Certificate of Appropriateness Application
for
Patio Renovation & Pergola Ross Residence 2336 N. Fillmore St Arlington, VA 22207
Contact: Jon Ross 202.841.7846
[email protected] Table of Contents Certificate of Appropriateness Application Overview of Proposed Work Site Location Existing Photographs Materials Samples • Patio Flagstone • Retaining Wall Stone • Fence • Pergola • Fireplace County Forester Email on Tree Removal Tree Removal Description
Ross residence: 2336 N. Fillmore St., Arlington
Overview Of Proposed Work This is a request by John & Margaret Ross, the owners of the property at 2336 N. Fillmore St., in the Maywood Historic District, which was constructed in 1997 in a four-square style, to: • Replace the current flagstone patio that has become a safety hazard due to tree roots uprooting the stones with a new Carderock Pennsylvania flagstone patio and expand the patio footprint by ~2-1/2 feet to ~ 32’x18’ from the current ~29’6”x15’6”by removing the current planter boxes that border three sides of the patio and replace with flagstone up to the current retaining wall. • Replace the current wood railroad tie retaining wall, which is showing signs of deteriorating, with a new retaining wall made of cement block and faced with Carderock Sawn Ashler Veneer Stone. This stone will be in keeping with the stone retaining wall in the front of the house. • Add a new pergola over the north side of the patio. The pergola will be made of fir and painted white to match the current trim color on our home. • Replace the current 4-foot picket fence on the north and south sides of the patio with a new 7-foot tall privacy fence. The privacy fence will follow Maywood design guidelines and be made of 1”x 6” cedar boards and painted white to match the current trim color on our home.
Site Location: 2336 N. Fillmore St, Ross Residence
Site Location 2013 Aerial Image: 2336 N. Fillmore St., Ross Residence
Rear Elevation – looking east from backyard to house
Side Elevation – looking northwest
Rear Elevation – looking southeast from backyard toward 2332 N Fillmore
Existing Photographs l Ross Residence l 2336 N. Fillmore St., Arlington, VA 22207
Front Elevation -- looking west
Patio – looking north from driveway. Same view as Elevation B on drawings.
Notes on planned work
Existing Photographs l Ross Residence l 2336 N. Fillmore St., Arlington, VA 22207
Backyard – looking west from backdoor. Same view as Elevation A on drawings. Existing – top left. \/ Planned work noted – bottom left.
Materials: Patio Flagstone Sample
Ross residence – 2336 N. Fillmore St., Arlington
For the patio we are proposing to use Carderock Pennsylvania Variegated Color Flagstone from Tri-State Stone in Bethesda to replace our current Pennsylvania flagstone patio.
The patio stone will be similar to the current patio below but with fewer grays and a mix of green/gray and a few browns to better match the paint color of our home, closely resembling the current patio. The photo of new flagstone (below left) is from a job built by our contractor (Café Amouri, 107 E. Church St, Vienna) and the exact mix of colors we would like to use. New proposed patio with Carderock PA flagstone
Current patio flagstone
Materials: Retaining Wall Sample
Ross residence – 2336 N. Fillmore St., Arlington
For the retaining wall we are proposing to use Carderock Sawn Ashler natural Veneer Stone from Tri-State Stone in Bethesda to replace our current deteriorating wood 6”x6” railroad tie retaining wall. This will better complement the stone retaining wall at the front of the house.
The retaining will be made of concrete block faced with the same colors as the Caderock Veneer Stone used on a project by our contractor (Café Amouri, 107 E. Church St, Vienna) and the photo shows the exact mix of colors we would like to use, which will complement both the color of our home and the flagstone for the patio (also seen in the photo below). New proposed retaining wall stone with Caderock Sawn Ashler Veneer Stone.
Materials/Scope of Work: Privacy Fence
Ross residence: 2336 N. Fillmore St., Arlington
The privacy fence would replace the 4-foot high picket fence along the north and south sides of the rear yard/patio. The fence would also be along back yard so it is consistent. It will be 7 feet tall and made of 1x6 vertical Cedar boards– as shown in the drawing below. The fence would be painted to match the current trim color on our house (Behr Premium Plus Exterior Semi-Gloss Enamel Ultra Pure White). See drawings for views of side and rear yard fence.
The fence would look similar to this fence in photo below … but would be painted white to match the trim on the house (Behr Premium Plus Exterior Semi-Gloss Enamel Ultra Pure White). New privacy fence would be same style as this fence but painted white
Ross residence: 2336 N. Fillmore St., Arlington
The new privacy fence would replace the current picket fence, shown in the photos below. New 7’ privacy fence replaces picket fence.
View of current fence facing north from driveway – same as view as drawing on first page. The new privacy fence will be painted to match current trim on house (Behr Premium Plus Exterior Semi-Gloss Enamel Ultra Pure White).
View of current fence on south side of property .
Materials: Pergola Samples
Ross residence: 2336 N. Fillmore St., Arlington
The pergola would be made of wood (fir) and be painted to match the current trim color on our house – see existing photos (Behr Premium Plus Exterior Semi-Gloss Enamel Ultra Pure White). See drawings for details. The specs for pergola include: 6”x6” posts, 6”x12” beams, 3”x6” run flats and 1.5”x1.5” top dressings.
We expect it would have a similar feel to the pergolas in the photos below (But without the lights of the top photo or the stunning lake view of the bottom). See drawings for details.
Materials: Fireplace Insert
Ross residence – 2336 N. Fillmore St., Arlington
For the patio we are would like to place a Napoleon Galaxy GSS48 fireplace insert (16-1/2”h x 47-1/2”w) into the retaining wall (west side of patio to the right of the stairs up to back yard as shown in the drawings.
Note: Will not have chrome trim
We would not use the optional chrome trim surround shown on the fireplace above, but would use it without as noted in this photo below. Only two photos available online to show.
Jon Ross <
[email protected]>
RE: tree rem ov al perm it questions--May w ood Vincent Verw eij To: Jon Ross <
[email protected]>, Rebeccah Ballo Cc: Meg Ross <
[email protected]>
Thu, Aug 7, 2014 at 4:33 PM
Hello all, This tree does not fall under historic preservation protection. It's a three stem 10 inch river birch. It's a nice tree, and there are options to preserve it, while still having a workable patio. These include using clean structural stones to raise the grade, and expanding the tree space somewhat. Of course I can't require that, but I'd be happy to provide some options for preserving the tree canopy. Sincerely, Vincent Verweij County forester Arlington county ISA certified Phone: 703-228-1863 http://www.facebook.com/groups/271134212980703/?ref=ts Sent from my mobile device [Quoted text hidden]
Tree Removal Description We need to remove the tree (a 10-inch three-stem river birch) in the patio because the roots are upending the patio making it unsafe – moving the flagstone anywhere from 4 inches to 5 inches. Also the tree is laying on our roof and gutter. County Forester Vincent Verweij inspected the tree and wrote in an email (enclosed) that “this tree does not fall under historic preservation protection.” While County Forester Verweij suggests possibly raising patio with stone, three contractors recommended removing the tree because the same thing will happen again in a few years as the tree continues to grow and the roots would push up again after we put thousands of dollars into the new patio. That’s why we want to remove the tree.
These flagstones were once all level with each other. Now they are hazardous to walk on.
These flagstones were once level with the top of the railroad tie step. Now they’ve sunk 5 inches.
Patio Renovation, Privacy Fence and Pergola
for
Ross Residence 2336 N. Fillmore St. Arlington, VA 22207
Drawings and Elevations
Elevation ‘A’ ¼” = 1’0”
Section A-A ¼” = 1’0”
Elevation B ¼” = 1’0”
Overhead View Not to scale
Pergola – Left Elevation ½” = 1’0”
Pergola – Overhead View Not to scale
Pergola – Post Cap Detail ¼” = 1”
Materials/Scope of Work: Privacy Fence
Ross residence: 2336 N. Fillmore St., Arlington
The privacy fence would replace the 4-foot high picket fence along the north and south sides of the rear yard/patio. The fence would also be along back yard so it is consistent. It will be 7 feet tall and made of 1x6 vertical Cedar boards– as shown in the drawing below. The fence would be painted to match the current trim color on our house (Behr Premium Plus Exterior Semi-Gloss Enamel Ultra Pure White). See drawings for views of side and rear yard fence.
The fence would look similar to this fence in photo below … but would be painted white to match the trim on the house (Behr Premium Plus Exterior Semi-Gloss Enamel Ultra Pure White). New privacy fence would be same style as this fence but painted white
Ross residence: 2336 N. Fillmore St., Arlington
The new privacy fence would replace the current picket fence, shown in the photos below. New 7’ privacy fence replaces picket fence.
View of current fence facing north from driveway – same as view as drawing on first page. The new privacy fence will be painted to match current trim on house (Behr Premium Plus Exterior Semi-Gloss Enamel Ultra Pure White).
View of current fence on south side of property .