MSE Results
Atlantic Herring MSE Results
MSE Peer Review March 13‐15, 2017
Results Just providing a few examples Results meeting specific objectives unavailable Experiences eliciting this information? Two types of plots, both two‐dimensional: 1) Display median of many CRs for single OM 2) Display percentiles of a few CRs among OMs
Results Hi M, Lo Steepness, Slow Growth, Unbiased
Results Hi M, Lo Steepness, Slow Growth, Unbiased
Results Hi M, Lo Steepness, Slow Growth, Unbiased
Results Hi M, Lo Steepness, Fast Growth, Unbiased
Results Hi M, Lo Steepness, Slow Growth, Unbiased
Results Hi M, Lo Steepness, Slow Growth, Unbiased
Results Hi M, Lo Steepness, Slow Growth, Unbiased
Results Hi M, Lo Steepness, Slow Growth, Unbiased
Results Just providing a few examples Results meeting specific objectives unavailable Experiences eliciting this information? Two types of plots, both two‐dimensional: 1) Display median of many CRs for single OM 2) Display percentiles of a few CRs among OMs a) Examine tradeoffs and uncertainty in tradeoffs b) Examine effect of assessment bias
Let’s Compare 4 CRs
12
Let’s Compare 4 CRs all with 3 year block – unbiased assessment
Let’s Compare 4 CRs all with 3 year block – unbiased assessment
Let’s Compare 4 CRs all with 3 year block – unbiased assessment
15
Let’s Compare 4 CRs all with 3 year block – unbiased assessment
16
Results Just providing a few examples Results meeting specific objectives unavailable Experiences eliciting this information? Two types of plots, both two‐dimensional: 1) Display median of many CRs for single OM 2) Display percentiles of a few CRs among OMs a) Examine tradeoffs and uncertainty in tradeoffs b) Examine effect of assessment bias
Let’s Compare 4 CRs all with 3 year block
Let’s Compare 4 CRs all with 3 year block
Let’s Compare 4 CRs all with 3 year block
Let’s Compare 4 CRs all with 3 year block
Results Just providing a few examples Results meeting specific objectives unavailable Experiences eliciting this information? Two types of plots, both two‐dimensional: 1) Display median of many CRs for single OM 2) Display percentiles of a few CRs among OMs a) Examine tradeoffs and uncertainty in tradeoffs b) Examine effect of assessment bias
Let’s Compare 4 CRs unbiased assessment
Let’s Compare 4 CRs unbiased assessment
Let’s Compare 4 CRs unbiased assessment
Let’s Compare 4 CRs unbiased assessment
Questions?
MSE Peer Review March 13‐15, 2017
Results Just providing a few examples Results meeting specific objectives unavailable Experiences eliciting this information? Two types of plots, both two‐dimensional: 1) Display median of many CRs for single OM 2) Display percentiles of a few CRs among OMs
Results Hi M, Lo Steepness, Slow Growth, Unbiased
Results Hi M, Lo Steepness, Slow Growth, Unbiased
Results Hi M, Lo Steepness, Slow Growth, Unbiased
Results Hi M, Lo Steepness, Fast Growth, Unbiased
Results Hi M, Lo Steepness, Slow Growth, Unbiased
Results Hi M, Lo Steepness, Slow Growth, Unbiased
Results Hi M, Lo Steepness, Slow Growth, Unbiased
Results Hi M, Lo Steepness, Slow Growth, Unbiased
Results Just providing a few examples Results meeting specific objectives unavailable Experiences eliciting this information? Two types of plots, both two‐dimensional: 1) Display median of many CRs for single OM 2) Display percentiles of a few CRs among OMs a) Examine tradeoffs and uncertainty in tradeoffs b) Examine effect of assessment bias
Let’s Compare 4 CRs
12
Let’s Compare 4 CRs all with 3 year block – unbiased assessment
Let’s Compare 4 CRs all with 3 year block – unbiased assessment
Let’s Compare 4 CRs all with 3 year block – unbiased assessment
15
Let’s Compare 4 CRs all with 3 year block – unbiased assessment
16
Results Just providing a few examples Results meeting specific objectives unavailable Experiences eliciting this information? Two types of plots, both two‐dimensional: 1) Display median of many CRs for single OM 2) Display percentiles of a few CRs among OMs a) Examine tradeoffs and uncertainty in tradeoffs b) Examine effect of assessment bias
Let’s Compare 4 CRs all with 3 year block
Let’s Compare 4 CRs all with 3 year block
Let’s Compare 4 CRs all with 3 year block
Let’s Compare 4 CRs all with 3 year block
Results Just providing a few examples Results meeting specific objectives unavailable Experiences eliciting this information? Two types of plots, both two‐dimensional: 1) Display median of many CRs for single OM 2) Display percentiles of a few CRs among OMs a) Examine tradeoffs and uncertainty in tradeoffs b) Examine effect of assessment bias
Let’s Compare 4 CRs unbiased assessment
Let’s Compare 4 CRs unbiased assessment
Let’s Compare 4 CRs unbiased assessment
Let’s Compare 4 CRs unbiased assessment
Questions?
