DRUG TOLERANCE CHALLENGES IN ENZYME INHIBITOR-BASED NEUTRALIZING ANTIBODY ASSAYS
JUNE 10, 2015
Outline
NAb assays for two inhibitors of plasma kallikrein • Ecallantide: 60 amino acid peptide inhibitor with short half life • DX-2930: human antibody inhibitor with long half life and drug tolerance challenge
Plasma Kallikrein-Kinin System (KKS)
FXII Charged Surface Coagulation Cascade
FXIIa 1-Chain HMWK
Prekallikrein
Active pKal 2-Chain HMWK + Bradykinin
C1-INH Ecallantide, DX-2930
B2R GPCR Activation
Edema / Pain
3
Hereditary Angioedema
•
Types: • Autosomal Dominant (AD) HAE Type 1 – Very low production of C1-INH • AD HAE Type 2 – Normal [C1-INH], but impaired C1-INH function • HAE Type 3 – Normal C1-INH levels, poorly characterized
•
Characterized by intermittent attacks of subcutaneous or submucosal edema affecting the face, larynx, gastrointestinal tract, or limbs
•
Laryngeal swelling can lead to death by asphyxiation (mortality 30% in undiagnosed individuals)
•
Attacks without warning, lasting up to >5 days
•
Orphan disease, prevalence ~ 1/10,000 – 1/50,000 Normal bowel before HAE attack
Swollen bowel during HAE attack
* Photographs courtesy of Dr. Marco Cicardi 4
Plasma Kallikrein Inhibitor: Ecallantide • 60 amino acid recombinant protein produced in Pichia Pastoris
• Kunitz domain • Discovered using phage display • Potent plasma kallikrein inhibitor (Ki = 25 pM) • Approved for treatment of acute attacks of hereditary angioedema • Half-life: ~2 hours • Cmax: ~600 ng/mL CONFIDENTIAL to DYAX CORP.
• Cut-Point (10.97%) determined using 30 individual human serum samples
20
10
0
0
500
1000
1500
2000
2500
[neutralizing Ab] (ng/mL)
10
Anti-Ecallantide NAb Assay: Drug Tolerance 15 10.97% Cut-point
%Neutralization
10
5
0
-5
-10
-15 0
10000
20000
30000
[Ecallantide] (ng/mL)
Low drug tolerance
11
Plasma Kallikrein Inhibitor: DX-2930 • Human IgG1 produced in CHO cells • Discovered using phage display • Potent plasma kallikrein inhibitor Ki = 125 pM
• In clinical trials for prophylactic treatment of HAE • Half-life: ~2 weeks • Cmax: up to 40 ug/mL (2 x 400 mg SC doses) CONFIDENTIAL to DYAX CORP.
12
Combine SPEAD Step with Enzyme Activity NAb Assay
Y
Plasma Sample
Y
+
nAb 1
7
Biotin DX-2930
7
E F
H
H
Neutralization Plate
Streptavidin Plate
S
P
S
P
pKal DX-2930 pKal DX-2930 NAb positive
NAb negative 13
Combine SPEAD Step with %Neutralization Enzyme Activity Pro-Phe-Arg-AMC
pKal + DX-2930 bound to NAb
Pro-Phe-Arg + AMC
120 500 ng/mL PC 1000 ng/mL PC 2000 ng/mL PC
%Neutralization
100
80
60
40
20
0 No DX-2930
2 ug/mL DX-2930
20 ug/mL DX-2930
SPEAD-enzyme activity assay does not have sufficient drug tolerance 14
Could we justify use of a binding Nab assay? Examine what we know about the structural biology of DX-2930
15
DX-2930 Binds pKal Active Site: Biacore SPR Analysis
80
pKal
Response (RU)
60
40
pKal+AEBSF
20
pKal+PFR-CMK 0
300
prekallikrein 400
500
600
700
800
900
1000
1100
Time (s)
16
pKal:DX-2930 Complex Crystal Structure
• Complex of DX-2930 Fab portion with a deglycosylated pKal variant • X-ray Diffraction to 2.1Å resolution
pKal
HV
• 2,404 Å2 of buried surface at the complex interface – large interaction area promotes specificity and affinity
LV DX-2930 Fab
HC
LC
17
LV-CDR2 Interactions
LV CDR2
E600
HV
E527 K528
pKal
Y555
LV DX-2930 Fab
K50
HC
LC
18
HV-CDR1 Interactions
FR1/HV CDR1
pKal
V410
R416
HV
L418
L439 L412
F27
F29
LV DX-2930 Fab
H434
Cyan = pKal catalytic triad residues
HC
LC
19
HV-CDR3 Interactions
HV CDR3
pKal Y475 S578 H434 D572
D483
HV
W598
R106
LV
R105 P104
DX-2930 Fab
V103
K575 E108
Cyan = pKal catalytic triad residues
HC
LC
20
HV-CDR3 Interactions
pKal
DX-2930 binds at the pKal active site; blocks substrate
• Drug tolerance: 250 μg/mL at 250 ng/mL positive control • Intra- and Inter-assay less than 30% (less than 20%) • Short term stability (20 h) and F/T cycles (6) acceptable • Specificity: A non-neutralizing mAb was below the cut-point
28
Summary
• Enzyme based NAb assays were sensitive to drug interference • A structural and biochemical understanding of the interaction leading to the bioactivity supports the use of a binding assay for NAb detection
• A drug tolerant, binding-based NAb assay can be used for an antibody inhibitor of an enzyme
29
Acknowledgements
Ecallantide and DX-2930: Dyax R&D Ecallantide Nab Assay: Tandem labs DX-2930 Structure: Dyax R&D and Berylium DX-2930 ADA and Nab Assay: WIL Research Jeff Sailstad