STEINWAY NYC Solar Thermal in Action
1
Introductions Bill Rigos – Facilities Manager, Steinway & Sons
2
Steinway—Piano Building at a Glance
8 months in 60 seconds
3
Piano Building at a Glance (cont)
4
Piano Building at a Glance (cont)
5
Piano Building at a Glance (cont)
6
Steinway—Finished Products
7
Part 1 - Project Overview
8
Project Background NYSERDA FlexTech Comprehensive Energy Study NYSERDA Emerging Technologies Grant – NY Feasibility ERS Approached Steinway Site Specific Feasibility Installation Grant Released Project Development Current Installation Status 9
Key Features Parabolic Tracking Concentrating Collectors Largest Rooftop System of its Kind Heat & Cool/Dehumidify 2E Absorption Chiller “Mature but New” Industrial Application Year Round Use Summer Peak Reduction 10
Project Team Steinway & Sons
GC, Project M anager, owner and operator
ERS, Inc.
Project facilitation Conceptual Design System performance analysis Instrumentation plan System commissioning Grant administration & reporting Mechanical Design & D ocumentation Permitting Control System Design & Integration Structural Design (Installation) Solar 2E absorption system concept design Collector performance modeling Mechanica l Contractor Electrical Contractor
Schuyler Engineering GCF -Inc (controls) Schmi tt Engineering Sustainable Energy Consulting Arista Associated Electric Major Equipment Abengoa IST Broad USA Armstrong
Solar trough supplier 2E absorption chiller supplier, chiller commissioning Steam11 Generator
The Facility – Location Steinway & Sons Manufacturing Facility Astoria, Queens, New York City 40 N latitude 1/3 cloudy, 1/3 partly cloudy, 1/3 clear
20,000 sq. ft. roof Reinforced Concrete
Progressive Mgt. 12
The Facility (continued)
Action Dept.
13
The Facility – Action Dept. Loads Cooling Load 23,000 square feet – Action Department Top floor of 1960s vintage building Recent closed loop dust collection project reduced OA by 80% to 1 ACH No prior AC 70-ton design load estimated Heating Load Constant 1,200 kBtu/hr process load Steam heat & humidification in winter 14
The Solar Thermal System
15
The Solar Thermal System
Broad 99-ton BZH 30 2E Multi-Energy Chiller 1.59 IPLV COP Steam Generator 900 lb/hr Steam
16
38 Abengoa IST PT-1 troughs, 5,700 sf
System Performance (Projected) 340 F hot water to chiller in summer 275 F hot water to generator in winter Productive starting 9 or 10 am 5%-10% reduction in building solar gain Annual
1,400 MMBtu/yr useful solar anticipated 80,000 ton-hr/yr available in summer (1.15 COP) 50,000 ton-hr/yr met with gas firing 870 MMBtu/yr steam generation 17
System Applicability Suitable for facilities with: Sustained thermal loads Sustained cooling loads Sustained dehumidification loads
Commercial Industrial Variety of latitudes
18
Part 2 – The Business Case
19
Project Requirements Action Department Manufacture wood components Assemble the piano’s “Action”
Humidity Control Component moisture content Assembly moisture control Employee Comfort
Overall Quality
20
The Steinway Perspective Vision for integrating efficiency, leading technologies and continuous improvement in manufacturing Quality
Continuous Improvement Ingenuity Willingness to explore creative ways of solving problems Must make business sense 21
The Internal Decision Process Capital projects are evaluated for: Productivity enhancement Quality improvement Economic payback (ROI, Cash flow – NPV)
Merit based decision, not PR based Full justification required for approval at CFO & Executive level
22
Economics – vs. RTU Cooling Costs: $1, 200,000 System cost, less ($300,000) NYSERDA cash grant - equipment ($100,000) NYSERDA feasibility study support ( $40,000) NYIRN cash grant ($200,000) 30% federal tax credit* ($200,000) NPV of MACRS+50% bonus 5-yr vs. RTU 20-yr depreciation ($250,000) Avoided RTU cost $110,000 initial incremental cost * 30% is applied to system cost less NYSERDA contribution
23
Part 3 – Implementation & Operations
24
Design Process Conceptual Design – feasibility study ERS Sustainable Energy Consulting Steinway
Detailed Design Process Steinway – Specific Input & Oversight Schuyler – Mechanical • Design & Bid Package • Permitting & Expediting
GCF – Controls Schmitt Engineering – Structural ERS – Coordination, Engineering Support
25
Bid Process Multiple Bidders for mechanical installation Long term relationship with selected mechanical contractor Lack of familiarity of system (solar, high temp) Contractors NYC Department of Buildings
Cost Escalation & Control
26
Installation (continued)
27
Installation (continued)
28
Installation (continued)
29
Installation Contractor Coordination
Equipment Vendors Mechanical Electrical Controls
30
Installation (continued)
31
Installation (continued)
32
Installation (continued)
33
Installation (continued) Installation Challenges
Coordination of key equipment lead times Weather Structural mounting to roof deck Component and controls integration
34
Installation (continued) Operational since Summer of 2010 Commissioning Monitoring Reporting
35
O & M Considerations Weather & Seasonal Concerns
System provides an alarm (local & email) Stow position Hurricane position Winter
Maintenance
Array Chiller Steam generator Cooling towers – seasonal use
Continual Data Acquisition Weather data, temps, solar insolation, pressures, flow rates 36
Conclusions Economics work with substantial grants, tax credits & high energy rates Installation challenges Heat transfer fluid Anchoring collectors Mechanical contractor costs Coordination Weather Chiller less expensive to operate than air-cooled system even without sun Packaged system could substantially reduce total 37 costs
Control System Display
38
Questions?
39
Contact • Steinway – Bill Rigos 718-721-2600
[email protected];
40