WHTE .PBLT
compe trustsubmssionsffled .in.theJmmyandBobby
...MotonstO
Brumey
cases
Texas
BATES
WHTE rCONOMIC
CON5ULTNG
Memorandum To
Home
Nathan
From
Marc
Scorceila
Januar1720l2 Re
Bobby
Bruml.y.crrse.analysis
.P te mb er 28
Summary have
the
of analysis
reviewed
have
that
bankruptcy
reorganizations
intended
assume
to
confirmation for claims
Brumley
worked
an
as
Brumley
located
Based
on
payments
my
and
processing
Trusts that
In is
Deposition
could
States
for
and
established
asbestos
to
material
asbestos
alleged
asbestos
and
the
ii
ACM
following
bankruptcy
determined
exposure
rorn
Typically
Trusts
tTusts
liability
of compensation
amount
may have
resulting
litigation
ijury
personal
asbestos-related
with Mesothelioma
in early
t940s
se.condary
as
as
that
claims
prior
to claims
basis
to the
currently
pending
testimony
from Bobby
of
basis
if
that
could
be
on
may have begun
asbestos
his
Following
and commercial Alabama
time
sites
.and
that
who
while
in the
Navy
primarily
other
can be
the
May26
Trusts
twenty-five filed
being
Trusts
established
for twenty-five
.675O00 based on each Trusts
at
states
in the
2011
future
Trust
28.201
claims
stated
current
twenty-two
identified
on September three
least
were
Existing
can be
made
against
Trusts
Pending
reorganization
taken
exposures his father
through
jobs.3
complaint
bankruptcy
to
196 12
to asbestos
exposure
Louisiana Tennessee
least
at
Of
Existing
omt
to
to
due
allegedly
take-home
industrial
for claiming
claire
against
various
insulation
recovery
mesothelioma
from 1957
at
travel
2011
exposure
occupational
Navy
insulator
an
total
of
result
States
temporary
conclude
paying
addition
of
debtors
history
be
United
an approximate for
the
Brumleys own
working
review
with
work
due
Bobby Brumley
elnims
potential
asbestos-containing
establishment
Occasionally he would
payment
average
Trust
Mr
for the
United
Southeastern
as the
insulator
Texas
in
diagnosed early
continued
of
of
any
reorganization
Trust
insulator.1
an
as
working
as
the
responsibility
rusts
summarize
to
bankruptcy
or installation
Mr Brumleys
such
was
may have begun
for
include
legal
various
from each
Bobby
Mr
the
Given
against
received
filed
distribution
manufacturing
in order
documents
various
companies
against
.PBLT
.9 I.
15
mid p23 plsintifts
AnswerS
to
Master Disrovety
13011
Eye
April
ESeel
22 2011
NW.5sile
000
t07-l0s
WeehgIot3C
20005
eeOc
202..400
13110
tSse
Gone but Not Forgotten
NO April
R0
CRR CLR
2025og.7030
EATISEWHITE.COM
Borne
121
a11Ihllrnn
rt
lndustr
tebei
$6
es
oduct
Approved
Si
Approved
Si
and
Product
Jimm Brum1e
Brumley
in case
responses
ofilarns
and
Ta
from
on testimoo
idenlificat
ula
iies
10
21
Texas
County
nile
alitoinia1
horpe
Trust
Approved
Product
JohnsManville
Lummus Design
Construction
Site
ideotit
on
cat
BR
Do
Trust
Approved
Sitc
Trust
Approsed
Site
sgjas
Ident
1250AB
lest
Bri rnlcy
Bobby
is
fication
ftorr
and
Curt
of Harris
ed
Product
identifi
and
Site
Co
$8100
texas
inty
ation
2010
is case
es
respo
scovery
the District
in
Corning
no
irony
irie
lame
Produc
jypsum
Owens
discovery
District Couit
Tn
Bobby
National
the
in
Trust
st
from
identification
AB
2509
$27
fr
lcslimony
Brnnt1ty
TO
____________ $5
ibrico IJS
500
3ypsu
Tnist
ii
Anrovcd
$67500
te
Peiulkgjrutc uitkote
Quigley Pit
Cor
sburgh
sing
Pioduct
iden
Pioduct
Identification
James
Dougl
ificat
is
or
testimony
from James
testimony
from Bobby
Douglas Brumley Brunul
and
Bruirley
________________
$673239
ToDI
it
is
naming
historical
defet
darts
rates
translrte
were
Summary
of
ii
hiought
at
and
recoveries
included
that
exposures
may have
seco
been
ug
than
hen
tales
associated
ts
detendan
the
trusts
slo
that
hese
If
may prove
alysis
pioduct
by
this
ms afanst
to
here
identified
ci
identified
pie
ana ysis
rcoiganized tort
barkruptey
airing
nt of
be an understatem
to
as
exposu
claims
was diagnosed
exposures
Ii
than
plairtiffs
higher frequency
Dust
futuie
ssorc
against
tuated
similar
by
potential Trust
Bi umley
claim
ile si
patterns
nto
Trust
potential
Bohh
Mr
thrt
ikely
with mesothelioma
udci
through
takehome hi
ate
in
2011
exposure
who ssciked
at
and
the
direct
as
an
ge
of
72
allegedly
occupational
insulator
Gone bu
Not
at
ic
to
His
exposure
undisclosed
Forgotten
asbestos
sites
ea liest
around
Ho
ne
the
123
tt
G1
OAF
holdings
Thorpe
Pipe
ilifornia
also
Co
foxes
orpe
covering
Contr
icting ssilh
of
insulation
paper in
primarily
Southern
alifornia
mt
Apptov
itractor
ha
distrihulk
asbestos
and
cement
insulatmg and
engaged
idling ofrefrac
the
sale
and
acid
in
ory
al
ins in
at
on
inaintenanc and
linings
isonry
removal
repair
related products
in
and industri
11
settings_primarily
Manvi
ohns
he
pe
Keene
rporation
Cons
ion
rue
of tional
oai ds
all
Corning
Pipe
Industnal
hiS
Thermil thr
ch
unit
ing
packing
sidii
shingles
Monospray the
including
from
rnicaljlants
cc
ii
and
and
design
1940s
the
thr
construction
the
nigh
1960
ncnt
cement
insulation
Kaylo
block
insulation
line
product
Gypsum roducis
retreetory
ured
Corning
Pipe
Genera
overview
Osei
past
tie
also
ptior
claimants
compensates 1968
to
of
Many
these
and
present
uture
billion
to asbestos
Tiusts
aie
To aceorp determine
if
claim
Tn
compromising
mnther
exped
ities
that
utilize
ings
insulation
for
felt
air
ai
insulation
cement
asbestos
manufactured
ootainingproduets
cx
for
by
pipe
other
and
companies
sealant
in
tjc
nibestos
The
sallow
review
these
iteria
iosuie
rune
of
of
aim
line
product
ott
2009
fi
after
from
purchasing
vir-ual
us
and
to
has
the
11
processing
shown
same
i.e
that
across
establish
systems
have
exposure to
criteria
contm
not
quickly this
process ial
negotiated
claims
or
or
the
Trust
ti
to
costs
mi mae
mesothelioma
many
Gone but No
is
$10
nearly
govern
to
eslve
to
transactional
sane
hms
Prior
out
se ard
the
for
dollars
paid
developed
util
laim
costs
lions
admiristrat
procedures
administer payments
to
md
reorgani/ation
bankruptcy
of
Trusts
medical
reys
ing
procedures
mimal
Tiptive
resolution
their
Mi
wit
these
in
int
designed
2010
with mi
piesu
endants
frusts
plaintillatto
claim
iling
pad
and
shed
estabi
de
Trust
hrough
billion
payment
ms
piocessing
cc
funded
From 2008 $4
dozns
established
have
oms
thus minimizing
My
te
deb
rusts have
ions
and
te
block
driven
have
with nealy
across
process
riediea
and
ms expeditiously
qualifies
submis
iium
tle
ay
irost
stada died
often
multip
to
has
gation
aims
plai itiffs
this
ish
2004
asbestos
ied
desig
it
reorganizations
Since
us
co
fircriek
cement
covering
and
estos-
as
procedures
asbestos
bankruptcy
clai
qualifying
of
962
of Trust
deade
sealsnts
number
________________________________
foci
and
block
spray
Refiacto
tigley
11
roofing
insulation
Manufie
Pittsburgh
ri
ent
Pyrospray
covermg contrae
crpiisure
sold
are
ceo
ion
rusts
PeiUhlnI Flintko
10
pipe
corn
covering
Plibric
Cypsurn
end
construction
certain refineries
im
Owens
and
Design
inside
peskets
insulutk
Spray
ummus Design
lock
coverrng
millboard
joining
Forgotten
claim
eessing
ARPC
was
Home
125
tp
Up
ip
/L11Ljjj
/w J/www
wLrnirunw
kur
un
tfl5tFH
bt
ii
iiL
hctui
ii
lm/F
it
ttt
I/007
LflI
LLtIcJAA
11
42
U1
Ut
Li
tIerAiirt
ni
nLI
ic
plu
01
pdE
ff
rrvrncnL
pi
LLL
//yw UI
J3I
Lhin 1U
II
Luni
Si
dDLLUL .lflLISMr
\VU
Jt1L
lO
ij
2O
uI
md
fo
Ic
iet
payrrents
of ary
for
net
tho5e
any
applicablc
amounts
iverag
published
fable
000
$1675
of
payment
Review
vidual
is
Range
of potentml
World
ndustr
Trusta
that
applicable
offer
the
Paymert
Pci
mately
payments
675 000
net of
Payment
receive
The
ages
mesot
in
id
summarizes
Percentages
sp
olihe
to
ii
maximum
twentyfve
oma claim based these
on
Tust the
results
from ualitymg
usts
$92
Arrr strong
Combs
es
Wilcox
cock
Stion
Hallihurto
DII
Ha
$18000
$11000
$12 220
459I 40110
iison
34
400
Walker industries
EagIePichcr federal
$13500
lnginccnng
Dli
Mogul
Flex
tallic
Fibrehoard
11
he could
typical
able
Amatex
at
cen
for
Payment Percentages apiox
option
12000
$15000
$14850
$19
800
$19
350
$13
loldings
330
49500
$68480
Califdrnia $57000 Joims
56 HO
Manville
Keene
$1000
Corporation
umirus lcsign
100
Gypsum
National
Owens
$40000
Construction
500
Corning
$4200
Plibnco
US
Peiidmg
$27000
5100
$46500
Gypsum
S3240
9000 $135
000
$3
750
1rnts
Flin kote
Qui
icy
Pittsburgh
Corning $673239
fotal
128
Asbestos
Medicine
Seminar
November
2012
$1673815
...MotonstO
Brumey
cases
Texas
BATES
WHTE rCONOMIC
CON5ULTNG
Memorandum To
Home
Nathan
From
Marc
Scorceila
Januar1720l2 Re
Bobby
Bruml.y.crrse.analysis
.P te mb er 28
Summary have
the
of analysis
reviewed
have
that
bankruptcy
reorganizations
intended
assume
to
confirmation for claims
Brumley
worked
an
as
Brumley
located
Based
on
payments
my
and
processing
Trusts that
In is
Deposition
could
States
for
and
established
asbestos
to
material
asbestos
alleged
asbestos
and
the
ii
ACM
following
bankruptcy
determined
exposure
rorn
Typically
Trusts
tTusts
liability
of compensation
amount
may have
resulting
litigation
ijury
personal
asbestos-related
with Mesothelioma
in early
t940s
se.condary
as
as
that
claims
prior
to claims
basis
to the
currently
pending
testimony
from Bobby
of
basis
if
that
could
be
on
may have begun
asbestos
his
Following
and commercial Alabama
time
sites
.and
that
who
while
in the
Navy
primarily
other
can be
the
May26
Trusts
twenty-five filed
being
Trusts
established
for twenty-five
.675O00 based on each Trusts
at
states
in the
2011
future
Trust
28.201
claims
stated
current
twenty-two
identified
on September three
least
were
Existing
can be
made
against
Trusts
Pending
reorganization
taken
exposures his father
through
jobs.3
complaint
bankruptcy
to
196 12
to asbestos
exposure
Louisiana Tennessee
least
at
Of
Existing
omt
to
to
due
allegedly
take-home
industrial
for claiming
claire
against
various
insulation
recovery
mesothelioma
from 1957
at
travel
2011
exposure
occupational
Navy
insulator
an
total
of
result
States
temporary
conclude
paying
addition
of
debtors
history
be
United
an approximate for
the
Brumleys own
working
review
with
work
due
Bobby Brumley
elnims
potential
asbestos-containing
establishment
Occasionally he would
payment
average
Trust
Mr
for the
United
Southeastern
as the
insulator
Texas
in
diagnosed early
continued
of
of
any
reorganization
Trust
insulator.1
an
as
working
as
the
responsibility
rusts
summarize
to
bankruptcy
or installation
Mr Brumleys
such
was
may have begun
for
include
legal
various
from each
Bobby
Mr
the
Given
against
received
filed
distribution
manufacturing
in order
documents
various
companies
against
.PBLT
.9 I.
15
mid p23 plsintifts
AnswerS
to
Master Disrovety
13011
Eye
April
ESeel
22 2011
NW.5sile
000
t07-l0s
WeehgIot3C
20005
eeOc
202..400
13110
tSse
Gone but Not Forgotten
NO April
R0
CRR CLR
2025og.7030
EATISEWHITE.COM
Borne
121
a11Ihllrnn
rt
lndustr
tebei
$6
es
oduct
Approved
Si
Approved
Si
and
Product
Jimm Brum1e
Brumley
in case
responses
ofilarns
and
Ta
from
on testimoo
idenlificat
ula
iies
10
21
Texas
County
nile
alitoinia1
horpe
Trust
Approved
Product
JohnsManville
Lummus Design
Construction
Site
ideotit
on
cat
BR
Do
Trust
Approved
Sitc
Trust
Approsed
Site
sgjas
Ident
1250AB
lest
Bri rnlcy
Bobby
is
fication
ftorr
and
Curt
of Harris
ed
Product
identifi
and
Site
Co
$8100
texas
inty
ation
2010
is case
es
respo
scovery
the District
in
Corning
no
irony
irie
lame
Produc
jypsum
Owens
discovery
District Couit
Tn
Bobby
National
the
in
Trust
st
from
identification
AB
2509
$27
fr
lcslimony
Brnnt1ty
TO
____________ $5
ibrico IJS
500
3ypsu
Tnist
ii
Anrovcd
$67500
te
Peiulkgjrutc uitkote
Quigley Pit
Cor
sburgh
sing
Pioduct
iden
Pioduct
Identification
James
Dougl
ificat
is
or
testimony
from James
testimony
from Bobby
Douglas Brumley Brunul
and
Bruirley
________________
$673239
ToDI
it
is
naming
historical
defet
darts
rates
translrte
were
Summary
of
ii
hiought
at
and
recoveries
included
that
exposures
may have
seco
been
ug
than
hen
tales
associated
ts
detendan
the
trusts
slo
that
hese
If
may prove
alysis
pioduct
by
this
ms afanst
to
here
identified
ci
identified
pie
ana ysis
rcoiganized tort
barkruptey
airing
nt of
be an understatem
to
as
exposu
claims
was diagnosed
exposures
Ii
than
plairtiffs
higher frequency
Dust
futuie
ssorc
against
tuated
similar
by
potential Trust
Bi umley
claim
ile si
patterns
nto
Trust
potential
Bohh
Mr
thrt
ikely
with mesothelioma
udci
through
takehome hi
ate
in
2011
exposure
who ssciked
at
and
the
direct
as
an
ge
of
72
allegedly
occupational
insulator
Gone bu
Not
at
ic
to
His
exposure
undisclosed
Forgotten
asbestos
sites
ea liest
around
Ho
ne
the
123
tt
G1
OAF
holdings
Thorpe
Pipe
ilifornia
also
Co
foxes
orpe
covering
Contr
icting ssilh
of
insulation
paper in
primarily
Southern
alifornia
mt
Apptov
itractor
ha
distrihulk
asbestos
and
cement
insulatmg and
engaged
idling ofrefrac
the
sale
and
acid
in
ory
al
ins in
at
on
inaintenanc and
linings
isonry
removal
repair
related products
in
and industri
11
settings_primarily
Manvi
ohns
he
pe
Keene
rporation
Cons
ion
rue
of tional
oai ds
all
Corning
Pipe
Industnal
hiS
Thermil thr
ch
unit
ing
packing
sidii
shingles
Monospray the
including
from
rnicaljlants
cc
ii
and
and
design
1940s
the
thr
construction
the
nigh
1960
ncnt
cement
insulation
Kaylo
block
insulation
line
product
Gypsum roducis
retreetory
ured
Corning
Pipe
Genera
overview
Osei
past
tie
also
ptior
claimants
compensates 1968
to
of
Many
these
and
present
uture
billion
to asbestos
Tiusts
aie
To aceorp determine
if
claim
Tn
compromising
mnther
exped
ities
that
utilize
ings
insulation
for
felt
air
ai
insulation
cement
asbestos
manufactured
ootainingproduets
cx
for
by
pipe
other
and
companies
sealant
in
tjc
nibestos
The
sallow
review
these
iteria
iosuie
rune
of
of
aim
line
product
ott
2009
fi
after
from
purchasing
vir-ual
us
and
to
has
the
11
processing
shown
same
i.e
that
across
establish
systems
have
exposure to
criteria
contm
not
quickly this
process ial
negotiated
claims
or
or
the
Trust
ti
to
costs
mi mae
mesothelioma
many
Gone but No
is
$10
nearly
govern
to
eslve
to
transactional
sane
hms
Prior
out
se ard
the
for
dollars
paid
developed
util
laim
costs
lions
admiristrat
procedures
administer payments
to
md
reorgani/ation
bankruptcy
of
Trusts
medical
reys
ing
procedures
mimal
Tiptive
resolution
their
Mi
wit
these
in
int
designed
2010
with mi
piesu
endants
frusts
plaintillatto
claim
iling
pad
and
shed
estabi
de
Trust
hrough
billion
payment
ms
piocessing
cc
funded
From 2008 $4
dozns
established
have
oms
thus minimizing
My
te
deb
rusts have
ions
and
te
block
driven
have
with nealy
across
process
riediea
and
ms expeditiously
qualifies
submis
iium
tle
ay
irost
stada died
often
multip
to
has
gation
aims
plai itiffs
this
ish
2004
asbestos
ied
desig
it
reorganizations
Since
us
co
fircriek
cement
covering
and
estos-
as
procedures
asbestos
bankruptcy
clai
qualifying
of
962
of Trust
deade
sealsnts
number
________________________________
foci
and
block
spray
Refiacto
tigley
11
roofing
insulation
Manufie
Pittsburgh
ri
ent
Pyrospray
covermg contrae
crpiisure
sold
are
ceo
ion
rusts
PeiUhlnI Flintko
10
pipe
corn
covering
Plibric
Cypsurn
end
construction
certain refineries
im
Owens
and
Design
inside
peskets
insulutk
Spray
ummus Design
lock
coverrng
millboard
joining
Forgotten
claim
eessing
ARPC
was
Home
125
tp
Up
ip
/L11Ljjj
/w J/www
wLrnirunw
kur
un
tfl5tFH
bt
ii
iiL
hctui
ii
lm/F
it
ttt
I/007
LflI
LLtIcJAA
11
42
U1
Ut
Li
tIerAiirt
ni
nLI
ic
plu
01
pdE
ff
rrvrncnL
pi
LLL
//yw UI
J3I
Lhin 1U
II
Luni
Si
dDLLUL .lflLISMr
\VU
Jt1L
lO
ij
2O
uI
md
fo
Ic
iet
payrrents
of ary
for
net
tho5e
any
applicablc
amounts
iverag
published
fable
000
$1675
of
payment
Review
vidual
is
Range
of potentml
World
ndustr
Trusta
that
applicable
offer
the
Paymert
Pci
mately
payments
675 000
net of
Payment
receive
The
ages
mesot
in
id
summarizes
Percentages
sp
olihe
to
ii
maximum
twentyfve
oma claim based these
on
Tust the
results
from ualitymg
usts
$92
Arrr strong
Combs
es
Wilcox
cock
Stion
Hallihurto
DII
Ha
$18000
$11000
$12 220
459I 40110
iison
34
400
Walker industries
EagIePichcr federal
$13500
lnginccnng
Dli
Mogul
Flex
tallic
Fibrehoard
11
he could
typical
able
Amatex
at
cen
for
Payment Percentages apiox
option
12000
$15000
$14850
$19
800
$19
350
$13
loldings
330
49500
$68480
Califdrnia $57000 Joims
56 HO
Manville
Keene
$1000
Corporation
umirus lcsign
100
Gypsum
National
Owens
$40000
Construction
500
Corning
$4200
Plibnco
US
Peiidmg
$27000
5100
$46500
Gypsum
S3240
9000 $135
000
$3
750
1rnts
Flin kote
Qui
icy
Pittsburgh
Corning $673239
fotal
128
Asbestos
Medicine
Seminar
November
2012
$1673815
