permanent mission of to the united nations office geneva

^m" w PERMANENT MISSION OF -

INDIA TO THE UNITED NATIONS OFFICE GENEVA

STATEIT{ENT BY MR. S.S.

AHLUWALIA'

II{EMBER OF PARLIAMENT

AND ATTERNATE LEADER OF THE INDIAN

DELEGATION

TO THE

45TH SESSION OF THE HUMAN RIGHTS COMMISSION.

AGENDA ITEM NO.4

: QUESTION OF THE VIOLATION

OF HUMAN

RIGHTS IN

THE OCCUPIED ARAB TERRITORIES

INCLUDING

PALESTINE.

GENEVA. FEBRUARY 2.

1989.

.4

$

Mr.

ir$ a

Chairman,

I

the

wouldrat

Iike

outset

to

extend

r3 a

to

you

of

my delegation

and to

members of

other

the

bureau

felicitations

the

{

confident in

that

the

like

to

for I

the like

would also

Chairman,

outgoing exemplary

tact,

presiding

over

Mr. the

year

rights

in

the

j-nalienable

of

Palestine,

the

that

has

the

the

of

by

a

in

the

to

-

civilian

an

the

increasing

of

the

remain

take

which

of

of

people

subj ected violations.

note

the

of of

the

since

territories

accumulated

population

human

of

population

Palestinian

uprising The

discussing

deterioration

occupied

of

The

recognition

human rights

dramatic

uprising

"i-ntifida". the

of

to

Commission

been

occupation the

levels

1947.

including

self-determination

the

situation

beginning

suffered

like

there

rights

cafled

higher

been

the

the

continued

whlle

has

"violations

for

his

year.

been

despite

community of

since

the

to

displayed

territories,

period,

success.

Palestine

on

would

for

previous

has

Arab

have

they

progressively

against be

world rights

would

item

this

he

of

itself

occupied

the

of

rights

this

Senegal

Nations

United

1968

During

the

human

the

of

the

question

the

gratitude

which

during

a

our

Sene

wisdom

Commission

human

sj-nce

Palestine".

fact

and

of

on

every

r

express

skill

agenda

support

briefly

the

cooperation

Commission

of

Ambassador

the

the

session

Chairman,

Commission

to

to

of

My delegation

and unstinted

sincere

knowledge

and

deliberations

guided.

ably

our

45th

the

We are

election.

experience

rights,

very

you of

assure

making

on

be

will

deserved

immense

human

of

well

your

with

field

Commission

your

on

has

come

to

frustrations the

occupied

zl-

territories

as

annexation

and

Israel

of and

in

Mr.

a

the

their

reaction the

the

of

of

the

freedom.

We in

colonial

rule

Minister

Mrs.

for

the

-

nr-|

d

Pcrl.

very

sD fL ! uryr yt ror cr rryl

ilehru

spoke

€ r un! r

against

out

for

ano consistent.

the

, . = y o .r d* i ni gn a ^-i,f. >a au

f raoed i es

I

hope

that

been

good

part

oods ,

the

the

thi-rties it-'h-'i--^

Palestinian

has

n (1'li r-v VUrruJ

when

to

were

f! !rvo l T l

JaWahaf

been

its

lal

Arabs,

which

Thus

subj ected.

has

been

ourselves

we

and

ua

cause

support

Arabs

inj ustice

the

Prime

words:

t^ndhi

L'lal1:aLllla

against

late

followinq

Palestinian

the

struggle

India's

cI U^! -E ^r Y. Ii r - n

and

time-tested

fl.'a

the

^J-...-^-

struggle

of

n^1^^!-i-..i^*^

the

e ! r r 4 u r l u

t

^1-^ SIIC

of

the

.

"The

svsternat

has

"

Paa:

]-^l llau

for

fight

summed up

particular,

in

people

their

Our

to

civilians.

independence

historical

in

fr ! Er a E uour li tnt ,-

Palestinians, support

our

i -^

in

bound

the

considered

^t^ T r r lrLr-rl I c l . D

ndenendenf

Even

For

their

had

the

lrrvupulrvulrL

L, I

inception.

'djst :Qs r c "

and

j

for

were

oppressed

domination.

struqql-e

sympathy

^€

L

for

Gandhi

humiliation

innumerable

international

Indira

the

of

Government

Pal-estinian

against

and foreiqn

and

times.

have always

the

the

self-determination

our

fought

Palestinian "Our

the

to

and

fndia

of

of

of

the

of

policy

by

policy

that

part

the

sagas

have

part

be

territories,

riqht

century,

Palestinians

pursued

struggle

epic

persistent

the

about by

on

inalienable

one

to

occupied

brought

Chairman,

of

colonisation

suffering

provoke

result

a

plight of

ica'l I v

-

nnnraqqad "YY'

I will

has

Palestinians

h i sf nrv -

indeed

achievement

of

am

Fcw ^nd

sure

be the

been

neon'l e

have in

humiliated

one been

their

-

this

will

key

to

harmony

change in

Own land.

soon

and

West Asia."

^l . . . . .

more

J l

The

Pal-estinian

there

is

no

struggle sign

of

remains

any

an

unfinished

diminishing

one

but

to

1t.

commitment

( The of of

intifida

has

occupation the

Geneva

of

Chairman,

that

the

occupied

a

to of

violation

of

rsraer

terrrtories

forced

rights

of

Arab

property;

displacement

of

nationalism

a

no

the

flagrant

of

on

the

new settlements

eviction,

expulsion,

of

indigenous

Arab

to

return;

sites,

Arab

occupied

of

rsrael. essential

the

occupied

of

fsraeli

svrian

displacement

and

and

and deniar

expropriation physicaf

dwellings;

desecration

Golan

and expansr-on

inhabitants

confiscation of

the

imposition

administration

Government

this

part

of

right

territoriar

state

from

the

considered

In

the

Jerusalem;

of

Convention

be

though

no

be

violation

giving

flow

annexation

hlstorical

grave

to

over

of

violations

destruction

can

commitments, the

part

of

There

Geneva

as

of

convention

territories

poricy

its

Fourth

population

is

power

the

Hague

a

situation

internationar

and

The

occupation

establishment

their

years

20

protection

the

power.

Fourth

occupied

of

and

The

the

ones I

to

civilian

occupying

transfer

of

constitutes

the

illegation

exr-sting

war

de-facto

including

the

provisions

t_he

military

jurisdiction

Heights;

of

nf

specific

the

of

occupying

constitute

other

factor:

of

ri ahq

its

that

spirit

related

itself

continues

territories

laws,

an

temporary,

integrity

Alr

time

is

that

whatsoever

of

in

territories.

stipurates

the

the

1949

occupation

human

broken

under

of

Israel

demonstrated

people.

persons

1907,

as

not

convention

civirian

doubt

have

Pal-estinian Mr.

of

resoundingly

of

religious

4l-

{ places;

i1l

punishment;

colfective

freedom

Mr. the

of

the

geographical

and

demographic

and

to in

status

to

stamp

the

area.

order of

inhabitants

is

of

development,

Israel

of

fhe

existence

nhvsi eal

population

the

of

grim

very

The

and

information new

the

inhabitants r

quote

available

pi-rase in

occupi-ed

:

territories,

the

documentation and

I'The to

the

picture

the

evolution characterised

of

by

a

drawn

l-eveI

the

The report

s ituation

the

the

upon

Committee

Special

a whole

catalogues

lands.

occupied

overall

of

a

these

in

heaped

atrocities in

gives

prevailing

reality

to

rights

human

territories

violations

of

Committee

the

affecting

presents

rights

instances

unfortunate

a

of report

human

of

specj-fic

says,

the

basis

very

the

Special

occupied

of

picture

territories. range

practices

Israeli

investigate

the

of

means

the

of

people.

these

of

remaining

the

destroy

to

legal

and

them

depriving

trying

report

latest

The

By

ethnic

territories

structure of

of

al-ter

to the

and

identity

the

out

some

stages

earlier

occupied

the

of

attention

attemptlng

institutional

their

occupied

which

to

character

composition

chanse

the

fact

is

Israel

physical

and

draw

the

during

that

namely

debate,

to

important

an

referred

have

like

would

to

Commission

deleqations this

I

Chairman,

the

of

one.

an unending

is

territories

in

Israel

by

Iist

the

Indeed

etc.

violations

rights

human

closure

territories;

occupied

the

institutions,

educational

of

of

resources

and

wealth

natural

the

of

exploitation

illegal

movement;

of

the

and

freedom

religious

with

interference

detentions;

administrative

and

arrests

mass

of

use

detainees;

of

torture

and

treatment

of

from

the

reflects in

the

violence

/

,y',

./

F

years

21

of

by

displayed and

deliberate

how

the

of v!

rrf nrce

ny vor rlv l i r - r r n v !f

fL l hI s e

j ust

A problem

population

and

n r^rwor t-vvrvr

-

,

durable found

be

cannot

territories without

the

Palestinian

people

without

Israel's

all

to

national

independence

right

to

establish

homeland,

their

Many have its

44Lh

important

historic

session

Council

declared

Palestrne

This

of

United

the

Human

was

Rights

nAne I i nnmonf

accorded

rr-

total

and

and

Arab

Jerusalem of

rights

right

return,

to

the

interference,

and

and

the

State

in

sovereignty Palestinian

On in

November

the

Algiers,

the

independence stated

declarati-on

committed

to

"the

Nations,

to

the

to

Manrr

r - n r ' r ni - r ' i a q

recosnition

to

the

the

at

Palestinian of

the the

that

Universal

and

of

of

at its

National State State

of of

principles

Declaration

of

principles

of

and

i nn'l rrd i nr^r India

State

year

end

the

purposes

policies

and r lqrr_z

15,

Palestine

fast

met

Commission

the

to

relating

developments

since

session.

Palestine.

East

Pdfestine.

place

taken

the

independent

an

Middle

inal-ienable

external

right

the

including

1961,

including

without

authorities

Pal-estinian

the

self-determination

as

suffered

l'rl owsrt .

of

of

portrays

Israeli

solution

since

exercj-se

the

and

it

by

occupied

a conscious

of

has

the

end

from

withdrawal

unconditional

by

implementation

becomes

vividly

also

the

brutality

and

are part

of

It

terror

report

The

Palestinian

the

of

the

authorities

pIan.

course

the

quotation).

of

that

Israeli

the

entire

result

(end

report

the

in

before

reached

occupation.rt

from

clear

a

never

repression

and

immefiately

Palestine.

6/-

/

place,

took

important

the

a just,

I

unabated.

and

before

prevent an

ensure

civilians

can only of

a

own

to

stress

just

comprehensive,

must

Palestinians,

there

and The

conflict.

homeland.

long

the

have

Without

and

a

crux state

than

in

ever order

in

and of

rights

basic

Such protection negotiation

the

of

settlement issue

the their

own

the

is in for

self-determination

can be no peace

of

situation

through

of

continue

taken

the

the

of

human

of it

by

be

of

lasting

Israeli

responsibility

must

run

there

the

from

territories.

occupied in

simultaneous

manifest

of

protection

the

hoped

violations

more

is

the

Regrettably,

deterioration

effective

Palestinians

a

the

that

commended and

occupied

measures

urgent

by ensured

Arab-Israeli the

territories

and

initiati-ve

response

the

come

to

has

India

Middle

the

in

Israel

flagrant

community

in

peace

Israel.

contrary,

achievement

the

towards

of

we regard

which

statement

leaders

from

further

a

the

encouraging

any

wish

that

to

evoke

international

the

19BB

will

in

Israe}

by

13,

peace

the

on

December

Palestinian

response

yet been

not

of

peace.

initiative

this

discuss

question

and comprehensive the

to

the

contribution

upon

Nations

to

made a

Arafat

United

itself

Geneva

on

address

the

of

Goverment.

the

relating

forging

constructive

to

item

his

in

him

rights

agenda

called

framework

has

in

lasting

He

East.

that

here

immeasurable

an

join

met

Chairman

Session,

of

session

In

Palestine.

as

43rd

Assembly

General

the

of

the

when

was

referred

have

speakers

earfier

several

which

to

and

which

development

important

another

Chairman,

Mr.

area'

a t

I

t-

the that their the

A

number

emphasised

that

The

position

has

been

Gandhi

of human

of

clear

said,

people

a

critical

no

and

lonqer

by

There

of

Palestinians

quote:

I for

their

can no

Arab

must

India's ds

the

viable

comprehensive

it

the

can

and violence

be

to

entered

anger

intifida. The

illegal

vacated.

right

!rYrrL

brave

has

justice.

r i nh I

a

Raj iv

the

Palestinian

must

q

of

brutality

without

issue

Minister

rights

lnalienable

h r r :qrv z 9o

this

The

to

their

self-

homeland.

be recognised.

support

unstintedr

crush

an

Th orr

rights

the

territories

have

on

accumulated

all

have

interlinked.

struggle

Their

peace

are

prime

legitimate

Not

debate

India

of

"The

phase.

be

determination.

qn^nqnrod

unegui-vocal.

fsrael can

occupation

most

and

this

peace

and

Government

be contained.

unleashed

These

rights

in

the

and

Palestinian new

delegations

has

for been

framework

peace

i nf glnS r r lui LOr vnr a r q] r_

the

Palestinian

consistent. for

settlement CvO e r rn ! sf !es fr e r vns C

a

We j ust,

is e

cause

W w r i t hL r r

a

is

believe

as that

durable United

lL-l hr Ea

and

Nations

n a 1 1 -L f i, u nf i I/q!

B/-

^-f

PaLf

i \^JhI l

of

parties

all

concerned,

-^! a- - lr r o -1 L^ -e: g l!-. ir l 'm are

(end of

people

reaffirms

expect

their

state.

They

practi-ces

of

pressure

to

expect

us

the

fsrael

be

upon

immediate

have

human

befalren been

homel-and; foreign

of

as

the

subj ected in

our

to

unparalleled

those

Palestinians

have to

been

tolerate

the

most

and

the

recent

civil who

hounded

Arab

and

i-n

its

is

the

refugees

the

power

homes

an end. we

the

should

occupied commission

to

put

an

The patestinian serious traqedv times. in

taken

massacred.

such a situation

put

their

of

rights have

to

palestinian

to

expect

measures.

and

This

comes to

occupying

in

the

fsrael

that

people

the

times

cxncr-f

Human Riqhts

on

repressive

Arab

the

return

anguish

rsraeri

efforts

of

then

peopre

Palestinian

human dignity

}ands

can continue

is

only

which

occupied

solution.

rights

and the

rights

all

the

the

and

sovereign

ilregar

support

can

the

rights them

is

commission

been

denied

human rt

Israel

to

have

decision

Thev

lasting

the

end to

in

who

territorj-es

The

the

nationals

a

the

human suffering

calf

denounce

others

towards

occupied

territories.

of

and

a

an independent

palestine.

ensured.

reaffirm

people

estabrish to

who courage

Commission

contribute

which

Through

to

the

its

further

in

can

again

from to

move

way

and the

sole

people. "

territories

persistent

shown

right

to on

actj-ons

from

the

paf estinian

the

occupied

includinq

commission

people

of

the

settring

territories

only

of

generations

two

determination

?

representative

pl,o,

the

quotation), The

for

including

at

its

a/-

viorations that

has

They

have

their

own

refuqe

in

The

world

own peril.

lloreover

prevaillng

the

terrj-tories

including

with

the

more

specifically

Palestine

estabrished

Through

on

15th

December

of

the

state

of

councir.

But

the

here.

authority

in are

prlnclpres

with

rights.

end

situation

the

a historic 19BB

upon

the

complete

international

universal

declaration

resolution

has

efforts

united

at

occupied

of

the

by of

the

Nations

If

human

of

Assembfv

National

Nations

bring

this

and

procramation

the

united

must

situation.

law

palestine

the

Arab

variance

Generar

acknowledged

Palestine

The

the

to

does

cannot bear

not

its

happen,

t

then

the

moral

structure

of

foundations the

of

the

Commission

united

itself

Nations

wirl

be

would

like

and

the

severelv

impaired. Mr. that

Chairman,

recent

events

demonstrated united in

crearly

and

the

suffering.

for

the

just

a

framework I

of

rndia to

conclusion, the

occupied

territories

that

the

palestinian

people

of

to their

will

efforts and

you,

continue

continue to

activate

comprehensive

Mr.

their

unrelenting

a UN sponsored

thank

f

in

determined

face

support

in

to

Chairman.

have are

more even

persecution

and

peace

settlement

international

state

struggle

extend

earry

to

whore-hearted negotiations within

conference.

the