Workshop Agenda
New England Fishery Management Council 50 WATER STREET
|
NEWBURYPORT, MASSACHUSETTS 01950
|
PHONE 978 465 0492
John F. Quinn, J.D., Ph.D., Chairman | Thomas A. Nies, Executive Director
|
FAX 978 465 3116
AGENDA 2ND WORKSHOP ON ATLANTIC HERRING ACCEPTABLE BIOLOGICAL CATCH CONTROL RULE MANAGEMENT STRATEGY EVALUATION DECEMBER 7-8, 2016 Sheraton Harborside Hotel 250 Market Street Portsmouth, NH 03801 Telephone: 603-431-2300
Wednesday December 7, Day 1 8:00 AM 9:00
9:25
10:30 10:50 11:20
12:00 PM 1:00
3:00
Grand Ballroom doors open (coffee, check-in, obtain folder and nametag) Opening remarks Council Chairman’s welcome – John Quinn Presentation: MSE introduction – Brian Irwin (Doc #4A) Presentation: MSE process overview – Rachel Feeney (Doc #4B) Setting the workshop’s stage – Brian Irwin MSE methods Session 1 – explaining models Presentation: Herring operating models and control rules – Jon Deroba (Doc #4C) Presentation: Predator models – Sarah Gaichas (Doc #4D) (with time to answer clarifying questions and identify discussion questions) Break MSE methods Session 2 – understanding models Large group discussion of identified questions – Brian Irwin MSE methods Session 3 – explaining and understanding output metrics Presentation: Herring output metrics – Jon Deroba (Doc #4E) Presentation: Predator output metrics – Sarah Gaichas (Doc #4F) Presentation: Economic output metrics – Min-Yang Lee (Doc #4G) (with time to answer clarifying questions, open discussion at end) Lunch on your own MSE results - using metrics and models to generate a range of performance Presentation: Herring metrics and models – Jon Deroba (Doc #4H) Presentation: Introduction to tradeoff – Jon Deroba (Doc #4I) (with time to answer clarifying questions, open discussion at end) Charge to small groups – Brian Irwin Break
3:10
Small group discussions - identify/refine range of acceptable performance Group A – Madeleine Hall-Arber Group B – Jessica Joyce Group C – Laura Singer
4:30
Closing remarks Recap Day 1; overnight tasks; Day 2 goals – Brian Irwin Adjourn (facilitators/staff consolidate discussion outcomes; analysts conduct additional work)
4:40
Thursday December 8, Day 2 8:30 AM 9:00 9:15 9:30
11:00 11:10
12:30 PM 2:00 2:45
3:45
4:15
Prescott Room doors open (coffee and check-in) Opening remarks Review Day 1; charge for Day 2 – Brian Irwin Report out from Day 1 small group discussions One consolidated summary – facilitator/staff TBD Identify/refine control rules Session 1 – exploring the possibilities Presentation: Meeting the range of performance identified – Jon Deroba (with time to answer clarifying questions, open discussion at end) Charge to small groups – Brian Irwin Break Identify/refine control rules Session 2 - small group discussions Group A – Madeleine Hall-Arber, Prescott Room Group B – Jessica Joyce, Amphitheater Group C - Laura Singer, Prescott Room Lunch on your own (facilitators/staff consolidate discussion outcomes) Identify/refine control rules Session 3 – finalizing workshop input Small groups report out, one consolidated summary – facilitator/staff TBD Large group Confirm range of control rules – Brian Irwin Refining thediscussion: Atlantic herring MSE Presentation: Broader performance of control rules identified – Jon Deroba o Revisit all metrics after control rules are narrowed down o Revisit robustness to operating models of narrowed range of control rules Large group discussion – Brian Irwin o MSE process to ensure understanding o Additional input before the MSE is finished o Ideas for research that may improve future MSEs or reduce uncertainty Closing remarks Additional work – Jon Deroba o Confirm ideas for any additional work before finishing the MSE o Identify what could be accomplished within the next few days/weeks Review timeline/next steps – Rachel Feeney Recap workshop/conclude – Brian Irwin Adjourn (turn in evaluation forms)
|
NEWBURYPORT, MASSACHUSETTS 01950
|
PHONE 978 465 0492
John F. Quinn, J.D., Ph.D., Chairman | Thomas A. Nies, Executive Director
|
FAX 978 465 3116
AGENDA 2ND WORKSHOP ON ATLANTIC HERRING ACCEPTABLE BIOLOGICAL CATCH CONTROL RULE MANAGEMENT STRATEGY EVALUATION DECEMBER 7-8, 2016 Sheraton Harborside Hotel 250 Market Street Portsmouth, NH 03801 Telephone: 603-431-2300
Wednesday December 7, Day 1 8:00 AM 9:00
9:25
10:30 10:50 11:20
12:00 PM 1:00
3:00
Grand Ballroom doors open (coffee, check-in, obtain folder and nametag) Opening remarks Council Chairman’s welcome – John Quinn Presentation: MSE introduction – Brian Irwin (Doc #4A) Presentation: MSE process overview – Rachel Feeney (Doc #4B) Setting the workshop’s stage – Brian Irwin MSE methods Session 1 – explaining models Presentation: Herring operating models and control rules – Jon Deroba (Doc #4C) Presentation: Predator models – Sarah Gaichas (Doc #4D) (with time to answer clarifying questions and identify discussion questions) Break MSE methods Session 2 – understanding models Large group discussion of identified questions – Brian Irwin MSE methods Session 3 – explaining and understanding output metrics Presentation: Herring output metrics – Jon Deroba (Doc #4E) Presentation: Predator output metrics – Sarah Gaichas (Doc #4F) Presentation: Economic output metrics – Min-Yang Lee (Doc #4G) (with time to answer clarifying questions, open discussion at end) Lunch on your own MSE results - using metrics and models to generate a range of performance Presentation: Herring metrics and models – Jon Deroba (Doc #4H) Presentation: Introduction to tradeoff – Jon Deroba (Doc #4I) (with time to answer clarifying questions, open discussion at end) Charge to small groups – Brian Irwin Break
3:10
Small group discussions - identify/refine range of acceptable performance Group A – Madeleine Hall-Arber Group B – Jessica Joyce Group C – Laura Singer
4:30
Closing remarks Recap Day 1; overnight tasks; Day 2 goals – Brian Irwin Adjourn (facilitators/staff consolidate discussion outcomes; analysts conduct additional work)
4:40
Thursday December 8, Day 2 8:30 AM 9:00 9:15 9:30
11:00 11:10
12:30 PM 2:00 2:45
3:45
4:15
Prescott Room doors open (coffee and check-in) Opening remarks Review Day 1; charge for Day 2 – Brian Irwin Report out from Day 1 small group discussions One consolidated summary – facilitator/staff TBD Identify/refine control rules Session 1 – exploring the possibilities Presentation: Meeting the range of performance identified – Jon Deroba (with time to answer clarifying questions, open discussion at end) Charge to small groups – Brian Irwin Break Identify/refine control rules Session 2 - small group discussions Group A – Madeleine Hall-Arber, Prescott Room Group B – Jessica Joyce, Amphitheater Group C - Laura Singer, Prescott Room Lunch on your own (facilitators/staff consolidate discussion outcomes) Identify/refine control rules Session 3 – finalizing workshop input Small groups report out, one consolidated summary – facilitator/staff TBD Large group Confirm range of control rules – Brian Irwin Refining thediscussion: Atlantic herring MSE Presentation: Broader performance of control rules identified – Jon Deroba o Revisit all metrics after control rules are narrowed down o Revisit robustness to operating models of narrowed range of control rules Large group discussion – Brian Irwin o MSE process to ensure understanding o Additional input before the MSE is finished o Ideas for research that may improve future MSEs or reduce uncertainty Closing remarks Additional work – Jon Deroba o Confirm ideas for any additional work before finishing the MSE o Identify what could be accomplished within the next few days/weeks Review timeline/next steps – Rachel Feeney Recap workshop/conclude – Brian Irwin Adjourn (turn in evaluation forms)
