Justifying Proofs using Memo Tables - Semantic Scholar

Justifying Proofs using Memo Tables Abhik Roychoudhury

C.R. Ramakrishnan

I.V. Ramakrishnan

Dept. of Computer Science SUNY Stony Brook Stony Brook, NY 11794, USA

Dept. of Computer Science SUNY Stony Brook Stony Brook, NY 11794, USA

Dept. of Computer Science SUNY Stony Brook Stony Brook, NY 11794, USA

[email protected]

[email protected]

[email protected]

ABSTRACT 




   "!
#$%&' (
# )*)+!',.-/
#0 ,.!)12!' 3 4
5
 *67(,!&8(
95,.#0(*:;6=?)  $@BAC  2%',#0!*DE,)FG)F$H"IKJL9 'M!F0!N3)F0DM )F
 ) 0!FG
#O'#!,.#0(O!
#O%9 0OK
!FO; )F4 2,) #0!*5
/ 5PQR3!','# )@LSTDEPUE)F$ 0'1V


 OW
5X'#*,.# 'K,.#Y(Z),.#0(1) R[!','# &P , '#!$:\,.#K' CE)F&
 
 /   =C#KDEF 3
9  &" "#T2,@&]\#K)F,"
+'U%DE5
 ^&)F&  _&! #) 0!),.#(O) 0!F`
#`P, '#!KDa,)F 9,.# )^ !',.#( bcd
Z,),#
>!5 
),#0
EPF0
Z*9)F"
!F)F09 P
. 0
Z),#O%'X9  *)F9HTIKJ|9 'E!F!}N~'@9)F0? !%
!}F ,.#0("X)F? U
#uF'#!)F0DM)F02 
Z),#1 #) !!)\

%
Z
E!#0 !%@ ˜@MEF0&M
!}FB)
(Z*>8–( UDE,)F/,";DE

#u
!N DE
iP
. 0
Z),#7U
.
 59
N~!
#Q+[ O*(
F ,!
.Q '#  )F"ž6±`;
#09F'.1
.P,
Zi)FM!#09  $@ESTDa PZ'U)F4Z)F0i  99
9\ #
9'# 
M*)F4
 
Z!}F 5g•DE
!F ,.#0(3)F&  P&
9(Z
h4
#0$F'#!&9
,.#7@ EFE.,i,
),#0E
,M)F?;.DE,.#(u,.# ),.#0( j 0),#0@ JE
#¤DEGs)rµ'­ c n o;s'm µo&
» z,)$;*
O(Z

;'t)F0 P
. 
),#/X>)F0&(Z
%,E! i &DE,)F0 0E P
. 0
Z),.#0(1)F0 (Z
@ ?_JE
#G)F$!#0) !),#y%1#0KDE,)F0 09,i
!),.#( )F[+';
#!*T)F[,.# ,),
VP
. 
),# ? JE
#O)F4 !# ) !4 Xa+&9
 %*9)F",(,.#
   9
,.#
'#!&%
&

 $,.#1' ?%
 
 1% U 0
Zy#`)F3x) 0),.-!
Z),#¤5)FZ(,!/ (
 )F0
Z '#! &)F0&

 K :•ž^! ),# « ='@ « @>k/3 !',.%3)F9!#0) !),#GM
$P, '#!3('#'
Z ;T
&
. ;.,.; 9EF0&!#0! '0M0x) ),.-0!
),#K;9E
&0
Z),C;M
u+D>' \

2%),),#k/T^,!' EF0D )F" '- #,),#Y!
#3%&2'# $5P
. 
),#Y·#
'9 /- #0,.#(Q
*!
 ]… ) 0!FG)F0
Z$:\,³=«zf

#,.-1Da,)F )F&F0
Z/(  …iU%
#Y:\,.,³="
!F*.,'
s  {¨,.#Y)Fu+*(  … F
 ©0k : {5« =  o;smr@B]\v  ©+
: zV2 = L® b ¯.nrUDE3!
#G2 
,.#¼)F,9;
,..    )F0DE,.#0( )F0
Z?;>
.7!'
 0 ”  …yDaFMF0
 ? # ,.;3DE,) F ziU )F'i,&
ZC
Z&#i.,'
s  { ,.¾ # … ) !}FB)F
´  ©0k: {is = v® b ¯.n r@ kK*!
.&) !}Fy#0' •'¼2 
#
),#K
3
v¯­µ b ¯³¯ d µ'­ c n p‚n o;r c o r ¿'¬%¯ bc0b o;p\­ c n'@ E ’”“•–i—–D˜$–@™1—¸˜” @ À%­µ b ¯\¯ d µ­ c n p‚no;r c oEr ¿'¬%¯ bc0b o;p\­ c ®­s bc5b o­º zÁ84\E s 4\
o 4V¬7s•­¦^s b ƒ º r bc £$o b ¥¯s r Œ”¨T£r c ­or£9¥ _ d ÂÃÄ L ÅÆ
: z&=5p‚n b n ro?­®"n ro\n&­® b o;­ºunMbn 4\
o 4

® +: V= o;smr­  ÃÄ L ÅÆ
: zV= É#} Ï ª}Ê6ªbË9Ë9˪¬},̔ÍΨÏ8p\oDC4r b µEC”},Ð?¥rp c ¦ b n ro ­® b o;­ºu( n É6{ Ï ªE{0Ê6ªbË9Ë#Ë1ªY{ Ò Ítn m µ&C*oDC b o
­

Ç 4”È s©
z

O_ÓÕÔ2Ó¢Ö»©+:k{f×Z= o;smr6¨ bc £ Ñ ¥ Ò ³ …ÙØÚz ¿ ” ÛÕ~ bc £ b n m¥n o;p\o;mo;p\­ c ¨nm µEC¨oiC b o z&Ü¿ _;z £ ~Ï_بk: { Ï ªE{ Ê ª#Ë9Ë9˪E{ Ò =.$4 bc ” 4”È®s©+:
zV = Q® b ¯.nºr ­ = Þɺßàͨ b n p c ¦¯ro;­ c µ­¯\¯rµo;p\­ c 8C0rs)rß፠ ÃÄ L ÅÆ
: zVÕ É6{ Ï ªE{0ʪ9ËbË9˪E{ Ò Í1p‚n5Do C0r"nº b ¯\¯rno'f @ oE

_  7$/L´9'!U%
Z9#(3)F0&,.{%''# &  ,.# Â k: { Ï ='U #&)F0
Z" E#0ZM!# 
,.#Y
#*
#!&N  { Ï@ EF·x) ),.-!
),#3)F0) )F5P
. 0  )"D&@ @ @% (
Z9·,.# µ b o;p\­ c ­s ® z p c r243$C0r c io C0rs•r9Er ¿^pno\n b nm µµ'rnn\®m:¯ 9$À

),.#0(K)F09- i!
 4s  "!#$!&%$D>iF0
PZ Â : "!#$!&%%
: -$ª)=•_ =  É6É# 
: -$ªkª-`fY= ª ÿ 6

G: g$ª : )ªkª@g &= ª
"!#$!&%%
: -`f6ª3g == ͺÍ^@ kK/!'

),P'y,.# PN~c  Am^n o;p ® d ;*%)F¤3)FY•DEO) 0
Z9@EEF5
 "
Ex• 0),.-* 4 ),.#0(3,!
Z2   U )F&)
#),),#K'
),#/;T)F0&
 0Z9

3kvž0U#0#0 ")FDQ)F
)F?;
!F !'
 0  … ,.#B)FiZ(
Z DEF0ZiF0
* # ,.-0 iDE,)» F ziU%',)F' :\,³=?)FE% Ï … ! # 
,.#M
M® b ¯.n r?.,'
;UT:\,.,³=a
.0.,'
a,.#

„ Ê l
mon
p
qsrotsu`vxwzy{ X3| U~} È E€ ô‚!ƒ 5 …G†‡Mˆ ‰zŠX‹ ˆ ŒMQŒ E Ø ³ Z@´L™ ´ ô E  È ° ¶µ T “ Ê·¢¸žLŸc ¡ m¯¦t°  ¥B± È E Ê?²™ r5¤ È ° T¹º» ²!™œ² Ê tsu¼¦§ r½¤ È °  Ù × Ø Ê tXu:¦
§ ¾ È Ê ¡ Ê tsu:¦
§ X3¿ y r5¤ È0 E Ù ® È Ð ò ßzÀ Þ Ê ­c¦zt ”  Ù ” 9 E ¦zmo­¦ ® È Ð ò ßä á Ê ­c¦zt ”  Ù ” 9 E ¦m¯­c¦ …† °  Ù Ì × Ø † £ F ,  à ¥ ° ¤Gp
qB¦l
ÁÂu p ® È Ð wy{ X| U@} È& F Ê)Ê ­c¦zt ”  Ù ” 9 E ¦m¯­¦ …G†ÅÄ`‰L—Æ–Xœ ¨ °  ÙÇ ªÈcªso©—™ª˜Ù ± È E ÊR…G†0X‰ ˜GªR˜ ¨ ‹X˜M0 E F 3 È ¥ Í ¿Î ÈG“ Î žLŸc ¡ Ê)Ê Ã p ¤Gp
qH¦zl
Á u ® È Ð wyz{ X3| U~} È3& F Ê•Ê ­¦t ”  Ù ” [ E ­¦t žLŸc ¡  Ù žLŸc ¡?® × E E Ø qX¦ztXÏ:q § E ¦zmo­¦ …G† E*¨ ‹X—SŠ ªcªsÐ«G–X—™˜!š ›
ª¬B† £ qX¦ztXÏ:q § E

öMŠ\‡%‘…,Ñ%ø”^§‘[, 9,
9 9@ !# 
,.#*#0# 
 u ,!
@kK–- ¸
ZaX.DM” ’”“•–i—–D˜$–@™1—I⠛@ãSä1–Üö"“—9Da,)F ,–

#,j "
T9 'ƒ´°“
D>'.%
,>˜° •P
.  D>'.. ;;

#0 K9 'Eƒ9 7“)@ ’”“•–i—–D˜$–@™1—Ið

c r c µ­£p c ¦ s•­­®8óE¥¯p.¦ b ;o p\­ õ c ô ò s•­­®

›@ã,—M™¶ö"–i—"¤IñŸ—r'£À%­¦p\µ ò s)­¦s b º Ò n m µ&C`oDC b o ®­s bc0d ¬7s)­­®T­¥°¯p ¦ b o;p\­ c ] bc £C¬7s)­­®"n d n o;rºc† ï?!: ]«ªY†", = |:!9r&=·_:s†€è÷]õøùî ± w y :kr&=T= ]X#»

9#0# ; ,),i,.³
,)` 2
i UE
9?

i,.#K
#YP, '#!9)53P
(,!i (
Z  ',P
),#t'@EAC# )FCZ)F0?F
#·U û 9
P'
%'–,.# )F?x) ),.-0!
),#B(
Fti
5),.#(� ",.#*)F&P, '#0! i)Z@ kKi
Z) 0 B  ï?!: ]«ª9†Tà = |!: ï ë !: ]&&= ªXï?ak: †"=, = |!: 9r&='@§aF `U ï ë ,
&9
 ,.#(&\| 7.,(Z
),#"T( #3
 ?
#0$ï?a ,5
$9
 ,.#0(*\Z
4 M  $
3(,!3Z(
Z$@3k/ \

)F03
) 9*)F
$  ï a 9
0 
!Fv T *K


# ,j 0 MÏ 7Z(
Z !'
 0 @EEF0#*)F'&2,"
&
),
³ #!),# ïÐa ý \Z Z(
 !'
 0*Ki

$@ @|,.þï?a:!ÿ= É6… Ï ªbË9Ë9˪Y… ñ ÍC;EZ9C

L  ÿ&
#3!'
 s  ɺ… Ï ª9Ë9Ë9Ë"ªE… ñ Íu)F'# Ï = €ÿC;>
.7_ ïÐa ý k: …fÐ),  Óèò ӑí%@±C,P'#1
Ex) ),.-!
),#$(
 ( F 7U ,.#*"5!#0) !M
#tP,#0!5)TDEC#Ï 1u!
Z&)F0

9>)F0Zi (
Z !'
 0&;&DEF,!F ï aý ,& '- #0%@5k/ )F'#O'
Z!$)F9 03") !Fv
$ (
 Ï !'
 0]  …¸DE,)FO)F0

i)F05!Ï  )%#^,.#(*?

ë  ï aý k: …&='@EwE3'%
Z^
  ,.#0(÷ïÐaý Cx• 0),.-!
),#K(
F(71
),.#(i\L)FCZ   7U DE&0
,.# û @: 77='@09
.U%DET'- # û
E;.DM” ’v“Ε–D—–i˜–™—cš
›~ã  ˜`¼˜$–@™1—€ñŸ—C0
,.#*)FE .,(
Z),» # -*Æ Å )%@ pTDuU§)F0"x• 0),.-!
),#`0  "!#$!&%('.-,+)"/C,5Ï #09 K
 ,.#( )FC- M!'
 &""!#$!&%%@%e"(Z
,.#$ ),.#($ïÐaý DEM9
3,C5
#
 .,!
Z),#B0 7 &:='@eM ,.#0(5·

i:°=–N # -tÆ Å )tDE5
,.#Y#4#D¨.,(Z
),#3)F0';5

5P, '#!3) ! #) 0!),#*,M!i %@MEF0T!#) !$ P,'#!5)", )FDE#*,.#*€"
,.&
&Zi,%@ 4.1 Justification in Model Checking EFi'#!,.#0(1)F5JEC6K9 '!F0!N",.#KQ
  ,
v-# ,.#0(G)F0   $
#0ç  %Û
  ^,!
(,!?Z(
Z9i,.#("0
Zi ' !F!}N~'·XZ)F0 ¸ !',.),#K
#( 
(Z&
#$Z)F0'T5%
·Z(,!&!
# %M
,.$0
,.#0%@T]X# ;
!>)F0T'#0! ^,.#(3)F&JEM6*9 ' !F0!N5DE
T
,.#Y,.#Y)F ,uX
)F ,#Y\Z  5HTIKJ|9 ' !F0!N)F
·, ),(#0&;P
. ?
),.#(&JMJMž"
#&)F09
 &  •!
!' . *i+
T(,!@¨I*$!'# )UMD>4
( H"IKJ¨$.,.#
[i%
EZ(,!Y:;6 C6§=C  '- # ,.#0(=%Û
 ,.#1
!! 
#!&DE,)F$)FC 7¶(,PZ'#$,.#Kƒ « “•@EF0E
(Z'

models(s0, ag(p))

tnot(models(s0, ef(not(p))))

models(s0, ef(not(p))

trans(s0,s1) s1

models(s1, ef(not(p)))

s3

p

models(s3, ef(not(p)))

trans(s1,s3) s0

p

models(s3, not(p)) p

s2

:;
=

fact

:\+= models(s0, ag(p))

p

s0

s1

negate(p, not(p))

fact

p

tnot(models(s0, ef(not(p)))

models(s0, ef(not(p))

models(s1, ef(not(p)))

p

models(s2, ef(not(p)))

s2

:;!°=

ancestor

ancestor

:;=

öCŠ\‡%‘…1B·ø5¡0l%ˆ‰Õù\*›†OŠ;ù;ù;‘ƒ‚“)@¶EF0*,. ;Z!5,*
#y0),i,½  ).,,.#0(yDE,.#0 D  ! &;$- Y)
#);'1PZ'K',
&.,.#0
#Q,50
9V)F0t” ± pM&JE8| ! T
!N%@OEF0%  Õ
P
9
 ;!}N,.#($Z!,T
#K'R[!','# " !;U(,!9 (
9&1
 
 O 9i
#0  P, /P, '#!9,a ),..,)$,.#K '§!}F!N,.#0( @ EF/!#0! '0KTx) ),.-0!
),#L,K
v '\

&,.#L)F'K
  .,!
Z),#@|w>'D DE1^,! 03,i$,.#GZ(
 i,.#0( @y]X# )F3P
. 
),#y
#$x) ),.-0!
Z),#yM
 
 ¼95DE3!
# !
1^,!#K)DE&,),.#0! "
.+',"'

Z"F
 ü  Ô
5j 0'  P
. 0
Z),#KF
&DEF'"D>un r b s)Eµ CC® ­s"Do C0r&Er ¿^pno;r c µr?§
i) !' ! )\

]eM )ª~´ 5  ªªºF@kKi)F
# N*€T
P, ž0@k/
'#3;
" '.,i,.#
3,i 9'# 
Z),#B%
Ex) ),.-'E;  %Z),),#
Z(
 U%
#4;MP
. 
 9^,! 0),#0& ,.#( )F&),(#Y)FiHTIKJ/x) ),.-0'@ 7. REFERENCES ƒ'“uAi@0eT('#7U0€5@0€T)';Uei@±"
)F DE
,Uo&@>"# ,.+';U Ni@+ž+@ oC
Z9
N,)F #
U7
#$€i@kQF ,@%eC#t'R3!',#  9
 !N$XM,i 9'# ),.#($  ,j

,  #0!F # ,½
),³#7@]X# ò s•­µ'rr'£p c ¦nE­$ ® ó0ó ò 9$À¼uU%ªZªª @ ƒ ˜°“V&@0eC
U o&$@ oM

N,)F #0
#