t &4*"$%& " 1 &(C &B]- 1 /_ C(9 6]D N]_f*$ N" (* V#6 C-P#" & 4.1 The On-Disk Index Tree 9i m16bs§uT8>" (*(uT E N(* [* *+,`b -$`-2 -7 *" ( 3 d- & "$% * G$" (*02/ &7-6X * y &4 $%= $ *" " d 1- < #"$\"9 6 (%D" * %. G("." - &$4 * / -. %"Q b" - &" 8 - & ?." U" ( V * b"$ & V4 -- &Q 02 &7+t]_$ -8D*-Q 1-%.(/ &0 &A*" (*
1 B 304#576 398 3:7@ 3C D<E >F@ G :7@ @ G:IHKJML#N O=JFV 8 LQW >F@
**CC DD--^B4 = ". 9C" 4T" ( 9=" "_°"_ &$6 (** &C (9"_ D-a-B" (*4 U 9 " +,W4 *$` bN * *$`b b4 "$ &
(*(* & & (9(9"_"_--aa" " (*(* U U14*]T4 QW"$"$ & & & BA 44 [[.." " 33''QQ" " (*(* \ \=4*]D4 _W"$"$ & & &
bb== x| *=7 ". &C%" 4 $ 6 \4 %1 4 [-%%1-",465-%&-7", *6}+, * $` b+, * $` > +
? ? vcvc & &%% " " 0202 \ } * 7 ". &C%" 4--$ 6H \4%&--4 - }%&7%1"O-6)4- %& 7",+O6g $`-%. (".4 X=$" 34" -= $" " _"- (* 1 & 'T $ " 1(- %.¯($ & f8P4uT($" U7" 4* $ & * 1 \ ;%" ( * P \ --Y" ( B_-$(- - 7" ( 9 " 2%1" ( / ^ & V K &*0 & * S $%" ( >4*" ' fQA 02% , 8N$i m1 Ss'?8 -U" (*b4-4 Xi n-j=s3''>5- G ".- 1 $4Z 4*N7"1";U8W U>uT?(*$4+t"$Q 7 &"$ " &$ i*j-7q" s§N#"8#" *Xb%&- *" 4*E3 " -" (*( ; F>)V 8 LQW >F@ §n ]_(N ? 7" *" 02- &" 769 _"A2" (*(* N U$ & %.(b .W-- *aI%&*- $6b 4 N 9-" *&8".- * 1 3K ~" (
" " ( (- V="P 4*-" (* 8a _4¯$ 1 V7 #". B=%." ( *.48^ *:O >* T &** 9_9" ? z *D -4 ? " "D(*$
W W & ~ " &A¯" \V(*1 N]T Np- &qN02vc ? 1=%A*"." ]D- 1$ 3 U"BC$($ **1%? b1(C]T" 1( 6
'*z *".-$ ?"N" 3% 4 " N" (* U$ 1 %.(/.- *8 'V:O G*" (* *' -[1" (]_ \ G1]T$ *_"$$ & &%? " &8- &Af]T C *$%&$U" (* ",]T/0- " 4.3 The Cutoff Index Tree %& 1 :O" f G-4vd-. - * 4* D4*V 2" 7" (%&g $".- " );4%&%&4- ?\ 9"$"1 8B & 3uz\ 1%&-T 4 #"-$ -* %Az"B]D" b( W-$1$]T* P 3"$ & * WK- & * * ". -4 * #" -$ Q - & f-" * `C"$$ 6 $ " - 5 &A" a(* b" ( 44 $++ uT(*%" Q 1- *%&W"%& .-" %(*6> V *%& ?-" %& *-.$-" / _" K( -=_"Q(*-4*(* &76b *$7 '- -f7 ",6 =".+§-$ -$ " 1&8 4 1:, / *%" . *- _" 3 & *#" &.cQ $(-G"_C*%&$ -'#"*_Y'- (* (*+,K -Q" ( $_ - 4*-4*c 2$4 %?(f%& A*8 ]D
" #"#". ( =4G" "D UjC " (%17 V6C]_#"$ &(* &Q 4CTn ;;%&---#" V- 7" j\(M 9"$ / *4*$ %& Q :# ± CH%&%& #" U18^ uT¯(* N $%1 [ m *8^ *V;"
Z\[^] 8I-J syu v g
Z
8UT >F>FV
aLK
BHM
F
8 L-W >7@ |
uT(* K- A " (* U=02 .Y%& #"Q¯" (Q-4*4* 2%?(/
t j 4.4 The Resampled Index Tree K - P$4uT 1(* - \ %.( & 4*b-4 =4*a]D &"$ /U & _"$ & * 1 - ?8V >c4uT"$- (* &- ; N 1 C4*Q"$
&& QB" *(- * &7" 4* " U1*a 4= ".-3" 9(4" WN4 % 9- " $+ *14]T4 ? \a"$"$ & A8B &$*B " * *->4 X A-7(]D (* W ( \1 02- _moN4* *4*4 .a" "$ ; &" T( - 1 G=cK4 -U " &(*&A
]D * W% ]T 1 -*$ T C" (*( P102 W- 476 D$1 w& Wmm-oUoQ4" 9 &" &A^4 1 ?P%?(1]T=]D ?D a"$ "$ & &8¯ ^:,]T ]D* T []T( =*0
" 14-]T4 ? &8^=P "$V b &%¯ Q" ¯"" 6 (* ( Q1 & C &4 m- o=+t 9' 4" &8 cB A uT; &(*$W T** " -vc * &% V" A9]D02 D N %&-- < T4%& %&_* 3..= 1" " T%? T( ? ["$$ $ > G G4* 1 =" &(V% &4$ - 6c" 3X]" T((*1 ? \] >=]D%1--* + "." V 1 W G$b$- * bPb" ($-b [" (z W -- 4*- A -*" (4 ;--4 &-P ["B " (" W & 9 " N T ; &02 & 4- &%" " (* 1
"$]_ _ 8"CuT(*W 9 1" X \"- 9 6@( =4"[-$- 8@ N- W *" 7" (* - ]_7697AP6)E - 4*02 > & 5$ 4* " 9-" ]D 1 =*BJ4 3 1 &I9_]*_ ( N%.-(/PbN-- 96C0 -".$76( b"O" ]_(* )%& [CK - ?=; >]_-]W *Q S7"$4*" & 14 GI9 7 * "$ & %& G
#"EC4*-C$ ;&%& ' #";_" K%&-(* 3 *C N%&* >" -¯v' Q " *(* \ ?N )k8P"$4 Z9 &4 " - &8G24-WnZ9%.[(Y" &A 4}]T p
44 9 ?" $'-K - & 5" -(; '- 1-]_ >-V% O8/=".¯) ° * G b 9r " ?58bR} & 3 1$-69 8H Z *%&G /C D<E ]T>7 @ ( %.( 1*02 b`>Dz &$w&- $16E$w&#" b -4/ 1 ?8^A¯uT]D( 3 1K - ) " A (*" ( &$
Qb -4* D C4¯ %.( 9" ` G C D<E >F@ 8 uzG 1- - /%.( *`cAa]D /(=0 b" X$%1 d=02 1 C D<E >F@ 4- " &A &$7" \ bU%&-#"T- 8 T >F>)V 8 LQW >F@ 4 QG%.5( * 1 `3%?(K-%?_(" ( * U`A[ " *(* *1 #" &44Y 8 9" X( 102 }" h_
*#"$ " 1 - b-$ X$" " 1( 5 9 6E" (= &&81{ Euz" )( 6X 1 **%&P / ." - *-- X" $ (& & & 5`&A-WT" (4 / 4 9 " ; 9-" . * V 31 b#" = & 4< N]W? 8B7"$Z " & b%& Q" C]T U ($`C102 b- $ V*%?%.(7@ 8 FK>) V 1 3K -x8 LQW &>F@ 8 $6;" ; *$`A2" (T #"$ **" uT(* U]_(- ;#" &4/p" (_ ? ' [% #" F
a
Z ]
F
^
Zx[y] 8 g v d b-s Z K 1 F G C D<E >7@ M F 8=T >F>)V a _ _ba c ] d egfhji k F 8 L-W >7@ a F 8UT >F>FV a Z ] _ ^ F 8 LQW >F@ x| q2 uT(* 9-4) E * Cr3 1- * %?( *`NP$w& C-4*4* 1 b=" &76 1
9" 3 &$69A9 &$7" C C%& #"Q Z\[^] 8U_a`cbQd h gqf ` fUgqg v 8UT >F>)V 1 8 L-W >7@ x| ]_P7" uT(/(* * \" (*=\ \02" (.*- _`f1%&]T #" *NP"$- * zb &" _-( V & * " ;(* l&o\4 * 1P /$%*&- $ *$
_ & b & / 9"$" E 7 & & \Z 7 &63%?W"" -( &q* ?'8-l- 8 $6
I
Z
F
a
K
B
M
F
d
Z\[^] 8 g v d g
Zx[y] 8 g ` gqf b-sFv a Zx[y] 8 I-J syd u v g a d Zx[y] 8 g v d b-s a Zx[y] 8U_a`cbQd h gqf I ` fUgqg v | §m- d 3a:7@ 4.5 The Choice of D- #"$. 9" ; E" ( %?(* %& 3 3 :7@ = $ 3 * [" >",]T> &+ Z
"$$ (*-%& U & X 1 f°BAa #" &10 A_ [ &c " 4 /- 4*- " & &}; * % /" $-* . ) * @W$ " -53[-%& -"Q $CC * * - . *=+t" "$%1 4 0&8J%&c7"OR54 6d- 3-- = ?$%AnX-K -$
Z
F
F
3 b-s N ` gqf Z 3 yZ m m Z 578 304#576 398 U n U F G C D<E >7@ U o2"!yn # U A g b X 8 ]_4 ( ? 9 " W%Z &m - m ".Z578 1 &8 ]T c ;ATuT-( ( 1 027 6 ? \'-" *( 3 - /AU1*" ]T4( 4 XN C( & "$* - & ( /"/-b%- /[&" " ((
+ ( -(9"N¯" ( V44 ?W"$ & 8 4.5.1.2 :4 O b &W._ * =P"WUpper " 1- &#" *N$n9*A Bound ]D _ V" ( %1="D >on" &(I Q*3 %1:7 @ % ."," 6b76b- &f *" $(* Q _4*" ( 4= "_D["$ "$ & Q & N 1- 'n[*4^-(* &" _(9"; G 02:F30@ 4# 576 391!8 N3 4:7" @ \#" l 8P &uT;(* "; ' 1 #" A " ( V44 ?_ >- /" ( U(* & (9"Q-¯" (* U4*4 W"$ & \ bg =b 3 3 N ` #gqf A Z m m Z 578 304#576 398 304#576 398 3 n G :q;=;?>F@ o2 Sn y| $ -&702"O ?69 &.AV-4f- 0 S ** *" &(>W" E- X3" &%.(*( C9 $$ 6S\J$ w& VAN8 " W( & *$ E".>-7" & &A>cb" (*& 36S *#" &U *$ 11 02 * + 4.5.2 Constraints due to Prediction Error " ( ?:, 3='" :F@GfC4^D<E-$>Fb @ " ( Pt--A-U"Y" ( / T * V1 3]T1]T ?$^b "$T- "$ ^ & B%- V\]& T b 9 ".-^ & 5b-$-.69 9 *8¯6; uT;4(" T 9" %&&A%&9" -*3 + 1 * N" #" " b9=" $b }-¯W1" ]T( ? V4 "$ & [ b 1%&%&^ &$4 $ & &8 &EVV- 5 /" " (( " K(- [ ;( " 9"1AP"$" - b" ( " ( / >:#± " X% %#" < &--$ -4 6 1 *7+O% " -° d * 1 $ b44 * ?+ "$ \ &B4 &&8 4.6 I/O Cost of the Predictions K P :, &- > 9B"V" -(* 4*W4*".$ 2$ %" %?"N(* - & Y Q4A* /*]T U &$
&]_& 9-" ¯ 1$6=1"C 5m0-A9--]D ) Q " ]_=(*" 3 :$Z±- &g%" %& - #"\4.5.2 ? 8 B " * ( %*" -vd44* -%.(@[ * &4 & * & 9";W" ( %.( %& b 3 :F@ 8Q 4 ; 1- *4%$4*" b- 1- / cA I9 1-$ *w", &6 &Ab^T 2-1";]T >" (*1" 8^ 3]_C(W 1]T 89 ;"$ &1^ 7@ #l *x | Ry1]T" ?(/D"$ * &% & ^ 1$ * " (*3 :7@ G C D<E >F@ ]_(*%?(W * (*6
100
10
1 0
,
100
% 0 (
200
300
400 500 600 data dimensionality
* + -,[ 5 N
,.
700
+ '7.'
800
900
1000
+ / , ')
_] 4* 7 4" (@- &%.%(>" &% fW A 17 E$]W -&6 EaW%1 &$ & NN"-- .$(* 6E ; $W:$w&± - -z8Gb%&®V---#"1; ]T7 * " 02 & %? 1 _ 1A¯-'" -$ (*#"& 3 N W &" (- *-- b" 4* " * &( } Q%1- -4 76 ++ - *B$`uTbX(- P 4*- *4*. " 4- *([%. Q(5 -¯#" X ? 1 " 8 (* V Cl1%&o_ %&" -v44 4* & Y" -(%. D(5:#± \d%4E #"" ¯>K-",^]T *>7vc- . * ? " $ = ".%&\ Q- *" ( _4 &- * $" -C - ^7 }" -Y &%?&84(*^ ®V$ 9b ?" D]" (TA2 b Q]T W%1-°* & b * &#"- $6)" ( V$ Q bw& >=".- &-1$ -"P$$6Cw& * N &4"P b N *
]_ 02uTz ( $
> 3&7:$6Xl1±-o A o Xo %&ob" -(#"b 2- * & /4 K - V *$p o3 - * 17"O69 &87 6 ^$- 6E *&8" $(* // " (* &U '$- -7 "O6 A 1 " -3(: & 02- D4%.Q(4 & 2&8 ?[-"$%." uT(/ a(*4* _ # &*2 *-% /4X" * f";8¯ Q:," 3 ]T* P"\ *`2r 7 &vco &- 94" 4 2 & /%?(G 1$ % U1A]T]D [ [-*$ $* $ + 4(* ?$ C' &%'"3P$4 &-7" b **".* 8B *Z E &%" " (*- / *% " 9" 1 & " (* C & 9" %]" T ?B X*%C Q%" T &$ S& & ` yV-" (* E X =".".3$ "$" .4H- E b- *%&4*$`%&> & Q$$ I9$4 ? " P"[( ;I9;**%1 $-697` + 8 " *uT(*$ (*; /e^A o-p ]_o o>o 8x_ ? uT3(*7 "+ " " (*(* & _ 4* 1 C%?" " >- 3$4 - %" C(* & C#"$ $ %1" C - * &8 */;uT]_(*7 C" (3° " #"(*; W%4 . X " *&8^%1=uT" (* &
J =*" 02 3 U"$ $* " (f_8aDV & 1-" $ 02 Q 1 "$.- *#' Q." \^n-o W±=&8
2500
2000
prediction
Z 4 *V 7 "b >3 #"$4 +t"$ 1 % * &" - %8y" & &8:, D"3uT" &(%.(N I9- %?*"< 7i" j2[0m=st A¯=" (*J 9" Z> Q+t "$ Y+ & >t"$ i n &o stAaA¯ U" (*?+§ "$ =+t?"$A¯ &" ( i7l Ql?s§+ A " (* \Q`9 )+O ? + P+t"$ 4 & C ;i'n--=[stA- ) > *" ( E V-#"$ >*%° " * i n k1-st8 "U%& 9".- * 1 X X" ( 4 - -* &4 4#"" - ( - * b"[)"$ *.- 1 $ #7K 6@ 0- [" DK--4 S[" (C" < -( -%= *%&"C+, & *$" $ (*$`&
* 3I* &T]T ? ;. 8
5.1 Runtime of the Predictions
% ?$ :,- C 4 b" =( - 1^3 @$ E&" %)$" -" ( 3 1 >]D _ +O * C-$`@ ? T" *E" (* c N 8S %&u¯%&%&- *" . /- G%*6Cj) - #"" (" W 4 ( @ > 1= * 02 %J " = &" -#" 027 + b=" &8VNN *$%&*$$ 1 E XZ &%" Eq 8 m3'V" (* [ & 4 1 G4*+
5.2 Accuracy of the Predictions
0 0
500
1000
1500
2000
on-disk
&
1
3000
*e # ,.' /01) 2+ + %$ '7+ 3:7@ Z q
3 N*# )'7 b+ '7 '/ Z + '7.'7,. 5
2500
Q00
*4$b --%.Y(YA¯4]D4 b ?Q"$ & V &#" b=02" " (#" b =" \7"N ;K--U_4= - [ .=" & &¯"- $( *= "a Q" '( TQ=" (*02 ? U.I9- * &",=6b" -0 ¯ W 4*$ - &P *-%" - W f8^B ¯-"+ *3 :< b;=;?>7l=@ n3$(*q*=8^]_NN"P] (T \ U %1 & >-$ 4* N 1K E --|44 " (2W %? (G-]_-.7" ('1 A" ( Ul A o o-*o/ "D - %&$Z & *%& " ]T E ) - &$%$ * 1$
G&N$ 7 K-(9 " 76/7"O]_6d7" -(/\ *" (* &% ) & *-$". 5]_(* & & y$ 69 8 " .. uT" " (*N3 P-]_'-4*(*%4*"Y %.2" (/( %?Q(*"Y &#"" Dl( &c o ^]To H ¯Y%1 -6V & ; 1$]x B - l&a o 4o "ab8 *2 1]_ \(9 &6V U" " ((* ^ P14*]T4 ¯Y --44
Z
k
Z
k
Z
Z
Z
Z
k
k
Q &8P ?$o - p l-A k-La -r - ;$ j & &m-`o Al1m n m-o-Lao A-n--j \n "$.- j #mKl- A mo o $: ±-%& q A#"q2[p o8 l1 .j V *+, *$` " ( N:< &;= ;x>F@ 4 1o% X| o j 3 p-:<j ;=A ;x>F@ C D<E >7@n9A o |l1o-r 2j n p r-r l1r A m-n-r &l q | n l G N & 4 1 X 3 :F@ jA j l A o j m j j A r-o2m n-%j | r k n G N:< &;= ;x>F@ 4 1o% X| o j 3 p-:<j ;=A ;xG>F@ C D<E >7@q A l= l=k mA o2k9l j2kA n=q q p2m | p-o r G :F@ %o | o j p-j A G C D<E >7@ l= DD**" " --vv 33:7@@ j nAA G :F@@ o o || o o j-j-p p j2j2 p-n qk m-m-ooll r r AA kko2o2mm r%r%|| q q 22nn G l1p D*" -v 3 :7@ q*A G :F@ o | o j-p j2 m-ol r A ko2m r%| q 2n k
Z
Z
Z
Z
Z
Z
a k
Z
k
a
Z
Z
_
k
Z
Z
_
k
Z
Z
X 9!
'7 1)
a
k
_
Z
Z
a
k
)(
_
2) '7
0] ,.* 1
5 '+
" %(** C" -*v4-44* 4*Q "$2 &%? C(fA 1]T=T V4 ?- \- 1 3 )(* =*]d ]T &" (" [( Q4 4* & *$4%" 7" \ *D" G *" (*
-** "37'K -b7*6} 7 '#" $ * *=" 1". 58 4R}- Y 8P &#"uT$ (* U%" 1- >" NC(" (* V T &'-_" - -z4 [ * &" c &%?$(*C 'I918 &P]_(%?( 4*-Q".- &2$ D"N fa"-AT (]T < T >C.-*-$ HP`mo o@ n9^ 1l aQ 1" B(*4 -- * K-%& %& &$$ Q] *T -tNpAa R5r &l-8 [ "C-8 i j j=sW4* 1 %" " -( 9]W"P'.- V/l&q[V$44 7"_ & *]_ & *V$- E&A2%&J %& &|$$ 1 c8".:,$ d"_" (* EuW e $V uT -V7 N"O6ePq p-oo *=%& %&". & $$ _$ &"11 EAz02 ?]D]_. 3- B( Q14 02 [ 1 Q %?76@(* " 1 &l& G 9j/"? &$4?02A2 &$ G7U"[ &" *(* Q 4 &1- *8;$ uT-"^ (]_3 ?( t ?' V G Ac" (]T4 C- ?--' &*-T ". 3=
" r &(A p--q*$"B l[4 b4-' - TD " N=( WP(Q"% (* 1 U( ? &b 9 "C-%1[--* 4 $ U " )" (*( /- V%&4*4%& - &$-$ * \&%%1" -4 -%%& &7$("O-6 &T`\' Q TK 1b * & ? & ]W_6[-'K c Q*A-" 7®V(*"$' &-7`-Q - *%& ; $%& ? $( $ & 9-" " -&8#+&8 9.i7l?sZcREFERENCES Z &8N &%%." ( 0 7$"O696 ?1 A* #" Q%&%& &$ " (! 'V 4¦ - 9 " £-Q1©-B -*4*a ` 1 1%]_"U" 1( 4 A" ( ¯¯"%&%& &($ B$ &°\ #"Ka-;-4(4 - 2(*+, *%?(;" &( *=$"¯- $ =V". *8 W" %?(* I9 V(-W" ( UK 1]_ *"O ]T$ -- _Ac- = .- 9" & &TK- * #" ¦§2 ¨ %?-N" 0-- ¡*. &¦,&8?:, A 4 $£1 &Vn -p-r #n k-¡VAfn-ª o-ao £-o 8 ?' ª¥?;£O© i7l&os[L¯)-¦K8 D %&.&% ¦ #b ¥-- t - 8 La-¦§= " ¨. && 8 D £-*1`"18$ N1 / %.-(Y484 uz 1 & *%.(b *=%1" --f / N 4--$ 1$"V n *q A ". i j j=s; [eD- Z 8L^R}76* Q $:#Nuy 1-4 A ®[ > O8 4+ & %8$"NKZ-®U%? (*eBb & -` * A%&eP \ ZX /#" Zc * 8 *6bD8' --l&"$Qq "1$l=8?{AVI9 % " -7 "O 96" +§ 7$ ".;1" l& 02%.2 ( k98 ¦K " ( *¦ W >£1(© a £-( - +, *,? ? &¡ $Y-- t9- f$4 -¦§%& &&8. -:O ? A $4 £1. $ &-'9-[£#© i j-qs Nl1-8 q ; n8o2" Rhm(*Aa(l&7_" ;--r -8 / >4 ; $8'2 -b Y-8 *Z %& 8*:O 7"O $6
.>
@
j
>
e>
.>
j
?>
>
e>
e>
>
.>
>
e>
>
E@
j
>
>
e>
e>
>
>
N>
j
>
@
>
Ambuj K. Singh
Department of Computer Science University of California Santa Barbara, CA 93106
Department of Computer Science University of California Santa Barbara, CA 93106
[email protected]
[email protected]
*"./ ( 1
02 3 & & ) 4* -4 $ 1 5 !4 #" $ & 0 %" $ 769 &8:,' )).(* * (*;+," *$%*" %?(@ H " * & %. 5( *#"J$I9 * &%>" K - &&AB" (*7"3 &$ C0)#"$7". -*D%" " *E (&8=M0 * " $(> %?- (C & *4*^ . *-/^4-$ ". G * &$("BaKK1--] " (*$(*1-1]S ]d-" " \c( %& -"^^7"D44 & *$ &K= -" T ' *-a]D TB $ &-#" &$ 02 &8 &a% " R5 1 3 W " ( B & 3" (--$ &6[02$ W Q-%-$ $ * #"$.4*4" & " *&8^ &^ 9-ea". =$ ++ . *D =B W b --b -7" - D [" &(*1 T] =02" (. D-" *4* ^ 1 '-B%?" *- *" V T-^ 44* " -Q"O]D " (* U'*f b]_" (* "N 4 8
ABSTRACT
*".@INTRODUCTION g ( 1-02 E * &C h 4*V - D4- $ 1 * h E h#"$ 4** % &" 0* *U >" (* U * ? fA _4 -- \$w& &. - R}r2:#k-D-k Ql&`!q2n>4 1K= ]T$-" .- " 76(o- [o$+ Ul14*=l 4" 8--$ " 1 DZ9%&6{ & -%. 3 " -} W *D Q" +, - )2k -n- m Xk9l 9Ab6G:$U:$Z9 +
1.
Permission to make digital or hard copies of all or part of this work for personal or classroom use is granted without fee provided that copies are not made or distributed for profit or commercial advantage and that copies bear this notice and the full citation on the first page. To copy otherwise, to republish, to post on servers or to redistribute to lists, requires prior specific permission and/or a fee. ACM SIGMOD 2001 May 21-24, Santa Barbara, California, USA Copyright 2001 ACM 1-58113-332-4/01/05 ... 5.00.
]_ &7" #"(( 1%0 C 3*" b" -* yJ /> " (* \ " * ? & f EAT " (*$`c /8N'*V *N%& \ *" ( ?
%1 - U > * & *"1 8 .-769A^" ( "$$6}" E$-0 /%1 > * ?+ $% 1 W' 1]_& 2-¦§-TK?-¦P?5¢a G-¦T' $'$N9¦K $-K K$>-b-¦§??£>. #1$9?9 ?T¦,3[ D®V-4 1" ]D(* 1 * &Q02% " 1A * [- ? **-Q* *(]TC-$% .(*`(+, & *%1- E & &&8 *$$>- - \" (#" ;$ %? *" ?* &#"¯($ -%?z"" *W [".`2 9 D" $ %?& }" 02- 4 .^%$c"[14--( W$ " &(* W&8 =^024 uT ? (4%& _%11A¯ W]T >9 6" U(*$ & * /' * V bQ" [$((%& W1-]|4*(* 1=] ++ $ $ 1W @ -"O4*]D4* & & -%.U(YA^1]W- +, }I9 -7("O6-(*+, I9"B --#"7"OP6)4* & *"[%$" 1 ]| 34*f 1U %? &" - @-$6-+ b *% *" $` *9E+§ " -(*$
& X- 4 4 -2W-%.(Y 8N R} } ;4-4* $ C& 9 @"V4"O]D(-$ " & &&8%?)(* I9C & 1_%?'(}\" 4*%? ( ?++ %&I9 $ - AD 1 @]T '- * & *02 7vc- 4S & 9%&-"#" &' C$65$b"w& )&A_ & #" =".b-$ " " /$" (*w& /&A_:#± - %&- #"7+ * & \ *-$ - < ",]T7" C &&8.U *R5 _$(*¯1b]--" ( 7=" "U N" '(E-#"" %?Q(*" ( I9 > &N 1 $ * "O[]D &" ( &
4 $7 " QB$(-%%&1 &]$$ " &( B]=_"B7 " *(b^U *$` 9 &+§* 4 - $ =&0 & a( c 8a(CuT4*( _ 1 %?4" - - &% 9%&".*. % ?6 + ]_( G="" ( / >" b 1 **%& E" ( /4 1 *%" - S%&-#"K
*( * I * &/"V -$ $ 1& E%& G *&8" (* V* 7'%& -4 ",6G $$-$ H]_4*7" " (!- )4* 1 %" " ( ; HK." &%%?".( -+ K" -(* (* & $(*b +, )-7-"O 6)" ($$( ? < 1" ]_- W\"%?(* * ( ".=I9 "[8@ >" (*uz" &G($ b" "b(- Z &p*%b" -" $% E &&%.k($8 *$ &IW*$ -8! UR} E44 & %1 =" ]_- " ( uK- b(*RELATED T C %&$
7K -- $ %>74 "OJ6d 1 E%&E - * 3"%& & 9G"$" .(*°* G " #" 1/02 & $#+ + T X 6 I9 $ E$6 -4 N _ & &-+§\"$ Y 9 &" AN] T$ & -%?3" " 1-(* ) &0 S9 &6 %&-" (*6}%& 3 I9=-" X- *" &" (*&8$ G C uT102?(" [.--°-8h E#"\i7 l&`*j *sQC=]_ " ]T - & &f#"-$ >%" 1 " *5" $-- i +,7 *l&sY4* & * &$$ & 9 "__ %&= ".#" _8y:, S &Xc$" bC4-%&4- *1+ A % &$`4*"-$%%& &$$ &V" K -N "O]T `2+,1 *]_$` &_ $$- -C"z X=".4* 8_ 1 _%$"363" ( >"V- 8;Ci n=sa ?-C0 "$" (* * C6 ?". --$ $ 1 * G {#" /$ " ( %?6 =" $*" " &(U >C * N%&* C *I9 * *>C -; &-> * K- *".GX$*46G ?%.vc 9`2" &" %" -&8 [1]_®V- b 1 y]T `9024+O -1++ A *l? &+§ &V- 9^" -=I97".*6- $ ]_" &7&8" W( D" ( ( %. (9 ( " +, * E & &$"\ $ t--8< 7-i"Oq-6 cs^$4]_4 -( &%&$ %. &(d8P 9"\uTb(*b& 6 %&6=".-N$$* ;4* 1" ¯" *N9 &N ;-4*"Q 1(* %? /" -' N & 1$*a7" -a / ;" ((- (*$ + %& *- $ &"1&88 PuT(T$(*-$" %&- [ & " [4 =.- "$ %Q * &D *$%&$$ & 2.
uT(* &$ _ * &B"$$6;" ;-%&%&- 9"^'-^" ( W * +,* 7' 7"O6[-" (*
2.2 Globally Parametric Models
K° . =#"".%Q3".-%&9_-6>#" V & &$ &c '3--V7"N7"O Q69+t8)$"$ &b Q-*K- " ]$ $1- >3 - "C -" ¯(8S4 U=Ji7.l1.--n=s_%".4* " a ? * $ &A& 9" & 1`2 * 5 \$" " (( *
+ -/7 *"O6[".]_$ ("1%.83(3uTB%(*&U°- #" 1; " U * T ¯" ]W(* -UO * (#" $ &%? 9" "P 1 X *" b &. *-$ * I9", 6 ?U - " 02 & "_$ * 1- C E" 7K_"B-]T' N9 +§l?`>V+§V96>hI9La*I9- 4 ? & &8 ;^4D -* _ +tN"$ - & / &&8 " %& Q ? "U * 8_#"t$8;uT (i7l& ? o6 +s " V ! BI9 ? -. &8B D:O b" \%1-4 $ N 1 *-Y%"^$4 " (%& N VT4LB$H" 7" - 3 :$ *± *hA " %&(-#"P"D &f%.(. * I-* V Q ? + $- 7 X" B Z & &$$ &i 9" j-lsB76-0 3 3(*b#" --. * &z^K-=\024 ?^ 1" *(* _%" *=".b-" $ (*"1 8B4uT ?(*$' &- *b *%&
]_" -(c( C.%.(b 9 %&- QPTI9 &$ ? %&$- 7P" 76 3 &- 04$% .*B]$" $ D-1 G- _`96E *" D$4 (=w" *J` ;¯= *U- "."U-4-- 83$ U&i &8=" s§ 8 % &*uT4#" & (* X *&A & Y 9 *-"N0- -- 9B".$" % 1#"] _ 9%&"$%& *. *%%6 1 ( d _$ -&%&$%-$" #"*W f- &ANc3.]D- X * $( V* 1-] 3(7 *" 1 1 1] @ -#"-T- 4* 9- *"(-N-%&W- hI9 &* E -$ &69&8$ 8X^1uT SuT((*"
* "_$ &%" ]_¯ 1-c]_7" (/" ( V7" 1 &z02-> 1* }D9 6)= *°" & **#" [P" 02-[ 4 $4 1 X *%-"PP" (*" " E%& #"V &$- $6T" ( \ G" 1(*= 4 -`2- ^ &_- -4*z " 1(* %" O [ -7+§%&% * . - %?69A= "z z" ( V4I-*$". $ 6"c]T" _ &` *$ * c a8D" *( -=T"Y" " (*(*
uT(* *W+§#" $ % - " (* U-(- &7" -((x"N-'a-_" (*" U(* V"$ & 8 7P+§6> * ?#+ N U b%&" ( N $ K AWf" ( *b - c$A9$]D* U &%1`- / -%.1(]_ & 102 * N-" G(-WU#"" $(* %" .- c$#"$ J=%" 7"O 69 8 " " ? (* &&A ^ 1- 1U4 c-8/ :, & 5$4$ &" & 9(%" 3 1° G%1K -%&-7=6 ]_ G¬a * * CA^]TZ 4 447'"9 1%& * " +ti ?+t"$Uj- q- &#"st$ ?8) +,®V%?`2" 31*]T#" $ & V02* -%1+ A ]D &Z8 %& D" (* D 7+§ ;a7"B CN$*$ "B " ( D ".$ "1A ]D
(7Y1]T02 V V" *C$ U 1 W[%& N " ( U44 -l \l&%&o-4 -f%&" (7"O N6/-- %&% - . *-f * =769". 8PA 1--_%.(< *4 -- V4 A " 4(*- C " &8U 7N+§U G /" ]_( BN%&]T - 9.". -&A )c" ( X ;14 02 . [--%1 /-4l -%&l17"Oo/6PN" (* 1 C **%& 1- 9-6 " (*- - *%? " -3l 1 l1 &o&A8 " Z( U *%& 1 b Q%&+t"$ & > & 2- W *-w&B /44-- 9" " _4[ Q1 b *b]_ %&(-102$
U#"$" (* %?" *=. X-c" $$( * 7`"O698/AuT" ((* V4 $(-*-= U]_&;"69 ( =" "[W &-02¯ &" 5(* V" (*'* *c () ]D
¯ >-" (** U l; *7 +§4 *%" ?_" < ( \ \%& - "Q % &" %& $ 7",6/]T 1 &I9 /-" (8 \ - -¯- " $ (*?" Tz ¯--*4* T b4 l2 TQ *& &694* %"1" 8BQ"¯ (* V *l2 t / a#"$$( *1%]_" B" [(* D% #"-$ *-%" 1 G=". + " ¯(*- _*- 3 l2 t Tf * &".4*%$ " W"" ¯( U [ 7l +§ %=^ $(* =%&]_-^" #" $( _%? -" 1 >4*- 1 / " (= U". -$ 3" + 4* 1 * b $(= ".- $ *`"18^ Q /D-$ %&&%& &- 9 3"_" -(*z Q - ? 4*4 ** 8PA2uT" (*( _ 4 ?-'-- & D -A*]Dc" U(( _102 V " 7 + 4 -1-]} " J&(69 &-!*"\$ 6U ;.£" V>ª*" ?(* C?-¦ £--Q ©&-2P¦§ £- *" ?_ f8bV`2 ¯%&" [(" a( 3 &$*" *J *= + " 9 6) %& * 9 *" / */V " &(#" .- **C$(* 1 f\A]D_ C 4*" ? & *$ &%%"Q" " ( * [ 4",]T &% &" 1 } :# ± 4~ &%%" 1#" I9* $6b & *V (* fA ]_( ?W*%14*- * 1 $ Q%(*" qE¯ * ". $
\n"/A]_%?O(*8G uz N-]D N G.-l= /\m- o- 5oCn9%&l-+§V4 {= I9 1 ) " ( & bP b%" " ( 4 - 4*- N%&%$ &w&$ &$ &8&PV]Q_T 7" ( 4" ( & ;%" 4 1 c 1A2 *" (% Q" 14* &4 *--% " 4 *$ 9 " \ &4* u_ $ ?&8 9" */" " * ' 1=" * 02 &%?" - ; ".- 1 XK " (* bD- D:Ob
n kk-A$r m o-A q2oE p p m3l=*p k1u_o+, *+,? 8 & $$- --D44 9 9" " ;T &4*4 & &$ $ && 9 9" " ;K" 1 " " * & _['$ 1=%." *(@ U-02 $4%" &-% "$T.-P %&Y9- F % "_ " b&AB-%- & 9U" ' "$ . K# 1'" & 1&A -p A m- ;o-o\$-j p-o.+,- * 9"a' & 1 *=$" *- &z 4* ". 9" a 1 ; &94*6U $
&&%& 9" . * *V " _(" D(4* T m %&nW W ?-"$" p A m-ao--o; #"" (9 D%.-`B4(0 - B "B * T¯69$4 1 _` &'"$ .9 6#l=K-m- oQ$4 1 C 1-*` $ &8 au_?8
N =
j
j
!
'7.'7,. ., ,. +
37% 24% 14% 6% 1% 10%
'&N!
25%
)(
Sample size
+* +-,
)'2
3 5 %
5 % 9 ,.' /
50%
).
01) 3, ,
K" -(*V & 02- & /4*" (* Q"$ w& & b%.( **I* U" " " ( ; 4 $ K 8_9%&N% *-4 " (* %Q6)%& - *W#"" $(*. - 9"U 7 + 4 - * c"1A-8^" Z( T *%& QU44 D . _=" - Wc%1" (- W &02 * ?+§B T $ [bC-* #"BP" (*( >l "P 1A -#"]_D(* *
W" ( \4- \%&-4 %&7"O6>-¯" (* V'*z c8 * *N * % & "1U;A]T" ( 3( Q4 -]_(G &($
-&$ 9 V-"\?-(*
*(* (G * %&3%&*" .(* \%6) ' *"O ?6 4 %1 7 *6(*:# P± K -= ]_ / *4*\ &$ *&%%" " * /B -*%&$%%&& .$-Y"% 69(8 D * ] 44* -%.( [- 1=" 4 _ &+t &4*"$%& " 1 &(C &B]- 1 /_ C(9 6]D N]_f*$ N" (* V#6 C-P#" & 4.1 The On-Disk Index Tree 9i m16bs§uT8>" (*(uT E N(* [* *+,`b -$`-2 -7 *" ( 3 d- & "$% * G$" (*02/ &7-6X * y &4 $%= $ *" " d 1- < #"$\"9 6 (%D" * %. G("." - &$4 * / -. %"Q b" - &" 8 - & ?." U" ( V * b"$ & V4 -- &Q 02 &7+t]_$ -8D*-Q 1-%.(/ &0 &A*" (*
1 B 304#576 398 3:7@ 3C D<E >F@ G :7@ @ G:IHKJML#N O=JFV 8 LQW >F@
**CC DD--^B4 = ". 9C" 4T" ( 9=" "_°"_ &$6 (** &C (9"_ D-a-B" (*4 U 9 " +,W4 *$` bN * *$`b b4 "$ &
(*(* & & (9(9"_"_--aa" " (*(* U U14*]T4 QW"$"$ & & & BA 44 [[.." " 33''QQ" " (*(* \ \=4*]D4 _W"$"$ & & &
bb== x| *=7 ". &C%" 4 $ 6 \4 %1 4 [-%%1-",465-%&-7", *6}+, * $` b+, * $` > +
? ? vcvc & &%% " " 0202 \ } * 7 ". &C%" 4--$ 6H \4%&--4 - }%&7%1"O-6)4- %& 7",+O6g $`-%. (".4 X=$" 34" -= $" " _"- (* 1 & 'T $ " 1(- %.¯($ & f8P4uT($" U7" 4* $ & * 1 \ ;%" ( * P \ --Y" ( B_-$(- - 7" ( 9 " 2%1" ( / ^ & V K &*0 & * S $%" ( >4*" ' fQA 02% , 8N$i m1 Ss'?8 -U" (*b4-4 Xi n-j=s3''>5- G ".- 1 $4Z 4*N7"1";U8W U>uT?(*$4+t"$Q 7 &"$ " &$ i*j-7q" s§N#"8#" *Xb%&- *" 4*E3 " -" (*( ; F>)V 8 LQW >F@ §n ]_(N ? 7" *" 02- &" 769 _"A2" (*(* N U$ & %.(b .W-- *aI%&*- $6b 4 N 9-" *&8".- * 1 3K ~" (
" " ( (- V="P 4*-" (* 8a _4¯$ 1 V7 #". B=%." ( *.48^ *:O >* T &** 9_9" ? z *D -4 ? " "D(*$
W W & ~ " &A¯" \V(*1 N]T Np- &qN02vc ? 1=%A*"." ]D- 1$ 3 U"BC$($ **1%? b1(C]T" 1( 6
'*z *".-$ ?"N" 3% 4 " N" (* U$ 1 %.(/.- *8 'V:O G*" (* *' -[1" (]_ \ G1]T$ *_"$$ & &%? " &8- &Af]T C *$%&$U" (* ",]T/0- " 4.3 The Cutoff Index Tree %& 1 :O" f G-4vd-. - * 4* D4*V 2" 7" (%&g $".- " );4%&%&4- ?\ 9"$"1 8B & 3uz\ 1%&-T 4 #"-$ -* %Az"B]D" b( W-$1$]T* P 3"$ & * WK- & * * ". -4 * #" -$ Q - & f-" * `C"$$ 6 $ " - 5 &A" a(* b" ( 44 $++ uT(*%" Q 1- *%&W"%& .-" %(*6> V *%& ?-" %& *-.$-" / _" K( -=_"Q(*-4*(* &76b *$7 '- -f7 ",6 =".+§-$ -$ " 1&8 4 1:, / *%" . *- _" 3 & *#" &.cQ $(-G"_C*%&$ -'#"*_Y'- (* (*+,K -Q" ( $_ - 4*-4*c 2$4 %?(f%& A*8 ]D
" #"#". ( =4G" "D UjC " (%17 V6C]_#"$ &(* &Q 4CTn ;;%&---#" V- 7" j\(M 9"$ / *4*$ %& Q :# ± CH%&%& #" U18^ uT¯(* N $%1 [ m *8^ *V;"
Z\[^] 8I-J syu v g
Z
8UT >F>FV
aLK
BHM
F
8 L-W >7@ |
uT(* K- A " (* U=02 .Y%& #"Q¯" (Q-4*4* 2%?(/
t j 4.4 The Resampled Index Tree K - P$4uT 1(* - \ %.( & 4*b-4 =4*a]D &"$ /U & _"$ & * 1 - ?8V >c4uT"$- (* &- ; N 1 C4*Q"$
&& QB" *(- * &7" 4* " U1*a 4= ".-3" 9(4" WN4 % 9- " $+ *14]T4 ? \a"$"$ & A8B &$*B " * *->4 X A-7(]D (* W ( \1 02- _moN4* *4*4 .a" "$ ; &" T( - 1 G=cK4 -U " &(*&A
]D * W% ]T 1 -*$ T C" (*( P102 W- 476 D$1 w& Wmm-oUoQ4" 9 &" &A^4 1 ?P%?(1]T=]D ?D a"$ "$ & &8¯ ^:,]T ]D* T []T( =*0
" 14-]T4 ? &8^=P "$V b &%¯ Q" ¯"" 6 (* ( Q1 & C &4 m- o=+t 9' 4" &8 cB A uT; &(*$W T** " -vc * &% V" A9]D02 D N %&-- < T4%& %&_* 3..= 1" " T%? T( ? ["$$ $ > G G4* 1 =" &(V% &4$ - 6c" 3X]" T((*1 ? \] >=]D%1--* + "." V 1 W G$b$- * bPb" ($-b [" (z W -- 4*- A -*" (4 ;--4 &-P ["B " (" W & 9 " N T ; &02 & 4- &%" " (* 1
"$]_ _ 8"CuT(*W 9 1" X \"- 9 6@( =4"[-$- 8@ N- W *" 7" (* - ]_7697AP6)E - 4*02 > & 5$ 4* " 9-" ]D 1 =*BJ4 3 1 &I9_]*_ ( N%.-(/PbN-- 96C0 -".$76( b"O" ]_(* )%& [CK - ?=; >]_-]W *Q S7"$4*" & 14 GI9 7 * "$ & %& G
#"EC4*-C$ ;&%& ' #";_" K%&-(* 3 *C N%&* >" -¯v' Q " *(* \ ?N )k8P"$4 Z9 &4 " - &8G24-WnZ9%.[(Y" &A 4}]T p
44 9 ?" $'-K - & 5" -(; '- 1-]_ >-V% O8/=".¯) ° * G b 9r " ?58bR} & 3 1$-69 8H Z *%&G /C D<E ]T>7 @ ( %.( 1*02 b`>Dz &$w&- $16E$w&#" b -4/ 1 ?8^A¯uT]D( 3 1K - ) " A (*" ( &$
Qb -4* D C4¯ %.( 9" ` G C D<E >F@ 8 uzG 1- - /%.( *`cAa]D /(=0 b" X$%1 d=02 1 C D<E >F@ 4- " &A &$7" \ bU%&-#"T- 8 T >F>)V 8 LQW >F@ 4 QG%.5( * 1 `3%?(K-%?_(" ( * U`A[ " *(* *1 #" &44Y 8 9" X( 102 }" h_
*#"$ " 1 - b-$ X$" " 1( 5 9 6E" (= &&81{ Euz" )( 6X 1 **%&P / ." - *-- X" $ (& & & 5`&A-WT" (4 / 4 9 " ; 9-" . * V 31 b#" = & 4< N]W? 8B7"$Z " & b%& Q" C]T U ($`C102 b- $ V*%?%.(7@ 8 FK>) V 1 3K -x8 LQW &>F@ 8 $6;" ; *$`A2" (T #"$ **" uT(* U]_(- ;#" &4/p" (_ ? ' [% #" F
a
Z ]
F
^
Zx[y] 8 g v d b-s Z K 1 F G C D<E >7@ M F 8=T >F>)V a _ _ba c ] d egfhji k F 8 L-W >7@ a F 8UT >F>FV a Z ] _ ^ F 8 LQW >F@ x| q2 uT(* 9-4) E * Cr3 1- * %?( *`NP$w& C-4*4* 1 b=" &76 1
9" 3 &$69A9 &$7" C C%& #"Q Z\[^] 8U_a`cbQd h gqf ` fUgqg v 8UT >F>)V 1 8 L-W >7@ x| ]_P7" uT(/(* * \" (*=\ \02" (.*- _`f1%&]T #" *NP"$- * zb &" _-( V & * " ;(* l&o\4 * 1P /$%*&- $ *$
_ & b & / 9"$" E 7 & & \Z 7 &63%?W"" -( &q* ?'8-l- 8 $6
I
Z
F
a
K
B
M
F
d
Z\[^] 8 g v d g
Zx[y] 8 g ` gqf b-sFv a Zx[y] 8 I-J syd u v g a d Zx[y] 8 g v d b-s a Zx[y] 8U_a`cbQd h gqf I ` fUgqg v | §m- d 3a:7@ 4.5 The Choice of D- #"$. 9" ; E" ( %?(* %& 3 3 :7@ = $ 3 * [" >",]T> &+ Z
"$$ (*-%& U & X 1 f°BAa #" &10 A_ [ &c " 4 /- 4*- " & &}; * % /" $-* . ) * @W$ " -53[-%& -"Q $CC * * - . *=+t" "$%1 4 0&8J%&c7"OR54 6d- 3-- = ?$%AnX-K -$
Z
F
F
3 b-s N ` gqf Z 3 yZ m m Z 578 304#576 398 U n U F G C D<E >7@ U o2"!yn # U A g b X 8 ]_4 ( ? 9 " W%Z &m - m ".Z578 1 &8 ]T c ;ATuT-( ( 1 027 6 ? \'-" *( 3 - /AU1*" ]T4( 4 XN C( & "$* - & ( /"/-b%- /[&" " ((
+ ( -(9"N¯" ( V44 ?W"$ & 8 4.5.1.2 :4 O b &W._ * =P"WUpper " 1- &#" *N$n9*A Bound ]D _ V" ( %1="D >on" &(I Q*3 %1:7 @ % ."," 6b76b- &f *" $(* Q _4*" ( 4= "_D["$ "$ & Q & N 1- 'n[*4^-(* &" _(9"; G 02:F30@ 4# 576 391!8 N3 4:7" @ \#" l 8P &uT;(* "; ' 1 #" A " ( V44 ?_ >- /" ( U(* & (9"Q-¯" (* U4*4 W"$ & \ bg =b 3 3 N ` #gqf A Z m m Z 578 304#576 398 304#576 398 3 n G :q;=;?>F@ o2 Sn y| $ -&702"O ?69 &.AV-4f- 0 S ** *" &(>W" E- X3" &%.(*( C9 $$ 6S\J$ w& VAN8 " W( & *$ E".>-7" & &A>cb" (*& 36S *#" &U *$ 11 02 * + 4.5.2 Constraints due to Prediction Error " ( ?:, 3='" :F@GfC4^D<E-$>Fb @ " ( Pt--A-U"Y" ( / T * V1 3]T1]T ?$^b "$T- "$ ^ & B%- V\]& T b 9 ".-^ & 5b-$-.69 9 *8¯6; uT;4(" T 9" %&&A%&9" -*3 + 1 * N" #" " b9=" $b }-¯W1" ]T( ? V4 "$ & [ b 1%&%&^ &$4 $ & &8 &EVV- 5 /" " (( " K(- [ ;( " 9"1AP"$" - b" ( " ( / >:#± " X% %#" < &--$ -4 6 1 *7+O% " -° d * 1 $ b44 * ?+ "$ \ &B4 &&8 4.6 I/O Cost of the Predictions K P :, &- > 9B"V" -(* 4*W4*".$ 2$ %" %?"N(* - & Y Q4A* /*]T U &$
&]_& 9-" ¯ 1$6=1"C 5m0-A9--]D ) Q " ]_=(*" 3 :$Z±- &g%" %& - #"\4.5.2 ? 8 B " * ( %*" -vd44* -%.(@[ * &4 & * & 9";W" ( %.( %& b 3 :F@ 8Q 4 ; 1- *4%$4*" b- 1- / cA I9 1-$ *w", &6 &Ab^T 2-1";]T >" (*1" 8^ 3]_C(W 1]T 89 ;"$ &1^ 7@ #l *x | Ry1]T" ?(/D"$ * &% & ^ 1$ * " (*3 :7@ G C D<E >F@ ]_(*%?(W * (*6
100
10
1 0
,
100
% 0 (
200
300
400 500 600 data dimensionality
* + -,[ 5 N
,.
700
+ '7.'
800
900
1000
+ / , ')
_] 4* 7 4" (@- &%.%(>" &% fW A 17 E$]W -&6 EaW%1 &$ & NN"-- .$(* 6E ; $W:$w&± - -z8Gb%&®V---#"1; ]T7 * " 02 & %? 1 _ 1A¯-'" -$ (*#"& 3 N W &" (- *-- b" 4* " * &( } Q%1- -4 76 ++ - *B$`uTbX(- P 4*- *4*. " 4- *([%. Q(5 -¯#" X ? 1 " 8 (* V Cl1%&o_ %&" -v44 4* & Y" -(%. D(5:#± \d%4E #"" ¯>K-",^]T *>7vc- . * ? " $ = ".%&\ Q- *" ( _4 &- * $" -C - ^7 }" -Y &%?&84(*^ ®V$ 9b ?" D]" (TA2 b Q]T W%1-°* & b * &#"- $6)" ( V$ Q bw& >=".- &-1$ -"P$$6Cw& * N &4"P b N *
]_ 02uTz ( $
> 3&7:$6Xl1±-o A o Xo %&ob" -(#"b 2- * & /4 K - V *$p o3 - * 17"O69 &87 6 ^$- 6E *&8" $(* // " (* &U '$- -7 "O6 A 1 " -3(: & 02- D4%.Q(4 & 2&8 ?[-"$%." uT(/ a(*4* _ # &*2 *-% /4X" * f";8¯ Q:," 3 ]T* P"\ *`2r 7 &vco &- 94" 4 2 & /%?(G 1$ % U1A]T]D [ [-*$ $* $ + 4(* ?$ C' &%'"3P$4 &-7" b **".* 8B *Z E &%" " (*- / *% " 9" 1 & " (* C & 9" %]" T ?B X*%C Q%" T &$ S& & ` yV-" (* E X =".".3$ "$" .4H- E b- *%&4*$`%&> & Q$$ I9$4 ? " P"[( ;I9;**%1 $-697` + 8 " *uT(*$ (*; /e^A o-p ]_o o>o 8x_ ? uT3(*7 "+ " " (*(* & _ 4* 1 C%?" " >- 3$4 - %" C(* & C#"$ $ %1" C - * &8 */;uT]_(*7 C" (3° " #"(*; W%4 . X " *&8^%1=uT" (* &
J =*" 02 3 U"$ $* " (f_8aDV & 1-" $ 02 Q 1 "$.- *#' Q." \^n-o W±=&8
2500
2000
prediction
Z 4 *V 7 "b >3 #"$4 +t"$ 1 % * &" - %8y" & &8:, D"3uT" &(%.(N I9- %?*"< 7i" j2[0m=st A¯=" (*J 9" Z> Q+t "$ Y+ & >t"$ i n &o stAaA¯ U" (*?+§ "$ =+t?"$A¯ &" ( i7l Ql?s§+ A " (* \Q`9 )+O ? + P+t"$ 4 & C ;i'n--=[stA- ) > *" ( E V-#"$ >*%° " * i n k1-st8 "U%& 9".- * 1 X X" ( 4 - -* &4 4#"" - ( - * b"[)"$ *.- 1 $ #7K 6@ 0- [" DK--4 S[" (C" < -( -%= *%&"C+, & *$" $ (*$`&
* 3I* &T]T ? ;. 8
5.1 Runtime of the Predictions
% ?$ :,- C 4 b" =( - 1^3 @$ E&" %)$" -" ( 3 1 >]D _ +O * C-$`@ ? T" *E" (* c N 8S %&u¯%&%&- *" . /- G%*6Cj) - #"" (" W 4 ( @ > 1= * 02 %J " = &" -#" 027 + b=" &8VNN *$%&*$$ 1 E XZ &%" Eq 8 m3'V" (* [ & 4 1 G4*+
5.2 Accuracy of the Predictions
0 0
500
1000
1500
2000
on-disk
&
1
3000
*e # ,.' /01) 2+ + %$ '7+ 3:7@ Z q
3 N*# )'7 b+ '7 '/ Z + '7.'7,. 5
2500
Q00
*4$b --%.Y(YA¯4]D4 b ?Q"$ & V &#" b=02" " (#" b =" \7"N ;K--U_4= - [ .=" & &¯"- $( *= "a Q" '( TQ=" (*02 ? U.I9- * &",=6b" -0 ¯ W 4*$ - &P *-%" - W f8^B ¯-"+ *3 :< b;=;?>7l=@ n3$(*q*=8^]_NN"P] (T \ U %1 & >-$ 4* N 1K E --|44 " (2W %? (G-]_-.7" ('1 A" ( Ul A o o-*o/ "D - %&$Z & *%& " ]T E ) - &$%$ * 1$
G&N$ 7 K-(9 " 76/7"O]_6d7" -(/\ *" (* &% ) & *-$". 5]_(* & & y$ 69 8 " .. uT" " (*N3 P-]_'-4*(*%4*"Y %.2" (/( %?Q(*"Y &#"" Dl( &c o ^]To H ¯Y%1 -6V & ; 1$]x B - l&a o 4o "ab8 *2 1]_ \(9 &6V U" " ((* ^ P14*]T4 ¯Y --44
Z
k
Z
k
Z
Z
Z
Z
k
k
Q &8P ?$o - p l-A k-La -r - ;$ j & &m-`o Al1m n m-o-Lao A-n--j \n "$.- j #mKl- A mo o $: ±-%& q A#"q2[p o8 l1 .j V *+, *$` " ( N:< &;= ;x>F@ 4 1o% X| o j 3 p-:<j ;=A ;x>F@ C D<E >7@n9A o |l1o-r 2j n p r-r l1r A m-n-r &l q | n l G N & 4 1 X 3 :F@ jA j l A o j m j j A r-o2m n-%j | r k n G N:< &;= ;x>F@ 4 1o% X| o j 3 p-:<j ;=A ;xG>F@ C D<E >7@q A l= l=k mA o2k9l j2kA n=q q p2m | p-o r G :F@ %o | o j p-j A G C D<E >7@ l= DD**" " --vv 33:7@@ j nAA G :F@@ o o || o o j-j-p p j2j2 p-n qk m-m-ooll r r AA kko2o2mm r%r%|| q q 22nn G l1p D*" -v 3 :7@ q*A G :F@ o | o j-p j2 m-ol r A ko2m r%| q 2n k
Z
Z
Z
Z
Z
Z
a k
Z
k
a
Z
Z
_
k
Z
Z
_
k
Z
Z
X 9!
'7 1)
a
k
_
Z
Z
a
k
)(
_
2) '7
0] ,.* 1
5 '+
" %(** C" -*v4-44* 4*Q "$2 &%? C(fA 1]T=T V4 ?- \- 1 3 )(* =*]d ]T &" (" [( Q4 4* & *$4%" 7" \ *D" G *" (*
-** "37'K -b7*6} 7 '#" $ * *=" 1". 58 4R}- Y 8P &#"uT$ (* U%" 1- >" NC(" (* V T &'-_" - -z4 [ * &" c &%?$(*C 'I918 &P]_(%?( 4*-Q".- &2$ D"N fa"-AT (]T < T >C.-*-$ HP`mo o@ n9^ 1l aQ 1" B(*4 -- * K-%& %& &$$ Q] *T -tNpAa R5r &l-8 [ "C-8 i j j=sW4* 1 %" " -( 9]W"P'.- V/l&q[V$44 7"_ & *]_ & *V$- E&A2%&J %& &|$$ 1 c8".:,$ d"_" (* EuW e $V uT -V7 N"O6ePq p-oo *=%& %&". & $$ _$ &"11 EAz02 ?]D]_. 3- B( Q14 02 [ 1 Q %?76@(* " 1 &l& G 9j/"? &$4?02A2 &$ G7U"[ &" *(* Q 4 &1- *8;$ uT-"^ (]_3 ?( t ?' V G Ac" (]T4 C- ?--' &*-T ". 3=
" r &(A p--q*$"B l[4 b4-' - TD " N=( WP(Q"% (* 1 U( ? &b 9 "C-%1[--* 4 $ U " )" (*( /- V%&4*4%& - &$-$ * \&%%1" -4 -%%& &7$("O-6 &T`\' Q TK 1b * & ? & ]W_6[-'K c Q*A-" 7®V(*"$' &-7`-Q - *%& ; $%& ? $( $ & 9-" " -&8#+&8 9.i7l?sZcREFERENCES Z &8N &%%." ( 0 7$"O696 ?1 A* #" Q%&%& &$ " (! 'V 4¦ - 9 " £-Q1©-B -*4*a ` 1 1%]_"U" 1( 4 A" ( ¯¯"%&%& &($ B$ &°\ #"Ka-;-4(4 - 2(*+, *%?(;" &( *=$"¯- $ =V". *8 W" %?(* I9 V(-W" ( UK 1]_ *"O ]T$ -- _Ac- = .- 9" & &TK- * #" ¦§2 ¨ %?-N" 0-- ¡*. &¦,&8?:, A 4 $£1 &Vn -p-r #n k-¡VAfn-ª o-ao £-o 8 ?' ª¥?;£O© i7l&os[L¯)-¦K8 D %&.&% ¦ #b ¥-- t - 8 La-¦§= " ¨. && 8 D £-*1`"18$ N1 / %.-(Y484 uz 1 & *%.(b *=%1" --f / N 4--$ 1$"V n *q A ". i j j=s; [eD- Z 8L^R}76* Q $:#Nuy 1-4 A ®[ > O8 4+ & %8$"NKZ-®U%? (*eBb & -` * A%&eP \ ZX /#" Zc * 8 *6bD8' --l&"$Qq "1$l=8?{AVI9 % " -7 "O 96" +§ 7$ ".;1" l& 02%.2 ( k98 ¦K " ( *¦ W >£1(© a £-( - +, *,? ? &¡ $Y-- t9- f$4 -¦§%& &&8. -:O ? A $4 £1. $ &-'9-[£#© i j-qs Nl1-8 q ; n8o2" Rhm(*Aa(l&7_" ;--r -8 / >4 ; $8'2 -b Y-8 *Z %& 8*:O 7"O $6
.>
@
j
>
e>
.>
j
?>
>
e>
e>
>
.>
>
e>
>
E@
j
>
>
e>
e>
>
>
N>
j
>
@
>
