National Securty Through Responsible Information Sharing
N AT I O N A L S E C U R I T Y THROUGH
RESPONSIBLE
I NFORMATION S HARING Mike Howell Deputy Program Manager Information Sharing Environment July 2013
VISION National security through responsible information sharing
M ISSION Advance responsible information sharing to further counterterrorism and homeland security missions Improve nationwide decision making by transforming information ownership to stewardship Promote partnerships across federal, state, local, and tribal governments, the private sector, and internationally
2
SCOPE International Private Sector Tribal Tr r Local Lo oca oca a Sta tat atee ate State Federal Fede ede de eral al
Frontline • Investigators • Analysts • Operators
Communities
Law Enforcement
Defense Intelligence Homeland Security
Information Sharing Environment (ISE)
Diplomacy
Information Technology Industry
3
D O M E S T I C I N F O R M AT I O N SHARING ENVIRONMENT Multiple Missions & Authorities Crushing Financial Pressures Evolving & Converging threats
300+ million People 80,000 Agencies 750,000+ Officers 250,000 911 Operators 1.2 million
National Approaches to Interoperability IIntegrated Capabilities & Shared Services Common Operating Models C
77 Fusion Centers nterrs 28 HITDAs 6 RISS Centers enter errs FBI
CJIS ▫ FIGs ▫ JTTFs ▫ JRIGs C
DHS
I&A ▫ ICE ▫ CBP ▫ DNDO ▫ NPPD
Firefighters g
2.2 million
Security Officers
18 CI/KR Sectors
* Numbers are estimates
Nlets
DOJ
ATF ▫ DEA ▫ OJP P
Maritime
in Domain
DoD
NORTHCOM
Air
NCTC JCAT
Domain D
Protection of Privacy, Civil Rights, and Civil Liberties
4
Principles: • Information as a national asset. • Information sharing and safeguarding requires shared risk management. • Information informs decision making. 5
D ATA - O N - T H E - E D G E : AGENCY VIEW
AGENCY A
Department and Agency Summary
PROVIDER
SHARED SHAR RED CORRELATED CORRE ELATED Data Da ata
EDGE
SERVICES EDGE
NON-SHARED NO ON-SHARED Data SHARED D RAW Data
• • • • • •
Discovery Data volume Entity maps Metadata Transport Changed data management
In the interagency data aggregation system assessment, it was determined that systems perform various levels of correlated data services based on the individual mission needs. Identified were (3) types of data stores: 1) Non-shared Data – Data not for sharing outside of the organization 2) Shared Raw Data – Data dumps that is made available for information sharing 3) Shared Correlated Data – Correlated data that is made available for information sharing
D ATA - O N - T H E - E D G E : INTERAGENCY VIEW PROVIDER
PROVIDER
NON-SHARED NO ON-SHARED Data SHARED D RAW Data SHARED SHAR RED CORRELATED CORRE ELATED Data Da ata
EDGE
AGENCY A AG B
EDGE
AGENCY A
EDGE
NON-SHARE NON-SHARED ED Data SHARED S HARED RAW Data
USER
SHARED SHA RED CORRELATED C ORRE ELATED D Data Da ata EDGE
SERVICES
SH S ARED D SHARED RAW Data NON-SHARED NO ON-SHARED Data
EDGE
SHARED SHA ARED CORRELATED CORRE ELATED Data Da ata
EDGE
EDGE
EDGE SHARED SHAR RED CORRELATED CORRE ELATED Data Da ata S HARED SHARED RAW Data NON-SHARED NONSHARE ED Data
AGENCY C
AGENCY D
PROVIDER and CONSUMER
CONSUMER
• • • • •
Native system Web service Guided navigation Visualization Multi-tool integration/widget
D A R E F E R E N C E TA X O N O M Y C A PA B I L I T Y L I F E C Y C L E - V E R B S Search Discover Identify y Profile Value Model Categorize Format/Structure
Ingest Inges st Persist Relate Resolve Re Reso olve Aggregate Access Reformatt Ref
Propagate Pr ropagate Deliver
P M - I S E G E O S PAT I A L P O R T F O L I O I N F O R M AT I O N S H A R I N G C O N T I N U U M
TS
Top Secret SBU
S
FICAM
SBU
Public P ublic
OPEN
Federal to Federal
Whole of Government Industry
Whole of Society
P M - I S E G E O S PAT I A L P O R T F O L I O I.
Advance Open Geospatial Standards: Not creating new standards… strengthening existing ones ¾ Extend geospatial elements of the National Information Exchange Model (NIEM) 9 Working with IC, DoD, DHS & industry standards partner OGC to develop best practices NIEM embedded GML and Adaptors
II. Geospatial Policy / Governance Alignment: Not creating new policy…
aligning existing policy to drive geospatial information sharing across policy frameworks ¾ National Strategy for Information Sharing & Safeguarding (NSISS)
III. Guide Geospatial Architecture Interoperability: Not developing new requirements… aligning with existing investments ¾ Develop Geospatial Interoperable Reference Architecture as part of EA Framework 9 Federal partner collaboration: NGA, DOI, DHS & NOAA to craft technical target & guidance
9 Supporting OMB Federal Enterprise Architecture Framework (FEAF) OV-1
P M - I S E G E O S PAT I A L P O R T F O L I O S TA N D A R D S : G E O 4 N I E M R E Q U I R E M E N T S • Develop recommendations for the inclusion and standard use of embedded GML with NIEM IEPDs. • Develop recommendations for the standardized use of Naming and Design Rules and the use of adaptors (e.g. NIEM wrapper for GML) • Test and demonstrate use of a standardized embedded GML and adaptors within NIEM IEPDs. • Develop architecture documentation and “Fact Sheet” for the use of embedded GML and adaptors for use with NIEM IEPDs • Develop recommendations for the inclusion of a Geospatial Domain within NIEM
P M - I S E G E O S PAT I A L P O R T F O L I O I N T E R O P E R A B I L I T Y: G I R A Federal Enterprise Architecture Guidance Federal Enterprise Architecture (FEA) OMB Collaborative Planning Methodology (CPM)
IC Architecture Community
Department of Defense Architecture Framework (DoDAF)
Aligned with…
ISE Architecture Community State, Local, Tribal FINAL 30 September 2010
DOJ Global Reference Architecture (GRA) IC Reference Models
Interoperability Framework (I2F)
Compatible with…
Audience: Executives & Program Managers
Governance / Guidance
Audience: Program Managers & Solution Architects
Practical Application
2007
2013 Appendix Geospatial Interoperability Reference Architecture (GIRA)
2014 Appendix IdAM Interoperability Reference Architecture IdAM IRA
Appendix Data Aggregation
ise.gov/standards-coordinating-council 13
V I S I T ISE. GOV
@shareandprotect 14
RESPONSIBLE
I NFORMATION S HARING Mike Howell Deputy Program Manager Information Sharing Environment July 2013
VISION National security through responsible information sharing
M ISSION Advance responsible information sharing to further counterterrorism and homeland security missions Improve nationwide decision making by transforming information ownership to stewardship Promote partnerships across federal, state, local, and tribal governments, the private sector, and internationally
2
SCOPE International Private Sector Tribal Tr r Local Lo oca oca a Sta tat atee ate State Federal Fede ede de eral al
Frontline • Investigators • Analysts • Operators
Communities
Law Enforcement
Defense Intelligence Homeland Security
Information Sharing Environment (ISE)
Diplomacy
Information Technology Industry
3
D O M E S T I C I N F O R M AT I O N SHARING ENVIRONMENT Multiple Missions & Authorities Crushing Financial Pressures Evolving & Converging threats
300+ million People 80,000 Agencies 750,000+ Officers 250,000 911 Operators 1.2 million
National Approaches to Interoperability IIntegrated Capabilities & Shared Services Common Operating Models C
77 Fusion Centers nterrs 28 HITDAs 6 RISS Centers enter errs FBI
CJIS ▫ FIGs ▫ JTTFs ▫ JRIGs C
DHS
I&A ▫ ICE ▫ CBP ▫ DNDO ▫ NPPD
Firefighters g
2.2 million
Security Officers
18 CI/KR Sectors
* Numbers are estimates
Nlets
DOJ
ATF ▫ DEA ▫ OJP P
Maritime
in Domain
DoD
NORTHCOM
Air
NCTC JCAT
Domain D
Protection of Privacy, Civil Rights, and Civil Liberties
4
Principles: • Information as a national asset. • Information sharing and safeguarding requires shared risk management. • Information informs decision making. 5
D ATA - O N - T H E - E D G E : AGENCY VIEW
AGENCY A
Department and Agency Summary
PROVIDER
SHARED SHAR RED CORRELATED CORRE ELATED Data Da ata
EDGE
SERVICES EDGE
NON-SHARED NO ON-SHARED Data SHARED D RAW Data
• • • • • •
Discovery Data volume Entity maps Metadata Transport Changed data management
In the interagency data aggregation system assessment, it was determined that systems perform various levels of correlated data services based on the individual mission needs. Identified were (3) types of data stores: 1) Non-shared Data – Data not for sharing outside of the organization 2) Shared Raw Data – Data dumps that is made available for information sharing 3) Shared Correlated Data – Correlated data that is made available for information sharing
D ATA - O N - T H E - E D G E : INTERAGENCY VIEW PROVIDER
PROVIDER
NON-SHARED NO ON-SHARED Data SHARED D RAW Data SHARED SHAR RED CORRELATED CORRE ELATED Data Da ata
EDGE
AGENCY A AG B
EDGE
AGENCY A
EDGE
NON-SHARE NON-SHARED ED Data SHARED S HARED RAW Data
USER
SHARED SHA RED CORRELATED C ORRE ELATED D Data Da ata EDGE
SERVICES
SH S ARED D SHARED RAW Data NON-SHARED NO ON-SHARED Data
EDGE
SHARED SHA ARED CORRELATED CORRE ELATED Data Da ata
EDGE
EDGE
EDGE SHARED SHAR RED CORRELATED CORRE ELATED Data Da ata S HARED SHARED RAW Data NON-SHARED NONSHARE ED Data
AGENCY C
AGENCY D
PROVIDER and CONSUMER
CONSUMER
• • • • •
Native system Web service Guided navigation Visualization Multi-tool integration/widget
D A R E F E R E N C E TA X O N O M Y C A PA B I L I T Y L I F E C Y C L E - V E R B S Search Discover Identify y Profile Value Model Categorize Format/Structure
Ingest Inges st Persist Relate Resolve Re Reso olve Aggregate Access Reformatt Ref
Propagate Pr ropagate Deliver
P M - I S E G E O S PAT I A L P O R T F O L I O I N F O R M AT I O N S H A R I N G C O N T I N U U M
TS
Top Secret SBU
S
FICAM
SBU
Public P ublic
OPEN
Federal to Federal
Whole of Government Industry
Whole of Society
P M - I S E G E O S PAT I A L P O R T F O L I O I.
Advance Open Geospatial Standards: Not creating new standards… strengthening existing ones ¾ Extend geospatial elements of the National Information Exchange Model (NIEM) 9 Working with IC, DoD, DHS & industry standards partner OGC to develop best practices NIEM embedded GML and Adaptors
II. Geospatial Policy / Governance Alignment: Not creating new policy…
aligning existing policy to drive geospatial information sharing across policy frameworks ¾ National Strategy for Information Sharing & Safeguarding (NSISS)
III. Guide Geospatial Architecture Interoperability: Not developing new requirements… aligning with existing investments ¾ Develop Geospatial Interoperable Reference Architecture as part of EA Framework 9 Federal partner collaboration: NGA, DOI, DHS & NOAA to craft technical target & guidance
9 Supporting OMB Federal Enterprise Architecture Framework (FEAF) OV-1
P M - I S E G E O S PAT I A L P O R T F O L I O S TA N D A R D S : G E O 4 N I E M R E Q U I R E M E N T S • Develop recommendations for the inclusion and standard use of embedded GML with NIEM IEPDs. • Develop recommendations for the standardized use of Naming and Design Rules and the use of adaptors (e.g. NIEM wrapper for GML) • Test and demonstrate use of a standardized embedded GML and adaptors within NIEM IEPDs. • Develop architecture documentation and “Fact Sheet” for the use of embedded GML and adaptors for use with NIEM IEPDs • Develop recommendations for the inclusion of a Geospatial Domain within NIEM
P M - I S E G E O S PAT I A L P O R T F O L I O I N T E R O P E R A B I L I T Y: G I R A Federal Enterprise Architecture Guidance Federal Enterprise Architecture (FEA) OMB Collaborative Planning Methodology (CPM)
IC Architecture Community
Department of Defense Architecture Framework (DoDAF)
Aligned with…
ISE Architecture Community State, Local, Tribal FINAL 30 September 2010
DOJ Global Reference Architecture (GRA) IC Reference Models
Interoperability Framework (I2F)
Compatible with…
Audience: Executives & Program Managers
Governance / Guidance
Audience: Program Managers & Solution Architects
Practical Application
2007
2013 Appendix Geospatial Interoperability Reference Architecture (GIRA)
2014 Appendix IdAM Interoperability Reference Architecture IdAM IRA
Appendix Data Aggregation
ise.gov/standards-coordinating-council 13
V I S I T ISE. GOV
@shareandprotect 14
