Close Reading Annotation Tools Bookmarks, Logs, Poster Bubbles, Task Cards, and Response Sheets
ELA Seminars, LLC © 2015 All Rights Reserved
Product Components Coded Annotation Bookmarks Annotation Log 8 Claim It. Prove It. Simplify It. Short Constructed Response Sheets
19 Reading Response Poster Bubbles with Striped Wall Display Letters 19 Task Cards (color and black and white versions)
8 Literacy Center Title Cards Notebook Reference Card: Core-Aligned Reading Response Stems 4 Reference Sheets Bonus: Close Reading-at-a-Glance Cheat Sheets
Definitions of Close Reading Close reading is the interactive, purposeful annotation of complex text. Kelly Gallagher (author of Readicide)
Close, analytic reading entails the careful gathering of observations about a text and careful consideration about what those observations taken together add up to. Partnership for Assessment of Readiness for College and Career Readiness
A close reading is a careful and purposeful reading. Well actually, it’s rereading. Dr. Douglas Fisher (ASCD Author)
Close Reading vs. Critical Reading What Does Close Reading Look Like? Students… …read short, challenging passages. …reread with a pen. …dive into text with limited or no prereading activities. …discuss impressions and personal observations of the text with others. …respond to text-dependent questions when rereading.
What Does Critical Reading Look Like? Students… ...preview text and build background. …evaluate the logic of the text. …summarize and outline. …compare and contrast. …respond to multi-level questions.
Annotation Helps Struggling and Proficient Readers For Struggling Readers: Annotation helps students focus while reading. For Proficient Readers: Annotation provides a framework for text analysis and discussions.
Annotation Basics 1) Teach the most important annotation strategies one at a time. 2) Annotation must be done during independent reading – not after. 3) Simple is better. A few thoughtful annotations work best. 4) Train students to annotate with a goal in mind (e.g. to compare/contrast, discuss, summarize, paraphrase, answer a prompt).
How to Use Annotation Code Cards:
1. Copy the annotation code cards on cardstock. 2. Cut and use as a reference while reading novels textbooks, articles, and short stories.
Annotation Log
1. Record two or three annotations for each assignment. 2. Submit completed logs, or use the log to facilitate class discussions.
Claim It. Prove It. Simplify It.
Note Taking & Short Response Sheets
Directions: Before Reading: Fold the paper along the dotted line and fill in the name and task lines found on the left side of the paper.
While Reading: Use the lined side of the paper to take notes.
After Reading: 1. Complete the Short Response Framework Stems. 2. Make sure the PROVE IT examples support the claim. 3. Include one of three reflections in the SIMPLIFY It section: a) What you thought or learned b) What you think a real or fictional character thought or learned c) What the writer wanted you to think or learn
Fold here. While Reading After Reading Note Taking Side Responding Side (e.g. interesting phrases)
List Phrases
( Claim It. Prove It. Simplify It.)
Complete Stems.
ELA Seminars, LLC © Copyright 2015. All Rights Reserved
SAMPLE
SHORT RESPONSE FRAMEWORK CLAIM IT. (1 point) Three of the most interesting phrases from Roald Dahl’s description of Agatha Trunchbull include: 1) “bends iron bars,” 2) “massive thighs,” and 3) “arrogant eyes.”
List of Phrases AgathaTrunchbullDescription: 1. muscles clearly in evidence 2. massive thighs 3. bends iron bars 4. tears telephone books in half 5. had been a famous athlete 6. had a cruel mouth 7. thick arms
PROVE IT. (2 points) These phrases help readers understand that even though this character is human, she possesses characteristics typically used to describe a monster. The fact that she is capable of “bending iron bars” indicates that she is stronger than the average mortal and that trying to contain her would be pretty pointless. Her “massive thighs” and “arrogant eyes,” tell me that her mere presence is simply terrifying.
8. obstinate chin 9. arrogant eyes 10. bull neck
Name: Carolyn McManus Text: Matilda, Chapter 1 ELA Seminars, LLC © 2015 All Rights Reserved
SIMPLIFY IT. (1 point)
It is evident that Agatha Trunchbull will be a significant antagonist in this novel since the author spent four paragraphs describing every unlikeable thing about her.
SHORT RESPONSE FRAMEWORK
Star Sentence
CLAIM IT. (1 point) The most important sentence…
Important Sentences __________________________________________ __________________________________________ __________________________________________
PROVE IT. (2 points) One reason…
__________________________________________ __________________________________________ __________________________________________ __________________________________________ __________________________________________ __________________________________________ __________________________________________ __________________________________________ __________________________________________
SIMPLIFY IT. (1 point) Another…
__________________________________________ __________________________________________ Name: __________________________________ Text: ___________________________________ ELA Seminars, LLC © 2015 All Rights Reserved
SHORT RESPONSE FRAMEWORK CLAIM IT. (1 point) Three of the most interesting phrases from _____________________________include: 1) _________________________________,
List of Phrases
2) ______________________________ and
3) _________________________________.
__________________________________________ __________________________________________ __________________________________________
PROVE IT. (2 points)
__________________________________________
These phrases help readers _____________
__________________________________________
(e.g. visualize, feel, create, understand)….
__________________________________________ __________________________________________ __________________________________________ __________________________________________ __________________________________________ __________________________________________ __________________________________________ __________________________________________ Name: __________________________________ Text: ___________________________________ ELA Seminars, LLC © 2015 All Rights Reserved
SIMPLIFY IT. (1 point) It is…
SHORT RESPONSE FRAMEWORK
Key Words
CLAIM IT. (1 point) One word that played a key role in this text (or One word I decoded) is the word
Precise or Unknown Words __________________________________________ __________________________________________
________________________________.
PROVE IT. (2 points) I selected it because… (or I figured out its meaning by…)
__________________________________________ __________________________________________ __________________________________________ __________________________________________ __________________________________________ __________________________________________ __________________________________________ __________________________________________ __________________________________________ __________________________________________ __________________________________________ __________________________________________
SIMPLIFY IT. (1 point) Another word that could be substituted for this word is
Name: __________________________________ Text: ___________________________________ ELA Seminars, LLC © 2015 All Rights Reserved
__________________________________.
SHORT RESPONSE FRAMEWORK
Quotable Quotes
CLAIM IT. (1 point) The most important quotation …
Quotation Locations __________________________________________ __________________________________________ __________________________________________ __________________________________________
PROVE IT. (2 points) It is significant because…
__________________________________________ __________________________________________ __________________________________________ __________________________________________ __________________________________________ __________________________________________ __________________________________________ __________________________________________
SIMPLIFY IT. (1 point) __________________________________________ Name: __________________________________ Text: __________________________________ ELA Seminars, LLC © 2015 All Rights Reserved
Maybe… or Clearly,
SHORT RESPONSE FRAMEWORK CLAIM IT.(1 point) The first question…
Burning Questions __________________________________________ __________________________________________ __________________________________________
CLAIM IT. (2 points) The second…
__________________________________________ __________________________________________ __________________________________________ __________________________________________ __________________________________________ __________________________________________ __________________________________________ __________________________________________
SIMPLIFY IT. (1 point)
__________________________________________
One prediction (or thought)…
__________________________________________ Name: __________________________________ Text: ___________________________________ ELA Seminars, LLC © 2015 All Rights Reserved
SHORT RESPONSE FRAMEWORK
Craft Analysis
CLAIM IT. (1 point) An observation I made about the writing style of the author…
Craft Observations __________________________________________ __________________________________________ __________________________________________
__________________________________________
PROVE IT. (2 points) This is effective (or interesting) because…
__________________________________________ __________________________________________ __________________________________________ __________________________________________ __________________________________________ __________________________________________ __________________________________________ __________________________________________ ______________________________________ Name: __________________________________ Text: ___________________________________ ELA Seminars, LLC © 2015 All Rights Reserved
SIMPLIFY IT. (1 point) Another…
Random Thoughts
SHORT RESPONSE FRAMEWORK CLAIM IT. (1 point) While reading …
Random Thought Notation __________________________________________ __________________________________________ __________________________________________
PROVE IT.(2 points) Another…
__________________________________________ __________________________________________
__________________________________________ __________________________________________ __________________________________________ __________________________________________ __________________________________________
__________________________________________ __________________________________________ __________________________________________ __________________________________________ Name: __________________________________
Text: ___________________________________ ELA Seminars, LLC © 2015 All Rights Reserved
SIMPLIIFY IT. (1 point) Perhaps… or It seems…
SHORT RESPONSE FRAMEWORK
Favorite Parts
CLAIM IT. (1 point) One of the best…
List of Favorites __________________________________________ __________________________________________ __________________________________________
PROVE IT. (2 points) Another…
__________________________________________ __________________________________________ __________________________________________ __________________________________________ __________________________________________ __________________________________________ __________________________________________
__________________________________________ __________________________________________
SIMPLIFY IT. (1 point)
__________________________________________
It’s…
Name: __________________________________ Text: ___________________________________ ELA Seminars, LLC © 2015 All Rights Reserved
EXTENSION Copy lined paper on the back of Note Taking and Framework Response Cards. Then require essays to be written using the outline information on the Response Frameworks.
Response Stem Annotation
19 Reading Response Task Cards (Color and Black and White Versions)
19 Speech Bubble Prompt Posters with Display Letters 8 Color Title Display Posters 1 Core-Aligned Reference Sheet
Common Core Alignment for Reading Response Stems Key Ideas and Details (Standards 1-3) The most important… Some interesting phrases… Some interesting words… The evidence I found… The reason… One quotation…
Craft and Structure (Standards 4-6) The writer… I figured out the meaning… It was easy to picture… I feel… My favorite part… While reading…
Integration of Knowledge (Standards 7-9) The difference between… When I compare… If I could give advice… I predict… One question… I wonder… I was disappointed… ELA Seminars, LLC © 2015 All Rights Reserved
Color Task Cards
Directions: 1. Run a set of task cards on cardstock for each student. 2. Have students cut, punch, and thread the task cards onto binder rings. 3. Students may use teacherselected or self-selected cards to annotate books during independent reading time or to run literature circle and small group discussions.
Reading Response Stems Speech Bubble Prompt Cards
ELA Seminars, LLC © 2015 All Rights Reserved
CCRRA.R.1-3
Stems
Response
CCRRA.R.1-3
CCRRA.R.1-3
CCRRA.R4-6
CCRRA.R1-3
CCRRA.R.4-6
CCRRA.R.1-3
CCRRA.R.4-6
CCRRA.R.1-3
CCRRA.R.7-9
CCRRA.R.7-9
CCRRA.R.4-6
CCRRA.R.7-9
CCRRA.R.7-9
CCRRA.R.7-9
CCRRA.R.4-6
CCRRA.R.1-3
CCRRA.R.7-9
CCRRA.R.7-9
Black and White Task Cards
Reading Response Stems: Literacy Center and Book Talk Speech Bubble Prompt Cards
ELA Seminars, LLC © 2015 All Rights Reserved
CCRRA.R.1-3
Stems
Response
CCRRA.R.1-3
CCRRA.R.1-3
CCRRA.R4-6
CCRRA.R1-3
CCRRA.R.4-6
CCRRA.R.1-3
CCRRA.R.4-6
CCRRA.R.1-3
CCRRA.R.7-9
CCRRA.R.7-9
CCRRA.R.4-6
CCRRA.R.7-9
CCRRA.R.7-9
CCRRA.R.7-9
CCRRA.R.4-6
CCRRA.R.1-3
CCRRA.R.7-9
CCRRA.R.7-9
8 Title Cards for Work Stations
Secrets of Teaching © Copyright 2015. All Rights Reserved
RECORD YOUR THINKING
WRITING ABOUT READING
STOP and JOT
Annotation Sentence Starters
Discussion Prompts
Reading Response Stems
Common Core Conversation Cards
RESPONSE STEMS
Speech Bubble Posters
Key Ideas and Details CCRRA.R.1-3
The most important… CCRRA.R.1-3
The evidence I found… CCRRA.R.1-3
Some interesting phrases… CCRRA.R.1-3
Some interesting words… CCRRA.R.1-3
CCRRA.R.1-3
One quotation…
The reason…
Craft and Structure CCRRA.R.4-6
I figured out the meaning …
It was easy to picture…
My favorite part…
The writer…
I feel…
While reading…
Integration of Knowledge and Ideas CCRRA.R.7-9
When I compare… CCRRA.R.7-9
One difference between… CCRRA.R.7-9
I predict…
CCRRA.R.7-9
One question…
CCRRA.R.7-9
CCRRA.R.7-9
I was disappointed…
If I could give advice… CCRRA.R.7-9
I wonder… CCRRA.R.7-9
Letter Templates for “RESPONSE STEMS”
READING RESPONSE NOTEBOOK QUICK-LOOK REFERENCE SHEETS
ELA Seminars, LLC © 2015 All Rights Reserved
ELA Seminars, LLC © 2015 All Rights Reserved
ELA Seminars, LLC © 2015 All Rights Reserved
ELA Seminars, LLC © 2015 All Rights Reserved
CLOSE READING AT A GLANCE
CLOSE READING AT A GLANCE
PURPOSE 1 Look = to summarize and infer nd 2 Look = to analyze craft, structure, or data 3rd Look = to share findings by citing evidence
PURPOSE 1 Look = to summarize and infer nd 2 Look = to analyze craft, structure, or data 3rd Look = to share findings by citing evidence
1st LOOK: Get the Gist ENGAGE WITH COMPLEX TEXT Read silently and annotate.
1st LOOK: Get the Gist ENGAGE WITH COMPLEX TEXT Read silently and annotate.
Share and compare annotations.
Share and compare annotations.
2nd LOOK: Dig a Little Deeper EXTRACT AND EMPLOY EVIDENCE Reread for a specific purpose. (Listen or read again.) Find evidence to address the purpose.
2nd LOOK: Dig a Little Deeper EXTRACT AND EMPLOY EVIDENCE Reread for a specific purpose. (Listen or read again.) Find evidence to address the purpose.
3rd LOOK: Demonstrate Understanding BUILD KNOWLEDGE Show what you know. (Write and/or present.) Share your findings.
3rd LOOK: Demonstrate Understanding BUILD KNOWLEDGE Show what you know. (Write and/or present.) Share your findings.
ANNOTATIONS Circle words (e.g. tone-setting, unfamiliar). Underline phrases (e.g. details, evidence). Star sentences (e.g. main points, themes).
ANNOTATIONS Circle words (e.g. tone-setting, unfamiliar). Underline phrases (e.g. details, evidence). Star sentences (e.g. main points, themes).
CRAFT EXAMPLES Sensory Words and Phrases Transition Words and Phrases Figurative and Technical Language Point of View and Character Revelation
CRAFT EXAMPLES Sensory Words and Phrases Transition Words and Phrases Figurative and Technical Language Point of View and Character Revelation
STRUCTURE EXAMPLES Stanzas, Scenes, and Chapters Charts, Captions, and Bullet Points Sequence, Flashback, and Pacing Comparing and Contrasting
STRUCTURE EXAMPLES Stanzas, Scenes, and Chapters Charts, Captions, and Bullet Points Sequence, Flashback, and Pacing Comparing and Contrasting
st
ELA Seminars, LLC © 2014 All Rights Reserved
st
ELA Seminars, LLC © 2014 All Rights Reserved
Check out 300+ Common Core Writing Lessons on Pinterest at http://bit.ly/1m5r4ri Download Free ELA Common Core Teacher Checklists for Grades 3-12 at http://bit.ly/1mjmybz