r AWS
...
-
/
1
2
;}:;..1C
(
lrn.o the Right Honourable the Lords of Council an l Seffeon, T
H
'
7 ;
('4~
,t,L,
/~ r/4-ug. S· i.. e~1{c11ce l1a,ri11gbee 11gi, er1 i11 fo r· tl1c ·)u1·fi1e1·,'' '"I~l1e Lo 1·cl 01 di 61 1 · ' ' 11(1.1 ~.., allo,vecl tl1e pt 11..f11e 1 to p10-ve p, ·oz ,t de jz,1e the fac iet fortl1 '' i11 111 co 11cleice11cle11ce, a11d all fatl:s a11cl ciI·ct1mfla11ces 1..elat i e ' ' tl1er·eto , a n cl g 1·a1: 1ted co1nrniJl1011.'' The clefe11cle1·s r·epr·eJen tccl ~1rrai1 !t tl1is i11ter·locl1to1-; btlt th e I. })refbte n1per ·e,.l t11e n 1a 11y 01·fle1·s ao-ai11!1 th 111 t o d ep o 11e a 11c.i e '"l1ibit )aper ·s~ l1e ,vas ob lige d to cal l tl1 e 111 as l1aver·s. Afte1 .. n111cl1 dela) t!11~c/? of t l1e 111 appea r·ecl, but Dol1g(1lEltl:011flicl not ar)pea1,.; a11 d after· fit'ft a11cl fecor 1d di lige11ces ,,,.er·e ect 1te 1 aga i11fr l1im , all tl1e le11gtl1 I1e 11t.11·Ll r· c011ld get lu n1 '\ ' aS to clepo 11e and ex 11ibit in J111y r I 76 3 ; l1c t11e11p1..oclucecl fL1nd1.._ p ape1's , a 11clcle11011ecl, t l1at l1e l1ad ie11t f'"..,-r.:al otl1 r·s, 011ce1~ni11 g tl1is qt1ellion to iVl1 · Jo l111 l'Go, \--nl1is age1 1t, i11 , , l1ole l1a11ds th ey '"'011ld frill b e. .t\ ccorclii1glJ -, a11 0rde1· '''l 111a le 01 1 111· 1 Go,v 11, as bei11. g ag nt i 11 t l1e C"11le, t0 11--oclt1ce tl1c 11a111· i11 I1is l1a11d ; bt 1t alth ot1g l1 tl1e Lo1·cl Ordi11ar·y 1· 11e,:\ecl ii ....or·cle ·s 011 l 1i111 t o tl1is p t11·pofe, the 1r 11e · 1· ver· 0 11J liecl , , , it]1 , 1 a n d at 1..!l, t l1e pet it io11e1--,i\ras obl igecl t0 obtct:n a c ilige11 e for citi11g l1i111, ,,rl1icl1l1ad t l1e effetf of gattin g l1i111 ~o 1nake a11ex, 1ibitio!1, b 11t n(> earlie1· tl1~111 rl1e I 11::of 1~1·J:1I 76 . E,·e1·y acco1111 t a11d doct1 1ne11t 111·oclt1cecJ, affot·c...eclaf~t ]1e cla., ,,,11t1 ' tl 1c clcp o 1e11t , ot1t of tl1e 111011c l1c got 0 1· tl e Co1111,ai1..j11 tl1e ' n1 a1·l-et, •
4
4
,re,
1
1
1
7
1
1
•
•
'
-
[
I
3
]
•
n1arket, gave Ja1nes Findlay L. r 5 Sterling, to co1nplete or 1nal· _ '' eut tl1e p1..ice tl1ereof; bt1t tl1e depo11cnt had not accefs to lcno,, r ~, 110,v or in ,vl1at 111~1ne1 .. J;ie 1·eceived tl1c re111ainclc1.. of tl1e IJt~icc, • I-Iacl tl1e arti le bee11 tl1e1~e fiated, tl1e pre.£:1 t di JJ1Jte coulc.l not l1a-,7ee"' i{l:ecl. Bt1t 1r \~7ot l1er·fpoon, "\Vho 1nade 11p tl1efe accon1pts, a11cl ,,·110 l1ad l1een i11t1..t1fl:ccl ,,,itl1.tl1e voucl1ers, '"''as tl1e 11e1 ..io11 to bla111e i11 01nitti 11g tl1i a1..ticle ; and ) 0l1 r· Lord{}1ips ]1a, e 111·oof1Jof1ti~le, tl1at tl1c l etitio11e1· co111plained of tl1e 01ni.1fio11, £01--,i\ l1icl1 1·eafo tl1c dotJt1et of tl1e accon11Jt I 743, ,, as fo fi·am d a t 1 efe1· e l1is cl~i111 l111der· it. H l1as now liquidated lie conclitio 1 of tl1e do1 i11 g ,,~ t1et b y fl:10,, l1at h e IJai d ; a11d the acco 1no:., tl1emfcl \Tes ilio,v ~ ~ tl1at 110 }Jar·t tl1e1·eof l1as ye'- bee11 allo,ved. He l1as arq t1i fc d in L. r 5 b ing takcR off hin1, though pro, ed only by the oath of one of tJ1e de.fe11cler,,,b11t tl1ey l1av;e not fo mt1cl1 as atte111rJted a 1 - e, ide11ce of a fu1·tl1e1~defalcatio1 1. It i:a 0111 y to be aclclecl on t1;iisl1eacl, tl1at neith e1.. of tl1 e acco1J1pts :\\ er·e t111det·frood to be fi11al fettlen1 tlt - · Tl1e cloq 11 t f" tl1 m 01 0,•r t11is; c:111d~1r· Sti1--lir1gof 1·aig bar·11et on~ of tl1 cl te11der·s clepo·1=s , '' Tl1at l1e docs 11ot 1·em e 1111 1· of' an~ fi11al l a1 a11c 1111, 011 Ll1e ft1bje St of tl1c co-par·t11er·) .'' Indeecl ,, l:iat a111ol 111t to proof p0fit iYe of this is, that no acco1npt ha s ever y t been ; iYcn o f th,= profit and lofs on the concern; no acco n1pt v1 a ren !cre el of :the pri arifing fron1 the mark.et -place "lllch had be n built at th e CollljJa 1 ' cxpc11c a11cl fold a11J 11-0ileiiecl b) r t,, ro of tl1 Ill ,~iz. I) )lt"""\aldflo11a11d ..r0111 1 Bt1chanan ai~te1 .. tl1e Co111fan .. '\ as di ol ed as a1)1)ears l, ..1 B1lcl1a1 a11's oatl1 · a11d a var·iet) 7 ot o::l1cr a1·tic1 ill r· ~111 ,:\i11ecl t111fe tled . Tl1e1·e is i11deed 110 gc11eI·al ~ ttlern t t a all· 1101 .. t·1·01na11y ,lccon1i)t y t f110,, r11 a11 it be k1 o\,'11 \\ h etl1 r rl1 1·e \\'e .:·e 11ot co11fi le1·al)le p1·ofits 011 the co11c 1·11. 5 to, '"f l1e clefencler·s iay it is i n1 p1·obable.. tl1·a tl1e })tJ 1·fi.1e1· aftP · l"!ai11g 1)aicJL . I oo for t]1e Co111pa11yat Ca11clle111a s .., ould ha, e go11e 01 1 0
1
•
1
1
•
•
\1 I
I
t
I
L
t
'I
I
I'
Ii
'
J I I I
'
'
I
.. \ '
'
'
\.J
1
0
\
l
\' I
) ' '
..
,
1Ja) 111e11ts to a g1·eater a11101111t \ irhot1t 1.. t ?_i11111cr , ] a l1e Co1n a1 1:1 o·\,recl l1i1n. Et1t he1·e again tl1e defe11d r · at·e l"'l aiecl \ ilft1ll)1 o 1nifl111de 1..ftand tl1e 11atuI·e o · tl1e }J ti io11e1· 1..a 1:.ac io11s.
111,'"l{i11g t1tl1e 1·
1
1
I-I •
r
I
7
]
e ,,,as f 011 ti111e to time 1·ec ·, i11g 111011cy belo 1~in 6 to tl1e Co11}Ja11y 011 the 011e ha 11d, an cl 1Ja1 i11g ot1t n101 1e)' for t11e1n on tl1e o he1·, ,, ,her· lJv llt 0 11 the ,vl1ole l1e b ecan e i1 acl, a 1pe fo rt e ,:,Jn1pa 11y bu l., to ,,,hat amot1t1t l1e could i10t £~1· llI 1 til his 1 a1·ti"t1la1 .. cco 1npts ,,ve1·e fettled, ,vhich did IJot ha1 1)ei1 till the 1Jcr·i s 11. · ~l- f · c fi~o111tl1e clilige 11c i11 }Jr·oceis. It is in 1 n1 ofccl to l1a,, pllt tl1is 111 0 11c ! r i11to tl e J1,i11cls of.. tJ1e 1Jetitio n c1·, is flill al;, -e ; a11cl of all otl1 1..s, l1e j ~ tl 1c 11°I·ion ,,~I.loin tl1e 11ctitio11e1·0 11gl1t to 11ave b e e11 1110ft nfi..aicl of, l1acl ]1c t) ee 11 c011 iciou of not l1ei ng f o1111declj 11 l1is actio11 . '"]l1e a o -c irate of" tl1e 11r· oceecli11gs ,, ill ab 111 1cla11tly 010,,r, to ,, l1at 11a1·t tl e tlcla, ;s l1a,'"e l)ec11o,,,i11gfi11ce tl1c a io11 ,, as r·aifed. L ~Jll)', It ,, 1 as faicl, TI1at tl1e 1)etitioner· l1acl clec1i11ecln11f,, e1·i110 · tl1 L o 1..cl' 1~cJi11a1·y's l1 ll flio 11c;: .fi1jl, Ho,,r 111a11) 1" of tl1e Ci .. i~ 1cl ali, 1 e a11cl l,o,,r 111a11 , fla1:10-l1t r·c l i11 tl1e n1~11..kct? _d/",, o v, l1e ca111e to d e111a11dthe ,, 1101 11·ic "''] 1e 11 11ar·t of,. it a11pca1·s to 112, c l)ee 11 11aicl. a11cl, 3dly, Iio,'r-.' 111l1cl1 of"tl1c 1J1·ice ,,,as }J,1icl, a11cl 110,, 111t1ch 1·e 111a i11c cl (l 1e? It , -ill ocr 11"to 3To11r I.01 (lf11i11~, tl'lat the d efe11clc1·s a1·e 11e1e 111i~ j 11g t \,~a i1j.tci· o c·1to r·s ; tl1e fi1·fi: of· ,, l1icl1 co11tai11~(1 a 11 o t·d 1· 11 0 11 th e pe ti tione 1· to ar f v 1· t ,,. l}t1e it1 0 11s ,, 1-\·
-
/
1
2
;}:;..1C
(
lrn.o the Right Honourable the Lords of Council an l Seffeon, T
H
'
7 ;
('4~
,t,L,
/~ r/4-ug. S· i.. e~1{c11ce l1a,ri11gbee 11gi, er1 i11 fo r· tl1c ·)u1·fi1e1·,'' '"I~l1e Lo 1·cl 01 di 61 1 · ' ' 11(1.1 ~.., allo,vecl tl1e pt 11..f11e 1 to p10-ve p, ·oz ,t de jz,1e the fac iet fortl1 '' i11 111 co 11cleice11cle11ce, a11d all fatl:s a11cl ciI·ct1mfla11ces 1..elat i e ' ' tl1er·eto , a n cl g 1·a1: 1ted co1nrniJl1011.'' The clefe11cle1·s r·epr·eJen tccl ~1rrai1 !t tl1is i11ter·locl1to1-; btlt th e I. })refbte n1per ·e,.l t11e n 1a 11y 01·fle1·s ao-ai11!1 th 111 t o d ep o 11e a 11c.i e '"l1ibit )aper ·s~ l1e ,vas ob lige d to cal l tl1 e 111 as l1aver·s. Afte1 .. n111cl1 dela) t!11~c/? of t l1e 111 appea r·ecl, but Dol1g(1lEltl:011flicl not ar)pea1,.; a11 d after· fit'ft a11cl fecor 1d di lige11ces ,,,.er·e ect 1te 1 aga i11fr l1im , all tl1e le11gtl1 I1e 11t.11·Ll r· c011ld get lu n1 '\ ' aS to clepo 11e and ex 11ibit in J111y r I 76 3 ; l1c t11e11p1..oclucecl fL1nd1.._ p ape1's , a 11clcle11011ecl, t l1at l1e l1ad ie11t f'"..,-r.:al otl1 r·s, 011ce1~ni11 g tl1is qt1ellion to iVl1 · Jo l111 l'Go, \--nl1is age1 1t, i11 , , l1ole l1a11ds th ey '"'011ld frill b e. .t\ ccorclii1glJ -, a11 0rde1· '''l 111a le 01 1 111· 1 Go,v 11, as bei11. g ag nt i 11 t l1e C"11le, t0 11--oclt1ce tl1c 11a111· i11 I1is l1a11d ; bt 1t alth ot1g l1 tl1e Lo1·cl Ordi11ar·y 1· 11e,:\ecl ii ....or·cle ·s 011 l 1i111 t o tl1is p t11·pofe, the 1r 11e · 1· ver· 0 11J liecl , , , it]1 , 1 a n d at 1..!l, t l1e pet it io11e1--,i\ras obl igecl t0 obtct:n a c ilige11 e for citi11g l1i111, ,,rl1icl1l1ad t l1e effetf of gattin g l1i111 ~o 1nake a11ex, 1ibitio!1, b 11t n(> earlie1· tl1~111 rl1e I 11::of 1~1·J:1I 76 . E,·e1·y acco1111 t a11d doct1 1ne11t 111·oclt1cecJ, affot·c...eclaf~t ]1e cla., ,,,11t1 ' tl 1c clcp o 1e11t , ot1t of tl1e 111011c l1c got 0 1· tl e Co1111,ai1..j11 tl1e ' n1 a1·l-et, •
4
4
,re,
1
1
1
7
1
1
•
•
'
-
[
I
3
]
•
n1arket, gave Ja1nes Findlay L. r 5 Sterling, to co1nplete or 1nal· _ '' eut tl1e p1..ice tl1ereof; bt1t tl1e depo11cnt had not accefs to lcno,, r ~, 110,v or in ,vl1at 111~1ne1 .. J;ie 1·eceived tl1c re111ainclc1.. of tl1e IJt~icc, • I-Iacl tl1e arti le bee11 tl1e1~e fiated, tl1e pre.£:1 t di JJ1Jte coulc.l not l1a-,7ee"' i{l:ecl. Bt1t 1r \~7ot l1er·fpoon, "\Vho 1nade 11p tl1efe accon1pts, a11cl ,,·110 l1ad l1een i11t1..t1fl:ccl ,,,itl1.tl1e voucl1ers, '"''as tl1e 11e1 ..io11 to bla111e i11 01nitti 11g tl1i a1..ticle ; and ) 0l1 r· Lord{}1ips ]1a, e 111·oof1Jof1ti~le, tl1at tl1c l etitio11e1· co111plained of tl1e 01ni.1fio11, £01--,i\ l1icl1 1·eafo tl1c dotJt1et of tl1e accon11Jt I 743, ,, as fo fi·am d a t 1 efe1· e l1is cl~i111 l111der· it. H l1as now liquidated lie conclitio 1 of tl1e do1 i11 g ,,~ t1et b y fl:10,, l1at h e IJai d ; a11d the acco 1no:., tl1emfcl \Tes ilio,v ~ ~ tl1at 110 }Jar·t tl1e1·eof l1as ye'- bee11 allo,ved. He l1as arq t1i fc d in L. r 5 b ing takcR off hin1, though pro, ed only by the oath of one of tJ1e de.fe11cler,,,b11t tl1ey l1av;e not fo mt1cl1 as atte111rJted a 1 - e, ide11ce of a fu1·tl1e1~defalcatio1 1. It i:a 0111 y to be aclclecl on t1;iisl1eacl, tl1at neith e1.. of tl1 e acco1J1pts :\\ er·e t111det·frood to be fi11al fettlen1 tlt - · Tl1e cloq 11 t f" tl1 m 01 0,•r t11is; c:111d~1r· Sti1--lir1gof 1·aig bar·11et on~ of tl1 cl te11der·s clepo·1=s , '' Tl1at l1e docs 11ot 1·em e 1111 1· of' an~ fi11al l a1 a11c 1111, 011 Ll1e ft1bje St of tl1c co-par·t11er·) .'' Indeecl ,, l:iat a111ol 111t to proof p0fit iYe of this is, that no acco1npt ha s ever y t been ; iYcn o f th,= profit and lofs on the concern; no acco n1pt v1 a ren !cre el of :the pri arifing fron1 the mark.et -place "lllch had be n built at th e CollljJa 1 ' cxpc11c a11cl fold a11J 11-0ileiiecl b) r t,, ro of tl1 Ill ,~iz. I) )lt"""\aldflo11a11d ..r0111 1 Bt1chanan ai~te1 .. tl1e Co111fan .. '\ as di ol ed as a1)1)ears l, ..1 B1lcl1a1 a11's oatl1 · a11d a var·iet) 7 ot o::l1cr a1·tic1 ill r· ~111 ,:\i11ecl t111fe tled . Tl1e1·e is i11deed 110 gc11eI·al ~ ttlern t t a all· 1101 .. t·1·01na11y ,lccon1i)t y t f110,, r11 a11 it be k1 o\,'11 \\ h etl1 r rl1 1·e \\'e .:·e 11ot co11fi le1·al)le p1·ofits 011 the co11c 1·11. 5 to, '"f l1e clefencler·s iay it is i n1 p1·obable.. tl1·a tl1e })tJ 1·fi.1e1· aftP · l"!ai11g 1)aicJL . I oo for t]1e Co111pa11yat Ca11clle111a s .., ould ha, e go11e 01 1 0
1
•
1
1
•
•
\1 I
I
t
I
L
t
'I
I
I'
Ii
'
J I I I
'
'
I
.. \ '
'
'
\.J
1
0
\
l
\' I
) ' '
..
,
1Ja) 111e11ts to a g1·eater a11101111t \ irhot1t 1.. t ?_i11111cr , ] a l1e Co1n a1 1:1 o·\,recl l1i1n. Et1t he1·e again tl1e defe11d r · at·e l"'l aiecl \ ilft1ll)1 o 1nifl111de 1..ftand tl1e 11atuI·e o · tl1e }J ti io11e1· 1..a 1:.ac io11s.
111,'"l{i11g t1tl1e 1·
1
1
I-I •
r
I
7
]
e ,,,as f 011 ti111e to time 1·ec ·, i11g 111011cy belo 1~in 6 to tl1e Co11}Ja11y 011 the 011e ha 11d, an cl 1Ja1 i11g ot1t n101 1e)' for t11e1n on tl1e o he1·, ,, ,her· lJv llt 0 11 the ,vl1ole l1e b ecan e i1 acl, a 1pe fo rt e ,:,Jn1pa 11y bu l., to ,,,hat amot1t1t l1e could i10t £~1· llI 1 til his 1 a1·ti"t1la1 .. cco 1npts ,,ve1·e fettled, ,vhich did IJot ha1 1)ei1 till the 1Jcr·i s 11. · ~l- f · c fi~o111tl1e clilige 11c i11 }Jr·oceis. It is in 1 n1 ofccl to l1a,, pllt tl1is 111 0 11c ! r i11to tl e J1,i11cls of.. tJ1e 1Jetitio n c1·, is flill al;, -e ; a11cl of all otl1 1..s, l1e j ~ tl 1c 11°I·ion ,,~I.loin tl1e 11ctitio11e1·0 11gl1t to 11ave b e e11 1110ft nfi..aicl of, l1acl ]1c t) ee 11 c011 iciou of not l1ei ng f o1111declj 11 l1is actio11 . '"]l1e a o -c irate of" tl1e 11r· oceecli11gs ,, ill ab 111 1cla11tly 010,,r, to ,, l1at 11a1·t tl e tlcla, ;s l1a,'"e l)ec11o,,,i11gfi11ce tl1c a io11 ,, as r·aifed. L ~Jll)', It ,, 1 as faicl, TI1at tl1e 1)etitioner· l1acl clec1i11ecln11f,, e1·i110 · tl1 L o 1..cl' 1~cJi11a1·y's l1 ll flio 11c;: .fi1jl, Ho,,r 111a11) 1" of tl1e Ci .. i~ 1cl ali, 1 e a11cl l,o,,r 111a11 , fla1:10-l1t r·c l i11 tl1e n1~11..kct? _d/",, o v, l1e ca111e to d e111a11dthe ,, 1101 11·ic "''] 1e 11 11ar·t of,. it a11pca1·s to 112, c l)ee 11 11aicl. a11cl, 3dly, Iio,'r-.' 111l1cl1 of"tl1c 1J1·ice ,,,as }J,1icl, a11cl 110,, 111t1ch 1·e 111a i11c cl (l 1e? It , -ill ocr 11"to 3To11r I.01 (lf11i11~, tl'lat the d efe11clc1·s a1·e 11e1e 111i~ j 11g t \,~a i1j.tci· o c·1to r·s ; tl1e fi1·fi: of· ,, l1icl1 co11tai11~(1 a 11 o t·d 1· 11 0 11 th e pe ti tione 1· to ar f v 1· t ,,. l}t1e it1 0 11s ,, 1-\·
